Copied from my post in r/CanadaUrbanism. I made a post a few months ago about Canadian suburbia and its unique features. I went to Montréal a few weeks ago (from Toronto) and spent a bit of time checking a few suburbs, notably, Vaudreuil-Dorion, CDN–NDG, and Brossard.
Suburban Montréal has a few distinct features:
- Multi-use trails all over the place, in a few instances, they are complete bi-directional cycle tracks. Now, this is consistent with my experience in the Toronto suburbs where most 905 municipalities have converted their sidewalks to multi-use trails (or built them from scratch). This also seems to be the case across Canada in the suburbs of places like Edmonton and Vancouver. You could make the argument that this is just a form of car infrastructure with cycling infrastructure “interfering” with pedestrian infrastructure, but that is more passable in areas where there may not be a lot of foot traffic.
Where suburban Montréal stands apart I would say is that they also have these on some side streets which is……… interesting to say the least. I know NJB went to Montréal a few years ago and criticized the fact that much of the city’s great cycling infrastructure was on side streets (can’t say I haven’t noticed that). Regardless, you can see that cycling is taken seriously in not just the city of Montréal, but even in its suburbs.
Traffic calming infrastructure at least in Vaudreuil-Dorion was surprisingly high quality, though again, this is becoming more common across much of suburban Canada.
2. Walk-up apartments. As an Ontarian, I am jealous. The housing style here literally was the stereotypical 905 “cookie-cutter” design, but I saw more walk up apartments. In Ontario, we do have this styled housing in townhome form, but not so much in apartment/walk-up form like here.
3. More mid to high-rise density is popping up
4. To what is known to many urbanists, Canadian suburbia is more compact and less sprawling than it’s American counterparts, and this is very true here. Many storefronts and buildings were facing parking lots but had plaza sidewalks that directly connected to the main road sidewalks.
5. Despite the cycling infrastructure, density, and compactness, I found Vaudreuil-Dorion (at least by the WalMart there) to be so “in your face” hostile to pedestrians. Like take a look at the 7th picture, you can see the plaza sidewalk does not connect to the pathway on the main road. At this particular plaza it was noticeable, and despite only a small grass median separating many store buildings from the multi-use trail, there technically was no true pedestrian connection (aside from a desired path by the Dollarama) in between. This was not so much in Brossard. Although look at picture 9 (technically in the City of Montréal!). I know this is not good from an urbanism perspective, but I do find this juxtaposition to be really interesting and honestly, it gives character.
6. The “sidewalk on only one side” or “no sidewalk at all” layout on side streets was extremely noticeable here, though some of y’all brought up how that is more of an eastern Canada thing. I will say, the narrow streets and bits of traffic-calming infrastructure do make up for that.
7. Did not take the transit in Vaudreuil-Dorion and Brossard (except for getting on/off the REM. Also, didI take the metro to CDN–NDG). From what I heard, it isn’t great, as is the regional rail in Montréal, though I’d rather some of y’all confirm that.
These are things I noticed. To sum it all up, typical Canadian car-centric suburbia, but with some hardcore urbanism here and there. Hostile to pedestrians and cyclists, but also surprisingly accommodating to them.