r/TrueAnon • u/Apart_Distribution72 • 22h ago
Fellow USians, do you ever feel like being American makes the things you do less inherently valuable?
This is a feeling I struggle with a lot, that living in this contrived society makes everything I do less authentic, that the things I create are inherently tainted by the context of their creation.
I try to believe that creating art is inherently valuable, that when I play my banjo and sing a song I'm doing something meaningful. I try to believe that I'm making queer art, that I'm standing proud in the face of fascism and continuing to bear my soul in the face of oppression.
I don't really know that that's true. I'm a white person in the imperial core. Being queer or trans doesn't negate the fact that first and foremost, I'm white and American.
There is a lot of racial infighting within the trans community right now as white trans folks are reeling with the fact that being trans doesn't make us any less oppressive. We are oppressed, sure, but we're oppressors first. We're in an odd position, being just as culpable as cis white people in the continued oppression of BIPOC communities, while also having significantly less social and political power to do anything to change it.
It's hard to feel like the things I do have value when I know that every advantage I've had in life was directly stolen from a non-white, probably non-American person. It feels a bit narcissistic to put myself on a pedestal and declare that the things I do are meaningful just because I'm a trans woman. It also feels narcissistic to sit here and mope about how I feel like everything is contrived and nothing matters while being incredibly privileged to live in the imperial core at all. "Woe is me nothing I do is serious because I live in a deeply unserious country that has also given me incredible privilege and opportunities." It's kinda pathetic, but I still feel this way. Oh well.
All I can do is keep fighting for what's right, try to uplift more oppressed voices, and deal with the fact that any kind of self determination or actualization I perform is likely going to be tainted with the curse of American individuality and exceptionalism.