Like most people in this subreddit, I loved the show as a whole but was disappointed with the later seasons and especially the final one, for all the reasons that have been discussed to death. My biggest gripe is with a handful of plot lines/character arcs that seemed to be started and never really got a conclusion - the biggest examples are as below;
Kayce as a candidate for governor. At one point in Kayce’s run as livestock commissioner, he was gaining the backing of influential local ranchers who loved his hardline stance on cattle rustling etc, and they were openly offering to back him for the state governor’s position. Then it never seems to be mentioned again, even when the gubernatorial race is a huge part of the story. Now I get that not wanting that role would be very in character for Kayce, but AFAIK there was never even a scene in which he’s asked to run and declines, or where John asks him not to get involved, or which in any way explains why he’s not a part of the race. There was so much wasted potential here - Kayce reluctantly running in order to oppose Jamie, Kayce’s influence over the ranchers having the potential to swing the election to either John or his opponent and him being conflicted over it, etc. Failing that, there could have at least been a hand-wave explanation for him not getting involved, but as far as I recall there’s nothing.
Beth blaming herself for her mother’s death. Alongside the abortion/sterilisation incident and Jamie’s role in that, the mother’s death is clearly the main driver of Beth’s alcoholism and mental illness, and it just never gets resolved - nobody ever tells her she didn’t do shit wrong and it’s insane for John to have let her carry that burden for decades. IMO there was a perfect opportunity to do something with this when Carter’s error resulted in John’s horse being put down - an incident that closely mirrored Beth’s past in that a teenager was put in charge of a horse without proper training and then blamed for the consequences of their inevitable mistake. Carter was made to feel like shit for this - Beth could have shown some growth by making him realise he’s an untrained kid and has no reason to feel guilty, then the penny could have dropped re. her own situation. Or John could have shown growth by having the same revelation re. Carter and realising he’s unfairly made Beth feel a hundred times worse over a situation that was also out of her hands. Or Rip could have… ahh you get the idea. Basically they could have done SOMETHING to resolve or at least address that key element of Beth’s character
Those two are the biggest that I can think of but sure there are more, what are some other missed opportunities in your view?