I posted here a few days ago about a bride who was heavily AI-editing my wedding photos and demanding that I recreate those edits.
Well, weāve now agreed that AI editing is off the table. However, sheās now sending me reference photos from another photographer and insisting that I edit her entire wedding gallery to look like those.
And hereās the best part: the reference photos are from the photographer she originally booked, then cancelled to book me instead.
Before the wedding, I actually raised concerns several times that my editing style was quite different from what she originally had in mind. Every single time, she reassured me that she loved my work and my style. She had seen my portfolio and still chose to work with me.
Now, after the wedding, she essentially wants me to recreate the editing style of the photographer she cancelled.
Iāve explained multiple times that Iām happy to make reasonable adjustments to exposure, colours, etc., but Iām not going to completely change my artistic style to imitate someone elseās work. Unfortunately, she doesnāt seem willing to accept that answer.
To make matters worse, this wedding was done on a collaboration basis. I photographed it without charging my usual fee, and in return we agreed on a dedicated Instagram collaboration post and publicity opportunities. Several other vendors also contributed on a collaboration basis and are now waiting for photographs to share.
Yes, I know. Doing this as a collaboration was probably a mistake, and Iāve definitely learned my lesson. But I canāt change that now.
I actually have a pretty strong contract covering all of this. It explicitly states that the client has reviewed my portfolio, understands my photographic style, and that I have the final say regarding artistic judgment and editing. It also states that disagreements over aesthetics arenāt grounds for terminating the agreement.
Her response? She says that when she signed the contract, she didnāt realise that editing could make such a big difference to how a photograph looks.
Which is honestly quite difficult for me to understand, considering she had seen my portfolio, weād discussed my editing style multiple times before the wedding, and she repeatedly reassured me that she loved it.
So at this point, Iām considering two options:
Option 1: Ideally, she accepts the adjusted editing, we move forward with the agreed collaboration post, the vendors receive their photographs, and everyone can finally move on. - very unlikely
Option 2: If she still refuses my editing, Iām considering offering her the option to pay my originally quoted photography fee in exchange for the RAW files. She could then take them to the photographer whose editing style she prefers and have them edited however she wants.
This would obviously require a separate written agreement, as my current contract doesnāt include RAW delivery. I would also want to ensure that my name isnāt associated with any third-party edits, and that the images arenāt distributed to vendors or publications as my work. Essentially, Iād step away from the collaboration entirely.
The downside is that the vendors who also participated on a collaboration basis could end up without the photographs they were expecting, which I feel terrible about.
But I also donāt think itās fair that Iām expected to completely change my editing style when this was something I explicitly discussed with her before the wedding. Not to brag or anything in my years I have been doing this I had never had anyone complain about my editing etc, I photographed weddings of big photographers, other public figures etc. iām always happy to hear different opinions but she just wants something totally different.
What would you do?
Would you stand firm and try to make the original collaboration work, or offer the second option and walk away? Has anyone negotiated something similar with a client before?
Iām genuinely interested in hearing how other photographers would handle this because I feel like Iāve exhausted every reasonable compromise.