Sharing this so nobody else wastes an afternoon on it.
I applied to a recommendation-system job on Upwork. I’m quite qualified for it (I’m the author of Cicerone, a self-hosted recommender system), so I sent a full proposal. That's my use of Upwork, I go twice a week and search for recommendation systems jobs, I learn and get paid for it, while being useful to the customer and eventually improving my own project. The client was freeleaps, which is itself a freelance marketplace. Their reply was a screenshot of a “quote here” button pointing to their site.
You can’t click a screenshot, so I told them I was interested, had my quote ready ($1,400), and asked for the direct link to the project page.
Their answer: they “can’t do that considering Upwork rule,” so I should sign up on freeleaps as a freelancer, find the job and quote there.
Let me get this straight. Sending a link to the project would break Upwork’s rules, but getting me to register on your own competing marketplace is fine? Bold reading of the ToS.
Normally I’d have walked away right there. But recommendation systems are one of my real interests, so I did something I wouldn’t usually do: I signed up and quoted. A few days later I got the rejection, on freeleaps of course. My plan was “one of the clearest we received,” but they went with someone cheaper. They’ll post more work like this on Freeleaps, and I’m welcome to quote again. Stay tuned!
So here’s the setup: a freelance marketplace posts a job on Upwork, and to bid you have to create an account on their marketplace, where they reject you and invite you back for more. Whether or not the job was real, it worked as a signup funnel paid for by Upwork’s traffic. And it works best on exactly the people who actually care about the subject.
Even if the job was 100% real, they had the exact same proposal on Upwork. They could have read it and turned it down right there. Instead they had me spend unpaid time setting up an account and quoting all over again on their platform, and that time happens to have bought them a new user. Funny how that works.
A few points:
- A competitor using Upwork to move freelancers onto its own platform is the kind of circumvention the ToS is meant to stop. Sending a screenshot instead of a link tells you they knew it. I’ve reported the message.
- If a client answers your proposal by sending you to another site to “quote,” check who owns that site. Here it was the client.
- Your time spent quoting is unpaid either way. Don’t let anyone add extra steps to it unless the steps benefit you.
On the bright side, I now have a freeleaps account I’ll never use (also because they just have no jobs to join basically), and some very polite feedback telling me I’m clear but expensive. 10/10, would get recruited again.
Has anyone else applied to an Upwork job from freeleaps, or from another platform, and been told to sign up on their site before you could quote?