r/andor • • Aug 16 '25

General Discussion Any shows or films that feel like Andor?

Post image
898 Upvotes

r/andor • • May 20 '25

Mod Announcement Politics and this Subreddit

1.5k Upvotes

Hi all,

I know there has been a lot of discussion, especially recently, about politics in this sub. Before reading any further, please know this -- politics are and will always be allowed on this subreddit. Star Wars (particularly Andor) is inherently political. We as mods believe it would be a disservice to you all to not allow discussion of the political themes of this show and the connections it makes to our real world...even the difficult ones.

This post is not changing that whatsoever.

However, we do understand that some of the community doesn't wish to see those types of posts, and that is OK. Some of us use social media (even Reddit) as escapism from the real world, and there is nothing wrong with that. We are seeing an uptick in reports on posts of a political or sensitive nature, and despite efforts to cull said reports the mods are overwhelmed. This is only worsened by the fact that we have a handful of people on the subreddit going around and spamming reports - most of them being baseless.

Reddit doesn't give us the best tools when it comes to managing reports on posts and comments, so all we can really do about that is ask you all to use the report button sincerely. The more reports that we get that are unsubstantiated or are just pissed-off-reports, the harder it is for us to recognize the real ones. But I digress.

The point of this post is to announce a new sidebar option on the subreddit, a content filter. If you click on the "No Politics" button, you will be shown a version of the subreddit that does not include any posts with the Real World Politics flair. The hope is that this will make it easier for those who do not wish to see those posts (either all the time or sometimes) a way to enjoy the subreddit. We want as many of you to be a part of this community as possible. Remember, this is a 100% VOLUNTARY option. If you do nothing, you will continue to see the sub as you always have.

Thanks,

- sud


r/andor • • 19h ago

Meme Tony Gilroy everyone

5.6k Upvotes

r/andor • • 13h ago

General Discussion Michael Clayton 4K finally coming - Criterion release (and bad 4K news for Andor fans)

Thumbnail
collider.com
626 Upvotes

 Andor Season 1 arrived on 4K Ultra HD and Blu-ray in April 2024, but collectors are still waiting to put Season 2 beside it. Asked whether there were plans for a box set, Gilroy said: “No idea. I really have no idea.” Weintraub asked what fans could do to make it happen. “I don’t know, man. I don’t know. I really don’t know. I have no conversation.” Gilroy then asked whether the set should already have been released. After Weintraub explained the gap between the two seasons’ physical editions, Gilroy had an observation of his own, saying:

“I’ll just tell you, there’s nothing in the Disney gift shop. There’s no Andor merchandise.”


r/andor • • 8h ago

Meme MY achievement! NOT yours!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
205 Upvotes

r/andor • • 13h ago

Real World Politics Remember folks, we are not done yet. Democracy requires constant effort, it breaks, it leaks.

Post image
548 Upvotes

r/andor • • 1d ago

General Discussion For such a short scene, the clones taking aim at the protestors on Ferrix was such a crucial shot to include and establish the duality of the clones - an army promoted to 'protect and liberate' was always one meant to oppress and control, and the clones will do it.

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

One of the most chilling scenes with the clones in the franchise, after Order 66. People too easily forget the nature of clones - they can make friends, fall in love, be good people - but at the end of the day, they're still soldiers genetically and mentally conditioned since birth to follow orders to the letter and kill.


r/andor • • 7h ago

General Discussion One possible source for Fiona's characterization of Maarva

20 Upvotes

Further to u/Dear-Yellow-5479's splendid series of deep-dive character portraits, I thought I might post the below: excerpt from a documentary about a 2012 production of MOTHER COURAGE AND HER CHILDREN (Brecht), in which Fiona Shaw plays the title character. If you don't know the play, it's well worth an ANDOR fan's time: set in the Thirty Years' War in Germany, but written by Brecht in the late 1930s, it tells the tale of a poor woman trying to eke out a living with a traveling buy & sell business that does business with both/all sides. It's savagely pessimistic (and great). Full disclosure: about 10 years ago I served as music director for a production by my Stateside university, and, after having stumbled upon this documentary, had to promptly stop watching, because the production was so compelling, I could tell it was going to be snuff out some of my own ideas.

Anyway, this sequence is Fiona going through the course of a performance day, while talking to the documentarians: physical and vocal warmups, costuming, hair/makeup, etc. You can literally feel her "armoring up" for this marathon role (Courage is in virtually every scene), and it's a really great portrait of a theatrical artist at work.

There's also a little bit of anticipation of Maarva, both in the Courage character, how she's costumed, and how Maarva interprets her. Makes me wonder whether TG, and/or Michael Wilkison, and/or others of the ANDOR team, might have seen this production; we know he cast Denise after seeing her in a London production of PEOPLE, PLACES, AND THINGS.

YMMV, but I think this is fascinating and wonderful. Thanks again to u/Dear-Yellow-5479 for the terrific, thoughtful portaits.

https://youtu.be/x6obtAUsju8?si=rphZ_B4oDpgwgI1z

Sorry, meant to cue directly to Fiona's bit; that's here, at 31:06:

https://youtu.be/x6obtAUsju8?si=LsEzdRi20I5LkKQK&t=1866


r/andor • • 17h ago

General Discussion ‘That Would Be Me’ (1.02) rewatch thoughts

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes
  1. I love the way the episode title connects to the ‘Who Are You?’/ identity theme of the series. In this episode, it’s Cassian’s answer to Maarva’s panicked question “Then who told these PreMor bastards about Kenari?” and that scene remains my favourite in this episode. Maarva’s introduction as a mother who is furious and upset that her son is in trouble with the law again really sets up the “I’ll be worried about you all the time” / “That’s just love” exchange in ep 7.

  2. The death of the girl tribe leader really is brutal. The man simply gets up, sees her retreating back and shoots to kill. It really sets up Maarva’s decision to abduct Kassa as the right one in terms of saving his life. I also like the detail that it takes a lot of darts to kill the man. The poison on them is probably only designed to bring down small game. It’s also established that Kassa sees the threat before any of the other children and his failure to shout a warning probably fuels his angry self-hatred in the aftermath, as he obviously hugely admired the ‘Alpha’. Interesting that Cassian’s first and last missions are led by a woman, and this feels like a prelude to that.

  3. Wow, the score for Luthen’s introduction is spectacular. “How long a walk this time?” also reminds us that he’s been to Ferrix at least five times already for face-to-face meetings with Bix, as Salman Paak later reveals under torture. He obviously ‘parks’ somewhere different each time but this time is extra far from the terminal because there’s “nothing safe” closer - implying he and the ship droid know PreMor are on their way for Cassian.

  4. Timm is drinking hard in the bar when he is spying on Bix and Cassian meeting up, and he’s seen drinking again from a bottle when he goes to make his phone call to the cops. This doesn’t paint him as someone who thinks he’s doing the right thing. Staring contemplatively into a cup of black coffee at home later suggests that he almost immediately regretted it.

  5. Bix’s booty call reveals that she’s been drinking a lot too. She spent a lot of that meeting with Cassian trying to avoid eye contact and when he grasped her hand in thanks she pushed it away using her fingertips. I think she doesn’t want to hurt herself too much by dwelling on just how much trouble Cassian is in. “What have you done?” being a question from both Bix and Maarva also implies that he knows that he’s been a disappointment to both women, as he’s evasive both times when he grudgingly answers: the confessional “I messed up” to Maarva and the more defensive “They were shaking me down!” to Bix. The subtext in the dialogue scenes in this episode is really well done.

  6. Mosk is such a delight to watch, and the way Syril immediately bonds with him is very telling: he thinks he’s identified a kindred spirit. “Pockets of fomenting” remains a strangely hilarious line. I’m torn on Mosk saying “Hats off to you and the Chief Inspector” and Syril saying “I’ll pass along your kind words to the Chief Inspector” - did Mosk know that Syril was probably disobeying orders? I’m inclined to think ‘yes’.

  7. I just love that final scene with Luthen on the shuttle ferry being pestered by Willi the salesman, leading to the line “If you can’t find it here, it’s not worth finding” and the cut to Cassian jogging towards the camera to the music ‘Pilgrim’ - the production code name for Andor. Absolute cinema, as they say.

Great episode; ridiculously underrated. Your thoughts?


r/andor • • 1d ago

Question How early was it for you when you realized “oh sh*t, this isn’t an ordinary Star Wars show” ?

454 Upvotes

Andor is my favorite show of all time and I think it should be regarded as one of the best shows of this decade and the past 20 years. It’s just a brilliant show. I wanted to know from you guys when did you realize that this was going to be a great show?


r/andor • • 1d ago

Meme “ Tony on his way blow up the AI centers “

2.2k Upvotes

r/andor • • 1d ago

Media & Art Even if it’s this wild im sure most men hope they get such stare from kleya

Post image
799 Upvotes

r/andor • • 12h ago

Media & Art Succession's Caroline Collinsworth would be amazing opposite to Eedy Karn. They'd either be best of cackling friends in the neighborhood sewing circle, or would soon poison the water supply of the village to kill each other's cats. Amazing writing/acting on both characters.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/andor • • 19h ago

Articles & Links Recommended analysis of an under-discussed scene : Cassian & Bix in s1 ep 7

Thumbnail
youtu.be
26 Upvotes

‘The Upstairs Lounge’ with another fascinating dissection.


r/andor • • 1d ago

General Discussion Andor characters confirmed for Claudia Gray's upcoming Princess of the Rebellion

Post image
205 Upvotes

From Claudia Gray's latest newsletter.

Between this book and From the Ashes, 2027 is shaping up to be a great year for Andor in the publishing world. Fingers crossed for a Kleya appearance. I think she'd be a fitting person for Leia to have to interact with as she and Luthen very much represented the darker side of the Rebellion that Bail and Breha would've tried to keep Leia shielded from.

For any Andor fans wanting a taste of Claudia Gray's writing before going into this, I strongly recommend Bloodline. Very intriguing book that goes into the political structure of the New Republic and shows how the Resistance and First Order begin forming six years prior to the sequel trilogy.


r/andor • • 2d ago

Meme This belongs to here

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

Totally true and must definitely shows what our goal for SW should be


r/andor • • 1d ago

General Discussion ‘Kassa’ (1.01) rewatch thoughts

Thumbnail
gallery
181 Upvotes

Thought I’d try to catch a few new things if I can on this full Andor -> Rogue One rewatch. Thought also it might be hard with season 1 in particular as I’ve lost count now of how many times I’ve seen it. But a few things:

  1. The sound design of Morlana 1 in those opening shots is fantastic. I’m watching on the Steelbook and catching so much in the background: music from other bars/brothels, snatches of conversation and a general ‘outdoors on a rainy night’ vibe. And the shake-down fight sounds as vicious as it looks, especially the throat punch.

  2. That scene when Cassian goes to see Bix at the salyard might just be the most densely packed in the whole season. It’s the scene where I really lost the thread of the plot on my first watch and had to stop and start again as I hadn’t appreciated just how much I had to lock tf in for this particular Star Wars series. It’s got lots of LOTS of exposition, but all via very naturalistic dialogue. Nothing is explained or described for our benefit alone. The blocking is superb, the tension between the characters palpable and the all the subtext beautifully done. Easily the most underrated scene in this episode. I feel I could write 20+ pages of analysis. Also, my feelings about Timm fluctuate all the time - I’m generally sympathetic - but he really shouldn’t have followed Bix. Warning signs about a possessive nature right there.

  3. There’s a great Syril moment when he’s standing outside the door of the air traffic control room in deep hesitation. One of his colleagues passes and asks if everything is OK and he gives a really meek and stuttering reply that is in total contrast to how he is soon to behave for the rest of this arc. It reminds me now of his season 2 scene where he is showing the new recruit around the Bureau of Standards and says unironically: “There’s a future here for those who dare”. I think that’s how he’s seeing himself here. I think he’s been struggling with himself for the couple of hours or so since Chief Inspector Hyne left about this whole ‘disobeying orders’ thing, in combination with conquering his own self-doubting introverted nature. He genuinely believes that what he’s about to do is a brave and heroic act for the greater good of Justice, against corruption and apathy. Once he commits, he’s forceful and confident with his colleagues and is soon exercising his power with threats and commands.

You can really see Syril as the ‘romantic with a vivid inner life’ (as Gilroy describes him) in this transition. In total contrast, Cassian is at his most messily un-heroic in this episode and even though his trauma explains it the writing and Luna’s performance fully lean into just how much of a ‘roach’ (Gilroy, again) he is at this point in his life.

  1. Those Kenari flashbacks all hurt like hell now. I kept thinking of the Interstellar meme with “Don’t let me leave, Murph!!” when young Kassa keeps shooing his sister away so he can mingle with the big kids, and yes I still think that when Pegla tells him as an adult “Don’t come back!” it triggers the memory of when he told his sister “I’m coming back” - but never did. That last frame made me tear up in a way it never did before, knowing now that this moment would remain forever a deep scar on Cassian’s soul and that the first and last time we see him dreaming it’s of this fateful day.

  2. Cassian’s interactions with both Brasso and B2EMO are so beautifully written and performed and I just have to tear up again when remembering that he doesn’t interact with either of them on screen in season 2. Ouch.

  3. That Ferrix set never ceases to amaze me and I just want to walk around there and get lost in it all.

  4. The Syril vs Hyne scene remains as delicious as when I first watched it and thought “God dammit, this is fantastic writing”. Hyne’s dry disdain is so funny and the dialogue so crisp I just want to quote it all. I’ll resist.

Anyone else rewatching and/or (!) with thoughts to share?


r/andor • • 9h ago

General Discussion What if The Mandalorian story arc had been 'Gilroy' star wars instead of 'Favreau '

Post image
0 Upvotes

No grogu? Less nostalgia bait? Recast Gina Carano to have a kick ass rebel shock trooper story line* ? A proper gritty look at the outer rim?

I would love to see a 'Gilroy' take on it, what would be your wishlist/what do you think he would nail that was missing ?

I feel like a arc about a bounty hunter clearing up imperial remnants would have been absolute gold as Gilroy star wars.

I think decent chunks of the first season of Mando gave me real hope for an authentic new Star wars story and then it slowly spiralled into more and more nostalgia bait.

There were absolutely snippets, that retained some heart and a core interesting story but it just got fewer and farther between as it progressed.

Learning about the droid gotra's inclusion is what finally got me to watch ithe movie because what an incredible story that would be to explore, but then it turned out they were just lifeless blaster fodder.

The thing that really got me wishing for the Andor-verse take on Mando was the hutts speaking English, that felt like the most Disney 'people will have their phones out, all exposition must be 10 words or less and repeated 3 times out loud' production decision, where Girloey was happy for the Ghors to all speak bloody French just to make sure we were paying attention.

*Maybe just cast a decent human being from the start.


r/andor • • 2d ago

Meme Remember Erskin Semaj from the cartoon? LOOK, HERE HE IS IN LIVE ACTION!!

Post image
570 Upvotes

r/andor • • 17h ago

General Discussion This is a weird hunch I have but why do I feel like Season 3 may still happen one day?

0 Upvotes

Like, feel free to disagree because even I think this is a ridiculous assumption, but the thought still lingers in my head. Season 2, while its viewership isn't as big as The Mandalorian's, still did really well, and while the creator is probably done with Star Wars, Disney, being the money-maker they are, probably won't waste such a juicy opportunity to milk this era of Star Wars and will probably create something from that era, and for I know, it could be another season of Andor with a completely different protagonist, probably Cassian's child, and just follow events of whatever the hell happens during the sequel trilogy from a new prospective to "fix" the mess that trilogy made (since Disney still wants to acknowledge the sequel trilogy is still canon to the Star Wars franchise)

But that's just me. What do you guys think?


r/andor • • 2d ago

General Discussion 4 years to the day since Luthen took on an Arrestor Cruiser, B2EMO and Cassian mourned Maarva, and Saw said “Let’s call it… War”. What are your favourite moments of s1 ep 11?

Thumbnail
gallery
274 Upvotes

I clearly remember the sensation of going from the exhilaration of Luthen’s great escape to the sadness of Cassian calling home to say that Maarva would be proud of him, only to discover that she’s died while he was in prison. Bee’s reaction had already devastated me. So too had Mon, confessing to Vel “I’ve found a solution” and simply glancing up towards Leida.

Something of a buildup episode to the finale but still filled with incredible moments like these.


r/andor • • 2d ago

General Discussion The three types of Star Wars: Fareau, Filoni, Gilroy

394 Upvotes

Borrowed from social media; 10/10, no notes:

[e/t/a]

Processing img ejy0fopmaz1i1...

https://www.threads.com/share/BAvX4NQMIU


r/andor • • 2d ago

Theory & Analysis How to Write A Perfect Season of TV - Andor

Thumbnail
youtu.be
81 Upvotes

r/andor • • 15h ago

Real World Politics Andor is great TV, and that's enough. It has little to none real-world politcal applicability.

0 Upvotes

I love Andor. It’s brilliant television. Still, the real world discourse surrounding this show sometimes misses the mark. I think people confuse the aesthetics of the show with political philosophy. Treating Andor as a guide or validation for real-world politics just makes no sense.

Strip away the mud and the corporate cubicles, and Andor’s political backdrop is just as basic as the rest of Star Wars. The only real difference is the packaging. Underneath the surface, we are still watching the same simple "evil empire vs. ragtag rebels" story. The show never gets into any discussion of what a good government actually looks like, or what a state owes its citizens.

I’m not saying Andor doesn’t have something to say politically, and a show doesn't need to hand out a policy handbook to count as a political show. A story can critique a system without offering a neat solution. My issue isn't with Andor; it's with fans trying to extract a real-world political blueprint from a show that isn't offering one.

We don't even know the political leanings of its main protagonists Cassian and Luthen. We can kind of assume Mon Mothma is something of a liberal centrist, but that is as close as we get. Fans love to quote Karis Nemik’s manifesto, and while his writing is moving prose about how fragile authoritarianism is, it isn't a plan for what should happen next. It’s just an explanation of why this empire has to fall. It describes how oppression feels, not how to build or run a society afterward.

Technically, we’re watching the birth of the "Alliance to Restore the Republic," yet anyone who knows Star Wars knows the Republic was deeply corrupt. In a lot of ways, it was just a more palatable version of the Empire. It had huge flaws, failed to care for vast swaths of its population, and dragged the galaxy into a prolonged war. Andor never gets into the weeds of that history, because it isn't trying to. It’s comfortable stopping at the general view that oppression is bad.

Andor also avoids the hardest ethical questions around the politics of revolution. By having the government build a planet-killing superweapon to vaporize its own citizens, the show sidesteps the messy, real-world debate over when violent rebellion is actually justified. Real-world politics don't have governments constructing Death Stars to eradicate entire planets. When your back is against a wall like that, rebellion isn't a philosophical choice.

In reality, people rebel against governments that aren't fascist, fascist regimes exist for decades with widespread public support, and citizens resist authoritarianism without starting an armed insurgency. The issues of when to resist government, how to resist government, and when is armed resistance appropriate is incredibly complex.

In most situations, the political will for violent rebellion simply does not exist in any real form and trying to manufacture an armed resitance is like a fly trying to challenge a windshield. Andor briefly alludes to the hard, unglamorous work required to build that public appetite, yet it doesn't actually show us how you get a mass of every day people on board.

When fans apply Andor’s logic to real life, they ignore those nuances and focus on the wrong part of the equation. Defaulting to violent rebellion as a political approach, without any grasp of the actual climate or whether the public will even exists, is reckless and completely out of touch with reality. It’s easy to see that kind of pure resistance as noble when you're watching Andor, yet uncritically adopting that mindset in the real world is how you end up sounding like a Tyler Durden fanboy.

To be clear, Andor isn't trying to tell anyone how to run a society. It's a character study of the people who get pulled into an underground movement. It gives us a realistic mix of the human motives of rebels: idealists, damaged people, people who just want their normal lives back, people driven by empathy, fanatics looking for an excuse to be violent, and opportunists trying to improve their own standing.

Take Saw Gerrera. He is an ideological void, a radical insurgent with no real goals for the world that comes after. In fact, he flat-out refuses to get into the weeds of ideological debates and calls other rebels who frame their resistance around political theory "lost." Looking at Saw, it's sort of hard to believe he would be all that invested in the return of a problematic liberal democracy like the Republic, yet here he is, fully vested in the rebellion. By writing him without a political philosophy, we are given an example of the far end of rebellion: people who have no plans but are attracted to the principle of reaistance. While that's interesting to see, it's not a great idea for real-world viewers to treat his character as some kind of revolutionary model.

The show works so well because it captures how ordinary people get swept into covert operations and shows how suffocating a totalitarian bureaucracy can be. What it doesn't offer is a plan for how to govern, or a deep philosophy on the morality of resistance. None of this makes it a bad show. It's a masterclass in tension and drama. When it comes to real-world politics, though, fans are wading in a very shallow pool. We should stop pretending the show is something it isn't.

 EDIT: Upon review, it seems a lot of people are just viscerally defending Andor from perceived criticism rather than engaging with the topic. I love Andor. I have no issues with Andor. This post warns against using the trappings of andor to argue for or against political action irl. Andor is great TV, and thats enough.


r/andor • • 2d ago

General Discussion Tony Gilroy AMA is now live on r/movies (joint one with Eva Victor)

Post image
92 Upvotes