RULE UPDATES
First, I want to start out by mentioning that some months ago, we re-wrote the rules to hopefully be less confusing and more consolidated. Nothing about the spirit of the rules has been changed, we simply wanted them to be easier to read, and shorter to read so people didn't have to wade through pages of text to understand everything. As always, the rules are listed in the sidebar, and you can access them on our wiki. There are two primary reasons for this post, however.
AI CONTENT FARM SITES AND ARTICLES
The first is a discussion about AI, in multiple parts. I think the easiest part to deal with is concerning websites that spit out AI-generated articles that don't really share new news, or don't do it well. I think we can all agree that links to those articles don't really add anything to our community. If there is legitimate news, then a serious news source will report on it. So, I'd like to compile a list of known content farms and place a blanket ban on articles submitted by those sites. I know www.screenrant.com is one such site that we get frequent submissions from. Feel free to list others in the comments below. And if you see a submission for a slop article, please report it, citing Rule 7: No Piracy, AI, or Bots.
Regarding the above point, if you have an argument for allowing posts from these sites and not creating a blanket ban on them, please share your thoughts. We want to consider all possibilities with this and other AI issues.
AI ART
The next part is regarding AI-generated art. We don't intend to change our stance on that. If your post contains art that was AI-generated, it's going to be removed. What makes this hard to enforce is that the models are getting too good and becoming harder and harder to recognize. Part of the updated rules state that art submissions should indicate how you created a piece of art, or where you found. We know not everyone is going to read this rule, so pictures won't automatically be removed if they don't have that information. However, if someone suspects a picture is AI-generated, or it receives a report, we'll remove the post and the only way to have it restored will be to provide the missing source information.
VIBE CODING
Now we come to something slightly controversial. How do we want to deal with websites that were coded with AI? The reality of the matter is that software development has changed. Almost no one is actually writing code that is completely free of AI assistance anymore. And if they are, there's no good way to prove it.
The previous part will still apply. If the site has any AI-generated artwork or text, then it will be removed. This is largely in response to a recent post someone made about a map/timeline website they created. Their original submission did have some small bits of AI artwork as place holders, and AI coding assistance was used to help develop the site, but most of the work was done by a human.
We purposefully ignored the reports on the original post because the AI-generated content was minimal, the post was highly upvoted, and the comments were generally positive. At the same time, that submission got more reports that any other post or comment in the last year. So we're asking for thoughts on these types of submissions. They have removed all AI-generated artwork from their sites and we allowed the new submission. But the code of the site was partially made using AI tools. As moderators, we think this is an acceptable use of AI, but we want to get your thoughts on the matter. There is a different between AI assisted coding and completely vibe coded content. I think regardless of what gets decided, any site that looks potentially dangerous in the way it was coded, or is clearly vibe coded and shows incomplete or broken functionality, will be removed under the No AI rule.
BOT ACCOUNTS
This next part is about LLM bots used as karma farms, or being built to sell later, or just used to train an LLM. We had a string of these recently. Here is an example:
I think there's a fourth one I missing and couldn't quickly find, and there have been a couple more after these that we've removed. They were all made by different accounts, created within days of each other, with similarly formatted names, and posting in the same pool of other subreddits. They are all talking about a shift in opinion about the same character. (Reminder that this is a No Spoiler post, so I don't want to discuss the contents of those posts in any detail).
There are a few issues with these kinds of bots we need to talk about. The first is that the sophistication of these is growing too complex. We moderators alone can't necessarily identify these kinds of accounts by ourselves. This one happened to be a bit too obvious, and we think it was assisted by vote manipulation, because their submissions are all a bit higher in upvote count than we'd normally expect. That said, all of the comments in the comment section of these post were good content. Possibly repetitive due to the nature of the subject, but largely legitimate discussion, which is something we want to foster.
The accounts above have been banned, but the posts are going to remain, largely so we can link them in this post and give others the chance to see what we're talking about. Combatting this kind of bot behavior is hard. Especially because repeat topic posts aren't unique to bots. We can get 4 different, legit post about Elayne in a single day.
We think the easiest solution for this kind of situation is to report them under Rule 6: Prioritize Unique, Discussion-Focused Content. (The wording is fancy for No Reposts and No Low Effort content). This will let us quickly find duplicate submissions and remove them. On the off chance that the submission isn't created by a bot, but is just coincidentally posting a similar topic, removing a post under this rule isn't as offensive to legitimate users.
If you suspect a particular account is a bot and have some evidence, you can also report it using the No AI rule, but it would help us if you provide a comment in the post (or send us a modmail) with why you suspect it's a bot. That helps us investigate infractions and deal with them faster.
We're also open to suggestions on how to better combat the bots on a more fundamental level. Our primary hang-up is that we don't want to make legitimate new readers and/or new reddit users jump through hoops in order to be able to contribute to our community. We don't have karma requirements, and we don't prevent new accounts from creating posts (although we do hold them for manual review).
EDIT: I have installed a Bot-Bouncer Devvit App. It's actually flagging these pretty well, so hopefully we can see a reduction in these kinds of posts and comments. But please still report anything that might slip past.
REPORT BUTTON
This last section is a plea to users to engage with the report button more. It's never going to be possible for us mods to read every single comment. Something has happened in the last year or two, but this community used to be pretty good at policing itself and helping us find infractions by reporting them. Overall, the number of reports we get has significantly decreased.
This means that sometimes when we find infractions (90% of the time it's just people being rude to each other), two or three people have been yelling back and forth at each other for an hour or two. If someone insults you, report them and don't engage. If you see two people insulting each other, report them both so we can cut off the chain of insults before it pollutes half the thread.
In the same vein, if you see someone being racist or sexist or some other hateful content, report it and don't engage with them. There are certainly times and conversations that warrant talking about difficult subjects like that in the wider context of the text itself, the fandom, and the author, but you don't need to be insulting while having those conversations. Report those making bad faith arguments and let us clear them away so that everyone else can have civil and well-reasoned discussions.