r/Troy • u/CollarCityCitizens • 10h ago
An Appearance of Conflict at the Land Bank
It is the purview of land banks such as the Troy Community Land Bank (TCLB) to acquire distressed properties and rehabilitate them to ensure their return to productive use on the tax rolls as livable homes.
One clear and common pipeline for acquisition of these properties is the City’s tax-foreclosure list, which in September included 2215 Old Sixth Ave, a distressed and vacant 2-family structure flanked on either side by City-owned lots up for auction on or around Sep 20.
Land bank acquisition of this type of property depends on many factors, including condition, cost, available grant funds and staff time, so these parcels are reviewed by the Land Bank’s Acquistion and Disposition Committee, which evaluates available properties and makes recommendations to the full board for final determination.
The New York, the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law § 1614 and Public Authorities Accountability Act, which restrict board members of public agencies from acting in conflict with the taxpayer-funded organizations they steer, and require disclosure of potential conflicts of interest to agency boards for review.
So it was with some surprise that I saw Magur Holdings, registered to TCLB Board Chair Jamie Magur, as the intended recipient of 2215 Old Sixth as part of Ordinance 48 at the November 5 Council meeting.
Having followed the Land Bank closely for some time (and with great admiration for the work done under executive director Brad Lewis), I was aware that the September 7 instance of the A&D Committee, which Magur, a Mantello appointment, chairs, was cancelled due to lack of quorum after Magur didn’t show up, leaving TCLB unable to bid on any of the auctioned properties later that month. (Note that 1 member of the 3 member committee arrived to the meeting, 2 were required for quorum.) No disclosure as to Magur’s intended purchase of 2215 Old Sixth Ave, a property on the foreclosure list, was made to the board ahead of time (Magur had apparently communicated his intention to purchase the property, demolish the existing structure, and work with a local developer to build new on-site to neighbors, however), in spite of the clear appearance of conflict Magur’s bid created.
Whether a mistake born of ignorance, an abuse of authority, or a mixture of the two, Magur’s actions act to diminish the community’s trust in the Land Bank and its partner entities, and call into question its competency as an organization.
At any rate, City Council amended the ordinance in question to strike the authorization for conveyance of the property in question, citing Troy City Code § 83-4, which requires sale of City-owned property to employees to receive pre-approval from the Law Committee, a step which Magur also failed to complete.
Discussion surrounding the conveyance of 2215 Old Sixth and the Land Bank’s procedure for resolving conflicts of interest are expected to be topics of discussion at the TCLB November Board meeting, scheduled November 18 at 8:30 am. An agenda can be found here.