We are developing a tool where users create a parent entity (similar to a page in Notion) that can reference multiple child entities (sub-pages or blocks). The challenge is that, at the time the parent is created, these child entities often do not yet exist.
The Problem:
Users are forced to interrupt the parent creation process, create each child—along with all required metadata—separately, and then return to link everything together. This creates an annoying disruption, especially when the user is still in the process of designing the parent's structure.
Example:
Notion handles this issue effectively. Within an existing page, you can type `[[New Page]]`, even if that page does not yet exist. A link is created immediately; when you click it, Notion generates a new page that is linked to its parent from the very start.
Approaches We Are Considering
- Inline Child Creation: Opening a small window (modal) or a sliding panel (drawer) from within the parent creation form to capture the child's details, then automatically linking it upon saving.
- Using Placeholder References: Allowing users to add references to child entities that do not yet exist, and subsequently "resolving" these references—either through background processes or via the user interface.
- Draft State for the Parent: The ability to save the parent as a "draft" until all child entities are created, or to publish it while marking incomplete child entities as "pending."
- Separation of Design and Execution Phases: Allowing users to first build the parent-child structure, and subsequently transition it into a fully operational structure once all required entities have been created. (Similar to how nested components and instances are managed in Figma).
How have you approached this challenge in similar products or systems? I am particularly interested in learning about the practical patterns employed in tools like Notion, Coda, Airtable, Linear, Figma, or other editors based on hierarchical structures. In practice, which approach yielded the best results, and what trade-offs did you encounter?