r/WillAndGrace • u/Naive_Hospital_4086 • 23h ago
Discussion Forbidden Fruit
Forbidden Fruit (Season 8, Episode 12). Will is still doing his best to become a lawyer that helps people instead of being a typical corporate attorney. Will tells everyone that he's working for the Coalition for Justice. Grace says that Will has inspired her to do something nice and she's going to do an interior design job for an old folk's home for free. Well, it turns out that both Will & Grace are not doing any charitable work, turns out that Will's old boss Margot has offered Will his old job back and Grace to design the office. Will & Grace find out about each other and have to admit that they like nice things and they were ashamed but accept that they like the paychecks they are getting and agree not to judge one another. Jack has come down with a bad cold and Karen offers for him to stay at the mansion and recover. While Jack is looking around the mansion, he sees a door that he's never opened and Karen tells him it's the "forbidden room". Jack is more intrigued than ever and finally finds out what's behind the door. It's the baby's room that Karen had designed in case she was pregnant the one time she had a scare years ago. She never changed the room and feels like it's comfort to her of what could have been. Jack tells her to keep the room as is and Karen reflects for a moment on what it could have been like had she become a mother.
FAVORITE QUOTE:
WILL: I thought you said I inspired you to finally do something charitable with your life?
GRACE: Well, you did, and then it went away.
WILL: Do I have to remind you that I quit that heartless, money-grubbing, corporate law firm and now you're choosing it over sweet, elderly people who just want to live out the rest of their days with dignity? Nice.
GRACE: When you say it like that, I feel awful.
WILL: Well, you should, Grace. I was proud of you for doing something meaningful.
GRACE: You were?
WILL: Yes.
GRACE: Okay, I won't take the job. Okay? I finally committed to doing something charitable and I'm going to see it through.
WILL: That's my Grace. You're a good person. Just like Jake Gyllenhaal. I don't know, sometimes when I look at my screen saver, I think... "Yeah, you're thinking about me, too."
GRACE: You know, I used to feel that way about Sarah Jessica Parker. But then, we shared an elevator ride together and she poked me in the boob with an umbrella and didn't apologize.
WILL: Were you trying to hug her?
GRACE: That's not important.
FAVORITE MOMENT:
Will & Grace keep missing each other in the office by bending over and standing up and switching and eventually finding each other under the table.
OPINION:
I sometimes feel like season 8 is this weird fever dream, it's definitely a mixed bag. There are some episodes that I forget exist and this is one of them. Let's start with Will & Grace. Will I was disappointed that the writers pretty much gave up Will trying to do something more meaningful with his life and just goes back to Margot. It makes his growth as a character seem pointless. Why not have him create his own firm that helps low income people or even a non profit organization of his own? He says he misses a nice office and that's why he went back to Margot. Could there just have been a better reason? He's not making as much money and needs the funds coming in to keep his home? Or that he wants to work there for a little while and save money to do something better since he quit so suddenly last time? Grace, honestly I expected this from Grace. Grace is not into charity or at least she'll be into it for 5 minutes and be distracted by something else. So I could say that I am not a fan of this storyline. I always forget about this episode and just have to remember later that "oh, yeah, Will decided he wanted to be a corporate lawyer again".
Karen had a pregnancy scare back in season 1's The Unsinkable Mommy Adler. So we see here, she's never gotten over that moment where she found out that she could be a mother. But was there really time for her to create a baby's room? Usually if you have a pregnancy scare, it's just a few days. I'm not buying that Karen had a baby's room created in the off chance that she would become a mother. I'm not buying that Karen kept it all those years either. Her and Stan were divorcing, why in the world would she keep that room? We get this moment where Karen looks at the room and tears up wondering what could have been. It is a sweet moment and I do think there are times in the series where Karen had wondered what life would be like as a mother, but I don't think she ever really committed herself to wanting a baby. So I could be wrong here, but the moment doesn't feel earned. I felt that in The Unsinkable Mommy Adler that small hug that Jack gives Karen at the end when she finds out that she's not pregnant meant more and I felt that sadness more so. I'm wondering if the writers just wanted to give Karen a deep moment but were not sure how to do so. Well, she's a woman, hasn't she ever wanted a baby? No, I don't think Karen wants to be a mother, I think she just got bored.
The episode for me is below average. It's not that funny and the storylines for me just didn't work. I feel bad picking on it because it's not a bad episode, it's just very bland. But I love reading the comments on each episode and seeing if there's something I missed and reading other opinions. Does anyone else feel that Karen's moment wanting to be a mother was earned or do you also feel that this was just a cheap way of having a sad moment for her? And do you feel that Will gave up too easily on wanting to make a difference and help people?
GUEST STARS:
- Lily Tomlin as Margot
- Jamie Kaler as Gary
- Keeshan Giles as Counter Man