Hey all, I've been going round in circles on this for ages, so I'm hoping some of you can talk sense into me.
I'm after one UL bag I can just grab for pretty much anything outside proper winter and not have to think "am I going to be cold tonight?", without lugging a heavy bag around. So I'm looking at something around 20F/-6C.
At the moment I'm using an Aegismax Dusk II. I've had it down to -4C and was fine, but I'd have liked to be a bit warmer. It's also a 7D shell, and it's already got a few holes where the zip has caught and ripped the fabric. That's what's got me stuck: do I stick with 7D for the weight, or go 10D for a bit more durability? Or am I overthinking it and should I just go 20D?
The ones I'm stuck between:
- Cumulus X-Lite 400: comes to about £473 for me with DHL and UK import VAT, which stings. I think it's 7D, same as what's already ripping on me.
- Therm-a-Rest Hyperion 20 UL Long: about £380 from a UK shop, 10D.
- Rockfront 450 UL
A bit about me and how I'll use it:
- I'm in the UK, so it's mostly damp cold, and condensation is a thing.
- Next year I'm doing the Camino del Norte straight into GR5/TMB, about 2.5 months back to back. I know -6C is overkill for most of that, but I want the margin, and the bag needs to survive months of daily stuffing and damp mornings.
- I'm 6'1" (185cm). The X-Lite Regular maxes out at exactly 185cm, which makes me a bit nervous, especially with a puffy on.
- I'm a warm sleeper.
- Base weight is usually 3-4kg. Shelter is a MLD Cricket Pro tarp in silpoly with a Tyvek bivy, so it's pretty open and the bag will see a fair bit of damp and breeze.
- Mat is a Robens zigzag CCF, with a 1/8" pad under it when needed. I've got an XTherm for winter.
- I've already got a Rab Ascent 900 for winter, but I want this to be my go-to for most trips.
- No quilts please, I've tried them and just don't get on with them.
So my questions:
- 7D vs 10D: has anyone done a long thru-hike with either and how did the shell hold up? Is 10D actually noticeably tougher, or is it worth going 20D?
- Has anyone used two or more of these and can compare them?
- Is the Cumulus worth roughly £90 more after import fees?
- Anything else I should be looking at? I've seen the Alpkit Pipedream 400, Rab Neutrino 400, ME Helium 400 and Criterion Quantum 450 mentioned.
Cheers in advance