Today, I had one of the most frustrating experiences at work, and I honestly need to get this off my chest.
I'm working as a junior UI/UX designer at a startup. We have three designers in total: two juniors (including me) and one senior designer.
Recently, our founder decided to change the brand colours, tweak some already designed screens, and even design a major section of our mobile app using AI.
Now, I have nothing against using AI in the design process. It can be a great tool. But the problem is that the designs he's producing are extremely cluttered and visually overwhelming. There's too much information competing for the user's attention, the screens are congested, and the overall experience feels heavily inspired by Japanese and Chinese social media and service provider apps. Very flashy, too many things happening in one place, and honestly, not particularly user-friendly.
During a discussion, I tried to raise some genuine UX concerns.
I asked whether we had any user testing results, market research, competitor analysis, or any meaningful data to support these design decisions. Because, from what I can see, we're mostly designing UI based on references from TikTok, Instagram, and other existing platforms. Taking inspiration from competitors is perfectly fine, but shouldn't we have some reasoning behind what we're borrowing and why?
I wanted to understand the actual users, their behaviour, their expectations, and how we intend to position our product in the market.
That's when things went downhill.
Instead of discussing the points I raised, the founder started complaining about how much time he was wasting, how much money he was losing, and how hard he was working.
At one point, I suggested that perhaps he could bring in someone to help manage some of his responsibilities so he could focus on his other businesses. He had previously mentioned (and repeatedly highlighted) that he runs multiple businesses with several employees working under him.
His response?
"Then why did I hire three designers if I need to hire another person?"
I genuinely don't know how he connected those two things. I wasn't suggesting hiring another designer. I was talking about management and delegation.
I then tried to explain that I naturally lean more towards the UX side of product design. I want to understand how real users will interact with the product, how they'll react to certain features, what the actual market looks like, and where we can position ourselves.
That's why I ask these questions. Not because I want to challenge his authority or prove that his designs are wrong.
But apparently, he took it personally.
He seemed to interpret my feedback as a direct challenge to his AI generated designs. The discussion turned into a rather uncomfortable meeting where he indirectly threw several negative comments at me.
And the frustrating part? He even started blaming our senior designer, questioning his work and capabilities.
For context, our senior designer is genuinely one of the most patient, generous, and talented people I've worked with. Sure, sometimes he leans more towards Behance-worthy aesthetics and overlooks certain usability, accessibility, and WCAG considerations. But whenever I explain my reasoning, he listens, shares his perspective, and we usually find common ground.
That's what I consider a healthy design discussion. You don't have to agree with everything, but you should at least be willing to listen.
Now, there's another thing that makes this whole situation even more frustrating.
The founder provided us with a document containing specific design instructions. I followed those instructions while designing, even though I personally felt that some of them would lead to a poor user experience.
The other junior designer, however, didn't really follow those instructions. Some of their designs also failed accessibility considerations, used colours that didn't align with the brand guidelines, and occasionally had confusing interactions.
But here's the interesting part: when we presented our designs, the founder preferred the other junior designer's work.
Their designs were visually beautiful, I'll give them that. But sometimes they were confusing, used much darker shades than the actual brand colours, and didn't necessarily follow the provided guidelines.
So what's the point of providing design instructions in the first place?
I could also create visually impressive, Behance-worthy screens. That's not the issue. But I was trying to follow the instructions I was given, even when I disagreed with some of them.
I'm not claiming to be the best designer in the room. I make mistakes too. My senior designer regularly points them out, explains what I'm doing wrong, and guides me through the process. And I genuinely appreciate that because that's how you grow as a designer.
But today made me realise something about the founder.
He seems to want designers who execute his ideas rather than designers who question, analyse, and contribute to the product's direction.
He wants feedback, perhaps, but only when it agrees with his own decisions.
And if you disagree, even with a valid UX argument, he takes it personally.
I understand that founders have enormous responsibilities. They're investing their money, taking risks, managing people, and trying to build something. I respect that.
But does being a founder automatically make someone right about every design decision?
Shouldn't design be a collaborative process? Shouldn't we be able to question decisions, ask for data, discuss usability, and disagree without someone turning it into an ego battle?
I'm a junior designer, and I genuinely want to learn. But I also don't want to spend my career blindly executing UI without understanding the UX behind it.
So, to other designers, especially those working in startups:
- Have you ever worked with a founder who takes constructive design feedback personally?
- How do you handle situations where the founder makes design decisions based on personal preferences rather than research or usability?
- At what point do you stop trying to explain UX principles and simply do what you're told?
- Am I expecting too much from a startup environment, or is this a genuinely unhealthy design culture?
Honestly, I'm not sure whether I handled the conversation correctly, but I know I don't want to lose my interest in UX just because someone doesn't want to hear about it.