r/anime • https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Oct 07 '26

Episode The Detective is Already Dead Season 2 • Tantei wa Mou, Shindeiru. Season 2 - Episode 1 discussion

Tantei wa Mou, Shindeiru. Season 2, episode 1

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.


Streams

Show information


All discussions

EpisodeLink
1Link
2Link
3Link
4Link
5Link
6Link
7Link

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

89 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

•

u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Oct 07 '26

Source Material Corner

Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.

The spoiler syntax is: [Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<

All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).

→ More replies (1)

79

u/IHatePoultrySG Oct 07 '26

A salute to everyone masochistic enough to seat through another season of this.

I wish you the best next 12-13 weeks.

17

u/reaperow Oct 07 '26

We're ready

16

u/IntelligentBudget142 Oct 07 '26

the fact that another work with a very similar name (and premise?) got an anime in the meantime must be the ultimate embarrassment

9

u/jrd_h Oct 07 '26

Oof, I forgot about that other one. That was a quick drop and wasted potential.

2

u/flow_mantle Oct 07 '26

what's the other one?

15

u/IntelligentBudget142 Oct 07 '26

Killed again Mr detective (lol)

-1

u/DugACCat Oct 08 '26

I thought this was that one and was quite confused as it seemed an entirely different anime and characters. 😅 Was thinking they’d rebooted it as a different thing but now I see it was just a very similar name and I never saw the first season of this one. Oops! At least I feel better about my confusion.

11

u/Namaryu Oct 07 '26

I am a big fan of the books and watching season 1 was painful. But this episode was not that bad honestly.

10

u/entelechtual Oct 08 '26

Season 1 was some of the most fun I’ve had with an anime… commenting on episode threads and watching everyone lose their sanity week by week.

6

u/VirJhin4Ever Oct 07 '26

Honestly it's not that bad. As a LN reader, I have high hopes.

3

u/Such_Selection9762 Oct 07 '26

Thank you for your concern. I would have never guessed that this one is getting a second season and since I watched the first season I will prevail through this.

2

u/DankieJutsu Oct 07 '26

I really don't think the series isn't all that bad. Was it better with Siesta? Absolutely, but that certainly didn't make it unwatchable without her and meme'd to hell for being a 2/10. It's just average

-1

u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Oct 08 '26

I wish you exactly what you deserve

31

u/Kadmos1 Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

Siesta is still sexy.

2

u/Niwaka_Samurai https://myanimelist.net/profile/Niwaka-Samurai Oct 07 '26

When everyone was rambling about Siesta Good of you to notice that. 

10

u/ThousandYearOldLoli Oct 07 '26

I watched the first season and was thoroughly confused for a good chunk of it. When the second episode told us it was recapping things, I thought "great first episode, time to acquaint the audience with wtf was going by the end there".

But halfway into the episode and we've pretty much explained nothing, the characters somehow ended up kidnapped and the kidnapper is the robot? How, why? And the robot has Siesta's body and part of her memories, but also it has the opposite attitutde to the MC and also other characters are trying to force us to see this as love quarrel when it seems like anything but. The entire setting just seems like ruleless nonsense and the supposed mystery has no workable answers. Maybe some of the stuff I'm trying to wrap my head around would be clarified by the end of the episode if I stuck to finishing it, but I'm not confident it would be enough to feel like I've got some footing to get through the rest of the season.

Yep, dropping this. The premise seemed really interesting but there's just too much nonsense.

9

u/rotten_riot https://anilist.co/user/RottenOrange Oct 07 '26

A source reader would need to correct me on it but I wouldn't be surprised if the kidnapping was an anime original scene to insert that recap of Season 1 lol

2

u/ThousandYearOldLoli Oct 07 '26

Quite possible, though it would make question the sanity of the people in charge of the project. A random unexplainable kidnapping that goes nowhere and is never addressed again after the characters are uncerimoniously released by someone whom I don't think was even straight up confirmed to be the kidnapper is hardly the thing one just adds for the kicks or to get characters to watch a recording together.

1

u/rotten_riot https://anilist.co/user/RottenOrange Oct 07 '26

Tbf I don't think it's that deep, if they know it was Noches they would obviously just forget about it cause it's not like they don't trust her or anything

1

u/potskiii Oct 16 '26

I think you're thinking about the kidnapping too much. it's clearly Noches who kidnapped them to relay the truth of Siesta via a video of her a year ago

and what do you mean not confirmed?
Kimihiko saying it and Noches confirming it - 10:25 - 10:34

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Oct 07 '26

Sorry, your comment has been removed.

  • This belongs in the Source Material Corner at the top of this thread. In discussion threads for currently airing anime, discussions about source material, spin-offs, author comments and unadapted content must be posted there.
  • Any comparison to the source material no matter how minor belongs there.
  • Your comment was NOT removed for spoilers; it was removed for discussion of the source material outside of the Source Material Corner.

Questions? Reply to this message, send a modmail, or leave a comment in the meta thread. Don't know the rules? Read them here.

1

u/potskiii Oct 16 '26

I don't think this episode was that bad as it's a new arc and it just followed through what happened in S1.

as someone who thought S1 was so bad, this first ep was a breath of fresh air and it's not confusing at all

I think you're attacking this 2nd season too much cuz of how confusing S1 is and in effect, you're confused about this ep cuz you barely retained info from S1

it is confusing but after I rewatched it, it made sense (blame the studio last season for mixing the order of events)

3

u/ThousandYearOldLoli Oct 16 '26

You're correct that S1 is in great part to blame, but I can't agree on the "it's not confusing at all". It starts nonsensical and moves to adding even more weirdness to the soup of barely explained concepts with now with this clone and it all feels so forced and like it follows from nothing. I'm sure I'd see a thread of some sort of if I had just finished watching S1, and I'm not saying the first episode of this new season it's not potentially better than how S1 handled things, but it did do a piss-poor job of helping people who weren't able to fully wrap their heads around S1 (like myself) actually understand what the deal is (It tried by recapping it just didn't help it make any sense at all) and get a footing in S2.

18

u/Namaryu Oct 07 '26

We got the animator for plane fight in the opening. Ryuki Hashimoto.

2

u/Niwaka_Samurai https://myanimelist.net/profile/Niwaka-Samurai Oct 07 '26

Glad to hear that. 

7

u/flow_mantle Oct 07 '26

for some reason, i remember s1 had mech fights.

12

u/reaperow Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

My friend who had read the light novel told me to watch the anime when it was first airing and we both ended up being extremely disappointed by it

(I still flame him for that lol)

Gonna try giving this a chance again for old time's sake

8

u/Namaryu Oct 07 '26

I mean noone expected for anime to change the order and mess up things so much...

4

u/mekerpan Oct 07 '26

Sort of like with Towa no Yuugure, I generally liked S1 of this despite it undeniably being a mess story-wise -- due largely to liking the main characters. Siesta, of course. But also Nagisa. I even read a big chunk of source material -- which still seemed like rather a mess story-wise.

2

u/Isekai_Dreamer Oct 07 '26

reminds me of that one time i told my friend to buy doge. he still hates me for that and i still have to buy him free lunch everyday because he lost his entire fortune.

8

u/ObvsThrowaway5120 Oct 07 '26

Never actually thought this would come back. Even when it was announced, I was kinda surprised. I think I’m gonna binge this one because I gotta rewatch the last season first. It was pretty convoluted from little I recall.

8

u/KumaKumaGambler Oct 07 '26

Nagisa will never be Siesta, but a part of me wants to see how Nagisa will develop into the next Ace Detective, assuming she takes up the mantle.

3

u/Master-Hair-7456 Oct 07 '26

Hmmm going a bit crazy at the end summoning hel after most the episode was mourning siesta's death. Also have robot siesta that I didnt expect coming into this season but I hope that we do get to see the real siesta this season even if its a little.

4

u/Niwaka_Samurai https://myanimelist.net/profile/Niwaka-Samurai Oct 07 '26

I just can't believe that it's already been 5 years since season 1 came out. Many anime that I watched during that time had their subsequent seasons come out and end during this time. The op is quite beautiful. So Nagisa (shore) was the name given to her by Siesta due to her love for the sea.. that's sweet. Didn't expect them to get kidnapped by Siesta's Bio Android Maid that looks exactly like her. Now everyone knows what happened to Siesta. So Siesta was from SPES but she escaped from them and became one of the Tuners belonging to an international agency in which her role was 'The Great Detective' and she later became tasked with taking down SPES I guess. I love how the anime team continues to throw out Tamil words in the op and in title card but they can't get the spelling right, haha.

They summoned Hel in Nagisa to know more about the mistake that Siesta failed to notice. Can't wait to see how this goes. 

2

u/Rooby_VTuber Oct 07 '26

Nice to this back again after 5 years, and it was a pretty funny way to start things off.

It is sad that our Siesta is gone for good, but at least we got somewhat of a replacement.

Nagisa has a lot of weight and responsibility to carry on her shoulders having to take on the will of Siesta and still have Hel inside her that she can turn into.

I'm looking forward to the next episode to see what Kimihiko & Hel are going to talk about.

7

u/Isekai_Dreamer Oct 07 '26

how did this get season 2? first season was so bad, a monkey could be the MC and it would've made no difference. the author would've handed him all the answers and luck either way.

19

u/Namaryu Oct 07 '26

The anime boosted the books by insane amount.

Siesta merch

-2

u/Master-Hair-7456 Oct 07 '26

What are you talking about ?

2

u/tapdancinghellspawn Oct 07 '26

Is this anime worth diving into? I've seen some bad to lukewarm reviews.

15

u/rotten_riot https://anilist.co/user/RottenOrange Oct 07 '26

Eh not really tbh

-8

u/Loli-Knight Oct 08 '26

Highly. Even though the source material started in 2019 it's written as if it were a visual novel or light novel from the 2006-2014 golden era. Most of the people you see saying anything bad about it are, quite literally, new age "fans", tourists, or people that just outright aren't the target demographic.

2

u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Oct 08 '26

16 hours in, and time for a "there is no legitimate reason to downvote any episode discussion thread, ever" check-in!

74 points (79% upvoted)

That's 101 up and 27 down.

1

u/HammyxHammy Oct 07 '26

Why would anyone watch a show where the only interesting character is already dead? This is like the exact opposite of Violet Evergarden. Then again, that show wasn't all that good.

5

u/VirJhin4Ever Oct 07 '26

Cause it's deeper than that, and if you only want to see Siesta, then this anime isn't for you. There's a lot more to it. Way much more.

3

u/mekerpan Oct 07 '26

Nagisa is no Siesta -- but ultimately she is not at all a bad character (IMHO).

2

u/notatoaster00 Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

You actually aren't wrong for your feelings about the opposite to Violet Evergarden, it IS the exact opposite. Violet Evergarden is slice of life coming of age, while Detective is already dead is a mystery novel in its very foundation. You're supposed to question what is going on, and there is in fact more to it than the "cover" if you will.

Without spoiling you but still helping to ease your expectations, your assumptions are not correct and are built on a preconceived notion the author intended.

It's sort of similar to how in Re Zero you have a subset of viewers who ragequit the show after the Season 1 ending/Season 2 beginning events pertaining to a specific character they were attached to.

6

u/HammyxHammy Oct 07 '26

It's been a hot minute since I watched S1E1 on release, but yes the detective already being dead kinda kills engagement in the show, even if she gets revived at the end by some bullshit, at which point the show has to end otherwise the title stops being fitting. So, either main cast moves on after the loss, or she revives, and the show ends.

So, the only way the show can give us main character-chan is through extensive use of flashbacks (fuck) or being told massively outside of chronological order (FUCK). And then on top of that, the show has a wildly unconventional setting and that might be the absolute worst possible kind of thing to give a timeline like that.

And, when we have a sort of badshit insane setting like this show, I don't think we necessarily need a sort of harrypotter fish out of water to surrogate the audience's introduction. It's okay, to say "yeah I know you don't have the context to understand what's going on right now, but bare with me". The Detective is Already Dead just goes massively off in the other direction and refuses to give the audience any capacity to understand the situation for the sake of being a "mystery".

1

u/HammeredWharf Oct 08 '26

On the other hand, Blast of Tempest had a similar premise (mystery/action show focused on the main character's dead girlfriend, who dominates the narrative via flashbacks), but it worked really well there, so I don't think the concept itself is bad.

0

u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Oct 08 '26

It's truly terrible when a story trusts the audience to be smart and pay attention. Welp, back to watching anime at 2× speed while scrolling on a phone

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Oct 07 '26

Sorry, your comment has been removed.

  • This belongs in the Source Material Corner at the top of this thread. In discussion threads for currently airing anime, discussions about source material, spin-offs, author comments and unadapted content must be posted there.
  • Any comparison to the source material no matter how minor belongs there.
  • Your comment was NOT removed for spoilers; it was removed for discussion of the source material outside of the Source Material Corner.

Questions? Reply to this message, send a modmail, or leave a comment in the meta thread. Don't know the rules? Read them here.

1

u/amourshipper_ Oct 07 '26

My head is spinning i can't get whats going on I know it's mystery but who's is nagi.sa ,hel, and who's is the daughter and what are personalities ,etc I got a gist it's sci fi but whats that supernatural things lol i can't understand can someone tell me

-1

u/Muja1337janni Oct 07 '26

Did you watch Season 1, if so Most of your questions were answerwd there, but Short form, Nagisa and hel Are the same but two personalities in the same Body, so a Split personality, I dont fully understand what you mean with daughter, if you mean the pink haired Girl thats the 3rd that was trapped in spes Island with natsunagi and siesta

-1

u/amourshipper_ Oct 07 '26

No i haven't watched s1 ,oh it's spilt personality that's crazy, by daughter i mean pink haired one ya that sies.ta mentions that she adopted like that Thanks for answering my query guess I have watch first s1

6

u/Muja1337janni Oct 07 '26

Just one quick question, what was the Reason that you saw it and Jumpers straight to Season 2 when you didn’t See Season 1 ?

-1

u/amourshipper_ Oct 07 '26

I found the title quite surprising and as it's new fall season starting so I am giving a go all new ani.mes and I found this one quite interesting

1

u/Andreiyutzzzz https://myanimelist.net/profile/Andreiyutzzzz Oct 07 '26

Brother we're moving through plot at the speed of light

1

u/extremegk Oct 08 '26

I dont even remember season 1 after siesta gone preety much downhill is she back or still dead :D

1

u/Akagikin https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kailakin Oct 07 '26

I'm pleasantly surprised this got a second season. I have no idea what the hell is happening (I'm going to need to rewatch S1) but at least there was some exposition on what has previously happened.

1

u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Oct 08 '26

0

u/SubstantialTurnip383 Oct 07 '26

Honestly good start, i enjoyes seaons 1 and i hope season 2 is better

-3

u/Loli-Knight Oct 08 '26

Glad to have this back, though the 5 year wait was particularly brutal.

To this day I'm shocked by the overly specific and weird negativity surrounding this series. It's like going through the visual and light novel golden age of 2006-2014. Though, I suppose with that in mind the typical sources of negativity check out.

0

u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Oct 08 '26

Source readers gonna do source reader things

Same as it ever was

21

u/Inner_Wall3411 Oct 07 '26

I just realised that this anime might be featuring one of the most fucked up romances I have ever seen. Guy and girl fall for each other, both of them adopt a daughter, girl gets killed by daughter's other personality and the new romance is between the guy and the amnesiac daughter(who still retains the killer personality)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Animasphere Oct 08 '26

It feels like early on the author just gave up on Nagisa.

She's introduced and then instantly takes a backseat to a long flashback arc for Siesta. Then she spends the last arc kidnapped and swapped out for Siesta.

Even in this episode, her act is to just tag out for Hel and MC just basically interupts her, leaving her sitting there doing nothing. Of her 3 personalities, she's had the barest of characterisation.

They keep talking about her being a Great Detective, but she's just a passenger to everything going on.