Finally tired of fighting my REI Sub-Kilo mummy bag (950g). It's rated at 20F but I start getting cold at 40F and am quite comfortable in it at 60F, so I doubt that rating. After the trip where I got cold at 40F I moved from a R2 Amazon pad to R 5.4 Nemo Tensor. I don't thru hike but I do count every gram, so the weight savings on a quilt are motivating. I have never used down anything so will be learning about lofting, but I always loft everything in the field.
I'm looking for comfort into the mid-to-high 30s F. I want to be able to open the footbox and use it as a top blanket up to 60F if possible (I sleep cold).
My comparisons:
Zenbivy UL Large 25F: $389, 538g, 326g @ 900FP fill
Waratah Pro 32F: $290, 513g, 323g @ 950FP
Katabatic Flex 30F: $389, 600g, 357g @ 850FP
HMG: expensive, the 40F seems like not enough and the 20F seems too much quilt.
Questions:
Am I looking in the right temperature range? Everyone says to shop comfort ratings but this info seems hard to come by and only the Waratah explicitly states a comfort rating.
Zenbivy gets a lot of hate and Katabatic much love, but it seems like these two quilts are the same price, equivalent warmth based on FP, and the Katabatic is heavier. What am I missing?
The Waratah seems too good to be true? Zenbivy just announced a BF 30% deal via email starting this weekend so the Zenbivy would actually be cheaper at that point. Comments on Waratah versus Zenbivy?
The Zenbivy bed looks intriguing to me. It seems like any of these could be converted for use with that bed. Are drafts really an issue sleeping in a tent (BA Tiger Wall Carbon), or is that mostly a tarp thing? Any other benefits to the bed?
Feels like I'm leaning towards Zenbivy after typing that out. Many thanks in advance.