r/acotar_rant • • 22d ago

Rant ✨🩷⚡️ACOSH RANT MEGATHREAD ⚡️🩷✨ SPOILER WARNING Spoiler

125 Upvotes

Hey, hi, hello ranters!

I know you all have Thoughts(™️) about the newest book in our favorite series, and boy do I want to hear them.

This megathread is for discussing all of your thoughts regarding the newest book. Spoilers will be rampant in here and we will not be requiring any spoiler tags on comments. If you don’t want to read any spoilers, why are you still here?? Learn some self discipline!!!! Go away!!!

Tell me:

What did you think of the POV’s? Who was your favorite? What scene made you roll your eyes the most?
Did any scene make your toes curl in your boots?

Feel free to share your thoughts chapter by chapter, give me a whole summary of the book, whatever suits your fancy.

some teensy tiny rules:
- no shipping drama. it’s fine to discuss ships but no fighting. take it to ship debate if you wanna deep dive <3 <3 <3
- normal sub rules still apply <3 <3 <3
- no outside drama blahhhhh keep it focused on the book THANK YOU!!!! <3 <3 <3
- mods reserve the right to delete comments as they deem necessary <3 <3 <3
- this sub is for snarkers, haters, and ranters alike. if you don’t like people’s comments, please consider just muting the sub instead of “well if you hate the books so much why do you read them?” because my answer is “go away we like being haters tyvm!” <3 <3 <3

mini mod announcement:

no posts about ACOSH will be allowed until Thursday. This is because we don’t require spoilers on this sub, and because Reddit’s algorithm forces this sub on people who don’t want to be spoiled!!! Feel free to make a post if you want in the meantime, but just know it won’t get approved until Thursday morning (8AM EST approximately)

Ok as always, love you, one million kisses to you all! 💋


r/acotar_rant • • Sep 03 '26

Mods / Admin Evil Mod Announcement

161 Upvotes

Hey, hi, hello ranters! The big Evil Mod is here to tell you that you will be seeing some new changes on this subreddit, and to please go ahead and yell at me now so we can get it over with ;-) (also, hi sloopies. can't wait to see you jerk this later <3)

First off, we need to clear the air. This sub is for EVERYBODY to rant, regardless of which "camp" they're in.

While we do allow people to share their critical opinions of this series, it's important to remember that ~everyone~ is allowed to participate. Some of you prefer Rhys, Feyre, the IC, etc. and some of you prefer Tamlin, Nesta, Lucien, etc. I want to make it clear that ALL of you are allowed to voice your opinions on characters here. With the new books coming out soon, we will have an influx of new readers on our sub. Let's keep this space welcoming towards all. <3

"So, what AM I allowed to rant about?" Oh, I thought you'd never ask!!! I've written up this handy dandy little cheat sheet for y'all to reference.

Rants that are acceptable:

  • "I do not like Tamlin because of x, y, z"
  • "I find Feyre insufferable because of _____"
  • "I LOVE Nesta but HATE Cassian"
  • "This fandom needs more positivity"
  • "I HATE the way SJM wrote this scene"

Rants that are not acceptable:

  • "Rhys faked his SA by Amarantha"

    Edit: This goes for all characters. No debating if anyone was SA’d or not.

  • "This [ship name]'s fans are EVIL"

  • "You support SA/racism/sexism/ableism if you think this"

  • general attacks on Sarah's personal life. Her writing style, plot choices or marketing is fine, but keep her personal life out of it.

  • targeted harassment towards others including users of other subs, their mods, etc.

So what's changing?

I've added some new rules:

No Gatekeeping. There's a perception that this sub is only for Tamlin/Nesta/Anti-IC fans, which I'd like us to get away from. Saying things like "are you lost?" on someone's rant because they're Anti-Tamlin/Nesta or Pro-IC does not mean they aren't allowed to post here. Everyone is welcome here. Some of you may have seen me comment something similar to this on people's posts. I will continue doing so, but now it's an Official Rule!!!!!

Let people rant! This is similar to the "no gatekeeping" rule, but slightly different. Do not tell people to stop reading the books because they have a negative opinion on something. Some people like hate-reading, some people like criticizing books, and some people just enjoy being a hater. That's okay. Telling people to "stop reading" the books is boring and halts discussion, ultimately pivoting the conversation away from the main point and results in arguments. Instead, I encourage you to challenge their rant instead. If someone says "Rhys is abusive because he twisted Feyre's arm," reply with something like "actually, it was a bone shard from the Wyrm. Here's where it says that in the books." If someone says, "Tamlin is an abuser," reply with your own evidence on why you disagree. Keep it civil!

Let new readers come to their own conclusions. If someone is a new reader, please let them come to their own conclusions. Do not spoil them for future events in the books. Do not try to change their mind on certain scenes or characters. New readers will have a new post flair they can use "New Reader, Spoilers OK" or "New Reader - No Spoilers". We all were new readers once, and most of us do not want to be spoiled. If the new reader says spoilers are okay, then that's fine. If they do not want spoilers, try your best to not spoil them. If you must, use the spoiler tag. > ! no spaces between the exclamation points ! <

Discussion and debates are allowed, but as soon as it turns into personal insults is when the mods have to step in. We do not like banning people. Please don't make us ban you. If we have to remove more than 10 of your comments in a month, you will get temporarily banned. If it continues after that, you will be permanently banned.

Additionally, as a reminder:

  • There's no victim blaming, no racism, no sexism, ableism, homophobia, or transphobia allowed.
  • Absolutely no AI use is allowed. Posts, comments, or images that are suspected of AI will be removed. Write your thoughts yourself - it doesn't have to be perfect, it just has to be from your own brain.
  • No outside drama. Screenshots of posts or comments from other subs with the direct intention of clowning on them is not allowed.
  • All posts get sent to the queue for mod approval. Sometimes it takes a while for us to approve it - this doesn't mean you necessarily did anything wrong! You can always send a modmail if it's been over 6 hours without a post approval, it'll help us see it sooner. If your post doesn't get approved, you will receive a reason as to why. If there's no reason, it just hasn't been approved yet!

If someone is engaging in bad faith arguments, trolling, or just being downright offensive: please report them and/or send a modmail. It's the fastest way to bring it to the mod's attention. I encourage you to disengage and move on if someone is behaving this way. Don't feed the trolls! Their stomach is bottomless and they'll never be satisfied.

*Basic Internet Safety Tips:

  • Reddit does allow you to make your posts and comments on your profile private now. This is something you can do from your account settings. Anyone caught stalking or harassing users will be permanently banned from this sub and reported to Reddit.
  • Do not doxx yourself. Be careful sharing links from IG or TikTok, as the links usually include your personal profile at the bottom.
  • Block anyone that makes you feel unsafe, uncomfortable, or you just can't stand seeing their posts/comments. Blocking people is to protect your own peace. It is okay to block people.

All of that being said,

The rant sub is really fun. I loveeeee reading everyone's theories and some of the discussions I've read on here have definitely changed my outlook on certain characters. Some of the best times I've had in the ACOTAR fandom have been on the rant sub. I love seeing all the silly memes, the cracktheories, the "hear me outs". Let's keep it fun, yeah?

Finally,

These rules are not to limit discussion or censor anyone, but to keep this community from turning into a one-note echo chamber. We want everyone to feel comfortable posting here. Thank you for understanding. <3

Okay, did you read all that? Are you mad at me? :( sorry bestie. I still love you!

"Excuse me ranters, sorry to bother you. I just have one more thing-"

We also aren't allowing any leaks about the upcoming books. Silly posts about leaks are allowed. Silly isn't banned.

EDIT:

After some feedback, I wanted to clear some things up.

debating, denying, or invalidating depictions of SA regarding ANY character is not allowed on this sub.

while this sub thrives on critical discussion, posts/comments that invalidates or debates SA quickly creates an unsafe environment for survivors in our community.

mentioning Rhys specifically in my “not allowed” guideline was meant as a general example, not an exception for him only.

moving forward, let’s keep this sub a safe space for everyone in our community. thank you 🩷


r/acotar_rant • • 6h ago

Rant azriel doing rhys’s dirty work is unnecessary

36 Upvotes

rhys’s whole thing about going into people’s minds without their consent being unethical is absolutely insane when his alternative is to have azriel torture those same people instead. waste of time and cruel.


r/acotar_rant • • 2h ago

ACOSH 🍞 Rejecting a mating bond VS “Unmating”

9 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

(A little disclaimer before I start: this isn't about shipping wars or anything like that, I'm just looking at this purely out of curiosity as a reader and what I'd find interesting to see)

I've been thinking about the mating bond mechanics in ACOTAR lately.

Ever since Elain and Lucien were revealed as mates, but with Elain clearly having no interest in it at the time, everyone in the fandom started talking about the possibility of Elain rejecting that bond. As a reader, that really caught my attention. Mainly because we already knew nature doesn't always pick right when it comes to mates but every single mating bond we'd seen in her books followed the exact same formula and worked out. So the idea of a rejection felt like completely uncharted territory. I was curious about it just because it was different.

However, the concept of whether mates can actually be unmated, breaking a bond that is already fully active and confirmed, is a possibility I hadn't even really considered before. Now that SJM has actually brought up the possibility, it stands out to me even more and makes it feel so much more interesting from a reader's perspective.

My working assumption has always been that if you reject the bond before it's truly established or accepted, it fades or never fully locks in, whereas breaking a confirmed bond I assumed it is way worse.

I'd love to hear what you guys think about the difference between both concepts, and whether you think Sarah will actually dare to fully develop either of these situations or if everything is just going to stay safe and work out as usual. Let me know your thoughts!


r/acotar_rant • • 5h ago

Hottake Rory Gilmore gives me Elain vibes.

8 Upvotes

Discuss!


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

Rant Re-read made me realize how dumb everyone is Spoiler

150 Upvotes

This is gonna be a long LONG rant about all of the icks I have for two of the characters so prepare I guess and Ill try to go in order bc I'm rereading the books and seeing spoilers and losing my mind bc what is happening

Ok, so to start off strong with our MC oh boy, where do I begin. I'm on book 3 rn and I've rolled my eyes so much they are gonna get permanently stuck soon. Feyre started off as this more or less ordinary person that was likable and went through a lot of shit but as the story progressed and she got powers, she started to become extremely insufferable. I'm still in the beginning where she is executing her ultra 1000+ IQ master plan to destroy the Spring Court bc her ex was an ass and she is just dumb as rocks and as prideful. You mean to tell me that her basically manipulating everyone, including her one genuine friend there, plus the staff and the residents, was completely okay just bc she was hurt by their High Lord?? Dragging everyone in her mess and drama with her ex bc her feelings were hurt and Tamlin became an asshole due to his own issues etc. She literally brought down an entire court bc she felt entitled to do so and bc she got some powers and thinks shes unstoppable and can do whatever she wants. All of the scenes where she was playing a power game and basically thinking to herself "Im so smart and cunning and beautiful", no youre just a cunt. Thinking shes so much better than literally everyone bc what?? Bad boy over there did some shitty stuff and no one in the history of anything has been through that kind of thing so she gets to do whatever?

I also read spoilers that she thought she should become High Queen or something and oh lord, please no. Girlie turned fae 10mins ago, became a teen mom in fae terms, just learned how to read and ur telling me she thinks shed make a great queen? Where is this audacity genuinely coming from, I need to know. And oh, her hypocrisy when it comes to Tamlin and Rhyssand and even Lucien is just... so idiotic and infuriating bc bat boy gets a pass cus hes hot and powerful but Tamlin doesnt bc the author decided she hates him now and so we should as well. I think Feyre is genuinely stupid, I'm not even joking or trying to be funny, she doesnt even know court politics or the history of the place she wants to rule over and is barely a High Lady like... go back to the cottage pls. I also find the image of her drawings being ugly hilarious and the fact that she painted the wooden cabin insulting bc what made you think that was okay? She had spent like 2 months in the Night Court and started doing whatever and order everyone like WHO ARE YOU???? I would've laughed in her fucking face alongside the whole IC bc who tf did you bring here and why is she the person I need to bow down to the fuck? Anyway, after learning that she has became a mom as well I've lost all interest in her bc she has been reduced to the pregnancy trope and from what I see, has become a Boy Mom which I find just as unappealing as her so ig she has become nothing more than Feyre, The Mom.

Now, onto the other character I'm lowk starting to dislike or actually already do, Rhys. My my, just his pure existence is hypocrisy on itself and all of his actions as well. Now, I need everyone to put on their thinking caps and lets do a quick comparison between Tamlin and Rhys:

- Tamlin, initially, took care of Feyre and tried to be as welcoming as he could, considering the circumstances and the chaos everything was in and also the fact he couldnt even directly tell her the truth.

- He gave her family riches and basically set them for life.

- He took care of her and genuinely loved her

- His powers had been reduced to almost nothing and yet, he still tried to protect her and his people

- In the end, because of his trauma and idiocy, he did a lot of shit, like borderline abusing Feyre and thinking he was doing good while harming her

- Did a very risky shitty deal in order to get her back bc he was so worried and heartbroken bc of the rumors of the Night Court that Rhyssand HIMSELF KEPT FEEDING INTO AND KEPT PRETENDING WERE TRUE AND NEVER DENIED THEM SO EVERYONE THOUGHT THAT WAS THE TRUTH, INCLUDING TAMLIN

- Rhyssand licked and kissed Feyre without consent UTM, scenes which I both found extremely gross and weird and I hated him for it

- He basically drugged her, gave her no clothes and paraded her around like his personal thing, all mostly to taunt Tamlin bc of his personal vendetta and jealousy

- Made fun of her multiple times and also caused her pain by twisting the bone in her arm in that one scene

- Pretended to be an evil asshole so he could ''protect her'' and had no qualms about fucking her even though she never really ended things with Tamlin officially

All in all, Rhyssand is a two faced piece of shit that did far worse things than Tamlin but its ok bc hes hot winged bat boy and very powerful and actually very kind and only cares about like a quarter of his entire court. He genuinely deserves the same amount of hate as Tamlin, if not even more, bc just bc he had trauma himself or wtv doesnt excuse him doing even half of the shit he has done. Also, him "protecting'' Feyre UTM was literally mostly done out of selfish reasons like jealousy and hatred and he used her to get under Tamlin's skin like bruh. Ur 500+ years old and u act like a 15 year old with a crush, genuinely get a life and grow up. And also, the whole withholding information from Feyre regarding her OWN HEALTH is okay but when Tamlin does the same, it's not??? There's genuinely a double standard here and it's very annoying to see, like a man is a man at the end of the day and all of this slobbering over Rhyssand and the other males in his IC is just annoying cus they're all immature assholes who had like hundreds of years to deal with their shit and never did like ok, at some point I stop caring and feeling bad bc what are you doing?? Rhyssand is also a liar and a manipulator and should NOT, under any circumstances, become a King of anything. Bro should deal with his own court first and then think about the rest bc wdym Illyrian women STILL get their wings clipped and are reduced to house maids?? Wasn't he the most powerful High Lord in history or something and very scary so like... what, exactly, is stopping him? "Change takes time" ok, well usually not that much unless ur not doing anything about it which seems to be the case. Truthfully, Rhyssand only gives a shit about Velaris which is his perfect little home and the rest of the NC can go fuck itself, alongside the people he supposedly cares about and loves.

Now, for the rest i dont have much to say yet bc I still havent read ACOSH but from I hear, Ill hate everyone else too soon enough so yeah. More coming in the future and pls feel free to add onto this and rent yourself etc.


r/acotar_rant • • 16h ago

ACOSH 🍞 ACOSH (and partly ACOSF) rant

21 Upvotes

[spoilers for all the books, especially ACOSF and ACOSH below. in depth rants about every character and also plot points in ACOSH]

what a waste of time. i spent a week rereading all of the other books in the series and it was amazing and i genuinely think this book had to be ghostwritten or something. like ive never hated characters more or wanted to drop a series this bad. im not a DNFer in general, and acotar was my favorite series (up until this point), but this book really might change that.

list of grievances:

  • nesta: ok this is one of my biggest gripes. i used to be a nesta hater, upon my reread i started to love her character and definitely now see her as one of the strongest and well written characters. she is one of the few in the series who has exhibited actual growth, and has a real personality beyond growling or having watery bowels imo. her giving the mask to bryce is definitely something that feyre would have done (which she agrees with herself), and probably even a lot of the rest of the IC. so i'm insanely confused on why everyone is so mad at her. like yes i get that it put prythian at risk but havent they all done things that put prythian at risk??? and even if they were mad at her, it makes so little sense to me that theyre THIS mad at her. like sure, a little talking-to, some yelling, fine. but wdym theyre all actively ignoring and punishing her like WHAT. especially cassian (which is my next point) bc if anything i would think he would support her??? god i love nesta and this was so strange to me honestly idk why she even bothers w the IC anymore atp i think SHE should be high lady. also the concept of rhys being so mad at her when like at the end of acosf he's thanking her on his knees and showering her w jewelry and everything for saving feyre's and nyx's lives, like correct me if i'm wrong but i would think his gratefulness for oh yeah saving his whole family would outweigh his anger at her giving away the mask that made it back safely???
  • cassian: while i used to be a huge cassian fan, upon my reread of the first 5 books i slowly started to cool down and dislike him more. but holy shit what happened to him in acosh??? like he CRAWLED to nesta across a battlefield and now she broke her arm and her mental health is deteoriating and she's trying to talk to him and all she wants is her mate or her husband or whatever tf he is and all he wants to do is get laid. like what. absolute character assassination bffr. and the fact that he breaks her confidence by telling rhys what nesta tells him privately is so awful and such a betrayal of everything a relationship stands for, especially with him knowing that nesta struggles to open up and wouldn't want her innermost thoughts displayed to rhys. i hope neris happens instead bc it looks like there's very little redemption for him. how do you come back from ignoring your mate's injuries and deteriorating mental health and inner pain and then just focus on her body and then go ahead and break her trust?? you don't. please please let nesta + eris happen that would be perfect.
  • rhys: okay nvm this might actually be my biggest gripe. wtf is sjm doing to rhys's character?? on my reread i started noticing the character assassination in earlier books too (especially putting a shield on feyre and not telling her about the baby killing her in acosf when those are both things she hated tamlin for), but who tf does this guy think he is. "oh we don't enforce rank in my court" my ass. first he had the nerve in acosf to tell cassian to get nesta out of the city before he killed her... for what??? telling feyre the truth he should've in the first place?? and the way he is treating azriel in acosh is actually taking me out (and in the azriel bonus scene, not sure what book that's originally from). i mean you would think them being brothers would put them on equal footing, or that he would care more about what his so-called brother needs or wants (whether azriel actually wants elain or wants an escape is tbd, but not relevant to my point atm) than the alliances. like i agree they're in a hard time and need to focus on building alliances and need lucien's help, but rhys clearly acts like he would put his family before everyone else, and he's just... not doing that. lowk if rhys died i would not shed tears icl. and why does he act like azriel doesnt have feelings omg saying he can find someone in the city but like the heart wants what it wants and all that but why does rhys not think his own brother has a heart and his own desires and feelings is my question. i would pick tamlin over rhys atp. side note also him not telling feyre a lot of things feels wildly out of character, like the only one i can think of off the top of my head is how he doesn't tell her he gave nesta the swords back but there's a lot of instances where he just doesn't tell her something which goes against everything he says in book 2.
  • feyre: adding onto the previous thing, feyre just accepts not being told things by rhys, it feels very submissive and out of character consisdering how strongly she felt about being in the loop in book 2. but i digress. the main point is that feyre is power hungry. obviously. i dont absolutely hate her like i do rhys now, but she wants to be high queen so bad omg. like i actually cant w her 😭 she also just thinks she knows allat when she's like 23??? and has been fae for a few YEARS??? more people need to call her on her bs, except that when they do, like amren, she just shuts them down bc she's high lady and apparently that makes her god in her eyes. like what. also im so pissed at her for not standing up to rhys for how he's acting. like in acosf she tells cassian that rhys had no right to chase nesta out of the city, but then proceeds to do... what about it? nothing. and you could say that feyre doesn't owe her sisters anything but this is a long shot from the same girl who told rhys that her sister wasn't some wild animal in acowar. same with acosh, when nesta describes rhys as acting like a tyrant (which he def is), feyre agrees, but she never steps in. somehow she is both deferring to rhys on everything, which is not the sign of a healthy partnership, but is power hungry and wants to be high queen and doesn't gaf about his own feelings. hm. also the concept of trying to encroach on the library under the house does not sit right w me, like it was gifted by rhys to the priestesses to ensure they feel safe and feyre thought that their safety was secondary to her need to kill. alr, makes a lot of sense. what happened to the girl who pleaded for no more death or killing?
  • azriel: as i mentioned earlier, upon my reread, i lost my love for cassian but wow did i gain some for azriel. after reading acosh that's gone too. i feel for him, but not in the same way i did for nesta in acosf, if that makes sense. he's obviously going through something, but like i genuinely think he might be going insane. the way his thoughts are very stream of consciousness and the way he wants elain bc she chases his darkness away is very icky to me. i see a lot of potential for az becoming a villain, which really hurts bc i do love his character. but he's very "i'll take elain w me and we'll run bc we love each other" when no, neither of you love each other. he just wants a reprieve from the shadows and i genuinely think he would resort to kidnapping her by framing whatever situation she's in as part of the narrative he's creating, and i feel like the last chapter w his POV really suggested something major going down. like he might even be possessed by koschei at this point idk. i think he's going to either be a villain or something drastic will have to happen to fix his mental state and let me tell you i do not think its going to be sleeping w elain, not by a long shot. EDIT: more of a theory, and i don't really have strong feelings on azriel ships bc i used to be an elain + azriel shipper but on the reread i didnt really gaf, but imo this book confirmed elain and azriel won't end up together. their relationship is completely built on trauma and escape, and i don't see this ever turning into a healthy relationship. i mean azriel is thinking about running away with her and elain is thinking about running away FROM him. i think the inclusion of gwyn's pov at the end was very intentional and strongly suggests azriel (hopefully after receiving some MUCH-NEEDED therapy) will end up with gwyn. as for elain, no idea what'll happen to her (i honestly doubt she'll end up with lucien, i've lightly shipped lucien with tinker for a while though bc he deserves someone who treats him well) but idk.
  • mor: i have not liked mor for this whole reread but since she's basically been written out of the series i'll keep my complaints to a minimum. she's consistently trying to ruin everyone's life, like she's always acting all flirty w cassian in acosf KNOWING it'll hurt nesta, and behaving coldly w her for no reason. in acosh she has the nerve to ask azriel if him sleeping w elain has to do w her, like why does she think so highly of herself omg. i cant. she just rubs me the wrong way, especially knowing that she's keeping smth secret about eris all those years ago.
  • lucien: no complaints, i just feel bad for him and hope he finds real love.
  • amren: same thing, except for when she apologized to feyre in acosh bc why tf would you do that. i do think she may end up betraying the IC bc i feel like they're setting her character up that way (excessive apologies, the hint in acowar where feyre thinks amren betrayed them when she makes feyre put her hand on the cauldron, telling nesta to bring gwydion to the prison where it immediately vanishes), but that's not something i hate her for and honestly feels the most consistent w the rest of the books than any of the other plot points.
  • elain: only opinion that didn't change on the reread... i've never liked elain. something always felt off, and it's clear to me that she's being extremely manipulative of everyone's relationships and their general coddling of her. she acts stifled by it, but she is obviously exploiting it. rhys even describes it as "elain is elain" or something in a previous book, as if she's somehow less at fault for letting feyre go into the woods than nesta is by virtue of her sweet nature. like... i don't see it. since we didn't really get anything from her POV or learn about her inner thoughts, we don't know if she actually feels for azriel, but i doubt it. i think she's also just seeking an escape, a way to be more interesting, as she put it. she just gives entitlement to me too and i cant stand it. EDIT: adding a theory that's just one of my measly hopes for redeeming this series - i definitely do think elain is being manipulated by koschei bc she was horrified at the thought of seeing skin through the illyrian leather pants in acowar i believe and now she's not even that horrified at everyone seeing her half naked?? this CANNOT be the same elain like a lot of the other things can be chalked up to character assassination but this is wildly out of character surely there's a reason for it.

now that we're done w the characters, other problems i have w acosh:

  • the whole defending the humans on the continent thing. i mean, tarquin was 100% right. also genuinely what makes feyre and rhys think that they're so intelligent and know what's best for everyone? tarquin rightly said they hadn't asked for aid, so why should they aid them? everything makes sense but their attitudes. like seriously why is feyre disgusted at the fact that no one wants to send their friends and family to be slaughtered for people they dont know and who are halfway across the world and who dont even want help. it makes very little sense.
  • the excessive focus on motherhood. i have never had a problem with depictions of motherhood, but that is not what this book was supposed to be. it's a romantasy, for gods sake. nyx is cute and all, but every other page there was something about him being so cute or his sleep schedule or his crib or rhys and feyre defending him or him feeding and like PLEASE STOP. we get it. you have a baby. you're taking care of him. why don't we focus on the real plot, which i'm assuming was meant to be about that hot mess of human problems.
  • the reversal of every bit of good that was done. book 5 is all about nesta's growth, her friendship with emerie and gwyn, her training. and yet we pop into book 6 finding that she is once again struggling, she is barely friends w emerie and gwyn anymore, and none of them are training. emerie is back in the illyrian store, and gwyn is back in the library. what's the point of book 5 then if youre just going to reverse everything?? i do not get it.

ok thats my rant, i think in the future on rereads im just going to stop at book 5. i have problems w that too but it has nesta's journey, which i love, and there are many, many more problems w book 6. i will still keep reading the rest of the series but im basically going to only treat the first 4 books as canon bc WHAT.


r/acotar_rant • • 9h ago

Theory All about water baby

1 Upvotes

Not exactly a theory but hear me out.

Gwen's nymph ancestors, Mama Archeron's drowned cousing, Kochei's lake and House of Many Waters. There's also that song of the willow tree in acotar, which reminds me of the Rusalka myth (slave folclore). She's a water nymph that was drowned and sings by a willow tree. There's also Tamlin's mysterious lake that was literally never brought up again.

I don't know, I do have a feeling that all of this will converge, eventually. What do y'all think?


r/acotar_rant • • 22h ago

Rant The only thing that’ll really piss me off is……

6 Upvotes

…. If the world ends before we get the answers we’re all theorizing about. Like if we don’t make it to January I’m gonna be super pissed that I’ll never know - if Feysand are in fact bad guys?? are the Valg still running rampant through the Maasverse?? Are the Valg the Asteri?! WHO IS THE BETRAYER?!?! HOW DID ELAINE GET ONTO THE BATTLEFIELD TO KILL HYBURN?!?!? WILL CASSIAN FIND HIS BALLS?!?!?

I will not be able to just roll over and die not knowing and will have to partake in some sort of cross continent dystopian mission to get my hands on this somehow.

I have a few unfinished series I’m waiting on but the build up for this will actually anger me to the point of villainy if I’m drinking bathtub water in the dark and reading the full wheel of time series I got at the thrift store.

That or “if it was all a dream”


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

ACOSH 🍞 Az and Elain - a discussion on ACOSH (not a shipping post)

9 Upvotes

I’ll start by saying this isn’t a shipping post. I don’t have any preference of who ends up with who and a just along for the ride. I just finished the book and wanted to discuss the events that took place regarding these two while it’s fresh in my head:

1. kitchen scene: I feel like Rhys was the only one making sense here. Az spent so long sulking after this and it was honestly making me mad because did you even hear what he said 😂 he basically says Elain should at least formally reject the bond first - which yes, makes complete sense. Why string Lucien along and give him any hope. I feel like Elian just wants to ignore the bond until it goes away but it doesn’t work like that. And he also said, do what you want just not in my house - which he’s also entitled to so I really don’t see what the problem is here 😅

2. Rhys relating to Lucien: I thought this was a good touch and made so much sense. Even though the circumstances are different, he can understand how it feels to know your mate is with someone else and doesn’t wish that for Lucien. I actually thought it was a sweet gesture towards Lucien on his part which we don’t see often.

3. Az and Elain on Autumn Equinox: okay so this whole situation is so avoidable. Like they managed to stay away from each-other until the one time Lucien is staying in the house 🤦🏻‍♀️ it almost felt intentional and maybe Elain wanted Lucien to know because she can’t just have a conversation and say she doesn’t want the bond. It felt petty on Azriels part, he knew the thing about the blood duel and how Rhys wanted to not hurt Lucien and keep him as an ally. Did he do it to spite Rhys? I don’t know, it was pretty stupid on both their parts and very easily avoidable for one night.

4. The aftermath: I liked how even though Rhys was pissed he never threw Az under the bus with Lucien and just said, “Yes, I knew” and didn’t try to explain that he tried to stop it. Like the damage is done and even though he’s pissed off at Az, he’s on his side and it was clear. Obviously everyone’s shock made perfect sense. Nesta snapping at Rhys to “watch your tone” was so uncalled for imo. It wasn’t about her and she used a similar tone with Elain the next day so girl what do you mean 😂

5. The argument with the sisters: this is perhaps one of my favorite moments of all three sisters in the whole series. I was rooting Nesta on like yes girl you tell her! 😂 seriously one my favorite Nesta moments ever and Elain really needed to hear that. I like how she stayed with her that night and didn’t say anything but then told her how it is the day after. I also would like to know how all the Rhys haters felt about this? I swear people have been hating him about this since the bonus chapter in SF so what are your thoughts about Nesta basically saying the exact same thing? I also am glad Nesta is the one who called her out and not Feyre because I swear if it was Feyre people would just hate and say Rhys and Feyre suck and she’s just saying what he’s saying because he’s her mate.

Anyway, those are just my thoughts on the whole situation. Would love to hear how others felt! And no, I don’t hate Elain or Az, they’re not my favorites and never have been but I just think they’re being very immature about the whole situation.


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

Theory There isn’t one forgotten melody Spoiler

10 Upvotes

“Elain is the forgotten melody!” “No, the mating bond between Az and Gwyn is the forgotten melody!” “No the dusk court is the forgotten melody!” Etc etc etc.

But why does there have to be one forgotten melody? I mean just look at splintered harmony. Was only one thing the splintered harmony? No! The Valkyries are a splintered harmony. The IC is a splintered harmony. Nessian is a splintered harmony. Lucien’s whole life is a splintered harmony. Azriel and Elain caused a splintered harmony. I mean the whole of Prythian is basically a splintered harmony. That’s the point of this book. That’s why it’s called a court of splintered harmony.

So why do people act like there can only be one forgotten melody? Literally every character in ACOSH had a splintered harmony, so maybe every character will have a forgotten melody.

Maybe Gwyns and Azriels mating bond is a forgotten melody. Maybe Nesta and Cassians love for each other is another forgotten melody. Maybe Elain is another forgotten melody. The dusk court is a forgotten melody. I think we will see the same thing happen as in acosh where every character will have their own forgotten melody. I’m curious for theories on what Mors/Lucien/Emerie etc. forgotten melodies will be.


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

ACOSH 🍞 Azriel needs to go with Nesta, not Elain.

103 Upvotes

This is NOT a post for Azriel/Nesta as a couple, but as platonic friends.

I REPEAT: this is NOT a post for Azriel/Nesta a couple, BUT AS FRIENDS. It might be shocking to some, but a guy and a woman can actually be FRIENDS.

You got that? Good. Then read on.

People have already pointed out several theories about whether Elain will end up with Lucien or Az, that she isn't happy in the Night Court...

But guess what, Azriel isn't happy there either, guys.

After centuries of unresolved trauma and serving as Rhys' spymaster/torturer, Azrielno longer quietly takes orders, he openly questions them. He goes on dangerous missions without his High Lord/Lady knowing about it. Rhys even wonders directly "where his brother is".

Hmmm, geez, Rhys, how could that be? Maybe because you never ASK Az how he feels about torturing people? Whether he wants to go for a nice vacation in the Summer Court, drink some cocktails by the beach? Whether he wants to build a family of his own instead of doing your dirty work for the next thousand or so years?

If Az isn't brooding, he's spying on Vallahan, giving orders to the two wraiths or sparring with Cassian. We rarely see him do anything else but his job. His entire identity is being "Rhys' spymaster" or "the Shadowsinger".

Enter Elain, who seeks responsibilities which Az wants to escape from, but who has no clue on how to act when said responsibilities are presented to her. Elain, who longs to leave the Night Court, who seeks distraction from self-loathing through sex - just like Azriel.

Leaving the Night Court was the best thing Elain did for Azriel. Because that distance will stop Azriel from putting Elain (and Mor) on a saintly pedestal and finally choose putting himself first. And he, NOT Cassian, will choose to leave the Night Court with Nesta.

I know. Shocking, right. I also assumed for a long while that Cassian will go with Nesta as her general to train her Valkyries. But Cassian has shown time and time again in ACOSF and in ACOSH that his primary loyalty is to Rhys and Illyria. Meanwhile, Az outright despises the Illyrians. Like Nesta, Az has a rebellious streak towards Rhys. Nesta, who is currently considering whether she can still trust Cassian with her most private thoughts, who is also contemplating whether her destiny lies beyond the Night Court, who has also been a victim of Rhys' wrath, who was the only one who stood up to Rhys for Az, while everyone else was coddling Elain.

Once Azriel lets go of Elain and Mor, I strongly believe he'll leave the Night Court with Nesta and find his self-worth among the other Valkyries in Dusk. Not to serve as a spymaster/torturer, but to understand the valkyries and the people in Hewn City through his Shadows. For so long, Azriel has been afraid to unleash his Shadows/true self - and I believe Nesta will be the one to help him overcome that self-loathing and be accepting of who he is.

Shadows do not exist at Night, nor in full daylight. They thrive in Dusk, where they are at their fullest potential.


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

ACOTAR 🐺🏹 Grammar Nerds, assemble!

10 Upvotes

Since the first book, I have noticed a consistent choice of SJM that I personally think MIGHT be grammatically incorrect. I’m curious to see if anyone else has noticed this or if anyone agrees with me!

(Before I dive in, I will say that I am a grammar nerd myself but I am prepared to be wrong about this. It sounds wrong to me, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it IS technically wrong.)

Frequently in dialogue or inner monologues, SJM uses the phrase “________ or no” to add emphasis or punctuate a thought. Personally, I think it should be “_____ or not” in most cases. (I also think she uses this device way too often.)

Here’s a few examples from ACOTAR:

“High Lord of Prythian or no, I wouldn’t cower, not after what I’d been through today.”

“Tamlin providing for them or no, glamouring them or no, I’d been erased from their lives.”

“I’d be damned if I let it become a weakness again, his personal agenda or no.”

Has anyone else noticed how often she uses this? Does it strike anyone else as sounding awkward or incorrect? I’ve been wondering this for a long time!


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

ACOSH 🍞 Questioning Sarah J. Maas's choices: Did she ruin Nessian, and is she trolling the fandom?

175 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I read ACOSH when it came out and ever since then I have the same thoughts circulating in my head. I need to know if I'm the only one feeling this way.

My main issue is that after reading this book, there are so many pieces that don't fit, and I honestly don't know which of those issues were intentionally planned by Sarah and which ones are just poor writing.

Take Nesta and Cassian, for example. I actually liked them in ACOSF, I thought they were endgame and people were never happy (yeah, I’m sorry) and also Eris didn’t do it for me either. But as soon as I read this new book and saw Cassian’s attitude (which was absolute sh*t) And how Eris keeps showing his interest on her, let me tell you, I’ve never switched sides faster. I’m loving all of these pumpkin spice guys instead of the bat boys, if I’m honest hahaha. My girl Nesta simply doesn't deserve that kind of treatment.

People have been very loud about how Cassian didn’t treat her right all of these years. So here is my question: If she intends for Cassian and Nesta to be endgame, why make Cassian even worse? Why write the relationship and his attitude in a way that makes it go backward, especially when Eris right there is showing that kind of interest?

I had to confess that while I was reading I was getting this weird feeling that it seemed like she read fan theories and she was trolling us. Like the whole Azriel/Elain situation, that felt like complete nonsense to me. (like for a minute I thought I was reading a fanfic kind of nonsense)

And I think Sarah said in her CHD interview that she doesn't let fan theories influence her, but reading this book, it genuinely felt like she was half-mocking those theories.

So I'm just really confused. What is going on with the writing here? Are these choices meant to be subtle setup for the next book, or has the writing just completely lost the plot? I'd love to hear your thoughts.


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

ACOMAF 💍🐦‍⬛ "My High Lady" right...

243 Upvotes

Just finished Acomaf and im gonna go ahead guess that the "High Lady" title is gonna be absolutely useless and is just gonna be used as a reason why Rhys is better Tamlin. Cuz the Night Court has a High Lady and the Sping Court doesn't. Dont piss me off. But idk let me go read the next.


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

Rant Midway through ACOSH and now I don’t like Azriel

56 Upvotes

No spoilers plz but Azriel is coming off as so woe is me, I’m pathetic, I hate myself…. He’s written so unlikable. Also cassian being so cold to Nesta is such a departure from the Cassian we met. Why is she destroying these characters?


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

ACOSH 🍞 I never DNF an audiobook. Let alone in a series I love. But ACOSH literally sucks all joy from my soul

51 Upvotes

I always do chores and general life while listening to audiobooks. My hobbies are done with an audiobook.

But when I play ACOSH (currently got 2 hours left of listening) I stop wanting to do anything. It drains all motivation and joy from me. I feel exhausted and want to go to bed. Just seeing it on my phone makes me feel sad.

I can't even put my finger on why this is. I've listened to plenty of books that had similar themes - political tension, parenthood, relationships, sudden character changes, and plenty of "bridge" novella type book where nothing really happens. I can't quite diagnose ACOSH with any single issue that makes it so difficult and depressive. It just is.

Not sure if anyone else has experienced this depressed feeling whilst reading (or listening to) this book, but if you have, please help me understand and pinpoint what is causing this. I feel so let down by this series now.


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

Hottake Anddd the healthiest couple award goes to…

60 Upvotes

Why are Kallius and Vivianne the most perfect and intriguing couple and we don’t even get their POV 😭😭

We only get a brief description of their love story and its amazing and not toxic and he’s been obsessed with her his whole life and he protected her from Amarantha and he went straight to her after he was freed and she took care of his people for 50 years and she never stopped looking for ways to free him and she didn’t realise she loved him until he was gone and they didn’t know they were mates until they were doing the you know what and hes the best and shes the best and i want more pls


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

Rant ACOTAR is the next Got (derogatory)

45 Upvotes

Major spoilers for Game of Thrones and the entire ACOTAR series below.

As a once huge fan of Game of Thrones and a currently spiraling fan of ACOTAR, I fear the next two books will be the Season 6-8 of Game of Thrones all over again. The fandom has been at each other’s throats since ACOSF and ACOSH has the fandom fractured into wildly different ideologies about all of the characters. There is simply no way that SJM ends this book franchise with all of her readers. I have already seen some people cancelling their pre-orders for ACOFM and I know if certain things do or do not happen in this next book, myself and many others will be done with the series.

I would like to say that I do not think my opinion is the only correct opinion, everyone is welcome to their opinions on characters and plots! I am just going to speak from my personal opinions because that’s all I have to go off of.

Azriel alone has four different ships, and the ship wars are brutal. And may I add that there is actually a fifth ship that I am a part of, which is Azriel needs to go to THERAPY and be alone for another 50 years to mature and work on himself. In the next book we will either get Azriel and Elaine’s ships confirmed, or it will be dragged out until the third book, but this next 900 page book will have to show us which ship is sailing. Only one ship can win unless SJM is brave enough for a polycule (likely not), so more than likely only the Elriels, Gwynriels, Azris, or Bryceriels will survive and three of those groups will be very upset. Not that that’s SJM’s fault, but it’s just one piece of a major puzzle that is going to piss people off next book.

The three Archerons have divided the fandom so much and I think this is the real tipping point. Some of us hate Feyre, some of us hate Nesta, some of us hate Elaine. And I think hate is a strong word to use, because most of us (myself included!) just want to see them held accountable for their actions and for them to continue growing as characters. I think it’s possible for this to happen, but very unlikely that it will happen in a way that doesn’t totally isolate half the fandom. My personal belief is that Feyre and the IC need past decisions to blow up in their faces so that they can reckon with their choices and grow as better leaders. There’s a whole other half of the fandom that thinks Feyre and Rhys have never done a single thing wrong in their life and are unable to be criticized. If SJM gives them another character arc that hold them accountable and has them grow, half the fandom throws a fit. If she doesn’t hold them accountable and pretends actions don’t have consequences for our perfect main characters, I’m going to throw a fit 😂 I don’t want a full Daenarys arc for Feyre, I’d just like SJM to say “hey maybe a 21 year old doesn’t know everything about ruling” and have Feysand work more on their diplomatic relationships and fixing their own court’s issues.

Elaine has not been given a single POV so far, and I don’t understand why people are so ride or die for her right now. I think that she COULD be a really interesting character and that hopefully we get her POV next book to explain things, but until then I don’t understand why people are defending her from any criticism at all. I am of the camp that believes she is being manipulated by Koeschi, not that she herself is evil or anything, but that she is being controlled or has chosen to sacrifice herself to save her family. That could be a really interesting character arc for her! But there are people who see absolutely no issue with anything she’s done in ACOSF or ACOFM and if SJM reveals that she is under a spell, they’ll be upset that criticism of her was correct.

Nesta is my ride or die and I think her arc and Elaine’s is what’s going to cause the most amount of lost fans next books. I think that there is nothing SJM can do with Nessian moving forward that doesn’t result in a loss of readers. I want them to break up so badly, even if it’s just temporarily I need Nesta to realize her worth and go on a solo journey without him dragging her down. Cassian needs to pick between Rhys and Nesta. If they stay together and SJM continues to write a toxic relationship as “perfect mates”, I will never read a book by her again. They are both deeply dysfunctional together and SJM should not be showing it as a perfect love story. Now, if SJM does break them up, a LOT of readers I have seen will be greatly insulted by this because they don’t see an issue either Nessian and would see it as SJM betraying them. If Nesta stays in the IC where they don’t trust or respect her, I will be upset. If Nesta goes to another court, a lot of readers will be upset.

And most importantly, if absolutely anyone becomes High King or Queen, I think half the fandom will riot. Feyre, Rhys, Nesta, Elaine, or Lucien. Absolutely none of the options will make everyone happy. And I know it’s not SJM’s job to make everyone happy! This is her story and she is going to tell it how she wants. I just have not seen a fandom this divided on opinions of characters and how the series should end since Game of Thrones, and absolutely everyone agrees that GoT was a horrible tv show and they refuse to rewatch it because of how disappointing the ending was.

I’d love to hear RESPECTFUL thoughts on how SJM could tie this up all nicely in a bow and not isolate most of the fandom. I don’t think any of the characters are evil or beyond redemption, I’d just really like to see each and every one of them grow in the next 900 chapters and fix their relationships, but I just can’t see SJM doing it without insulting a lot of people.


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

Rant 5 chapters into ACOSH - cauldron boil me (spoilers) Spoiler

78 Upvotes

Feyre became an even more entitled teenager, the high lady title got into her head a bit too much. Like she's only willing to listen to her precious mate, only his opinion matters.

Everyone is treating Nesta like she's a traitor to the supreme nation, including Cassian (don't even get me started on this POS). If Nesta burns the NC to the ground I will genuinely be happy for her.

Like they can see her mental health is deteriorating again but she didn't listen to the supreme leader Rhys so why should anybody give a shit right??

Az needs 500 years of therapy.

Elain is precious baby who still needs a protective bubble.

BREASTMILK BREASTMILK BREASTMILK.

everyone is STRETCHED THIN.

Anyway wish me luck and sanity thank you


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

ACOSH 🍞 Just finished ACOSH. This is my review / ranting. Let me know your thoughts Spoiler

44 Upvotes

This book has been all over the place. The plot is practically nonexistent, and the multiple POVs seem to serve only as a way to give us more insight into increasingly awful people. This series is becoming a case of "the less I know of everyone, the better". I don't want any more inner dialogue. They're all awful people.

Once we got out of the daemati's rose-coloured lenses of Feyre darling, everything started looking a little less appealing. The Inner Circle basically sucks. Everyone is either a mindless follower, a fanatic driven by jealousy and resentment, or a full-turned conqueror and tyrant. And the more we get into their heads, the less I understand what exactly we're supposed to admire about them.

More POVs should ideally complicate our understanding of a character. They should introduce contradictions, expose blind spots, challenge our assumptions and make the world feel larger. Instead, they're revealing that the people we've been asked to admire are considerably less appealing when we actually understand their motivations. And the worst part is that they don't necessarily become more interesting. The book opens up their interiority without necessarily giving us the depth we expected.

There's also a particularly frustrating contradiction in the way the Inner Circle talks about family. They call each other brothers, they talk about loyalty, sacrifice and belonging, but underneath that, there's so much competition, resentment and insecurity. At some point, you have to wonder whether these people actually like each other or whether they've simply spent centuries reinforcing a shared identity that none of them knows how to leave. The batboys call each other brothers while holding an extraordinary amount of resentment, jealousy and contempt for one another. Idk, dude.

The war being the only conflict Sarah comes up with to reinforce the IC's role as saviours against the establishment is truly reductive. But besides that, the way this one is being set up is just as frustrating. There's an actual already stablished threat to Prythian: Koschei. That should logically demand political coordination, intelligence gathering, military preparation and strategic alliances. Instead of gathering forces and strategizing about how to face that threat, these people are meddling in conflicts in other lands because "how would they face Nyx in the future?" And not only that, but apparently this is reason enough for the other courts to blindly follow them into a conflict that, again, doesn't affect their territories, that the Night Court wants to involve itself in because of its own agendas, and that would once again put all the people of those courts at risk.

All these people who, different from the Night Court, were under Amarantha's rule and went from that straight into war, and now the IC is acting like a bunch of warmongers, while those who don't align with them are suddenly unreasonable, untrustworthy people? Why should the other courts risk their populations, their armies and their political stability for a conflict that the Night Court wants to pursue? Especially when the Night Court seems to regard their cooperation as something they're entitled to.

There's a distinction between being a responsible political ally and being an expansionist power, and the IC seems increasingly unable to tell the difference.

This also undermines the worldbuilding. We are supposedly dealing with several distinct courts, each with its own history, interests, political structures and populations. But when the story needs them to cooperate, suddenly their individual interests become inconvenient details. Their rulers are either with the Night Court or they're obstacles. That's not particularly sophisticated political storytelling.

overall, it left me feeling cheated. Not much of anything happens, and I was honestly more interested in the theorizing with fans than in what the actual book was delivering. I truly don't understand why this had to be a part of a book when it could have been shorter and perhaps even a whole book of its own, idk. This one was more rage-inducing than anything.

When readers are more invested in discussing the possibilities, implications and potential character developments than in what the actual story is delivering, something has gone wrong with the balance between setup and payoff.

And if a book introduces multiple POVs, expands its political conflicts, adds new interpersonal tensions and gives us more access to characters' thoughts, but leaves you feeling that you'd actually prefer to know less about everyone, that's quite an achievement. Enter the quote “the hottest thing a men could do is being silent”

End of review introduced characters rants below

  1. Azriel: the mystery was doing a lot of heavy lifting

There is a difference between a quiet, reserved character having an interesting interiority and a quiet character whose interiority turns out to be an endless stream of self-pity, entitlement and romantic resentment.

Azriel's entitlement to the third sister. Because how could it possibly be that he's left without one???? The whole "my blade abandoned me" and "I'm a monster, that's why I want Elain, because maybe she can save me" — DUDE! I really liked Azriel in his silences; once we got into his POV, he became pathetic and in need of therapy ASAP. His jealousy of Lucien is so embarrassingly petty, and now I can't help wondering whether his kindness towards Nesta was genuine or just another move in his silent conquest of Elain.

  1. Cassian: Nesta's growth apparently only matters when it makes her easier to love

Cassian just gets worse. He never prioritized Nesta; he said a lot of words, but his actions were never aligned. Nesta's journey in ACOSF was about reclaiming herself, not becoming easier for everyone else to love or finally falling in line with the IC. Yet Cassian seems to understand her growth only insofar as it brings her closer to the life he wants. His justification for the silent treatment? Things were going so well, and then she had to disrupt everything by having a mind of her own. No shit, Sherlock! And calling his mate "witch"? The Illyrian slur? And Cassian's thoughts of Mor´s beauty, her supposed sister, and how he controlled his lust for her for the good of the IC? While Nesta is drowning to more effect??

Truly, all these men are shit.

  1. Elain: the distinction between being overlooked and choosing not to participate

There's a perfectly legitimate argument that Elain was neglected, infantilized and treated as someone whose primary purpose was to be protected. BUT there's also a difference between being denied agency and choosing not to exercise it.

Elain keeps getting on my nerves. She wanted to be left alone, felt disrupter with all war and conflict related and acted like “pls don’t include mee at least is necessary this is all very upsetting”, people finally listened, and now she's resentful of being reduced to baking and gardening, and everyone assuming she has no mind of her own? You can't have it both ways. I could understand her acting out being with Azriel as an answer to her frustration with Feyre and Rhys using her to honey-trap Lucien without ever asking her, but her conversation with Mor shows us that Elain understands the political and social capital attached to her appearance, her family connections and her perceived harmlessness "I'm pretty, so I can use it to make people do what I want. I can disappear in plain sight, so people can forget I'm there. I know about politics despite everyone thinking I'm oblivious. If I go as the sister of the High Lord, people would take seriously what you say and see my presence as a sign of trust."

All of this gives us a side of Elain that isn't the oh-so-sweet Elain, but a rather conniving person who knows how to play on the expectations attached to her appearance for her own gain. And there's nothing wrong with that in itself, not at all, but is keep splitting our perception of her and the IC´s further, not in a well thought way.

  1. Feyre: the transformation from underdog to authoritarian figure

Feyre has gone full tyrant.

She was already a person who, having only just learned to read and been introduced to a world she conceded she knew nothing about, was given the powers of all the High Lords and the political power of being a High Lady. She's already proven her disrespect for boundaries and her emotional intelligence and strategic mind of a toddler, which apparently only grew stronger with motherhood.

Now she´s convinced she has to save Navarre and Monteserre and wants everyone to be with her and is willing to control other courts if neccesary, make Rhys High King (and herself HQ, duh), throw her power around when someone disagrees with her, and apparently violate the sanctity of the library because how dare Clotho???? Her feathers were showing from the moment her sisters arrived, when she seemed more inclined to remind them she was their High Lady than their sister. And it has only gotten worse.

And the thing is, Feyre becoming an authoritarian figure could actually be fascinating. Someone who once fought against oppressive power structures gradually reproducing them because she believes her intentions are better? That's an interesting character development. But the narrative needs to recognize what is happening. It needs to question her decisions instead of presenting her authority as inherently justified, and all around her blindly coinciding.

  1. Rhys: the most powerful High Lord in all of Prythian, apparently

So, the most powerful High Lord in all of Prythian, so gathered and contained, the good Lord and the best-of-the-best candidate for High King, has never found a way to put an end to the violence in the Illyrian camps. He has not put in place any meaningful way to help those victims or empower Illyrian females, beyond suggesting some little changes with zero follow-up and, apparently, little reinforcement, and pattimg himself in the back because vhange takes time in fae lands.

The same level headed guy that wanted to killed Nesta bc she told the truth? And only didn’t do it bc Feyre would not forgive two thing then?

And this same male is the one who wants a better world and is involving himself in another war in another territory to reinforce his hero-and-saviour identity?

How exactly does that work?

How can you claim the moral authority to intervene in other people's conflicts while failing to address the violence and inequality within your own territory? How can you expect other courts to trust your intentions when you haven't even managed to make meaningful changes at home?

It's another example of the disconnect between what the IC claims to stand for and what they actually do.

  1. Amren and Mor

Was that Amren at the end? Maybe Amren-shaped, but idk, it didn't feel like Amren. More like some other force taking her place, maybe a shapeshifter, maybe Amren possessed? (She's just fae now, after all.)

And Mor's "been there, done that, even if only in her head" comment... buah. I'm trying not to dislike her, especially as the queer character so far, but there's not much to like beyond a little representation.

______

And this is where the whole thing falls apart for me
There is nothing inherently wrong with having:
· A manipulative High Lord.
· A politically ambitious High Lady.
· A possessive and jealous spymaster.
· A warrior who struggles to distinguish loyalty from obedience.
· A woman who uses her perceived harmlessness to manipulate people.
· A group of friends whose relationships are built on unresolved resentment.

Actually, that sounds like a potentially excellent collection of characters.

But then the narrative has to commit to exploring those characteristics. It has to allow other characters to challenge them. It has to let their decisions have consequences. It has to acknowledge that being traumatized doesn't automatically make someone a good person, that loving someone doesn't excuse controlling them, and that having good intentions doesn't make political domination acceptable.
And, crucially, it has to allow the reader to disagree with the protagonists without treating that disagreement as a failure to understand them. And right now it feels more like Sarah doesn’t know how to take the story exactly where he wants it to go and the result is a mismatch of stuff with an uncleared intention and a poor Delievery.


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

Fan Fic Feyre should've sent Nesta to the summer court.

30 Upvotes

(I didn't know what to use for the flair but this sounds like a fanfic so 👍)

It's really obvious that Cassian isn't good for Nesta and staying with him will only hurt her more. It was so clear he was a shitty mate in ACOSF AND ACOSH, I'm so glad people are finally calling him out on it.

Everyone says Eris is better for Nesta but no one can really know that. We've never had his perspective and he seems a mix of cruel and kind. There's no guarantee he'll be one of those people who seem mean but are soft-hearted.

I came up with this idea that in ACOSF, instead of locking Nesta up with a horny Illyrian who ultimately wants to fuck her, what if they'd sent her to the Summer Court?

I know the Night Court and the Summer Court aren't all that friendly after what Feyre and Rhys did but Tarquin is nice enough.

Anyways this is what I imagined to have happened (it's not all planned properly):

- Nesta clearly needs help so Feyre sends her to the Summer Court since idk, summer is supposed to be all warmth, joy, sunshine and happiness.

- In the Summer Court, Nesta lives with Tarquin.

- Tarquin is 100x times nicer than everyone in the night court so he's super supportive. He doesn't force feed her, helps her through the ED she has, and supports her healing. (This part of ACOSF really bothered me. Nesta had ED and struggled with food and Cassian basically forced her to eat which is not a good strategy. And it's clear in ACOSH she's still struggling with this.)

- Nesta trains with Varian, but only when she's comfortable and wants to. (I think he's Tarquin's guard but it's been a while since I read the series so I may be wrong. all I remember is that he and Amren have a thing.)

- And maybe she'll even develop a good bond with Cresseida.

- Nesta can help with rebuilding the Summer Court after the war.

- Every 2-3 weeks, Amren could visit for a few days to meet Varian and also see if Nesta is developing.

- The Night Court ultimately creates a better relationship with the Summer Court.

- Maybe Nesta stays there forever of her own accord.

- If I rewrote the entire of ACOSF, Nesta would have no mate. She'd stay the independent bad bitch she is.

- The Valkyries wouldn't be found andd Gwyn and Emerie wouldn't have happened but I didn't find a loophole through that 🙁 (they were my favs)

- Summer Solstice could be some big turning point for her. Plus, we only see Winter Solstice celebrated so this could add to the worldbuilding.

Honestly, I really like that better than what actually happened. Nesta is away from the IC who ultimately shame her every chance she gets. I don't see her being mates with Tarquin but that would've been nice. But I do see her healing better in the Summer Court than anywhere else.

Or maybe I'm just glazing it because Tarquin's my favourite 😭


r/acotar_rant • • 4d ago

Rant Why do the Fae eat normal, human food?

223 Upvotes

I'm not shy about thinking SJBum's worldbuilding is atrocious but if there was one thing that had consistently bothered me is that the Fae eat human food.

Why do these 500 year old Immortal beings eat mundane breakfast foods like scrambled eggs or their dinner plate is chicken, potatoes and gravy or the likes? This doesn't make them feel supernatural as they don't seem to have any culture that gives them distinguishing difference against humans.

Across six books, all they seem to do is eat basic tier human food. For someone who larps as a LOTR super fan, why couldn't SJMid have just made something similar to the Lembas Bread? She’s not above copying as evidenced from her irritating need to borrow from Tolkien, GRRM and Anne Bishop.

The Spring Court should have been the most unique one of them to have say many floral inspired blends of teas or even fantastical plants that naturally produce soy/almond milk or giving fantastical twists to real world food.

A well defined fantasy gastronomy actually helps builds the worlds to feel more immersive. Making these supernatural creatures eat eggs, bacon and toast just makes them less fantastical than they should be.


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

Rant The more I think, the more I despise the idea of a "realistic" love story for Nesta

110 Upvotes

You know what? I don't want a "realistic" relationship for Nesta. I don't want this to be her story. In a world where we have a lot of MMCs doing horrible things and getting their LI who would accept them as they are, who would "change them for the better" I find it fucking sad that we're so okay with Nesta receiving the short straw of a "realistic" story.

Rhys literally assaulted Feyre—the topic of reasons aside—and the narrative has her thinking, "I can sense he's actually a good guy deep down" since the very fucking beginning. Feyre asked Rhys directly not to keep her in the dark anymore, and he doesn't respect her wishes, yet she doesn't spend even a minute giving him the cold shoulder or wondering whether he's trustworthy. He admitted to her that he had committed cold hearted killings and enjoyed it, and she said okay. He suicide-baits Tamlin, and Feyre says, "Questionable, but you deserve a little treat for being such a good boy." Rhys will humiliate her and make her cry to ensure his intervention plan for Nesta, and she will fucking trust him and act alongside him.

Hell, even vice versa, Feyre showed Rhys, "See this beast? That's me" and he said, "Cool, you wanna try for a baby?" She destroyed an entire court in her rage, endangered multiple civilians through her actions, and he'll still say stupid shit like she's the light, the queen, bla bla bla

Nesta fucking deserves a similar story. She deserved a guy who would accept her entirely, who wouldn't care that she had done bad things, and who would prioritise her wellbeing. Someone who would take care of her, when she was injured down the stairs. Because he wants to help her heal, not punish her for going against orders. A guy who would see Nesta lashing out because she's hurt and wouldn't take her on a hell hike. He'd give her a blanket, a hug, and some tissues, and tell her, "Questionable, but you were valid"

And when she's doing something guided by her soul and mind(which he supposedly knows and loves), something that directly saves an entire world, I would've wanted a LI who acted like a partner, not an auditor. "Is she or isn't she trustworthy?" The fuck? And for what? For an event where she was eventually proven right, unlike Rhys, who fucked up so many times and was twice part of the reason Feyre died.

Not only is this "realistic" love very unbalanced, but it also carries multiple signs of emotional abuse.

And while Rhys and Lucien have the decency to feel guilty about these beautiful, smart, and kind girls being shackled to them, Cassian will scream in public about how HE feels shackled to Nesta.

So I'll be honest: in the context of everything we've had up until now in ACOTAR, I don't care about "men's emotional health." I don't care about "she wanted to show that a relationship can be flawed." I don't care about any of this. I wanted a LI for Nesta who would be a narrative gift: someone who would accept her and be on her side no matter what, who would be kind to her, and who wouldn't give her the cold shoulder for weeks because he's questioning her trustworthiness. Someone who would stay and comfort her after she was nearly raped hours before. Someone who would cross her boundaries to take care of her, not only when has a hard dick or wants to show who is the boss in the room.


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

Rant ACoTaR - no spoilers - 50% through... i am not seeing the hype

35 Upvotes

ACoTaR - no spoilers - 50% through... i am not seeing the hype.

I'm reading this for the first time. And i am not getting the hype. First of all, the pacing is bad. Things happen and i feel like i've missed something but no its just the delivery of the event is thrown in your face.

Then....for most of the book (im 50% through) and Feyre is insufferably frustrating. She finally started to get likable but then became annoying again.

Then - try not to spoil this - but the first 50% of the book teases you.

And i'm.just like... wait... is this what all the hype is about?

Like i feel like im reading a high school fantasy of sexuality? But not actually adult?

And people are obsessed with this?

I should love it but i'm just struggling to get into it?

Maybe im just more freaky and this is super vanila for me?