r/anime • • 1d ago

Discussion Its been 24 years since Misty was permanently written off the Pokemon anime as a main character

I'm actually a little late here, as according to bulbapedia this episode aired on Nov. 7th 2002 in Japan and we're now Nov. 17th, so a few weeks late:

https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/EP273

As we all know, this would be Misty's end as a main character for basically the entire duration of the anime for 20 years, besides her small 9 ep return in MPM which acted as a bookend to Ash's series after Journey's ended.

Funnily enough, Misty is only in roughly 20% of the animes total episodes now if you count just to the end of Ash's series (not including Horizons). Which makes sense, Johto was only Gen 2 and Ash's series went to the end of Gen 8. This episode aired in 2002 and Ash's end came in 2023, quite literally 20 years later. The passage of time made Misty relatively short-lived in terms of the overall over.

As we know Ash would get new travel companions every series going forward, as May became the new female lead and this would lead to new companions every series after (and Brock would leave after DP as well). Misty wound up being replaced with a whopping 8 different female companions over the series (imagine traveling back in time to 2002 and telling someone that, lol), and nowadays also 80% of the current Pokemon fanbase grew up watching the anime in the mid-2000's or 2010's+ long after she was gone.

What's also interesting to me is how "permanent" this was, sure Misty would reappear from time to time, but this really was the end of the original trio for pretty much 20 years. The writers never went back to it for a full series, and the people who thought Misty wouldn't leave the show got proven wrong about everything over these last 20 years.

Well that's all I have to say for now, it really has been 24 years from 2002-2026.

2.2k Upvotes

208 comments sorted by

287

u/JadowArcadia 1d ago

Yeah Misty was a big favourite for me as a kid and I always held out hope she'd come back permanently. I think Brocks last episode might have been when I left the show.

14

u/precita 1d ago

I don't think anyone truly expected Misty back full-time. She had a few cameos in Hoenn but even as early as that everyone predicted she would stay off the main cast. May became popular right after she left and that's what kind of convinced the writers not to go back to her. Then by the time DP started and Dawn was introduced, Misty was just flat out dropped entirely with no appearances till Sun/Moon anime.

207

u/ELLinversionista 1d ago

I felt some things watching Misty as a boy and now looking back that is how I grew up to be a degenerate

44

u/messem10 https://myanimelist.net/profile/bookkid900 23h ago

There were also shows like Totally Spies which I have no idea how that was approved for kids to watch…

1

u/Ranwulf 2h ago

Idk how I didnt notice all the weird stuff in Total Spies back then...but watching some episodes WOW the writers were not even trying to hidratante anything.

43

u/Electric_jungle 1d ago

I just watched the first two episodes with my 2 year old cus she demanded Pikachu and this is hilarious to me. But to be fair to 12 year old me, I'm not sure it was the show itself or the fact that early internet and torrent sites you could search wild shit only a little kid would think up and it would be like sure here's an image pack to download.

3

u/Nebresto 20h ago

Brocks last episode might have been when I left the show.

Same I think. They brought in some weird salad headed hippie to replace Brock, but one can never replace Brock.

736

u/Jamsterd 1d ago

As someone that only watched the early series as a kid, I assumed the trio had continued after i stopped watching. And any split between them would be temporary.

You are correct in saying that telling this info to someone from the 2002 era would blow their mind 😄

37

u/precita 1d ago

She does come back, but only for 9 episodes at the tail-end of Ash's run, if you mean as a travel companion.

37

u/Wtfitzchris 1d ago edited 1d ago

She also comes back in Sun and Moon for two episodes (along with Brock) where she battles Ash’s Pikachu with a Mega Gyarados and loses.

11

u/zerkeras 15h ago

She really learned nothing huh? Gyrados takes like super fucking double damage from lightning due to being flying/water.

14

u/Mitsuyan_ https://anilist.co/user/mitsuyan 21h ago

I recommend the Alola v Kanto battles even as standalone episodes. Trigger's involvement shone through in how batshit the Misty battle was

3

u/SDRPGLVR 21h ago

Trigger's involvement shone through in how batshit the Misty battle was

Well color me an idiot for not keeping up with my first anime from 30 years ago. I need to look that shit up.

222

u/HavronEX 1d ago

This is funny as someone who never really got into Pokémon, I had no idea Misty wasn’t there for most of it. I couldn’t even tell you any other characters other than Ash, Brock, Misty, and Team Rocket. So reading this post was kind of mind blowing.

-108

u/GrandLingonberry4159 1d ago

Well of course you couldn't tell anyone the other characters. You just admitted that you never got into the franchise, so why would you not know the characters who came after the Pokemania fad.

57

u/Dry_Button_3552 23h ago

Because they transcend the Fandom and went mainstream. I'm not a Pokémon anime or manga fan. Haven't watched it at all, I just enjoy the earlier games. But even I know ash ketchum, misty, brock, and team rocket is blasting off again. And of course professor oak.

I could not name a single other character (aside from Pokémon), I didn't even know ash was gone.

1

u/batmansthediddler :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/pamela_handerson 9h ago

Ash is gone???

46

u/Soupjam_Stevens 1d ago

Same! I stopped watching maybe halfway through Advanced when I was like 10 or 11 so I had seen a couple years of stuff with May but just kind of assumed the original trio had eventually got back together. I was like peripherally aware that other companions had continued to come and go, but I didn't realize Misty mostly stayed gone or that Brock eventually left too

5

u/GrandLingonberry4159 1d ago

They did get back together one last time for the final series before Ash/Satoshi's departure.

6

u/BobTheSkrull https://myanimelist.net/profile/BobTheSkrull 19h ago

Ngl that was me with Naruto. Any splits to the "main trio" of a series had to be temporary, because that's the way it had always been. Imagine my shock when the MC lost his fight with Sasuke.

4

u/Purest_Prodigy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Purest_Prodigy 1d ago

Same, I stopped in Johto League Champions

1

u/Mr_Roll288 9h ago

Same! I had no idea either of them were gone! 

1

u/meneldal2 18h ago

Well tbh wouldn't mind Brock never showing back up after he first left during the Orange Islands arc.

51

u/Silent_Shadow05 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silent-Shadow05 1d ago edited 1d ago

Losing Misty was really devastating for the young me. She was one of my childhood crush and seeing her not appear as a main was tough. I couldn't watch Pokémon for a few years.

Then when Brock left, I held on until Pokémon XY series as I liked the dynamic between Ash, Serena, Clemont and Bonnie.

After this I just stopped watching altogether.

I just miss the original trio, man :(

8

u/precita 1d ago

Misty was only in the anime for 5 years, and most fans already stopped halfway into Johto due to the filler

33

u/Qazoup 1d ago

when you are a child time seems slower than it does as an adult because it is more of a percent of your life
"5 years" felt like the whole childhood. it would be literally half if you were 5 at time of watching. that's a third of your life at 15

10

u/SinfulCrownIAdorn 22h ago

Not to mention those years are extremely impactful and formative.

71

u/Gaming_Gent 1d ago

Losing Misty and Brock was why I stopped watching the show. One was bad, losing the other pushed me away. The squad was gone. No new squad could replace it.

6

u/precita 1d ago

Brock doesn't leave for 8 more years than Misty, and by that point Brock had worn out his welcome. Misty/Brock were also already pretty stagnant for most of Johto

21

u/GrandLingonberry4159 1d ago

I think in hindsight, Misty/Kasumi leaving was a good call. After early Kanto, she pretty much did nothing and by the time Johto came around, it was pretty obvious the writers didn't know what to do with her.

5

u/Outlulz 18h ago

Brock wasn't doing much else either and they were already willing to dump him in Orange Islands but he stuck around for way longer.

2

u/WWECreativegenius 19h ago

Yeah when Brock left that’s when I slowly stopped watching. Never really liked that green haired replacement

1

u/toadfan64 11h ago

As an OG from the first episode, I always really liked May. Even Dawn was pretty cool, but after Dawn I kinda checked out of the anime.

4

u/Sum1nne 1d ago

They brough Brock back for the Alolan region didn't they? Did they really not include Misty there? That's pretty strange honestly.

3

u/precita 20h ago

They return only for 4 episodes. That's not returning to the main cast for a 100+ ep season

3

u/intenselistener 19h ago

Why would there be any expectation that she would come back for a full season after being permanently removed? lol

TPC has always come off to me as very set in its positions. With decades between demographics that would experience nostalgia from her appearances and the target demographic, it just doesn’t seem that there would ever be worth it, aside from anniversary specials.

5

u/Retsam19 :FC::FD: 1d ago

Misty was included there with Brock.

1

u/hobozombie 22h ago

written off the Pokemon anime as a main character

2.0k

u/saumanahaii 1d ago

I want a nostalgia bait movie with them all as adults coming back together for one last adventure targeted at all the people who grew up with them.

397

u/Bart-Harley-Jarvis- 1d ago

The Pokemon company refuses to accept that any fan is over the age of 12.

135

u/dalzmc 1d ago

Well, after the age of 12 they are called “customers” and exist to give money

29

u/TheTallCunt 21h ago

I think this is one the reasons i enjoy the older games, like yeah your character is young, but it doesnt constantly remind you that youre a kid like from sun/moon onwards.

17

u/Lemurians myanimelist.net/profile/Lemurians 15h ago

They also had some semblance of a challenge. Gary could kick your ass. An early gym leader's ace could wipe you out if you weren't prepared.

I stopped playing the games because they basically became auto-play and they refuse to implement difficulty levels.

5

u/silvertwo777 9h ago

This is something I will never understand, why can't they make something that target adults or atleast 16 years old and above, something more mature?

The typical answer would be because of the brand, to protect the image that it's a children brand for all ages. But in that way they miss out on so much potential this franchise could have.

8

u/Bart-Harley-Jarvis- 8h ago

Because adults keep buying it is the simplest reason.

5

u/Outlulz 19h ago

The final bit of Ash's run was all nostalgia bait for the older fans, what are you talking about.

1

u/TurbulentVillage2042 8h ago

I remembered what happened in Sonic X, when adult Chris turned back into a child. We didn't even get to see his adult self in ful body, just a part of his body in a suit.

Meanwhile, Jesse and James have already had children.

800

u/Suspicious-Lime-2439 1d ago

Starring The Rock and Kevin Hart

563

u/Chaeryeeong 1d ago

Robert Pattinson as Pikachu

138

u/Beautiful-Cabinet364 1d ago

You know… he nailed The Heron in The Boy and The Heron. The guy might be a legit voice actor.

102

u/bigfoot1291 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bigfoot1291 1d ago

He's honestly one of the best all around actors in Hollywood currently. Bro aces literally every role.

36

u/DaFuzi_J 1d ago

I will watch literally anything Pattinson is in. Dude got his foot in the door with Twilight and Harry Potter, and now he gets to be picky with things he thinks are cool. Daniel Radcliffe gets to do the same shit.

Being in middle school when Twilight actually came out, the weird sparkly guy has turned into one of my favorite actors ever.

24

u/jandrese 1d ago

The difference is that Daniel Radcliffe only seems interested in projects if they're super weird. Robert Pattinson has turned into a more mainstream actor.

30

u/DaFuzi_J 23h ago

Dan's just out there havin a good time, and I love him for it. Guns Akimbo and that Weird Al movie were hilarious.

12

u/Dry_Button_3552 23h ago

How about the one where he played a farting corpse

10

u/SinfulCrownIAdorn 22h ago

I did not care for Swiss Army Man, but Dan absolutely committed to the role.

→ More replies

5

u/kwokinator https://anilist.co/user/kwokinator 23h ago

I can't say I've watched a lot of his weirder movies, but I'm all for it. If you already have fuck you money since you're a teenager and still love acting for the sake of it, why not?

4

u/DaFuzi_J 23h ago

He's been doing a lot of stage-play stuff lately, also. Which, imo, seems like his true calling as an actor. He's so great.

→ More replies

4

u/EldritchCarver :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pilomotor 23h ago

I think it's because so many people looked down on him because of Twilight. They acted like he was an abysmal actor, when he was actually a great actor doing a great portrayal of an abysmal character. Because of that, he prefers roles in more widely-respected genres and/or well-established franchises so he won't always be remembered as the sparkly vampire.

9

u/Dangerous_Ad_7042 1d ago

His acting in Mickey 17 really sold me on how great he actually is.

26

u/just_Okapi 1d ago

He's gonna be a killer James Bond.

21

u/Suspicious-Lime-2439 1d ago

The kid from the Twilight movies is in his 40s and playing James Bond now.

Fuck, that makes me feel old

8

u/BottlesforCaps 1d ago

What the actual fuck I thought this was a joke....that's hilarious

27

u/Reptile449 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Reptile44 1d ago

With 100% improv

7

u/AdWestern1561 23h ago

And Danny Devito as Meowth.

11

u/thehalfdragon380 1d ago

Somebody get these Pokemon out of here

4

u/zaborgmonarch 12h ago

I could see him as adult Paul ngl. Then again I can also see Paul as Batman

36

u/aichiwawa 1d ago

The Rock as Brock and Kevin Hart as Pikachu

12

u/alteisen99 1d ago

he's about to change the hierarchy of the pokemon cinematic universe

2

u/ExLuckMaster 1d ago

That’s gonna be a short adventure for Ash. The Rock is contracted not to lose.

25

u/AndrasEllon 1d ago

Which one plays Misty?

65

u/Hina_is_my_waifu 1d ago

With current movie industry you know it will be Zendaya

24

u/Een_man_met_voornaam 1d ago

If it's animated voiced by Aquafina

1

u/invaderpixel https://myanimelist.net/profile/invaderpixel 23h ago

Seriously she is everywhere... but nothing was better than putting on Raya and the Last Dragon, watching my husband slowly get into the action and animation and worldbuilding, and then BOOM Awkwafina jumpscare.

5

u/BigTadpole 21h ago

She actually did a great job in Wildwood where she played a rat. Which makes much more sense than a dragon 😆

49

u/Beautiful-Cabinet364 1d ago

Ryan Reynolds

10

u/cyberscythe 1d ago

Chris Pratt

1

u/Crimson_Raven 1d ago

Who's the Team Rocket Trio?

3

u/MicoJive :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MicoJive 22h ago

Jack Black and a second Jack Black green screened in.

9

u/atropicalpenguin https://myanimelist.net/profile/atropicalpenguin 1d ago

Karen Gillian

3

u/yamiyaiba 1d ago

Sydney Sweeny, obviously. Because Hollywood loves her tits

1

u/darwinooc 1d ago

Zendaya

1

u/AnameAmos 1d ago

Cate Blanchett 

1

u/Brokenpipeisbroken https://myanimelist.net/profile/elitar 1d ago

Terry Crews

1

u/MatejMadar 20h ago

Bella Ramsey

1

u/NazRyuuzaki 19h ago

Terry Crews

10

u/Altruistic-Pause341 1d ago

Anne Hathaway as Ash’s mom

1

u/EdgyPlum 21h ago

Jack Black as Mr. Mime then?

2

u/CBAlan777 1d ago

Aim for the bushes.

2

u/Phaselocker 22h ago

i mean, we literally had Ryan Reynolds pikachu, anything is possible lol

2

u/g0ing_postal 20h ago

The Rock as Ash, Kevin Hart as Brock, Karen Gillian as Misty, Danny devito as professor oak, and Jack Black as Pikachu

1

u/OHFTP 2h ago

I would watch it.

2

u/NoRest4Wicked88 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NoRest4Wicked 1d ago

The Rock as Brock and Kevin Hart as Ash's step dad, er i mean Mr. Mime.

1

u/EdgyPlum 21h ago

Oh God, please no...

1

u/Nuxij 10h ago

No don’t fucking ruin it like that

1

u/OHFTP 3h ago

Right, but who is Ash in this casting?

2

u/Suspicious-Lime-2439 2h ago

Robert Pattinson

23

u/Torque-A 1d ago

They sorta did? The last couple episodes before Ash left the anime were like that.

22

u/Tessorio 1d ago

Oh god!? Why did I imagine a digimon-tri like thing and the trio va all singing the OP.

5

u/BadIdeaSociety 1d ago

Honestly, after the weird Ojamajo movie, the retired adult Ash reunites with Misty has potential.

5

u/TheRealSticky 1d ago

Something with Mewtwo please

2

u/kerorobot 17h ago

yeah good luck with that, they don't even let Ash age even one bit during all the time in anime.

1

u/g-six 10h ago

Thats what Digimon did with one of their movies. I cried buckets it was so beautiful.

1

u/John___Titor 18h ago

That sounds awful.

153

u/cyberscythe 1d ago

i didn't watch 'til the end; did she ever get her bike back?

190

u/Retsam19 :FC::FD: 1d ago

[deeply important Pokemon spoiler] Yes, in the episode where she leaves the party

93

u/Silent_Shadow05 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silent-Shadow05 1d ago

That episode kinda broke the young me lol.

66

u/Tels315 20h ago

You say Misty was relatively short lived, but also that Misty was in 20% of all episodes over 20 years, and that she was replaced by 8 different girls over the following seasons.

It's hard to say that she was short lived. If anything, it would imply she's the longest lived of his female companions. If Misty was his companion through 20% of all episodes, it means each of the following 8 can only get 10%, at best, of the remaining episodes.

23

u/TheBluBalloon 19h ago

10% would be the average, not the maximum. What the reality is idk

2

u/hectic_hooligan 3h ago • Bravo

And she was the best. Pokeshipping for life

27

u/Pootie_Tange_lvr 22h ago

It's crazy how long Misty was gone when you think about it. For people who grew up with the original trio, she always felt like an essential part of the show. The constant rotation of companions became normal eventually, but the original group still has a special place in the series.

25

u/starship777 1d ago

I can't believe this is how I find out Misty was sent to live on a farm upstate

205

u/Retsam19 :FC::FD: 1d ago

FWIW, I do think this was more-or-less the right call. Misty is a great character, but I also think the variety of having new travel companions and rivals did a lot to keep the series fresh.

And that was usually primarily through whatever was going on with the female companion: May's Pokemon contests, Dawn's "Coordinator" thing, Iris being the worst, etc - which is probably why Brock sticks around longer, because he's more of a side-character.

(Also clearly Ash is an ageless timelord and they normally change travel companions regularly /s)

45

u/cyberscythe 1d ago

yeah, reading this post made me think that it's basically a Doctor Who situation where they change companions every now and then

i also think Ash did reincarnate at least once

11

u/bombader 1d ago

I think I read that Horizons was supposed to be a new Ash, to solve the age issue and not require past shows for new watchers, but then Misty and Brock cameo sorta threw that out the window lol.

122

u/ruf2tup 1d ago

The fact that the companion was usually one of the main protagonists of that generations games was great for marketing

May, dawn, and Serena are insanely popular. Depending on the generation of viewers, they might have more fans than misty

53

u/Retsam19 :FC::FD: 1d ago

The fact that the companion was usually one of the main protagonists of that generations games was great for marketing

I also think they probably got more conscious about trying to appeal to girls more, too, which is probably why the later female companions tend to have their own 'thing' more than Misty did. (And may be a downside to Misty's 'tomboyishness')

11

u/psiphre 23h ago

not that there's anything wrong with a tomboy.

13

u/Retsam19 :FC::FD: 22h ago

No; I just think that in the 90s/early 00s, if you're a tv writer thinking "how do we get girls to watch this" then "booty-short-wearing tomboy" might not be your first thought.

2

u/psiphre 21h ago

i suppose that's fair. in order to be maximally interesting to girls, a girly girl character would be in order.

11

u/Lepony :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/dinglegrip 21h ago

Shoutouts to Liko who is the main protagonist the current series and I would've absolutely loved her as a child.

3

u/Outlulz 18h ago

I always thought the new female companions doing the stereotypically girly way of being a training kinda sucked. The return to basics with Iris was good but then Serena was back to girly girl does the girly stuff. Misty also liked dresses and girly stuff but it wasn't her ambition.

11

u/GrandLingonberry4159 1d ago

By Johto it was pretty obvious that writers didn't know what to do with her.

6

u/Pylgrim :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pylgrim 17h ago edited 10h ago

There was no reason whatsoever for her to leave Kanto. She had no big dreams and aspirations herself in the Pokemon world, she always came back to her status as Gym Leader (which, by the by, was sort of treated like a joke in the anime but in reality, it's very remarkable as she's one of the youngest Gym leaders ever).

1

u/Ranwulf 2h ago

Her following Ashe through the Orange Isles was a good call, as it made sense from her afinity to water. But I agree Johto already forced too much, not helping that she had Togepi for what? 3 years?

2

u/GrandLingonberry4159 2h ago

Also not helped by Johto having so much filler because Gen 3 was about 3 years away.

9

u/helloquain 23h ago

It's 100% the right call, if you're going to have an endless series you have to remove and introduce characters or you'll just run out of space to tell stories.

At some point your character's arc is simply over and it's time to move on from them.

41

u/atropicalpenguin https://myanimelist.net/profile/atropicalpenguin 1d ago

At least Misty still got to show up. Sadly May's voice actress had to retire due to illness. 

12

u/GrandLingonberry4159 1d ago

She showed up as a guest in DP, but that was about months/a year before her VA started having voice problems.

19

u/HarbingerOfGachaHell 15h ago edited 8h ago

People need to appreciate how SPECIFIC the each regional companion is designed for a particular role in the story, after the OG trio (and Tracey). 

Pokemon Beauty Contest was introduced in Gen III so May was designed specifically for it while also combined with Brendan’s subplot in Adventures manga as a gym leader’s kid. 

Dawn then took the Pokemon Beauty Contest role further without having to amalgamate with her male game counterpart. 

Then in Black & White, Iris and Cillian were just cruising along. Maybe because they’re the only gym leaders with canon replacements so they can be written off their gym leaders roles easily. Iris is also interesting because she also became a Champion in the expansion (B2/W2) so she COULD HAVE been a perfect foil to Ash. Shame that the anime didn’t expand on that much. Maybe they should’ve had her participate in the Pokemon League as well. 

The writing team in XY then tries to draw in more female audience using Serena by stacking her feminine charm to Level 120, with the separated-since-childhood romance subplot and Pokemon Showcase which is Pokemon Contests but with even greater Idol spin. Based on viewership stats, her being so extremely shojo-coded definitely helped revitalising the interest in the anime series. 

Then the Alola (Sun/Moon) squad expanded on the crew of 5 concept that the XY game was criticised for. It was definitely executed better than the XY version. 

And then came Pokemon Journeys, which is more of a duo dynamic with Goh taking a protege/understudy, DC-Robin-like role to Ash. 

53

u/Torque-A 1d ago

Honestly, I appreciate the anime team for trying to cycle things up. I believe an interview with one of the anime leads talked about their focus on changing the heroines primarily so I’m surprised Brock held up for so long, though.

Hell, with the new anime in a transition period before the new games, I wonder if they’ll try to pull the same thing twice.

73

u/Gilthwixt 1d ago

Having the female leads change but not Ash was kind of a weird choice imo. I think it would have been cooler if the series pulled a Digimon where every generation is a new cast and the older trainers get to cameo every now and then. Imagine the latest Gen is a kid challenging a 30+ year old Elite Four Ash and how that would feel to watch as a parent watching the show with their kids.

35

u/t8rt0t00 1d ago

Pikachu is the mascot of the pokemon so ditching Ash would've probably meant ditching Pikachu as well. This is probably the main reason why they kept him around. Not sure about Brock though, like what kind of gym leader just abandons his gym forever lol

18

u/Gilthwixt 1d ago

At least in the manga they handled this by having multiple Pikachus. Red has one, but so does Yellow. They could have Marry Poppins it or something where we follow Pikachu from kid to kid lol

9

u/PhenomsServant 1d ago

Its not like Ash had the only Pikachu on the planet. As weve proven nowadays they can keep Pikachu on the show without Ash

2

u/clone69 19h ago

Yet Horizons still has a Pikachu as an important character despite the being no Ash. So removing Ash doesn't necessarily mean removing Pikachu

22

u/FreeDaemon 1d ago

For some reason I find this funny. I remember my brother and I playing basketball with our nephews and we would go ham. Bumping and knocking them over. The score would be like 30-1. That’s how I imagine it would look like with a 10 yr old challenging a 30+ trainer.

19

u/Gilthwixt 1d ago

Lol if the show were realistic, maybe. But Ash already regularly beat grown adults as a 10 year old and it's apparently somehow completely normal for unaccompanied minors to travel the world, so maybe kids here are just built different.

4

u/HAK_HAK_HAK 1d ago

The best fan theory I've heard is that kids are better at forming strong bonds with new Pokemon, so they get more out of them than an equivalent adult trainer would. This is why most adult trainers never use more than a couple Pokemon.

-2

u/Aperger94 23h ago

that doesn't really track with most gym leaders and E4

9

u/HAK_HAK_HAK 23h ago

Here lemme help you:

Most adults are not gym leaders or E4

3

u/1dbad 23h ago

That's actually how the Pokémon Adventures manga handles things. 

4

u/PhenomsServant 1d ago

That was always my belief. If they had any balls, they wouldve ended Ash’s journey with him besting Gary to win the Silver Conference and Hoenn wouldve changed the cast and followed May or someone else.

1

u/Torque-A 1d ago

To be fair, they are trying now. But I think they're holding their cards to their chest - if Ash cameoed now, I fear everyone will just start comparing Liko and Roy to Ash again

1

u/ToastyMozart 16h ago

They were probably too afraid of alienating the existing fans to go full JoJo and replace the show's two main faces (since he and the Pikachu were a package deal).

They got there eventually with Horizons.

0

u/Innsui 20h ago

It would be cool but it wont be as recognizable as it is now. Pikachu was too big of a mascots to replace.

10

u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: 1d ago

Brock was technically be first to be replaced (Tracey for the Orange Islands arc). There's two sources giving the background here:

  • (Japanese) Takeshi Shudo (Pokemon chief writer up to ep 244) in a column/memoir mostly about Misty (but also mentions that Pokemon launching internationally there was concern Brocks narrow eyes wouldn't be well-received overseas so they debuted an alternative character for that arc but by the time that arc was over it was clear that wasn't a problem so he returned.
  • (English) Director Masamitsu Hidaka in an interview with Pokebeach. A few other details (wanting to give changing up the cast a go) some small differences (nothing too major) but that's not uncommon for history as The Anime Business shows (esp Manga Entertainment stuff, different employees have different accounts of the same events).

2

u/Torque-A 1d ago

Thanks for the links! I was paraphrasing a video about the subject trying to debunk the major rumors, which uses the same sources but I just didn't have them on hand.

-1

u/meneldal2 18h ago

Funny they didn't think the issue was him sexually harassing every single woman (and also men who dress up as women)

10

u/LeggedMien7 1d ago

Piggybacking off of this post to recommend the current season (Horizons) to anyone feeling like watching Pokemon.

It does not have Ash or any of the nostalgia inducing stuff that people like. But for a pokemon series it's VERY solid and it has a different formula compared to all seasons prior to S&M

27

u/MakoShark93 1d ago

I remember feeling a bit sad when Misty departed when I watched it as a kid. I also remember when May filled her spot I think that was during the 4th Gen? Can’t recall exactly but I liked May’s character. I stopped watching Pokemon after Advanced Generation, though. Sometimes I wish I could go back to it but it’s been almost 20 years for me and I would probably be off put by the juvenility.

17

u/Tuckertcs 22h ago

I’ve tried a few times to revisit the show, but it really is just a kids show.

And I say that as someone who loves Adventure Time, Avatar, and other cartoons. But those have enough substance to be truly enjoyable for adults and kids alike.

2

u/MakoShark93 14h ago

Yeah, thanks for somewhat confirming that for me. Similarly but adjacently, I remember a few years ago I had tried to rewatch G Gundam since I remembered loving it as a kid and found that I couldn’t watch it and it felt far more kiddish than I remembered. I say all that to say; we’re adults now and our interests change — what you thought was a good plot as a child might look very basic as an adult.

1

u/waterspider745 5h ago

Here I am in my 40's and consider G Gundam just as good as any "mature" television show. Hell, two of my Top 5 Favorite Gundam shows are from the Build sub-franchise.

12

u/WorldEaterYoshi 1d ago

Have kids and then you have an excuse to watch kids stuff without whatever issues you have with it getting in the way. Did it recently and it wasn't bad.

4

u/Shantotto11 1d ago

Third gen. Dawn (Diamond & Pearl) was fourth gen.

1

u/MakoShark93 22h ago

Gotcha. I guess it was between the 3rd and 4th gen that I stopped watching. I had got Diamond and Pearl (I chose Diamond) for the DS but then I went to High School that year (2007) and stopped playing Pokemon altogether.

1

u/Shantotto11 21h ago

Let me guess. You stopped watching when all of the voices changed?

2

u/MakoShark93 14h ago

No, a little before. But I remember sitting down and trying to watch an episode with my younger sister and her friends a few years ago and I had zero familiarity with the voices lol. Kinda figured an era had come to a close and the newer era didn’t exactly fill my cup of tea.

3

u/1dbad 23h ago

You could try doing a subbed rewatch? You'd be shocked at the sort of things 4Kids censored out of Kanto and Orange Islands. (Though starting with Johto even the Japanese version starts getting tamer) 

1

u/shadowysea07 1d ago

Ruby emerald sapphire gen is gen 3. Pearl diamond platinum with dawn is gen 4. Couldn't tell you the others. 

1

u/CurveElectronic6996 23h ago

You stopped right before the best one! Sinnoh is great. It’s free on prime video at the moment.

1

u/MakoShark93 14h ago

It very well may have. I had thought that the Diamond and Pearl era (which I presume is Sinnoh) was going to be pretty cool, but because I was starting High School I figured I should put Pokemon behind me since I was getting ready to be more “mature” (kids are hilarious — I knew nothing).

2

u/JustARedditAccoumt 13h ago

Diamond and Pearl era (which I presume is Sinnoh)

You are correct.

8

u/Nero_De_Angelo :IA::IB::IC: 1d ago

well, technically thentrio was already broken up BEFORE Gen 2, during Ash's travels through thw 4 Islands inbetween Gen1 and 2. Brock was actually written out, sraying with a female professor, and instead got replaced by another guy. Now, I do not knownthe english name, as I never watched Pokemon in english, only german. But in german they guys name was "Tracey" I believe.

That was the first time the trio got broken up. Eventually, Brock returns during Johto while Tracey stays with Professor Oak. And as far as I remember, we never got a reason as for WHY Brock returns, and he never opened about it when asked.

Most likely guess is that in Japan no one liked Tracey, so they replaced him with Brock again. But that is just my Theory.

15

u/GrandLingonberry4159 1d ago

Brock was initially replaced because Pokémon was going global and the higher ups at Nintendo were afraid that people overseas would see him as an offensive Asian caricature because of his eyes always being closed. Brock/Takeshi was brought back because no one actually cared and people disliked Tracey/Kenji for replacing him.

1

u/Nero_De_Angelo :IA::IB::IC: 12h ago

Thabk you for clarifying, so I was spot on with my assumption that nobody liked Tracey xD

5

u/elfridpaytonshair 1d ago

I stopped when she left, 7 year old me was devastated, couldn’t get back into it

13

u/zazakmazak 1d ago

Pokemon is a great setting, but they really do the utmost to make it appealing to only kids and casual watchers who might not tune to every episode that airs on the tv, made sense for the times and huuuge merchandise sales that bankroll the whole thing.

I really wished they had a separate anime for older audiences with permanent progression and more mature themes and characters that would air in the same way other seasonal anime, it would be like another shounen series are.

4

u/SacaeGaming 1d ago

Still to this day believe gen 3 was the best the series ever was as a show. Don’t know where the rest of the fandom stands but gen 3 and gen 5 were simply magical.

6

u/Outlulz 18h ago

To me it's just the Indigo League. Not solely from nostalgia but because the franchise wasn't established yet so it got to do a lot of weird and rule breaking and unique stuff that was not allowed by Gen 3.

2

u/SacaeGaming 18h ago

Fully agree with the nostalgia and uniqueness of gen 1, but man something about that switch from season 5 to season 6 truly felt great

4

u/Carleen_de_Schwartz 18h ago

My bro she is the LONGEST lived of them all. If anything Serena, a relatively well popular among the female companions as well, had one of the shortest times

3

u/Ekillaa22 1d ago

I’d say when Brock left it really changed man was with Ash for so long

5

u/Perryn 1d ago edited 1d ago

Does this make Misty the Rose Tyler of Pokemon?

1

u/waterspider745 5h ago

It always kind of annoyed me how much the US fanbase slobbers all over Misty. I like the character well enough, but she had long outgrown her role in the show (as did Brock, but that's another story), and Japan were more than willing to embrace the other female companions, as Dawn, Iris, and Serena are far more popular there over Misty. Yet in the US fandom having 1,200 episodes of the same trio doing the same things every episode is preferred, and any change to that should result in the creative staff being sent to GitMo.

2

u/precita 5h ago

May already became more popular back in 2003 in the west/Japan. It's just Misty fans genuinely trick themselves into thinking Misty is more popular than she actually is. The writing staff would have never been able to drop Misty from the show as easily as they did back in 2003 when most of the original fanbase was still the target audience if they thought her popularity would have a negative impact on viewership of the show. That's actually why the writers even originally stop Misty's cameos in Hoenn and she doesn't appear again for 12 years later.

2

u/PandaTheAB 22h ago

I kinda felt the MCs/permanent recurring cast of the show were technically Team Rocket. (atleast in first ten years)
The protagonists in some arcs and movies in first decade were not Ash Team but Team Rocket had been part of every story/movie/arc in the first decade or so.

2

u/perfectbluu :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MoghyBear 22h ago

I was so sad when she left 

2

u/ptd163 20h ago

I remember the Pokemania of the 90s and early 00s. You really thought that any separation wouldn't actually be permanent. Then as we got older we started wondering if a female Ash would start a second wave of Pokemania.

Another explosion of fan art, discussion, culture as Misty (and the other girls to a lesser extent) had done. If they could do that as companions, but what could they do as the Ash?

Then when Liko finally did arrive with Horizons the response was tepid at best imo. She's just kind of there. I don't remember a time where the main pokegirl wasn't the most popular girl of her series/generation.

2

u/lemons7472 20h ago

That’s almost as old as me

2

u/Emergency_Paper9613 11h ago

As a 90s kid her and tifa  were  my big crushes  lol, back in the day it would be on after  school  and you didnt really have a easy  way to watch it so I never  knew when her and  Brock  left  just being sad  the new  companions changed growing up  with each new season 

1

u/Kartonrealista https://myanimelist.net/profile/karton_realista 23h ago

It's kinda weird to say that since a few of those years don't include any of the original characters, since the show ended and Pokémon Horizons, with a different plot and characters has been airing to this day. Like correct, you said since, but you really ought to stop counting after the show ended.

1

u/TurbulentVillage2042 8h ago edited 8h ago

I first I’ve heard that Misty was excluded O_o She was my favorite character(((

1

u/Maxximillianaire 7h ago

When they play the old episodes on twitch that still have misty and the original VAs it's so fun to watch

1

u/SwimmingStranger 3h ago

Wait wait wait you're telling me Ash isn't the main character of pokemon anymore? Wtf lol

1

u/Life_Sheepherder965 3h ago

They are the still the main trio in my mind. I never watch anything after them. I think the first generation is a lost media, or do you happen to know where can I watch them again ?

1

u/IcyAnimeFan 2h ago

That's crazy to me thinking about this. My brother basically grew up with Pokémon and he loved the original anime to death.

What a crazy thought to think he was saying Goodbye to Misty on the same day he got to say Hello to Me for the First time! (Date of airing is my Birthday!)

1

u/Echoogoesmad 2h ago

No freaking way

1

u/Welpe 13h ago

I don’t understand why there would be any expectation that she would ever appear again when she is an NPC from the first game, that’s it. She wasn’t “written out”, she had been in FAR more of the anime than appropriate already and it moved on from her.

Why wouldn’t this happen? Why wouldn’t it be expected to be permanent? Why aren’t you writing a topic on any other Kanto NPC that didn’t come back after the material covering the first game?

0

u/Financial_Sale_7366 18h ago

Her and May are the hottest

-1

u/skepticalmiller 15h ago

I stopped watching. I will not watch unless she is in an episode. <3 </3

4

u/Kamunami 1d ago

Say, why do people call Misty a tomboy anyway? Booty shorts and a midriff bearing top? Side ponytail and super-slender physique? A feisty, catty personality with a fiery temper and a hatred of bugs? She doesn't even dislike traditionally feminine things.

29

u/Retsam19 :FC::FD: 1d ago

In the original game her title (on the sign in front of her gym) was:

Cerulean City Pokémon Gym Leader: Misty
The Tomboyish Mermaid!

The anime doesn't go full tomboy, especially with the hatred of bugs thing, but I'd still say she qualifies as "Tomboyish", especially compared to her sisters (or many of Ash's later travel companions).

And the "fiery temper" aspect is not a traditional feminine trait, especially in Japan.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/GrandLingonberry4159 1d ago

Japan rarely ever depicts tomboys that don't have feminine traits.

7

u/Kamunami 1d ago

I think the boyish part is what makes a tomboy.

11

u/VicisSubsisto 1d ago

It's about having the positive aspects associated with boyhood while still also being attractive as a girl. Casual, athletic, looks good without makeup, not afraid to go out on adventures like hiking, camping, and fighting monsters, can hang out as "one of the guys" and doesn't need to be treated like a princess.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/WrenInTheAir 1d ago

90s gender roles were really, really dumb. A boy brushing his hair meant he was gay. A girl riding a bike, ready and willing to punch people, and wearing shorts, not a skirt? Totally tomboy and/or gay.