The consensus among our community is that Rise of the Titans was really bad. I disagree and I would like to hear what you all think about my interpretation of several controversial parts of the movie.
Over the past summer, I rewatched the entire series and then the movie. Throughout my rewatch, I realized that I didn't remember Rise of the Titans. I thought that I had actually never watched it. That brings me to my first point.
After rewatching the movie, I realized that I had definitely seen it, but I remembered everything that happened as just being the finale to Wizards. From my viewpoint, RotT feels just like the rest of the series. But I do recognize that "the vibes are the same" is not a good argument whatsoever. So let's go through an itemized list of gripes I've seen with the movie.
First, MPreg! I'll admit, Steve getting pregnant is kinda weird, especially considering he is a teenager (about 19/20 I think). but also, this works really well to wrap up his redemption arc. In the earlier episodes of Trollhunters, Steve displays obvious misogyny, as is typical for the jock bully archetype. Throughout the later seasons, he fully redeems himself through his heroics and showing genuine care to Eli, Jim, etc. In 3 Below, this climaxes with Steve and Aja's relationship.
Despite this, Steve's misogyny still shows through at times. Steve very much shows that he has strong beliefs in traditional gender roles throughout 3 Below with his obsession with maintaining his masculinity and dealing with him feeling inferior as he sees that Aja is much stronger and independent than he wants to believe. With the ending of Steve's redemption arc in RotT, Steve's pregnancy and Aja fully displaying her strength as a warrior queen completely flips the gender roles that Steve had wanted to fill, and yet, Steve is comfortable and happy with it.
Now, time to address the elephant in the room: the ending. In Rise of the Titans, we are faced with the tragic deaths of some of the most beloved characters. And while Tales of Arcadia is no stranger to killing its characters, these deaths hit much harder. Strickler's death was a beautiful scene and an end to his character arc. From villain to savior. From trying to kill Jim to sacrificing himself for Jim's cause. And yet, it wasn't worth it in the end. Even with Strickler's great sacrifice, they still failed the mission. That is what makes Strickler's death so much more tragic. This is the moment when the entire tone shifts for the rest of the movie.
The tone slowly rises back up as we reach the final battle. And just when we see our heroes win, we notice someone's missing. Jim finds Toby buried in the rubble. Toby gave the most noble sacrifice for his best friend. He was the final decider of the battle. This incredibly emotional moment looks like the end. Jim is devastated. Wouldn't we all, had we lost our closest friend? And as much as this moment is about losing Toby, this is actually the defining moment in Jim's character arc.
Merlin's amulet chose Jim for a single reason. Jim's humanity would be the factor that saves trollkind. And yet, Merlin transforms Jim into a troll and we have to watch in pain as Jim loses part of that humanity. Eventually, you could say that Jim was more troll than he was human. And while this made him so much more powerful, it took away the gift that made him the greatest Trollhunter.
At the end of Wizards, Jim finally regains his human form. Yet you have to imagine, he spent so long as a troll. That must have left quite the mental scar. So the transition back to human would be rough, especially as the world is on the verge of extinction once again. Toby's death fully snaps Jim back to being fully human. All sense of putting the mission first is gone. And this leads Jim to make his infamous decision. The decision that strikes controversy through our entire fandom. Jim rewinds time back to the day he found the amulet, and instead, lets Toby find it.
The obvious argument for why this decision makes no sense is that we have already seen why Jim was the Trollhunter. This argument stems from season 2, episode 11 of Trollhunters, "Unbecoming". In this episode, Jim wishes that he never became the Trollhunter and is then granted a vision by Merlin that shows him why he was chosen and the chaos that would come from any other outcome. And while this evidence for the ending not making sense sounds good on paper, there are a few things to consider.
First of all, with the reset at the end of RotT, Jim keeps his memories when he goes back. And with Toby as the Trollhunter, Jim will still be part of the team. And that will bring along with it Claire. In this timeline, Strickler will not put Barbara in danger. And with Toby as the Trollhunter and Jim still possessing the fruits of his training and his knowledge, they will be able to accomplish their missions with much more success.
Secondly, we have seen throughout The Tales of Arcadia that Merlin is unreliable. So we can't necessarily trust the timeline that he showed Jim. Merlin's ego often gets in the way of him seeing possibilities other than the one he believes. We also know that Merlin does not mess with time travel, so it's reasonable to assume that what Jim was shown was completely fabricated based on Merlin's beliefs. In the alternate timeline, it's shown that the amulet did not choose a human. This wouldn't make much sense though since Jim was chosen for his humanity. You'd think that if Jim wasn't chosen, the amulet still would have chosen a human. This leads me to believe that the timeline is indeed a fabrication of Merlin's, and that this is an oversight on his behalf.
Assuming that both of these points are true, it would make sense that Jim also realizes these things as he has become rather insightful throughout the series. With this in mind, I would say it is safe to assume that even though Jim's decision to reset the timeline looked like an act of desperation and emotion, it was still a strategic decision. And if it wasn't, Merlin said that Jim's humanity is his greatest strength, and what is more human than sacrificing everyone for the people you love?