r/TransChristianity • u/IDontEvenKnowAlt • 3h ago
My mom handed me a printout of the Catholic Church's teaching on "gender theory." I need some help knowing what to do with this.
I've lived as a woman for the past four years. My parents have known for three, and I've been on HRT for more than two of that. Outside of my parents, nobody really sees me as a man. Yet the pressure is still there. I'm currently trapped living with my parents, since I graduated college, and I acknowledge that it's going to take some time for them to understand, but that doesn't make it any less painful. I don't have a job, or any means right now of living on my own, so I have to live every day hiding my gender, and it's painful. When I told them, tonight, that y'know, maybe I'm so withdrawn because I'm literally not myself, they acted as if I'd offended them or demanded they accepted me, when it's just the truth. I'm severely depressed, stuck in a life that doesn't feel worth living. I cope with bad habits, I spend every day smoking copious amounts of weed, and hiding that too.
With tonight's argument, my mom brought up how the Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church officially denounces gender theory. She genuinely believes that if I do not stick with our conservative Roman Catholic tradition, I am going to be living in sin, and going to hell. My dad, even if he's more willing to live and let live, likely feels something similar. That's what makes it painful. She genuinely believes she's trying to save me.
I skimmed it. I mean, I already see some issues (greatest possible difference? there's so much to be said about how sex characteristics overlap so much). But of course, part of me is still scared. I'm doing a sex change. I identify as transsexual. I want a vagina someday. I would do almost anything to have a uterus. The assumptions it makes about sex change are just wrong, but I don't know how to convince my mom otherwise. I don't know if I can.
I'm worried she's going to use this against me more. I don't even consider myself as being away from God. Back in college, I enjoyed going to the Episcopal service with my girlfriend at the time--also trans. My best friend, who's also trans, talks to me about faith all the time, especially since I introduced her to the Episcopal church. Honestly, my ideal religion is probably "Catholicism if it was just Mary and unabashedly woke and feminist." My mom brought me a Miraculous Medal home from her pilgrimage in France, and I feel so proud and happy to have something that so evokes our Blessed Mother around my neck.
And in her eyes, I'm still a lost sheep. I don't blame her. I'm a bisexual socialist stoner who's lost track of her body count. But I love God, which means the Catholic guilt is still there. And of course, reading this blatant rebuke of everything I've fought for stings a little. I guess I need some help knowing what to do about this, how to process this, how to respond to this--everything, I guess.