r/Trading • • 7h ago

Discussion The beginner mistake that feels like progress: collecting information instead of learning

0 Upvotes

The funny thing is that I thought I was learning. Looking back, I was mostly collecting information. And collecting information feels a lot like progress. Until you realize your account balance isn't moving. Then reality shows up. Because the market doesn't care how many videos you've watched, the market doesn't care how many books you've read, the market doesn't care how many definitions you know, the market only rewards understanding and understanding takes time.

That's a passage from something I've been writing, and I see the pattern in a lot of beginner posts here. Another course, another indicator, another YouTube playlist, another Discord. Each one feels productive because you're learning new words. But knowing what a stop loss is doesn't change what you do when a trade goes against you.

What seems to help is the boring version: pick one setup, stay with it long enough to get a real sample, and review your own trades instead of consuming more content. For people further along: what was the point where you stopped collecting and started actually learning?

Educational discussion only, not financial advice. Trading involves risk of loss.


r/Trading • • 4h ago

Discussion I want to start trading.

0 Upvotes

I’m (16M) and I’m decently at maths but have no idea about actual trading I still attend school but I’m fully interested in learning and everything about trading Tipps??


r/Trading • • 3h ago

Discussion Can I really make good money of TRADING?

1 Upvotes

Hey guys I'm 23M.

Im a Computer science graduate and passed out in 2025

I couldn't get placed, i have no job. I have no source of income.

Instead of me wasting time i started learning forex and I'm really hooked into it. It's been around 3 months of trading and I have breached a 5k funded acc and now bought my second account.

Now I'm really into this. I have decided that I want to be a TRADER. But sometimes I will have these thoughts that

Can I really make it?

Is it okay to make this my main source of income?

What if this won't work out and everything is a scam?

Can y'all please help me!!


r/Trading • • 11h ago

Question Just a trader trying to find his way. I need someone to show me the ropes, not sell me dreams.

1 Upvotes

I’ve been putting a lot of effort into developing the right mindset, understanding what I should and shouldn’t do, and approaching trading in a more structured and disciplined way.

I’m not a gambler. I don’t want to take random trades or jump from one strategy to another. I’ve chosen the SMC/ICT path in trading, but I don’t want to blindly follow YouTubers who come up with a completely different strategy every other week.

I’d really appreciate it if someone who sees a bit of their former self in me could help me find a solid, well-structured strategy to stick to.

I’m honestly tired of fake gurus, endless strategies, and all the noise surrounding trading. I just want to focus on learning, mastering one approach, and becoming consistently profitable.

If you’ve been in my position before and managed to find your way, please feel free to DM me. I’d genuinely appreciate any guidance.
Thank you!


r/Trading • • 8h ago

Discussion Can anyone help me with Trading Psychology???

4 Upvotes

Looking for a bit of guidance with trading psychology.

Hi everyone,

I've been learning to trade for quite a few years now, and I feel like I've reached a point where I need to be honest with myself about what's holding me back.

I don't think my biggest problem is necessarily finding trades or understanding the charts. It's what happens emotionally once I'm actually in a trade.

When I'm in drawdown, I sometimes convince myself that the trade will turn around because I still believe in my analysis. Instead of accepting that I might be wrong, I hold on longer than I should, by moving my stop loss.

Then, when I'm in profit, I have the opposite problem. Rather than being happy with what I've made, I start thinking about how much more I could get out of the move. I end up holding on, sometimes giving back profits that I could have banked or I end the trade early and then watch the lost profits.

It's frustrating because I know what I should be doing, but putting it into practice when real money is involved is a completely different story.

I'm not looking for signals, shortcuts or someone to tell me when to buy and sell. I'd genuinely like to learn from someone who has been through this themselves and has managed to develop the discipline to accept both winning and losing trades without letting emotions take over.

I'm willing to put the work in, listen, learn and take constructive criticism. I don't expect anyone to hold my hand or give me all the answers. Sometimes it helps just having someone experienced to talk things through with and learn from.

If anyone has been in a similar position and wouldn't mind sharing their experience or offering a bit of guidance, I'd genuinely appreciate it.

I'm here to learn, improve and become a more disciplined trader. Thanks for taking the time to read this.


r/Trading • • 7h ago

Question is ironfx a scam?

0 Upvotes

good and bad ratings all over, and so many years in the business. just confused at this point


r/Trading • • 13h ago

Question What is the best orderflow/optionflow software?

0 Upvotes

Share your experiences.


r/Trading • • 10h ago

Discussion Hate Tradingview new update limiting my chart Objects to 30. Need to pay to even Backtest

0 Upvotes

This is a bummer for unsuccessful Retail


r/Trading • • 16h ago

Futures Tjr trade recaps

0 Upvotes

Does any1 know where all tjr trade recaps are? They are removed from yt


r/Trading • • 7h ago

Resources Free Trading Journal (Open source & Self hosted)

8 Upvotes

Hey guys i built a trading journal that you can self host on your own machine for free(i built it as a free tradezella alternative for myself) and i wanted to make it publicly available. Because a good trading journal should be free and open sourced.(I am not monitizing it, and never will. Its completely free)

I dont want to oversell it, because its better to just see it yourself. But its better than most paid alternatives.

Hope you find it helpful, enjoy. You can view the live demo before downloading anything.

https://github.com/coreyheyman/roninflow

(Demo: https://coreyheyman.github.io/roninflow/)


r/Trading • • 12h ago

Question Trend trading vs mean reversion

16 Upvotes

I’ve been trading for the past 3.5 years and been profitable for the last 2 years, i did 30R(34%) in my first year as profitable and 53R(65%) in the last 11 months on my trading account. I am primarily swing trading trends on the 4h and daily and i average 31% winrate which has done great with 1% risk, however if i would up it to say 2% the loss streaks would be brutal.

Im thinking about pivoting to a more mean reversion style as this will likely bring up my winrate substantially. The average win will likely be smaller but %return can be dealt with by upping the risk.

Pros of switching:
Higher winrate will probably equal more steady portfolio growth.

I could probably start daytrading as well as trend trading on lower timeframes haven’t been my strenght.

Cons:
I will basically throw out 3.5 years of learning trend trading.

Would like any experienced trader to give me some advice or insight. Thanks

Edit: to add to the pros, evals and funded accounts will likely be easier to pass with a higher winrate


r/Trading • • 6h ago

Discussion Tradingview are wilding ngl.

Post image
3 Upvotes

Never knew I'd have to pay to draw lines on a chart.

Recommend free platforms.


r/Trading • • 8h ago

Technical analysis I stress-tested a $900 gold EA with 3 tests anyone can run with the free demo. It passed one and failed two.

0 Upvotes

I wanted to know if a popular gold EA on the MQL5 Market (My AI Gold, v1.82, $899.95) has a real edge or is fitted to past prices. I didn't buy it: everything below uses its free demo in the MT5 Strategy Tester, on custom symbols built from real broker prices (0.10 fixed lots, all signals allowed).

Its own history looks great: profit factor about 1.7-2.5 on XAUUSD 2016-2026.

Three stress tests:

Test EA profit factor Random entries
Disguised year: 2015 data relabelled as 2016 (it never trades 2015) 2.10 (passed) 0.92
Twin market: gold priced in euro (hourly moves 0.84 correlated with XAUUSD) 1.09 (failed) 0.96
Shuffled days (3 versions) 0.89-1.17 (failed) ~1.0
Shuffled weeks (control) 2.38 ~1.0

The twin-market result is the telling one. The EA's dollar-gold signals, applied to euro-gold prices, still give PF 1.73. But when the EA reads the euro prices itself, only 21% of its entries match, and the edge is gone. Small changes in the price path flip most of its decisions. Our own run on the last six months (June-November 2026) gave PF 1.06.

My take: it's not an empty backtest, since it held up on the disguised year. But the edge looks tied to the exact XAUUSD price history. It could be fitted, or it could depend on dollar-specific moves; only new data will tell.

Limits: one demo broker's data, 1-minute OHLC modelling, management reconstructed from reports (SL $40, TP $25, close at +$16).

No affiliation with the developer, no affiliate links, not investment advice.

Sources: product page · independent review on MQL5

Have you ever bought a bot that kept its backtest edge live? What do you check before paying?

Happy to answer questions about the method.


r/Trading • • 15h ago

Discussion Are We Trading the Market or Just Following the Crowd?

3 Upvotes

Hello traders and investors!

I want to start a discussion about the Indian stock market, especially NIFTY 50 and BANK NIFTY.

The market can be unpredictable. Sometimes technical indicators give clear signals, but price action behaves completely differently.

I would love to know how other traders approach the market.

A few questions for discussion:

  1. Do you prefer price action, indicators, or pure order flow trading?
  2. How do you identify fake breakouts and liquidity sweeps?
  3. Do you use VWAP, Volume Profile, Delta, or market structure for entries?
  4. What is your biggest challenge in intraday trading?
  5. What is more important for consistent profitability: strategy, risk management, or psychology?

r/Trading • • 23h ago

Discussion How do you tell the difference between a genuine trading opportunity and FOMO?

4 Upvotes

Something I've been thinking about recently is how quickly the fear of missing out can change the way we interpret a chart.

You might have a clear set of conditions you're waiting for, but then a share price starts moving and suddenly you feel pressured to enter.

The interesting part is that the market hasn't necessarily provided any new evidence supporting your original plan. It's the feeling of urgency that's changed.

I've started thinking that asking why I want to enter a trade is just as important as deciding where.

For those who journal their trades, do you record when FOMO influenced your decisions? And has that helped you identify patterns?