I’m 22M, and the girl I’ve been romantically involved with is 24F. I’m posting anonymously because I genuinely need advice from people who have no connection to either of us.
This situation has become so emotionally complicated that I’m struggling to distinguish between my own insecurities, legitimate trust issues, and whether we’re simply incompatible.
I want to explain the entire situation, including where I might be wrong, because I don’t want a bunch of strangers blindly agreeing with me.
Some background about me:
I’m 22, financially independent, a college student, and I make my living through social media and livestreaming. I also own a business.
I have a lot of responsibilities outside of work. My father is terminally ill, and I help care for him. Between my family responsibilities, school, and work, my life is already pretty demanding.
I’m not saying any of this to make myself sound better than anyone else. I’m explaining it because stability, honesty, and peace are extremely important to me, especially considering everything else I’m dealing with.
I met this girl in September. She lives in another state, and we connected through social media.
Things developed pretty quickly. We started talking romantically, getting to know each other, and eventually made plans for her to come visit me in Florida.
I was genuinely excited about her.
I found her attractive, enjoyed her personality, and felt like there was something special developing between us.
But what I didn’t know was that the entire situation was already much more complicated than she’d led me to believe.
1. She lied about when she last slept with her ex before coming to visit me.
This is probably the single biggest issue in our entire relationship.
Before she visited me, we discussed her previous relationship.
She told me that she hadn’t slept with her ex-boyfriend in approximately THREE MONTHS.
Not three weeks. Not a month.
Three months.
I believed her.
I thought she had been out of that relationship for a reasonable amount of time and was genuinely moving forward.
Based on that understanding, I helped arrange and pay for transportation so she could come see me.
She flew down to Florida, stayed with me, and we became romantically and physically involved.
I welcomed her into my home, spent time and money on her, and started developing serious feelings.
Then, later on, information began surfacing about her ex.
He claimed that their relationship had continued much closer to her visit than she’d admitted. He even alleged that they were still together when she traveled to see me.
I understand that an ex-boyfriend isn’t automatically a reliable source. He could have been jealous, angry, or trying to interfere.
But eventually, she admitted something herself.
She admitted that she and her ex had been in the same bed together shortly before she visited me. She also admitted they’d had sex just a few days earlier.
Remember, she’d previously told me it had been three months.
That wasn’t a small misunderstanding.
That was a completely different story.
And it made me question the entire foundation of our relationship.
I wasn’t necessarily expecting exclusivity before we’d officially established a relationship. I understand that people date, have sex, and move on from previous partners.
But why lie?
Why tell me it had been three months when it had actually been days?
Why allow me to pay for transportation, welcome her into my home, become intimate with her, and develop feelings without telling me the truth?
Had I known she’d just been sleeping with her ex, I might have made a completely different decision about having her visit.
I feel like I wasn’t given the opportunity to make that decision with accurate information.
And that’s what bothers me more than the sex itself.
It’s the fact that she looked me in the face and gave me a false version of events.
To make matters worse, her ex alleged that they were still romantically involved when she came to Florida.
I cannot independently verify his entire account, so I’m not going to present every allegation as fact.
But the admission about the timing of their sexual relationship was enough to make me question what else I didn’t know.
2. Then I discovered explicit videos of her having sex with that same ex.
This is where things became even more difficult emotionally.
She had previously made explicit content with her ex-boyfriend.
Some of that content was still accessible online.
I ended up watching two videos of them together.
I cannot explain how much I regret watching them.
Seeing someone you’re developing serious feelings for having sex with another man is already difficult for some people.
But seeing her with the exact same ex she’d lied to me about sleeping with immediately before visiting me made it significantly worse.
I started having intrusive thoughts about the videos.
I compared myself to him physically and sexually.
I questioned whether she enjoyed being with him more.
I wondered whether she was genuinely over him when she came to see me.
And I kept thinking about how she’d been intimate with him only days before becoming intimate with me.
I recognize that some of these reactions are insecurity and retroactive jealousy.
I’m not proud of comparing myself to another man or allowing those images to occupy so much space in my head.
I also made the mistake of revisiting the content, which only made things worse.
But the dishonesty surrounding her ex made it extremely difficult to view the videos as simply something from her distant past.
This wasn’t some guy she’d been involved with years earlier.
This was someone she’d been sleeping with just days before visiting me, after telling me otherwise.
And knowing the content was still available for other people to watch made it even harder.
I started wondering whether I could ever genuinely accept that part of her history without becoming resentful.
I don’t think she’s inherently a bad person for making adult content.
But I also don’t think everyone is automatically compatible with someone who has made explicit content with a previous partner.
3. Our social media lifestyles complicate everything.
We both have involvement in social media and livestreaming.
My work involves entertaining an audience, interacting with supporters, and dealing with people who sometimes become emotionally attached to creators.
I understand better than most people how complicated those relationships can become.
Her online activities have also involved sexual attention from men, which adds another layer of discomfort for me.
I realize there could be some hypocrisy here if I expect her to accept the attention I receive online while being uncomfortable with the attention she receives.
That’s something I’m willing to examine about myself.
But I also believe there are differences between entertaining an audience, flirting for engagement, and maintaining sexual content involving an ex-partner.
I don’t want to dictate how she earns money or what she chooses to do online.
At the same time, I have to be realistic about what I’m emotionally capable of accepting in a romantic relationship.
And I’m starting to question whether our boundaries and expectations are fundamentally different.
4. Despite everything, we developed genuine feelings.
This is what makes the situation so difficult.
If she were simply someone I didn’t care about, I would have walked away a long time ago.
But I genuinely have feelings for her.
She’s affectionate, funny, loving, and capable of making me feel incredibly appreciated.
We’ve spent time together, shared personal experiences, and developed an emotional connection.
She’s been there for me during difficult moments involving my family and work.
She’s sent me long, heartfelt messages telling me how much she loves me, how happy I’ve made her, and how much she wants to support my future.
She tells me she believes in me and wants to be someone I can count on.
And I don’t necessarily think those feelings are fake.
I believe it’s possible for someone to genuinely love you while also having made decisions that hurt you.
I also recognize that she has experienced difficult circumstances in her own life, and I don’t want to dismiss that.
There are moments when we’re together when everything feels natural.
We laugh, enjoy each other’s company, and genuinely seem happy.
But then something reminds me of the dishonesty, the videos, or her ex, and all those feelings come rushing back.
It’s almost like there are two completely different versions of our relationship.
One where we’re happy and affectionate.
And another where I’m constantly questioning whether I can trust her.
5. I started feeling resentment, and I know that isn’t healthy.
As our relationship progressed, I found myself becoming increasingly bothered by things that had happened before we met.
Sometimes I would think about the videos.
Sometimes I would think about her sleeping in the same bed as her ex.
Sometimes I would remember that she told me three months when the actual timeline was only days.
And sometimes I would wonder whether there were other things I still didn’t know.
I know this isn’t healthy.
I recognize that if I choose to forgive someone and continue a relationship, I can’t constantly punish them for their past.
But I also don’t believe forgiveness automatically restores trust.
And I don’t know whether I’ve actually forgiven the dishonesty or whether I’ve just been trying to ignore it because I love her.
I don’t want to become someone who constantly interrogates his partner, brings up old situations, or makes her feel guilty for things she can’t change.
That’s not the kind of relationship I want.
But I also don’t want to convince myself that I’m simply insecure when there were actual lies involved.
6. I eventually tried to end things, but she came to my house anyway.
Toward the end of October, everything became overwhelming.
I told her I didn’t think I could continue the relationship.
The explicit videos, the dishonesty, and the constant thoughts about her ex had become too much.
I felt like I was losing my peace.
I also told her that I didn’t want her coming to my house.
She came anyway.
I understand that she may have believed showing up would give us an opportunity to work things out.
But I had explicitly communicated that I didn’t want the visit.
To me, that’s another issue involving boundaries.
I don’t think love gives someone permission to disregard another person’s wishes.
At the same time, I want to acknowledge that our situation hasn’t always been black and white.
There have been mixed signals, emotional conversations, affection, and moments where we’ve both struggled to let go.
I’m not pretending that I’ve handled every situation perfectly.
But I do think someone saying they don’t want a visit should be respected.
7. We keep finding ourselves drawn back to each other.
Even after the arguments, the attempted breakup, and everything that happened, we haven’t been able to completely disconnect.
We’ve continued spending time together and showing affection.
There are moments when I genuinely think things could work.
She can be incredibly sweet and supportive, and I enjoy having her around.
But I also recognize that enjoying someone’s company isn’t the same as having a healthy foundation for a relationship.
I’ve told people close to me that I don’t want to rush into anything serious.
I don’t want to combine our lives, become responsible for each other’s entire futures, or make major commitments while I’m still uncertain.
I want to take things as they come.
But even that creates complications because feelings don’t necessarily stay casual just because you want them to.
And I worry that continuing to spend time together while being uncertain about the future could end up hurting her, too.
8. I feel torn between my feelings for her and my self-respect.
This is the part I’m really struggling with.
I genuinely care about her.
I don’t want to lose someone who makes me happy in so many ways.
But I also feel like I’ve compromised my own emotional well-being trying to make this work.
I keep asking myself whether I’m being too sensitive.
Am I allowing another man’s existence to affect my confidence?
Am I being unfair by judging her for sexual experiences that happened before we were officially together?
Am I letting explicit videos destroy something that could otherwise be meaningful?
Or am I overlooking the most important part of this entire situation?
She lied to me about sleeping with her ex immediately before coming to visit me.
And now I’m trying to build a relationship with someone whose honesty I already have reasons to question.
I don’t think the fact that she slept with her ex before we were exclusive automatically makes her a terrible person.
But I do think lying about it when directly discussing the timeline matters.
Especially when the truth might have changed my decision to pursue the relationship.
I also don’t know whether I can ever completely erase the images I saw.
I don’t want to spend the next several months or years feeling insecure about another man.
I don’t want to make her feel ashamed of herself.
And I don’t want to be in a relationship where I’m constantly wondering whether I’m getting the full truth.
9. Where I’m at now.
I’m exhausted by the emotional back-and-forth.
I have a demanding life already, and I want a relationship that adds happiness and stability rather than constant uncertainty.
I don’t expect a perfect partner.
I don’t expect someone without a sexual history.
And I don’t expect someone to revolve their entire life around me.
What I do expect is honesty, mutual respect, loyalty when we’ve agreed to it, and respect for boundaries.
I want to be able to trust someone’s words without feeling the need to investigate whether they’re true.
I want to be with someone whose lifestyle and values are compatible with mine.
And I want to be emotionally mature enough to recognize when my own insecurities are contributing to a problem.
I can acknowledge that I have things to work on while also believing that I deserved honesty from the beginning.
I think that’s why this has been so difficult.
I don’t necessarily believe either of us is an inherently bad person.
But I’m starting to wonder whether two people can genuinely love each other and still be fundamentally wrong for one another.
And whether continuing to try is actually doing more damage than walking away would.
What I need advice on:
1. Is the lie about her ex enough to justify ending things? She told me it had been three months when she’d actually slept with him just days before visiting me. Would you be able to rebuild trust after that?
2. Am I experiencing retroactive jealousy, or is this a legitimate trust issue? I understand that my reactions to the videos involve insecurity, but the dishonesty seems like a separate problem.
3. Would the explicit videos be a dealbreaker for you? Especially knowing that the person in those videos was someone she was still sleeping with immediately before meeting you.
4. How serious is the boundary issue? Would someone showing up at your home after being explicitly told not to change how you viewed the relationship?
5. Am I being unfair by continuing to pursue her when I’m not sure I can accept everything that’s happened? I don’t want to keep giving her hope if I’m ultimately going to remain resentful.
6. Can genuine love overcome this kind of beginning? Or does the fact that our connection started with dishonesty mean we’re constantly going to struggle with trust?
7. If you were in my position, would you walk away or attempt to rebuild the relationship? And if you chose to rebuild, what would actually need to change?
I would really appreciate honest advice, particularly from people who’ve dealt with dishonesty at the beginning of a relationship, explicit content involving an ex, or situations where love and compatibility didn’t necessarily align.
Please don’t just tell me to break up with her because it’s Reddit, and please don’t automatically assume I’m innocent in every aspect of this.
I know I have insecurities, and I know I’ve made mistakes in how I’ve handled some of this.
I’m trying to figure out whether I’m holding onto something that could genuinely become healthy or whether I’m ignoring what should have been a dealbreaker from the beginning.
TL;DR: I’m 22M, and the girl I’m involved with (24F) told me she hadn’t slept with her ex in three months before traveling to visit me. She later admitted they’d been in the same bed and had sex just days before the visit. Her ex also alleged their relationship was still ongoing, although I can’t independently verify that. I helped pay for her travel, welcomed her into my home, and became romantically involved with her without knowing the truth. I later discovered explicit videos of her with that same ex, which caused significant jealousy and insecurity. We’ve developed genuine feelings, but the dishonesty, resentment, repeated conflict, and an incident where she came to my house after I told her not to have made everything extremely complicated. I don’t know whether to work through my insecurities and try rebuilding trust or accept that we’re incompatible and walk away.