At the beginning of the game the vast majority of husks are described being as hardly intelligent, with almost nothing carried over from the person they were in life. Which seems weird since that way they can’t really understand their punishment, I mean, they’re hardly even the person who earned it.
And then we kind of see them presented as people anyways, like in the Sisyphean army, the souls trying to break free of the leviathan, or people organizing an escape from violence. Gabriel asks himself “how many had I killed” as if 90% of them weren’t unfeeling beasts.
How would the lust layer form into a city with trains and homes if 10% of the resident were capable of human thought?
Idk it just doesn’t really fit together with the idea that we’re supposed to sympathize with the sinners.