If I had more time to write this I would go into more detail, but I don’t so here’s a rundown(this is still gonna be a little long but there is a TLDR at the end):
My boyfriend is 21, I am 19 we have been together for almost 4 years and I plan to finally break up with him tomorrow. There’s a lot of different reasons that would require running down our entire relationship which again I don’t have time for but the most important ones are because he’s misogynistic, hypocritical, thinks everyone is dumb because they don’t agree with him or they aren’t on his level of intellect (the level being he will think of solutions to problems that instead of sharing he will just look at everyone like they are stupid for not immediately thinking of it), a cheater, and as I’ve just found out today a racist, anti-semitic, bigot.
Here’s an argument we’ve had that I can provide for each of those reasons:
Misogyny: A recent one (few months ago), I asked him not to refer to women as females because it was dehumanizing. He then got angry, saying he didn’t understand what the issue was and that we ARE females so we shouldn’t be offended. I told him, fine okay nevermind (by this point I’ve withdrawn from having any type of discussion or argument with him because it proves to be pointless). He continued to provoke after I said nevermind, “No, no explain this to me because I really don’t understand it. We wouldn’t get upset if women called us males so why does it bother you when we call you females?” So I told him if he really wanted to know Google is free and there’s plenty of answers there. Then I sent him three articles with an answer and said nothing else. He then picked apart each article with quotes arguing against it and it turned into a two day argument that somehow moved into the zone of how he doesn’t get why white people can’t say the n word(we are both black). By the time it was nearing its end I was just trying to explain that no matter what you believe if someone you care about is asking you not to say something because it makes them uncomfortable most people would just say “oh sorry no I won’t say that” rather than arguing and trying to convince them you should say this thing that makes them uncomfortable. His defense to this was that he was too objective for that and that he holds me to a higher expectation as his girlfriend so he would hope I wouldnt be sensitive about that. I stayed, not even sure how or why, but that was around when I started to officially pull away.
Hypocritical: He expects my sister to be nice to him or say goodnight I love you to him despite the fact that he treats her like a burden. Granted this is mainly because my family forces so much responsibility of her on me and he doesn’t like how stressed I get over it, she’s only 8 though so it’s not really her fault but she is a horror show sometimes if you take her phone and she *hates* listening. However, hat is not HIS place to enforce on her and if anything the only time he interacts with her is when she is refusing to listen to me and he will say something to get her to listen (as if she’s going to listen to him when she won’t listen to me) or if he’s trying to make an example out of disciplining her to me. He does this because he’s always criticizing how she acts because we don’t discipline her enough which is true yes but again not his place. On the same topic there was a time when I got back from work at the same time as him, had to come home feed my dogs, clean up after her, fold the laundry, and get her ready for school then do my schoolwork. He was home that entire time and did not offer to help or anything he just sat there doing his own homework with an attitude, then he randomly left my house to drive around and I had to go outside and investigate what was wrong with him just for him to tell me that he was upset about how easy my sister gets off and how it stresses him out having to see how she acts and how little we do to discipline her. And I had to apologize to HIM that he was upset and for our lack of discipline. I thought this was bullshit when it happened and the apology was incredibly half assed because I was pissed at his audacity, but I was so exhausted I didn’t want to argue because I knew if I brought up how messed up that was for him to victimize himself and complain to me about the struggles I ACTIVELY have to go through I would have to deal with arguing with him.
Thinks he is smarter than everyone: This was a quick but short incident that works as an example but i would like to make it clear he does stuff like this every. single. day. Especially to me if I do something in a way he wouldn’t have done or he thinks was unnecessary or stupid. My family had just gotten home from getting the groceries and he was helping put them away and bring them inside. My brother was looking for his car keys once we’d finished and brother thought he’d put them in the grocery bags by accident. So we all begin asking around to see if anyone saw them or grabbed them and are searching the bags left over. My brother and my mom are getting very upset(my house is always in shambles so this is common) and he’s now going up and down the stairs to look. My boyfriend for some reason is not helping, he is standing beside my grandma on the steps shaking his head and rubbing his temples with his usual “are you people stupid” look on his face. As he is doing this my other brother goes to the car to check and and the one who lost his keys comes with me to check the trash cans. As soon as we walk back in, my boyfriend is pacing now looking down and rubbing his temples as if he lost HIS keys. In the exact same “captain obvious” tone he asked “did you guys check the trash?” “Have you checked all the bags?” And my grandma told him we did. He continued to pace and ask stupid questions then he started helping and when my brother found the keys( can’t remember where) he shook his head like he was disappointed in us then went up stairs.
Sidenote as well: He doesn’t really talk. Like he will if addressed but he doesn’t go out of his way to *interact* with people unless he has to so this is him acting like this when he’s not even really built that huge of a rapport with my family who *always* talks. He usually gets lucky because most of my family has just accepted that he’s a quiet guy who talks when he wants to but after this incident my grandmother pulled me aside to ask me if he always acts like that, and I told the truth. He does. It took another argument (one where I was begging him to stop giving me solutions when I’m trying to vent because I just want to get my emotions out and I don’t need solutions I just want an ear. He ignored me for about 2 days with this argument. Then I had to also tell him to stop talking to everyone like they were stupid. Claimed he will and was still pretty upset and thought it was stupid people just want to complain about their problems versus fixing them but he agreed to stop doing that too.) for him to finally stop and he still slips up sometimes but I think he really has been trying. Either that or I just don’t care or notice when he does it anymore because I’m kind of stepped out of the relationship anyway.
Cheater: He was kissed by his ex the day of our one month anniversary, this one I never really counted but once I thought about it I never really found out if he pulled away. I don’t doubt she kissed him his ex was an asshole who was disrespectful to our relationship non-stop (he allowed this) but I never found out if it was a “I have a girlfriend” pull away or if it was a kiss that surprised him and he just left. I’m on the line about this because he did come straight to me to tell me about it when it happened. The next time I’m not sure I can officially count as cheating because we were on a “break” but I still felt like I’d been cheated on. This is after I told him over and over that the one thing I wouldn’t be able to take is if he cheated and that I’d rather he break up with me if he felt tempted. And if it did happen I begged him to atleast tell me and not let me find out from someone else. I’d never been cheated on before him but that was something I considered unthinkable. Anyway he slept with someone the day after the break started. Bear in mind I had asked for the break because I was sick of us always arguing at work(we worked together at the time) and I had a lot going on at home so I was hitting suicidal ideation again and I just needed a few days to collect myself. He accused me of asking for a break so I could go cheat with someone he thought I was flirting with the day before, (not even openly he just said “if you’re asking for this break because of what I think you are we will never be the same”) and I then got upset that he had such little faith in me. Anyway, he cheated on me the next day and I felt it when it happened. At 7:30 that day I had started to text him and say “please don’t cheat on me” but i didn’t send it because I didn’t want him to feel how he made me feel a day before. Found out a week later at work by someone else who was gossiping about how the girl he cheated with was showing everyone videos of them fucking. He let her FILM it. Everyone at our job knows we are together. I went to school with that girl. I broke up with him then, but it only lasted a month because I allowed a friend of ours(who I had no idea at the time was a much WORSE serial cheater) convince me it didn’t really count because we were on a break and that he was truly heartbroken over it. This was about a year ago maybe a year and a half ago officially.
Finally, what stupidly was the nail in the coffin even though there has been so much more, him officially branding himself a bigot in my mind: He texted me today saying he was upset and not feeling good. We no longer discuss politics because he is always on the …well if you can’t guess by now which side let’s just say he’s a Andrew Tate(yes even after the conviction, I didn’t find this out until a few days ago. I thought he’d stopped being a fan after that but I never asked bc politics and he just sent me a reel knowing I hate that guy trying to be motivational because I was having a bad day.) and Charlie Kirk fan(also an argument we had that entailed another two days of being ignored and I was told I was being manipulative when I told him Charlie Kirk was a terrible dog whistling person and he threatened to cut me off/break up with me over this man that wouldn’t even like him). Anyways he texts me saying he knows that we don’t talk about politics and he knows where I stand on most stuff, but asks me to look up something happening in our town that very much upset him and how he doesn’t want to even really talk about it because he’s worried he’ll be alone forever because of his thinking on it. I look it up, it’s a bunch of hateful videos and bigotry about a mosque in our town expanding and videos of people in our town meeting screaming about how wrong it is and being antisemitic. I tell him I have no issue with Muslims having somewhere to pray, and that its basically the same as all the 8000 churches we have on every street corner. I also tell him that any reasons I see arguing against it are racist and hateful, so unless he has a good reason outside of bigotry, yes he is going to end up alone. I ALSO have to tell him that the no matter what those reasons may be anyway freedom of religion is a thing and so stripping them of that right is unconstitutional. He pivots and says they started building it ILLEGALLY and that’s his main issue. Wrong again, a quick google check later, not only has the building already been there for 3 years, it went through seven different submittals and code restrictions over the span of 14 months before it could even start building. He then pivots again to: “It’s more of a religious thing. I forget you’re not religious” as if that has anything to do with it. So I ask if it’s a Christian vs Muslims thing bc that’s wrong and if it is they have as much as a right to protest all the churches being built as he does to complain about mosques being built. He then pivots to: **bigotry**. All of a sudden he’s being the only objective one in saying that America is right to be threatened by Muslims right now, not because of us bombing Iran, no but because of how many Muslims hold senate seats and how “Abdul El Sayed won’t denounce the Muslim brotherhood even though it’s a terriorist organization”(yet I’ve never seen him ask any of his favorite white politicians to denounce the KKK) and how Islam is a conquering religion and that we may have freedom of religion but we are a “Christian nation” and everyone seems to have forgotten that.
…Doesn’t sound very objective to me. I tell him that they could say the same about the bible with its slavery, misogynistic, and sexist quotes and depictions. He says as far as he knows Jesus has never said anything misogynistic. I never said Jesus said it, said it was in the bible. He now wants me to point out where that’s in the bible. I am an agnostic/atheist, which as you can see is something he KNOWS and I was clear about before we started dating and he said it was okay. I, the atheist, am now expected to teach this Christian man his own religion. I’m not doing that, Google is free. He also said that people still complain about slavery (remember that the huge genoicde that involved turning people’s skin into leather and feeding babies to crocodiles, yeah that one?) which happened 150+ years ago(pretty sure this isn’t true) but we all seem to be forgetting about 9/11(yeah 9/11 that thing we commemorate literally every year on September 11 yeah that one that people are lowkey convinced was an inside job by Israel or the U.S…we forget about that one🫥). Basically any antisemitic or racist rhetoric people spewed back when Mamdani was running and just started working came out of his mouth.
I stopped responding.
Now this is a tad long and I’m sure many of you are asking, why the hell would you be with someone like this for four years? Well, it’s not a great excuse but I started dating him when I was 16. He was my first body and has remained my only one. I think maybe for the first year or two I thought I could change him. And I say that because as bad as this sounds, he’s really a good guy. Well I guess you can’t really be both bigoted and a good person but he was a good boyfriend atleast in the grand scheme of things. I know he cares deeply about me and he loves me. Probably a lot more than I love him by now. He always talks about how he wants to work hard so I don’t have to stress or work and he’s goofy, and considerate (sometimes?), and a sweetheart. And I think because of that I thought I could fix the part of him that had been broken by incel culture and hate from the internet. And I also think I gave him a big pass because I knew he was just another kid who got taken advantage of the Andrew Tates and the Charlie Kirk’s and the Fresh and Fits. But I’ve realized something.
It’s up to him now to grow out of that mindset. He’s a grown man, and I can’t keep using the excuse that he fell down the right wing rabbit hole when he’s more than capable of getting himself out of it by now. It sucks that he fell in, but he has more than enough resources to crawl back out. He is *happy* where he is in his dark empty hole. And I don’t want to be stuck down there with him anymore.
I also realized I’m not who I was when I started dating him. I’ve become so disconnected, hurt, and frustrated. I don’t feel comfortable making friends anymore because I’m scared they won’t be who I thought they were. I worry I hvave to quiz everyone I want to be friends with on their views and I find myself swallowing up my emotions and thoughts because I don’t want to argue with him and then blaming myself when we argue for even saying anything rather than blaming him for making a problem out of my feelings. I used to be outspoken and my family used to call me the social justice warrior of my family or the annoying one. And yet I’m in love with my polar opposite.
He has literally done to me what he always said his ex did to him. He turned me from the loving girl I was into a cautious girl who doesn’t wear her heart on her sleeve anymore.
But the resentment I hold towards him for everything that’s happened has just begun to outweigh the love I hold for that good part I fell in love with. But it’s not fair to me. I’m younger than him, I shouldn’t be more aware of the world and how the system exploits us wherever and whenever it can than he is. He even gets angry whenever someone tells him he should HAVE to work this hard just to survive, especially not from people who haven’t achieved their dreams because he believes everyone just wants handouts and “*he’s* not like that”.
I hate him so so much for killing the beautiful loving and romantic girl I was when I was 16. I hate him for snuffing out my light and turning me into a shadow of my former self. I hate him for allowing a literal sex trafficker to dictate how he treats others, himself, and me.
But I realized today that I really can’t change him. Or maybe I can, I don’t know. There’s been a few things I’ve been able to get him to flip on like abortion or trump(barely) or even his behavior sometimes. But I don’t *want* to change him anymore. And even if I did want to, HE doesn’t want to change. He doesn’t know he’s a product of hate that could be the perfect man. But he’s okay with who he is. He *loves* who he is. The only times he really gets disappointed with himself is when he mentions his body or his money. But he truly thinks he is peak intellect and I genuinely cannot take it anymore. He is not going to change unless he WANTS to. And I hate that it took me this long to realize it. I hate that I wasted four years of my life on this man. And I hate that I couldn’t help him more. Because he has no idea how miserable he is going to be living with such beliefs, with such *hatred* for those around him who don’t fit *his* standard.
I’ve always heard it, but whoever said “You can’t change those who don’t want to change themselves” was right. And I knew they where, but I truly thought those little pebble sized steps forward could erase boulder sized steps back.
Also, yes I do know it is idiotic that it took what it did for me to hit a breaking point but I guess I was more okay with it when it was all hateful stuff that would really only affect me. I guess I thought I deserved to deal with it. I’ve always hated myself, so maybe I’d come up with my own form of cruel punishment with him. But I refuse ***REFUSE*** to even be involved, or even associated with someone who would say things like that about others that he said today. I want to clarify he has truly never talked about anyone or any group of people the way he spoke to me about Muslims today. How he doesn’t realize those are the exact same things people said years ago about us black people I have no clue. How we were infecting the senate and gonna take over, just ew. I was so disgusted and appalled and I guess that’s where I drew the line.
Again dumb, I know but that’s just kind of my M.O. I basically cursed him out into not saying the r or f slur anymore(he still tries with the r one but will say stuff like “I wanna use a different word but I won’t out of respect for you” like ew that just makes me feel so much worse why even say that) and he does not say or call any women females around me but he is sort of a smart ass about it (ex. Referred to a female cop as a female cop then corrected himself like “sorrryy woman cop I guess” that kind of thing).
Anyways. I’m breaking up with him tomorrow. And during said break up I can’t just blurt out everything he’s done wrong and list it but I also don’t want to just do it without explanation(not that I can’t but I think in this case he needs to know that I’m breaking up with him because of his disgusting beliefs). Anyone got advice on how to go about this appropriately without ending up in another argument/debate but also not avoiding addressing that he needs to work on himself and being a better human being? Also without being mean because if I’m mean or if my tone is “snarky” he gets mad at me and basically just goes straight into defense mode without actually listening to anything I say.
TL/DR: My boyfriend of four years is basically an incel because he fell down that right wing rabbit hole when he was about 14( Andrew Tate, Charlie Kirk, Fresh&Fit, that stuff) and he has grown into a mysogynist bigot who today spat some of the most disgusting antisemitism rhetoric I’ve ever heard(think things said about Abdul El Sayed, or Mamdani) and that was my breaking point. He is a genuinely good guy/boyfriend but basically fell victim to that whole shtick and it’s become his entire personality. After years of trying to fix it or break him out of it I’m at my limit because I’m no longer the loving girl I was when we started dating when I was 16. I realize it’s not my job to change him and I resent him more than I love him now. How can I go about breaking up with him that won’t be mean and hurtful but will still prompt him to want to look into his dangerous and hurtful beliefs and be better? And if you’ve no advice for that can you guys just give me encouragement to do it and not back out? I have a tendency to back down when trying to do this or he will talk me out of it with an apology and us both promising to be better but I know this needs to be done because I’m just avoiding the inevitable. Any thoughts or just support on getting this done is appreciated even if it’s in the form of grilling me for staying this long, thanks.