r/WarhammerCompetitive • u/soutioirsim • 10h ago
40k Discussion Is Disruption vs Priority Assets the worst match up?
Historically, people have thought that Disruption vs Recon was the hardest matchup, due to how easily Recon can remove markers and then score (hold one, hold more, observe enemy unit, remove all markers). But the scoring by Disruption isn't too bad with hold one and then decoying multiple objectives. It's an uphill battle, but doable.
I feel the like the Disruption vs Priority Assets is awful and has gone under the radar. The game goes like this:
- The Disruption player places 5 markers on terrain pieces in no mans land.
- Both players have to do an action on the central objective, and then they can remove a marker of their choosing.
- When there's only one marker left, neither player can do the action, and it remains there for the rest of the game.
Both players score 4VP at the end of their turn if there's only one marker left, they have a unit on that particular terrain piece, and there are no other enemy units on that terrain. Here is the rest of how each player's scoring:
PA -> hold one (4VP), do action (4VP), kill unit of objective (3VP)
Disruption -> hold one (4VP), kill unit on objective (4VP)
The Disruption player gets no points for doing the action, but the PA player does. Yes, the Disruption player gets one more point for kills on objectives, but that only equates to an extra ~4VP typically over the entire game, as it's capped to one kill per turn. The PA player will likely be getting 4-12VP for doing the action.
You might argue that the Disruption player gets to choose the terrain pieces to put the markers on, but all the layouts have 5 or 7 terrain pieces wholly in no man's land. So a lot of the time there's no choice, and even with the 7 terrain piece layouts, the most favourable terrain pieces get removed early by both players anyway.
If you look at the Disruption win rates since the last dataslate (courtesy of https://listhammer.info/stats), then you can see this is backed up empirically:
vs Purge -> 50.3% (n=332)
vs Recon -> 49% (n=153)
vs Take and Hold -> 45.7% (n=541)
vs Priority Assets -> 40.5% (n=333)