r/UniversalExtinction • u/Par-Adox-9 • 2d ago
Question The paradox or Extinctionism
How do you reconsile the following facts:
- that only creatures which suffer wish for extinction, or would extinguish themselves
- Creatures who do not suffer would not extinguish themselves even if they wish for extinction broadly.
So in order for extinctionism to reach ita goal, it has to produce suffering, but, ita against suffering, so it has to create a self fulfilling prophecy whareby it creates more suffering which proves to it that it should end life and justifies that it should create more suffering, circularly.
And if not that, then its reduced to passively waiting for people who dont suffer to for some reason be convinced that the mear existance of suffering should imply that we aught take the choice of all beings whoch could be, thining that we know better then the unborn about whether they should not be born. - Someone that is born can chose to die, while someone who is not born can not chose to live, hence, there is more freedom in being forced to be alive, then to be forcefully prevented from being born ( "forcefuly prevented" in the sense that we have a desire to reprosuce initially, and only through cirtain conceptual understanding do we create a physically unbreachable boundery when we decide to not reproduce and when all of lifes circumstances allowed us to actually never reproduce, and so the "forcefully" in that term, refers to the fact that only a stronger force can stop a weaker force, and we are made of different forces, hence all acts are forcefull in one way or another, so dont get me wrong, im not aaying that there is anything particularly more forceful about not reproducing)
- If what we call "non-living" matter has no feelings, then who is extinction for, when there would be no one living to apreciate extinction nor even to notice the difference.
- If realoty come from nothing then even if its destroyed, it can arrise again.
If nothing can create something, then that nothong already exists and is something, thus existance is eternal.
If life arrose once by some arrangement of matter, and if reality is eternal, then reality will keep producing life from time to time forever, with no actual way to end it universally.
Not to mention, infinity is big enough that we could never account for all beings that exist.
6. If the only way to reach safety is enough of a cirtain kind of knowledge, and the only way to have knowledge is to be alive, but in order to have the type of knowledge nreded is to evolve both the animal and the system of signs and concepts(language), and use it to build technology and ideology, medicine and so on.
Then, isnt extinction simply making it so that all progress made is destroyed right at the point at which we are most able to create a better world, for the fact that
A) we would be more capable
B) but more importantly, that we would be empathetic enough to care to reduce suffering to begin with
If empathy leads to extinction, then the very precondition for making life better, gets subverted in sabotaging the only chance life has from blind and eternal suffering with no actual time period in which to enjoy its existance.
And if indeed reality is eternal, whether ot not the universe is eternal, if its matter is eternal, and if hypotheticallly, every civilisation that gets to our level allways evolves to comit extinction, then we would be doomed to alleays suffer eithout any hope for at the very least, sometimes reaching a state of existance, whare we are safe, curious, and enjoy life as a whole society with the least amounr if unfortunate suffering as possible.
In the universe in which extinction is garanteed upon recieving knowlerge— what gets created, is a world in which only pergatory and hell exist, without even the slightest chance of a more widespread and longlasting heaven, except for brief moments, which are otherwise outwighed by the suffering and lack of experience.
Sure, we will allways be doomed to forget all of this whether or not its heaven, hell, or pergatory, but even so, an experience matters only when we have it, and besides that, it doesnt matter in a broader sense, even if we do care about the experiences of others, which i do, its nevertheless the case that the reality they percieve and the one i do, are a world appart, and no matter what i do i can never feel what its like to be them, nor they can feel what its like to be me in any given moment, and so, if we have the chance to either actually experience mostly hell even if we forget it, or actually experience heaven even if we forget it, then its much better to actually experience heaven at least some of that time, rather then none of it.
Non life, not jon existance, but non life, presumably, has no feelings, and so time isnt experienced inbetween one life and then death, ans then the very next moment of life, its like one never died, but just lost their memories and entered a different body.
Again, nonlife, isnt an experience, its nothing at all in terms of feelings, so there is no sense of restfulness in it.
leaving things to the unintelegable machinations of nature with no intelect, will allways end up in blind suffering, untill extinction.
Do you think humans cause so much suffering because we got smarter?
Yes, it is true on one hand, for had we less power over knowledge, we couldnt cause the suffering.
But in another sense; in the sense of our social psyfhological, political fields of life, we are primitive beyond belief, and thats why we use the blessings of science, philosophy, technology and art, on evil and suffering.
Were we more advanced in matters of society, of the humanities, we would be a much kinder joyous, curious species, even if we had all the weapons.
So this is the paradox, or paradoxes of Extinctionism.
Mind you, i dont believe that there are beliefs that lack paradoxes, and so i find paradoxes in all philosophical movements, because a paradox is like a driving energy, or a prepulsion mechanism, and so the reason i point thease out, is to ask, whether thease outcomes are worth it, because thats all that really matters, it doesnt matter if its a paradox or not if it actualy makes things better, but i hope that i have sufficiently proven to any materialist or non materialist, that this is unfortunately not something that can lead to good outcomes, pretty much no mater how we spin it, and in fact, it crrates only bad outcomes, unless we talk about individuals who suffer too much who sadly decide to end it because they cant take the extreme suffering, but otherwise, if we talk about a whole species, well, only if none of them wanted to live and reproduce, should they not do so, and even then, they would be simply sabotaging the evolution process in order for the temporary relief— because again, their matter will reformulate again, and have to go through alllll that evolution to get to a better place, and then bam, extinction again, and so, matter then, will have such a low chance of actually being accidentally born into a good world
Hence, extinctionism is a self fulfilling prophecy which either needs more suffering to sucseed, and then, even if it does sucseed, it creates more suffering as a result of its sabotage of reaching enough knowledge to reduce suffering.