r/WebsiteSEO • u/Low-Anteater513 • 5h ago
Impressions up, clicks down for 3 months with the same positions. AI answers or something with my snippets?
I run a small content site, about 14 months old, mostly guides and comparisons in one niche. For the first year everything moved in the right direction. Then around August I noticed something odd in Search Console: impressions keep climbing, about 35% more than in the spring, but clicks have dropped by almost a third. My average position barely changed, it sits around 6 to 8 for most of my main pages, so I'm not being pushed down the results in the usual sense.
I went through the obvious stuff. Titles and meta descriptions havent been touched, so it's not a rewrite gone wrong. Core Web Vitals are green, nothing broke technically, and the pages are still indexed. I checked a few of my top queries manually and in several of them there is now an AI overview box at the top that answers the question, with my page sitting below it. Other queries show a big "People also ask" block and a video carousel above the organic results. So my guess is that the clicks are simply going elsewhere, but I cant tell how much of the drop is that and how much is something I can still fix.
What I'm trying to figure out: is there a reliable way to separate "AI overview and SERP features are eating my clicks" from "my snippets just got less attractive"? Ive thought about filtering by query type in Search Console and comparing informational vs commercial queries, but I'm not sure that proves anything. And has anyone actually managed to win some of those clicks back, for example by changing how the page opens or the title angle? Or is this just the new normal and I should focus on queries where AI answers dont appear?