r/anime • u/Turbostrider27 • 22h ago
Misc. Neon Genesis Evangelion “was so brilliant that I felt despair rather than awe.” Renowned artist Takashi Murakami explains why he gave up on the anime industry
https://automaton-media.com/en/news/neon-genesis-evangelion-was-so-brilliant-that-i-felt-despair-rather-than-awe-renowned-artist-takashi-murakami-explains-why-he-gave-up-on-the-anime-industry/
2.3k
Upvotes
275
u/il887 https://myanimelist.net/profile/il887 21h ago
It’s rather sad that watching an anime made aspiring creator gave up on their dreams instead of inspiring them. Come on man, Evangelion is not the first and not the last such an influential work out there.
329
u/Will-Isley 22h ago
End of Evangelion will always be a religious experience to me. The show was amazing but the movie is some next level shit we rarely get in media
900
u/blakeavon 22h ago •
It’s a work of art in every possible way. Flawed. Brilliant. Hits like a truck. Stays with you. It also, sadly, spawned a million contrarians who are all like ‘meh, it’s rubbish, I write better things in my sleep’ but all of who cant manage the wisdom to be able to respect it for what it tried to achieve and the undeniable impact it had on popular culture, even if they dont like it.
105
u/Due_Enthusiasm1145 21h ago edited 21h ago
I think a lot of people that scoff at the impact Evangelion had on people, often don't know the context around the series, especially if they're comparing it to anime that came out AFTER Evangelion, when Evangelion influenced so much of the industry.
This is SUPER nerdy, but its kinda like how people call Macbeth lame in school, missing the context for why its so revolutionary. Macbeth wasn't actually a wholly original play by Shakespeare. It was common practice back then to take existing plays and give your spin on it, similar to subgenres nowadays, like Mecha within scifi. What made Macbeth so good, is that it took this existing revenge wish fulfillment story, and turned it into a psychological thriller and character study. Audiences were blown away by this, and it influenced SO MANY writers after it, but that influence means that people look back at it now and call it unoriginal, missing its originally revolutionary status.
Evangelion exists in the mecha genre as something similar. It was a work within a genre that dealt with bigger themes like war and oppression, or sometimes just simple wish fulfillment and power/revenge fantasies, and turned into a tragedy, a psychological thriller and a character study, using the tools of the genre as allegories and metaphors for the character.
What's even more impressive is he didn't even set out to do that. The week to week nature separates it from something like Macbeth, which was intended on being subversive, and instead gives Evangelion a unique aura as a piece of media that started earnest and slowly turned into a deconstruction of its genre. That real life shift adds a sense of realness to the work, that while yes may make it feel choppy compared to later pieces that set out with the intent, also loses that real life discovery of the dark underbelly of the story.
Evangelion, like many pieces of art considered amazing, is also harmed by its success, influence and age, because now other stories have gone on to do the same thing, but have the ability to refine it further. That should be factored in when speaking of the quality of Evangelion.
108
u/Jusenkyo_5 22h ago
Bro knows ball
13
u/HanaMizukiy 21h ago
I think artists sometimes forget they don't have to surpass the greatest works ever made. Creating something that genuinely connects with even a handful of people is already worth something.
23
u/ashleyriot31 22h ago
my goat
34
u/actuallyrndthoughts :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NaNiNuNeNo 20h ago
The worst thing about threads like these, is most people have their posting history hidden, so i can't go throught it to judge their so superior tastes. Like, i'm sure your battle shounen diet has nothing to do with "hating" eva. trust
10
u/Nijindia18 https://myanimelist.net/profile/IndianNinja1 19h ago
Man really said "peak" and stopped looking for another mountain 😔
44
u/Kabraxal 21h ago
No matter how you feel about NGE, that is an extreme overreaction. There could be nothing so great in any medium that would cause me to feel despair and drop out of that participating in that industry.
Shit work conditions and bad execs? Sure, but “this thing was so great that it’s only downhill and not worth the effort!” is a rather pathetic attitude. Maybe you never measure up or find its equal. Doesn’t mean you should fucking stop trying.
36
u/Alukrad 19h ago
Growing up I kept having people telling me that I need to watch this, so every time I attempted to watch it I just couldn't enjoy it... The main character cried too much and it annoyed me so much that I kept dropping it.
Then one day I sat through it, powered through the whole thing and it made me realize this anime is absolutely not for me. I hated all the characters, the story made absolutely no sense to me as the show kept going, and that ending left me more confused than anything. Then I jumped on the remake version, which made no sense to me either and the ending was completely different too.
I really don't understand this anime. I tried to watch a breakdown on YouTube and that left me more confused because now we're getting into alternate dimensions or something. I really don't understand what people see in this anime and I really, really tried to like it.
8
u/CVfxReddit 15h ago
This is one of those shows I appreciate but don't actually like. But it is an interesting portrait of a guy with a lot of issues working them out on screen.
Of course it's also full of a lot of scantily clad super thin underage women which has led to the greatest merch potential in all of fiction, which says some pretty bleak things about the human race.
4
u/Big-Fun9872 20h ago
クソみたいに落ち込んでる鬱病の時に見たからめちゃくちゃ良かったわ、最後のシーンは生きる力くれたよ
逆に映画は特にシンエヴァ4作はいらない、てか映画全部いらない
2
u/Low_Understanding326 16h ago
Watched it. Didn't enjoy it as much as I hoped. People said to watch the movie remakes then. Maybe one day I will.
2
u/karatemnn 15h ago
i get how the show can be confusing especially the finale, but i think people
simply saying the show is surface level don't even pay attention to the dynamics of a teenage kid going through all that shit, like the horrible actions of everyone involved in the show to the lead kid is incredibly engaging ... but people think it's just an edgy giant robot show
12
u/AscendedViking7 22h ago
Arguably the greatest anime of all time
3
u/Wutanghang 20h ago
Ive never watched evangelion its too late
3
u/KernelWizard https://myanimelist.net/profile/DangoDaikazoku 11h ago edited 11h ago
Well the only thing I understand from Neon Genesis Evangelion was: Boy depressed, boy fight in giant mecha, boy wank on female friend, everyone turns to Fanta, the end lmao. I totally enjoyed it the whole way through.
8
u/gho5trun3r 21h ago
Feels like anytime someone criticizes this anime, they get met with a Rick and Morty fan logic of "you just aren't smart enough to understand. Only intellectuals can get it."
I didn't like this show. I thought the left turns were random and unearned. The trauma wasn't built up convincingly enough in the show to showcase the surreal parts that came later. And the surreal parts took over the main plot and by the end of the show, I felt like we hadn't resolved the main storyline. I feel like the show is kind of a mess and all over the place. It's also one of the weirdest shows to watch when a roommate walks by.
If people like the mess, that's fine. But calling this the best of anime is some crazy claim. The show is divisive for a reason and it's not because people just "don't get it." It's because some people "just don't like it."
5
u/NTolegna 21h ago
Most overrated anime
3
u/MacroMicro1313 12h ago
Spirited Away was better
2
u/bulovalunar 12h ago
The only reason I like it is because I love the angel designs, the theological/sci Fi aspects and concepts like the death of ego, instrumentality, SEELE etc. Couldn't care less about Shinji and the underage waifu bait. I know it doesn't make me a proper fan but I don't really care.
1
u/Command0Dude 16h ago edited 15h ago
I cannot understand how people rave about this anime so much. To me, the writing is just entirely up its own ass. No matter how much people try to explain it, I just don't get it. So much of Evangelion feels superficial and shallow. I'm reminded the first time I read an article that talked about how much of the artistic iconography had no deeper meaning behind it other than it "looked cool" to Anno.
People have been bending over backwards to make this anime into a deeper story than it actually is for over 30 years now. Ironically, people didn't even 'get' the anime when it first came out. Anno released an entire redone ending that was intended to mock his own fans because of it.
I've seen so many other, better anime do the things that people purport Evangelion to be so amazing for. Welcome to the NHK is way better as a character study of otaku, there are so many Gundam shows that do "war sucks" better, Psycho Pass is a better psychological thriller, Vinland Saga is a better tragedy, and there are over a hundred anime characters that are way more interesting than Evangelion's entire cast.
1
u/banishedwolf 20h ago
That's very interesting. I've never thought much about the impact of Eva from the perspective of someone like that.
1
u/Dizzy-By-Degrees 19h ago
Reminds me of the anecdote of how one of Picasso’s peers was so stunned by his art he decided there was no place in the world for him because he’d never compete. Young artists are competitive as they are melodramatic.
But at least he is still in the game and willing to put something out there. Never give up.
1
u/ligital 15h ago
It is very polarising, but that’s why it’s so memorable. I have already watched it thrice, and I know I will likely watch it a 4th time some day.
1
u/catinterpreter 15h ago
This is a paid promo post.
1
u/Electrical-Lack-8865 13h ago
Why is Jett not in here?
1
u/AzeiteGalo https://myanimelist.net/profile/StrawHatList 10h ago
Yes its edgy and perhaps overly depressing but I think it was groundbreaking and refreshing in the world of anime. Very few anime shows or movies dare to be that experimental and take so many risks. You hate the MC because you watch this as a kid and you are used to the Mc being the cool guy, always ready to save the day, the hero. But NGE and this finale shows what a real human kid would go through if landed in a reality like this one. Of course there are some flaws, mainly the unnecessary fanservice, but I think they needed something to keep the audiences until the end as this was not your typical show.
1
u/Jippi_kotobagari 8h ago
One thing I find interesting about Evangelion is its use of colors.
Rei is blue, Asuka is red, and Eva-01 is purple — the color you get when you mix blue and red. Blue and red are also the colors commonly used to represent veins and arteries.
Shinji's black-and-white school uniform also reminds me of piano keys.
I don't know how much of this was intentional, but Evangelion is really interesting to watch when you pay attention to the colors.
1
u/headphonesXX 7h ago
this dude never worked as an animator so why the fuck he speaking on anything? dude has a team of assistance he pays to make art for him. he physically doesnt create any art.
1
u/RollingStoned9824 5h ago
As a teenager this anime broke my brain and I loved it. I love the TV series and the ending. I so old I had to by a bootleg version of end of evangelion because it wasn't released in the States at the time. I was not a fan of the movie.
1
u/KMFCM :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kmfcm 3h ago
So, we see a bunch if conflicting opinions here.
I would like to know if the people that don't like the original series bothered watching the Rebuilds, and if so, what do they think of them.
I personally know people that love the original and disliked the Rebuilds.
1
u/Wolfrast 16m ago
I feel like this anime is more like an art house movie and what most people watch is more like Blockbuster movie versions of anime they don’t want to be challenged. They don’t want something that’s complex or artistic. They just want something. That’s fun trigger certain emotions that are familiar, like when you go to a blockbuster movie, you know what you’re getting into you have your popcorn in your soda and you have your laughs and you have your excitement and you have your sad moments at all. The music will pretty much subliminally queue, you on what to feel at certain times it’s all very rehearsed( no pun intended) but Evangelion seemed to be more like an arthouse movie, and if you like that kind of thing, it’s a great show, but the movies are better. The newer stuff I’m not a fan of, but I exceptionally enjoyed it because I don’t really want to be held at gunpoint on what to feel or think I’d rather have the space and the looseness to decide on what’s happening in my own mind instead of a very clear indication. I’ll never forget the words of the director of A Taste of Cherry, when he spoke about how movies can hold you at gunpoint, as if you were a hostage on what you should feel while watching them because of all the tools and implements that they use to create certain emotions and feelings, totally fine. His use of words is a little bit intense, but I also can see as a movie like his movie or perhaps an anime like Evangelion was striving for that sense of freedom where even the crater doesn’t know what they made.
1
u/its_Preshh 20h ago
It's in my top 3 best anime of all time alongside Attack on Titan and Legend of the Galactic Heroes.
I understand it's not for everyone and as with other critically acclaimed shows, you have the usual contrarians who claim it's bad or overrated.
Evangelion is a masterpiece. End of Evangelion is the best anime movie I've ever watched and probably the best ending I've ever seen in anime.
Not everyone will resonate with it or appreciate it and that is fine. It does not mean these people are bad at media or that the show is bad.
I only find issue with people who dedicate so much time to hating on a piece of media trying to justify themselves for not liking it. E.g "i dont like X media, so X media must be bad and everyone who likes it must be stvpid".
-1
u/gerty88 20h ago
Utter bollocks series with like 3 good moments lol. It was so monster of the week 🥱
-36
u/aDoorMarkedPirate420 22h ago
Honestly I think it’s pretty overhyped. It’s definitely good, but I don’t understand all the glaze still.