r/VibeCodeDevs • u/According_Good_6158 • 21h ago
i killed 4 ideas in 7 months before one made money. these are the 5 tests i run on every idea now
the idea i was most excited about failed every test on this list. the one i almost didn't build has been paying my rent for over a year.
i saw a post here this week asking how you tell a real pivot from running away when things get hard. i did the running away version 4 times in a row, so here's what i burned through and the tests i wrote down afterward.
the 4 ideas i killed:
- an AI meal planner for people who lift. 6 weeks of building, 31 signups, 0 payments.
- a marketplace for notion templates. quit after 3 weeks because i got bored, not because it failed.
- invoice reminders for freelancers. 2 paying users at $12/month, both churned in month 2.
- a CRM for wedding photographers. spent a month on it and never got a single one on a call.
every one of them felt like "the one" the day i started. that feeling turned out to be useless as a signal.
these are the 5 tests i run now, in order. each one comes from a specific idea that failed it.
1/ find 10 complaints from the last 90 days in under an hour
the meal planner failed this. i found tons of people talking about meal planning, but almost all of them were asking for free app recommendations. nobody was annoyed enough to mention money or wasted time.
now i only count a complaint if it says what the problem costs them. "i spend every sunday night fixing this" counts. "would be cool if" doesn't.
2/ someone has to be paying for a bad version already
invoice reminders passed this one, and that's what fooled me. freelancers were paying for invoicing tools.
the problem was that the reminder part was already free inside every one of those tools. they weren't paying for the thing i built. i check now that the specific part i'm building is the part people pay for, not just the category.
3/ name the exact place 50 of them hang out
wedding photographers failed this badly. they're spread across instagram, a few private facebook groups i couldn't get into, and local vendor networks.
i sent 40 DMs and got 2 replies, both "not interested." if i can't name one forum, subreddit, group or directory where i can reach 50 of them in a week, i move on.
4/ get 3 calls booked within 2 weeks, before writing code
this is the test i skipped on all 4 ideas. it's also the one that would have saved me the most time.
for the idea that worked, i messaged 25 people who'd left complaints and booked 5 calls in 9 days. that alone told me more than the 6 weeks of meal planner code did.
5/ write down the most boring week of building it
this one came from the notion templates. i quit when it turned into hours of formatting and support emails.
now before i start, i write out what a dull week looks like 3 months in. if my first reaction is relief that i don't have to do it yet, that's my answer.
how the one that worked scored
it passed all 5, and it wasn't exciting at all. the complaints were specific. people were already paying a freelancer for part of it. they all hung out in 2 or 3 subreddits, and i had 5 calls booked before i built anything.
excitement on day 1 + no tests = 7 months gone.
the complaint searches for test 1 are the slowest part, so these days i start from a repo that groups complaints by how many different companies repeat them, then go read the original threads myself.
pick the idea you're most excited about right now and run it through test 4 this week. 3 calls or it goes in the drawer.