r/UrbanHell • u/Mailman354 • Dec 22 '24
Concrete Wasteland Why does this sub rush to defend Japan? I've been there5 times. Love it. But it's urban centers arnt above criticism
Like Yes Japan is clean Organized Plenty to do Culture Trains
But it's still got urban congestion(i will forever hate Osaka-Umeda) and crowding
And lots of its cities are just gray.
I've traveled all over the US and Korea and Japan. I make it a point to always got to a tower of there is one
Tokyo, Japan from Skytree is simultaneously an awesome view(seeing Fuji when it's visible in the winter, the absolutely gargantuan size of Tokyo) but also the most depressing(gray, gray, gray, a sea of GRAAAAAAAAAY for miles).
Pointing these out doesn't mean JapanBAD
Again I've loved my time in Japan. Went there one, went back four more times. Probably going back more.
But I could never live in Japan(or Korea) permanently. For work? Sure, looking at jobs there now.
Forever? Absolutely not
The small living quarters and cramped congestion feels inhumane.
I'm not even space greedy. I just don't want to live in a small quarter. I want a house, with a backyard maybe even a few bushes and a tree.
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 22 '24
Do not comment to gatekeep that something "isn't urban" or "isn't hell". Our rules are very expansive in content we welcome, so do not assume just based off your false impression of the phrase "UrbanHell"
UrbanHell is any human-built place you think is worth critizing. Suburban Hell, Rural Hell, and wealthy locales are allowed. Gatekeeping comments may be removed. Want to shitpost about shitty posts? Go to /r/urbanhellcirclejerk. Still have questions?: Read our FAQ.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
234
u/ivlivscaesar213 Dec 22 '24
Yeah Japan’s urban density is crazy and that’s coming from someone who was born and raised here
Though Umeda is nothing compared to Shibuya, Shinjuku etc
499
u/fruityfox69 Dec 22 '24 edited Dec 22 '24
Tokyo is one of the lowest scoring cities in geenspace per capita of any large city
274
u/sakuratanoshiii Dec 22 '24
In Tokyo I could afford to live in an apartment by myself but in Australia I can't. Also I have to have a car here.
I really miss my 9 tatami apato. There are lots of little parks and peaceful places dotted about in neighbourhoods. Also the shopping street in my neighbourhood was amazing and the people were friendly and kind.
99
u/Eis_ber Dec 22 '24
The reason it's overcrowded is because the majority of the job opportunities are within a select number of cities which could be a point of criticism since the rest of japan is getting more and more empty. Nothing wrong with wanting a house with a yard and some greens, but then you have the far opposite end of the spectrum where nothing is built with efficiency in mind and it's all designed to only serve cars and waste space.
74
u/GoyleTheCreator Dec 22 '24
Loads of good reasons here but one that came to mind is reddit is full of young people that LOVE japan. There's a ton of weebs on this site. r/anime has 12 million subscribers. It's one of the top communities, bar the default ones that reddit assigns to every new account. Japan and now recently South Korea has presented itself as very cool places. Rightfully so, I think they're fucking awesome.
10
u/TIFUPronx Dec 22 '24
Either these are their justifications:
a) tokyo problems are "developed world problems" compared to the likes of manila, mumbai, sao paolo & port-au-prince.
b) people who like dense urban-living in general more despite of its problems.
c) they're weebs/eastasiaboos, self-explanatory.
c) all (or some) of the above lol.
91
u/RiverWithywindle Dec 22 '24
The weebs on this website are so hilarious
12
u/Fungled Dec 22 '24
I agree absolutely that Japanese cities are very often gray and extremely ugly. But as cities, they functional excellently. There are also plenty of cities around the world that are both ugly and broken
76
u/No-Section-1092 Dec 22 '24
Surprise: Big cities with lots of people have lots of people.
When lots of people want to live on limited land, the more density increases.
One major reason Western urbanists praise Japan is because they have an extremely abundant and affordable housing stock. They make it incredibly easy to build and crank out housing at scale like nobody’s business.
The downside is it’s not all pretty. The upside is it’s mostly cheap, which is more important, because people need shelter to survive.
Furthermore, Japanese transit is top notch and almost all neighbourhoods allow mixed use, which makes it very easy to live without cars.
There are literally plenty of areas of Japan where you can have this too.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
What are you talking about? One of the first things I noticed when I was there was a) ease of walk-ability b) despite being a huge city the residential areas even around central areas were quieter than your average suburb
24
u/squiddlane Dec 22 '24
I live in Tokyo and I'm 15 minute walking distance to three incredible parks.
Theres also dozens of little neighborhood parks that are smaller scattered throughout the neighborhoods. Everything is walking or biking accessible. Trains everywhere. You don't need to have a car. Apartments range from tiny and super affordable to huge and unaffordable. There's a shitload of single family houses, many of which have yards.
People defend Tokyo because it's legitimately a nice place to live.
50
u/JapanPizzaNumberOne Dec 22 '24
Does this guy expect Megacities to be purple or something?
17
u/CurtisLui Dec 22 '24
The r/urbanhellcirclejerk subreddit is just for you!
32
u/Local_Gur9116 Dec 22 '24
Lol the weebs jumped to the rescue
10
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
Where tree?
16
u/innnerthrowaway Dec 22 '24
There are some really pretty spots and I appreciate that it’s somewhat affordable for people but Japan - and I was just there - is seriously lacking green spaces. Most of the built environment is ugly af. It’s also not as clean as everyone talks about; I was walking in a neighborhood in Osaka and there were piles of rubbish in empty lots taller than me. It’s endlessly annoying that Japan refuses to have rubbish bins in public.
27
u/Effective_Pack8265 Dec 22 '24
I’d move back to Japan in a heartbeat. Loved it there.
6
u/DerPanzerzwerg Dec 22 '24
Place: :| Place, Japan: :D
35
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
I suspect it is better than where you live
3
u/joe_dirty365 Dec 22 '24
Other than shinjuku it really wasn't that bad imo. But I wasn't there for that long either.
3
u/FlamingoRush Dec 22 '24
It's clean and safe and still organised!
3
u/timbotheny26 Dec 22 '24
I was always under the impression that Japan was popular among urbanists because of its' very walkable streets and exceptional public transit.
The only downside I see to it is how cramped it can be and the lacking of greenspace(s).
5
u/BureauOfBureaucrats Dec 22 '24
I’ve always wanted a small house on a large lot 🤷♀️
7
u/Radusili Dec 22 '24
Because it's Japan. How can you nit defent the kawaii anime uwu land. They have like...(Idk insert something here that is either bs or unimportant).
And did you know that the age of cons....(and yeah that also changed fortunately)
In short. The kind of people who would think like this are the exact ones that would go out of their way to defend on social media something obviously bad.
10
u/MomoDeve Dec 22 '24 edited Dec 22 '24
My point from the start was that Korea > Japan in terms of urban planning. There are more highways in Korean cities, but they also dedicate much more space to the green areas compared to Japan. Everybody will tell you to get on a train for an hour+ to experience just a bit of forest nature in Tokyo/Osaka lol. The cities are truly the concrete jungles and they suck if you live there long term
9
u/sleepy_din0saur Dec 22 '24
Walkable, affordable, liveable, low crime, and clean
5
u/dennis-w220 Dec 22 '24
Never lived in Japan. But as a tourist, I have to say that Japan's restaurant is way better and cheaper than that of Bay Area nowadays. I love Kyoto more than Tokyo, very much that kind of a small city with history and I want to live in.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
The people make Japan's urban centers to much better than the rest of the world, not to mention super safe, super clean and trains are ON Time
2
u/dirkdigdig Dec 22 '24
It’s clean, organized, and easy to get around.
2
u/SakiEndo Dec 22 '24
And the problem everyone just looks at the big cities, take a look at the smaller places and look at the urban design or sheer lack of. Sometimes it can be quite charming but also it can be downright ugly with badly aligned roads, cluttered huge signage, electrical wire chaos, poor cycling facilities, poor separation of motorized traffic and pedestrian facilities, a lack of vegetation, a lack of architectural merit in many "modern" buildings which are fantastic at resisting earthquakes but age poorly and often leads to a sea of tin shed buildings. Don't get me wrong, I love Japan, and there's sometimes a lot of really nice urban elements, but a lot of it is quite dreary and tedious once you break outside of the big metropolises.
2
u/HandinGlov3 Dec 22 '24
People spend way too much time putting Japan on a pedestal.
3
u/ElKuhnTucker Dec 22 '24
I love being in Japan, but the big city architecture and residential areas always struck me as ugly. Japan is a harsh mistress
3
u/polmeeee Dec 22 '24
I think it's just a matter of preference. Like you mentioned in your last line you prefer suburban with a landed property instead of an apartment in a high density urban zone.
3
u/madrid987 Dec 22 '24
Another downside is that it is extremely crowded. South Korea has a much higher population density than Japan, but it is actually much less crowded.
3
u/kjbeats57 Dec 22 '24
Because anime
3
u/Wennie_D Dec 22 '24
Go live in the countryside or a small town then
2
u/sometimesifeellikemu Dec 22 '24
They are pretty kick ass urban centers.
2
u/Palanki96 Dec 22 '24
Thing 😐
Thing in Japan 😍
2
u/jijodelmaiz Dec 22 '24
Because of this.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
The people who rush to defend Japan are always Americans and Europeans. Not even the native population is able to live in Japan well. Their society is very homogenized and working to death. You then have Western tourism that overly glamorizes the country, forgetting the reality.
2
u/Redditing-Dutchman Dec 22 '24
Even though it's not very green the streets in Tokyo are so calm, clean, safe and comfortable. You don't walk into crazy meth heads, there is little, if any graffiti or run down shit. People are polite and calm. A convenience store is never more than a minute away, etc. Take for example Barcelona. Way more beautiful in terms of architecture. But I can never really let my guard down there.
1
u/Quarterwit_85 Dec 22 '24
There’s a lot of neuro-divergent people here who love the order and cleanliness of the place. The same people don’t worry too much about a lack of independence or personal agency, a fair judicial system or children being sexualised.
1
u/dicecop Dec 22 '24
Absolutely. Also, horrendous "modern" architecture
1
u/ich-bin-ein-mann Dec 22 '24
They are built to withstand major earthquakes
1
u/HeckleJekyllHyde Dec 22 '24
Pftttt, lookit this fancy guy over here wanting trees.
1
u/Danger_Closer Dec 22 '24
It's not just the cities, even the aesthetic of Japanese villages is mostly drab and sterile concrete and tarmac with low hangling power lines, no trees and no sidewalks, but with a vending machine in view weebs will orgasm over the sight.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
There are places like that in Japan, not everywhere is a city. Cities are supposed to be dense, not everyone has to live in one if you don't want to, but also don't criticize them for being what they're supposed to. Tokyo could use more greenspace, I'll say that, but you shouldn't expect every city to have gigantic houses and backyards, that's a stupid use of a space.
1
u/juicejohnson Dec 22 '24
I think the urban density is easier to deal with there thanks to minimal trash, graffiti and other social norms that aren’t seen in other cities.
1
u/aztroneka Dec 22 '24
Tokio, Japan: 🥰 | São Paulo: 😨
1
u/KikiYuyu Dec 22 '24
Tokyo is the only place where an aerial shot makes me feel claustrophobic
1
u/fasda Dec 22 '24
Because cars suck at their job
1
u/TnYamaneko Dec 23 '24
The worst to me is that due to the sarin attacks in the 90s', there's not a fucking trash can in sight, so you have to carry your trash with you back to the place you live in for the whole day. And Japanese products have a revolting amount of small packaging inside bigger containers.
1
u/girthy10incher Dec 23 '24 edited Dec 23 '24
Not really that impressive when cities like Manchester which itself isn't London both more or less look like that nowadays.
1
u/KedaiNasi_ Dec 23 '24
fellas, have you seen how they are now expanding upon the sea to build even more buildings. but still it's much more 'cleaner' than this man-made archipelago which is plague with algae
1
u/Tochuri Dec 23 '24
Maybe it is because Tokyo is an extremely livable city, I live in Tokyo and I've lived in a very green city in Australia and I'd take Tokyo any day of the week, I can afford an apartment to myself, trains come every 5 minutes, food and drink is affordable and extremely accessible, the city is clean and safe. Yes there's a few less trees here but there's way less traffic and rubbish, I don't have to drive 10 minutes to go to the shops, I can just step outside
People defend Tokyo if they know Tokyo
1
u/Limesmack91 Dec 23 '24
it's a lot of gray (during the day) and it's cramped that's for sure
I think the biggest thing that sets it apart from other big cities is its excellent and extensive public transport network
1
u/Maximum-Objective-39 Dec 23 '24 edited Dec 23 '24
Most of the praise comes down to the fact that, if you have to build that dense, because your country has very little flat land, Japan does it pretty good and avoids most of the worst pit falls that American cities are suffering. There's also lessons that could be applied to places that have more flat land so that you can develop a better happy medium.
1
u/Mysterious_Device_51 Dec 23 '25
Looking at the comments, I wonder if I Iive in the same city or if everyone else has a pair of glasses that filter out what is objectively bad (before being blasted by some Japan's paladin weeaboo: I'd still choose to live here one thousand times than in my home country - Italy).
-2
u/Deep_Space52 Dec 22 '24
It's the cleanest first-world nation you'll ever set foot in
1
u/HappyTreeFriends8964 Dec 22 '24
You said: pointing these out doesn’t mean JapanBAD.
Sure, defending these doesn’t mean they think they’re bad and want to attack you. It’s part of their freedom.
You pointed out whatever you believed you should, while they defended whatever they believed worthy to defend.
You can say it’s over-reacting while they can say it’s not.
1
u/Beat_Saber_Music Dec 22 '24
In Japan the rents aren't exploding out of control even in Tokyo at least. Also it's generally walkable because of public transit and shops being legal to build in a lot of places while density restrictions don't make small corner stores ecobomically infeasible.
Imo an ideal zoning system is one with Japanese flexibility of minimal restrictions, in addition to minimal architectural requirements (like mandating just a color scheme and certain roof design and nlthing more).
1
u/Fatty2Fly Dec 22 '24
Beautiful in to devastating type of way
1
u/Rob_Rockley Dec 22 '24
The key to a dense urban core is the society that inhabits it. Humans living and thriving amongst concrete slabs is a kind of metaphor for human adaptability. Living peaceably in close proximity is a testament to a spirit of cooperation that is, interestingly, different for every dense locale. The Japanese probably exemplify this spirit as much or more so than other places on the planet.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '24
Don't come again.
0
u/tyger2020 Dec 22 '24
I'm not gonna lie, most of Japans cities come across as overcrowded and incredibly ugly.
It's not to do with density, either. Tokyo metro has a density of like 1,000 per square km. Barcelona metro is similar, yet one is very pretty and the other is a big jumbled mess.
0
u/poweredbytexas Dec 22 '24
It’s defended by Japans tourism industry.