r/anime • • 22h ago

Misc. Neon Genesis Evangelion “was so brilliant that I felt despair rather than awe.” Renowned artist Takashi Murakami explains why he gave up on the anime industry

https://automaton-media.com/en/news/neon-genesis-evangelion-was-so-brilliant-that-i-felt-despair-rather-than-awe-renowned-artist-takashi-murakami-explains-why-he-gave-up-on-the-anime-industry/
2.3k Upvotes

440 comments sorted by

275

u/il887 https://myanimelist.net/profile/il887 21h ago

It’s rather sad that watching an anime made aspiring creator gave up on their dreams instead of inspiring them. Come on man, Evangelion is not the first and not the last such an influential work out there.

221

u/Ashteron 21h ago

He didn't give up art though.

There are stories about more positive reactions. In some interview with Nasu (Fate creator) he said that he was aspiring to be a writer, but wasn't really taking it seriously. Watching Evangelion's opening was an utterly mindblowing experience for him and it motivated him to finally dedicate himself to becoming a writer.

201

u/XF10 21h ago

Evangelion to "Tohsaka's defenseless anus" pipeline

78

u/tlst9999 21h ago

to "People die when they are killed" pipeline

20

u/Kadmos1 16h ago

Probably one of the best mistranlated lines in the industry ever.

20

u/Taberaremasen 11h ago

I mean the actual line in Japanese is "人は殺されれば死ぬ" and the translation is very literal and accurate. The problem is that one line is taken out of context without regard for the rest of the conversation being had.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/guyblade 17h ago

I often hear that mentioned when Fate comes up, but the first time that any version (all ages or AO) of the Fate/stay night game got an official English translation was in 2024 with the remaster.

That fact makes me wonder to what extent that is a real line vs. the fan translation just having fun.

19

u/XF10 17h ago

Eroge h scene writing is just that wild, bet at best it was something like "bare anus" in og. At end of the day it's just dudes translating it and remaster only has official stamp over fanslation(but doesn't have sex scenes to begin with since it's Realta Nua)

I mean Muramasa sex scenes will have MC go on the most misoginystic rant you will ever see

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/Jusenkyo_5 21h ago

Horny and it's peak, a perfect combo.

7

u/minty-moose 17h ago

as god intended

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/BambooGentleman :IG: 7h ago edited 7h ago

It's hard to argue that a more influential anime came out after Evangelion, though.
...or before.

6

u/il887 https://myanimelist.net/profile/il887 5h ago

Before is easy, quick googling gives like 5-10 classic titles from which I watched myself Gundam and Space Battleship Yamato. For "after" I’m thinking primarily Madoka Magica and Revolutionary Girl Utena. Some say Love Hina and SAO were pretty influential too in their genres (harem/isekai).

→ More replies (6)

329

u/Will-Isley 22h ago

End of Evangelion will always be a religious experience to me. The show was amazing but the movie is some next level shit we rarely get in media

85

u/Jusenkyo_5 22h ago

End of Evangelion might be the #1 movie of all time.

48

u/Noxious89123 21h ago

Oh damn.

I watched Evangelion, but I never got around to watch the movie that came after.

One more thing to add to the list.

42

u/Ayiekie 18h ago

To dampen your expectations to something I think is a bit more realistic, End of Evangelion is extremely surreal and divisive due to this. Some people really, really like it, some people very much do not. If you like really trippy surreal things generally it'll likely appeal to you, if you were not a fan of Eva's last two episodes at all I'd be more cautious.

20

u/Avloren 16h ago

I wouldn't describe it that way. Sure, parts of the movie are surreal and trippy and hard to interpret what exactly is supposed to actually be happening. But other parts of it are very grounded, hard-hitting character drama, as in very tangible things definitely happen to real people in the real world. And it also includes (IMO) the best action sequence in the franchise (Asuka vs. the mass production units). It's a little of everything that Evangelion was, bundled together and turned up to 11.

I wouldn't really compare it to the last two episodes, which are 110% surreal and trippy and "WTF am I supposed to even take away from that scene", with nothing else to balance it.

18

u/aimglitchz 21h ago

End of evangelion is the continuation of the story of season

11

u/eetsumkaus https://myanimelist.net/profile/kausdc 17h ago

it's more like the part between episodes 22 and 23 that was meant to be in the anime itself.

20

u/andreeinprogress 21h ago

More of an alternative point of view of the ending than a continuation but yeah, should be watched.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Jusenkyo_5 21h ago

I could not recommend it more. I have around 1,000 anime watched and EoE is one of like 15 10/10s for me.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Platinum_Rad 17h ago

it's just got the single best apocalypse scene

i don't think anyone's ever done it any better

4

u/Constant-Pain1878 21h ago

Do you have to watch the show to understand the movie? 

84

u/vikatmigolemiqhui 21h ago

Even if you watch the show you might not understand the movie

11

u/Bromolochus 20h ago

This is why they had so much exposition in 3.0 but it was still pretty hype. A different ending for a different era

54

u/XF10 21h ago

Yes the movie called End of Evangelion is the epilogue of Evangelion series lol

17

u/Jusenkyo_5 21h ago

Yes, it's a sequel.

6

u/Adept_Advertising_98 21h ago

The movie is what the TV version’s finale would’ve been if they had time to get it animated, but they ran out of time and made the TV ending fully in Instrumentality.

5

u/GGG100 18h ago

It’s the true final episode (or episodes) of the original series. I believe there were title cards that even label each segment of the movie as episodes 25 and 26.

4

u/JonathanAltd :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Deoxysos 16h ago

it's the kind of abstract master piece that you need to watch very carefully and might get new things from on rewatch, made me think of this meme /img/xmrm0dve7b0z.jpg

3

u/bravetailor 16h ago

You absolutely have to.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/HomemLobo 18h ago

These words speak to me.

2

u/PhortDruid 21h ago

Good endorsement. I’ve only watched the show thus far. I’ll have to watch it soon!

18

u/CheesecakeMage42 21h ago

I just saw it for the first time in theaters for the anniversary showing. I expected two or three other people at the theater, pretty much every single seat was taken.

the movie ended, the lights came on, and the entire theater was still and silent for a good minute. i don't think I've ever had a theater be that quiet. Drove home in an absolute daze in a bizarre in between state of absolute despair and hopefulness

7

u/greater_golem 20h ago

state of absolute despair and hopefulness

Sounds about right.

5

u/Dolomite808 19h ago

He was trapped in the AT field.

2

u/nerdshark 18h ago

they were all so fucked up

900

u/blakeavon 22h ago • Diamonds are Forever Bravo

It’s a work of art in every possible way. Flawed. Brilliant. Hits like a truck. Stays with you. It also, sadly, spawned a million contrarians who are all like ‘meh, it’s rubbish, I write better things in my sleep’ but all of who cant manage the wisdom to be able to respect it for what it tried to achieve and the undeniable impact it had on popular culture, even if they dont like it.

83

u/Alarming_Ask_244 22h ago

What would say are its flaws?

291

u/Jusenkyo_5 22h ago

A lot of the "text" of the story is nonsensical and is purely there to drive emotion.

I wouldn't necessarily say it's a flaw, I see it the same way that I see Angel's Egg. The emotion that the story evokes as well as it's theme around connection is what's important and the surface story is secondary to that. I would never say that it makes zero sense, but a lot of the SEELE stuff definitely wasn't there 100%.

128

u/Kumorrii 22h ago

Yeah, a lot of the lore is pretty much vibes based but that's not necessarily a bad thing. But the same thing happens in the Rebuild movies and the issue is that people bash their heads trying to make sense of nonsensical lore when it's mainly used to drive a character-driven story first and foremost.

16

u/[deleted] 21h ago edited 21h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Eaten_by_Mimics 18h ago

Yeah, I think a lot of people balk at the series because they expect it to be more plot-focused, like genre fiction has historically been, rather than character-focused, as literary fiction generally is. I’ve always considered NGE more of a character study than a full-fledged sci-fi story.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/SuperPapernick 9h ago

I think that's what ultimately put me off, personally. I can totally see why Eva is such a beloved and popular series, but I just couldn't get over the fact that a lot of the "nuts and bolts" holding the plot together just make very little sense. It's admittedly all to get characters to do or feel certain things or simply because it looks/sounds cool, famously applying to all the biblical names and imagery that were chosen specifically because the creators wanted them to sound exotic and weird and not because that was supposed to carry any particular meaning or inform an understanding of the plot. But in the end I personally just couldn't vibe with it. It all ended up as a hodgepodge that had me asking "but why is any of this actually happening, really?" all the way.

53

u/t3rmina1 21h ago

The most obvious ones are the end of the TV series, eps 25 and 26

Kazuya Tsurumaki interview, Red Cross Book wrote:

What did you think about developments during the second half of the TV series?

KT - I didn't mind it. The schedule was an utter disaster and the number of cels plummeted, so there were some places where unfortunately the quality suffered. However, the tension of the staff as we all became more desperate and frenzied certainly showed up in the film.

About the time that the production system was completely falling apart, there were some opinions to the effect that, "If we can't do satisfactory work, then what's the point of continuing?" However, I didn't feel that way. My opinion was, "Why don't we show them the entire process including our breakdown." You know -- make it a work that shows everything including our inability to create a satisfactory product. I figured that, "In 10 years or so, if we look back on something that we made while we were drunk out of our minds, we wouldn't feel bad even if the quality wasn't so good."

19

u/banishedwolf 21h ago

I liked the endings. And it's ironic that their struggle ended up delivering one of the most unique endings ever.

11

u/yondazo 21h ago

Ironically, I found episodes 25 and 26 to be the most interesting part of the show back when I watched it.

80

u/Dagordae 21h ago edited 21h ago

It’s regularly opaque to the point where it harms the story and narrative, mystery is fine but mystery for the sake of mystery is not.

The symbolism is also all over the place. Sometimes it’s deep and incisive, sometimes it’s pathetically shallow, and sometimes it’s clearly just been thrown it because it looks cool with no regard with meaning.

The pacing is similarly messy.

Rei rather famously completely and utterly failed at her intended role in the story.

And, of course, you have the infamous budget induced flaws. You know, the end of the show which was so bad they made a movie to replace it. Regular reuse of footage, extended flashbacks to stuff we already say, frames held for long periods of time just because.

18

u/Jusenkyo_5 21h ago

Rey rather famously completely and utterly failed at her intended role in the story.

Context on this? I don't see any issue with Rei for the most part.

42

u/Dagordae 21h ago

She was originally intended to be a creepy, inhuman, and off-putting character who the audience slowly warms up to as she gains humanity. That… yeah that didn’t happen. Very much the opposite.

It doesn’t hurt the story per se, it’s just a flaw in the intended design and results in a bit of early series jank.

11

u/Jusenkyo_5 21h ago

Huh, yeah I wouldn't have expected that that is the intended outcome. I think Rei's highlight is her relationship with Gendo.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/yondazo 21h ago

It half worked, I never warmed up to her. ;)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/camaron28 20h ago

Not sure if this is supposed to be what OP means, but they finished off her character development during the Rei II episode, i think it was chapter 7 or so.

This means that she didn't do much (compared with the other MCs) for the rest of the series until the Rei III chapter.

4

u/DrStein1010 https://myanimelist.net/profile/mQDrStein1010 19h ago

Rei definitely worked out for the better (especially if you include the Rebuilds), but it's clear Anno had no idea what to do with her for most of the series.

4

u/lI1IlL071245B3341IlI 11h ago edited 11h ago

When asked about Evangelion's extensive use of Christian imagery, such as crosses, angels and biblical references, the production team explained that it was largely an aesthetic choice. Christianity was relatively unfamiliar in Japan, which gave its imagery an air of mystery and helped distinguish the series from other mecha anime. As assistant director Kazuya Tsurumaki famously put it, they simply thought the Christian symbols looked cool.

Video review capturing it's flaws https://youtu.be/ZnihGeRjG3U

8

u/Witch-kingOfBrynMawr 21h ago

Well, there are some, er, animation-quality issues at times. Lots of padding and pacing issues, static frames.

There are some avoidable issues with plot clarity.

(It's my favorite anime. Watched it at 36 years old, first anime I'd ever seen. Also the second anime I've ever seen, because I immediately rewatched it with subtitles.)

17

u/Viktorv22 20h ago edited 20h ago

I didn't care for a single character in it. Actually scratch that - I actively disliked all of them. I guess you have to be different kind of a person to get enjoyment out of it. Also I don't think nihilistic ending is for everyone.

But are these flaws? Hard to say. As all art, it's all subjective.

Maybe I will appreciate the story and characters in a different part of my life if I happen to rewatch it, who knows.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DrStein1010 https://myanimelist.net/profile/mQDrStein1010 19h ago

The pacing is pretty awful, both rushed or way too slow at various points.

There are a few areas where the disaster production isn't covered by the artistry.

A lot of the lore and plot are nonsensical in unneeded ways, and a lot of stuff isn't explained where it actually should be, like what the angels actually are.

9

u/Kumorrii 22h ago

A lot of people try to pass off some moments as art, but I think Eva definitely hit some budget issues during certain parts of the production. The movie had to be made as a proper conclusion to the anime because I think they genuinely ran out of money by like episode 25

20

u/Adept_Advertising_98 21h ago

Correction: they ran out of time to actually animate because of the amount of rewrites.

4

u/bravetailor 16h ago

I think the budget issues actually help the gritty and raw feel of the show, even if unintentionally. The show was about stripping its characters' psyche down raw, and having a stripped down show budget wise definitely felt fitting in a way.

It helps that the design work and compositions still remained at a high quality even though the animation quality suffered.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Alarming_Ask_244 20h ago

I’m an ep 25/26 defender but only because I was able to watch EoE immediately afterwards

5

u/DrStein1010 https://myanimelist.net/profile/mQDrStein1010 19h ago

25 and 26 are my favorite part of the whole franchise, but, yeah, you do need to resolve the actual plot at some point.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/rathyAro 17h ago

Just because someone disagrees doesn't make them a contrarian. Plenty of people don't like eva.

14

u/N0UMENON1 21h ago

Why am I a contrarian for saying that I hated it? Is it not allowed to dislike something just because it's deemed a classic?

37

u/Jusenkyo_5 20h ago

No, but the majority of people who dislike it happen to be contrarians.

→ More replies (13)

12

u/blakeavon 19h ago

Because hate is a silly word. I get someone saying they didn’t like it, but the show is clearly way more deserving than someone blindly ‘hating’ it. It’s not hard to value the impact of a piece of popular culture even though you don’t like it. But to ‘hate’ it means you aren’t willing to take a step back and understand the value of it beyond your personal hate.

5

u/Cornchip97 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LordEnglish 12h ago

It's not about personal preference, its about some people's desire to shit on one of the foundational pillars of anime. Like walking into an art gallery and loudly announcing that you think Starry Night is trash.

There becomes a point where a work/artist so profoundly affects the trajectory of its medium that it holds decorum even if its not personally appealing.

3

u/Ranwulf 3h ago

Also its kinda annoying that people comment on the show, say they hated it, bu barely explain why or what they like.

Not liking the show is fine, but smearing your opinion that no one asked without at least giving some proper ground it just kinda useless for a discussion.

13

u/Arabik_ 20h ago edited 15h ago

Whenever you dislike something that is widely regarded by major critics as excellent, you should expect your opinion to be questioned and be prepared to back it up with solid arguments. I think Evangelion is fucking brilliant, but I find Fullmetal Alchemist disappointing. I know I'll get criticized for the latter, and I'm perfectly fine with that. I'll take the criticism and try to defend my position.

Even among manga artists, the vast majority consider it an exceptional work. So yes, your opinion is bound to raise eyebrows. Own it.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Unconfidence https://myanimelist.net/profile/AhoMahouShoujo 20h ago

all of who cant manage the wisdom to be able to respect it for what it tried to achieve and the undeniable impact it had on popular culture, even if they dont like it.

I mean, this also holds true for Birth of a Nation. This is no different than saying "it's popular, haters can't deny".

→ More replies (6)

105

u/Due_Enthusiasm1145 21h ago edited 21h ago

I think a lot of people that scoff at the impact Evangelion had on people, often don't know the context around the series, especially if they're comparing it to anime that came out AFTER Evangelion, when Evangelion influenced so much of the industry.

This is SUPER nerdy, but its kinda like how people call Macbeth lame in school, missing the context for why its so revolutionary. Macbeth wasn't actually a wholly original play by Shakespeare. It was common practice back then to take existing plays and give your spin on it, similar to subgenres nowadays, like Mecha within scifi. What made Macbeth so good, is that it took this existing revenge wish fulfillment story, and turned it into a psychological thriller and character study. Audiences were blown away by this, and it influenced SO MANY writers after it, but that influence means that people look back at it now and call it unoriginal, missing its originally revolutionary status.

Evangelion exists in the mecha genre as something similar. It was a work within a genre that dealt with bigger themes like war and oppression, or sometimes just simple wish fulfillment and power/revenge fantasies, and turned into a tragedy, a psychological thriller and a character study, using the tools of the genre as allegories and metaphors for the character.

What's even more impressive is he didn't even set out to do that. The week to week nature separates it from something like Macbeth, which was intended on being subversive, and instead gives Evangelion a unique aura as a piece of media that started earnest and slowly turned into a deconstruction of its genre. That real life shift adds a sense of realness to the work, that while yes may make it feel choppy compared to later pieces that set out with the intent, also loses that real life discovery of the dark underbelly of the story.

Evangelion, like many pieces of art considered amazing, is also harmed by its success, influence and age, because now other stories have gone on to do the same thing, but have the ability to refine it further. That should be factored in when speaking of the quality of Evangelion.

37

u/XF10 21h ago

Hell just like at how many "clones" it directly spawned in early 2000 among mechas:Rahxephon,Fafner In The Azure,Eureka Seven,Mazinger Zero,Linebarrels of Iron etc.

12

u/VF-Atomos 18h ago

Rahxephon took much inspirations in Brave Radeen and other sources, rather than purely Evangelion.

I loved how people praised Evangelion but they never mentioned prior works that influenced Evangelion insanely hard. Like you can look into Gainax's past interviews and they mentioned Space Runaway Ideon/Gundam 0079/Mazinger/Devilman. Hideaki Anno also worked and took parts in some of those works before.

And the biggest elephant in the room on topic of Tokusatsu & Kaiju stuffs. The guy was loving those shows so much in his childhood that he put so many homage in Evangelion. He even got his dream of directing live films on Shin Ultraman (2022) and Shin Godzilla (2016) because everyone in that film industry already knew his interest and thought he could deliver a good job and he did.

7

u/XF10 17h ago

Yeah i mentioned Rahxephon being tied to Raideen in another comment. It's also done by Izubuchi who did Patlabor and mecha design for Gundam CCA(or kaijin design in Kamen Rider OOO)

Also i constantly mention Anno and Tomino in relation to Evangelion's history. All of mecha ties back to Gundam or Mazinger

18

u/Adept_Advertising_98 21h ago

Eureka 7 isn’t really an Evangelion clone, it’s a clone of Gundam X(which reimagined concepts from Xabungle), but with a few elements of Evangelion(sentient biological frames for mecha), as well as character designs and archetypes from Gundam 0079(the kids are Katz, Kika, and Letz, and there was an expanded version of the Ramba Ral arc) and Galaxy Drifter Vifam(Eureka’s design is Katue Pearson)

12

u/XF10 20h ago

Yes it is derived from Gundam X(as Bones were Sunrise alumni) but creator was heavily influenced by Evangelion more than just bio-frames; we have Eureka being a Rei-clone and Summer of Love being analogue of Second Impact or also Acperience episode being like the contact with Angels. He also wanted a more bittersweet ending but fans and rest of the staff pushed for happy ending

Anyway he helped work on Rebuild and then made its own equivalent of it with Hi-Evolution. Also forgot to mention Macross(made by Kawamori who is mecha designer of E7) elements like Beams being ace couple with red and blue mecha, Itano Circus or reference to episode 1 when Hikaru saved Minmay by catching her in the cockpit of his mecha

It's how Rahxephon is heavily influenced by Eva but also a spiritual remake of Raideen at its core

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Status_Detective5043 19h ago

I'd argue there's also a lot of Double Zeta in there, especially with how they basically keep Renton in a kids' show on purpose for like a full cour to hide him away from the full truth until it can't be ignored anymore

3

u/Due_Enthusiasm1145 21h ago

I think that's a fair distinction from calling it a "clone", but still highlights just how influential Evangelion was, that its hard to find a mecha after Evangelion that wasn't influenced by Evangelion.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 14h ago

RahXephon was created by veterans formerly from Sunrise who made the mecha shows that inspired Eva in the first place. It’s big influences were not Eva but rather the mecha anime Brave Raideen and the short story The Dandelion Girl.

E7 was again, created by veteran animators who had worked for Sunrise as well. Gundam was a far bigger influence than Eva.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/redwingz11 18h ago

isnt Gundam already dealt with it, but its eva that get the praise usually. bigger mech nerd can talk more about this (especially Tomin's other work), but sadly mecha outside the big name is rarely talked about.

3

u/FauxGw2 4h ago

While yes to a point, not to the levels of Evangelion. Gundam was more about war and the hardships with that while Evan was depression of human life, depression, insecurities, abuse. One is anti war and the other is depression showcase.

Both can have overlap but there is a clear distinction.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Command0Dude 16h ago

Evangelion exists in the mecha genre as something similar. It was a work within a genre that dealt with bigger themes like war and oppression, or sometimes just simple wish fulfillment and power/revenge fantasies, and turned into a tragedy, a psychological thriller and a character study, using the tools of the genre as allegories and metaphors for the character.

Gundam had already been doing that for over a decade by that point.

I don't think Evangelion is as foundational as people make it out to be.

3

u/Due_Enthusiasm1145 1h ago

Hear me out.

I do agree Gundam's role of creating Real Mecha, did bring about darker tones. However, I think people's inability to acknowledge this makes people miss the difference.

Gundam uses its darker tone predominantly as war allegory, which is great. I fucking love Gundam. Its tragic that Gundam gets overlooked, because it is amazing at war allegory by using the mechs as stand ins for military power. This popularized mecha as a political thriller genre, which really elevated the genre.

However. I would argue that is distinct from the two things Evangelion did;

  • Evangelion is a character study and psychological thriller, instead of a war allegory and political thriller. That is not to say Gundam didn't focus on characters or psychology, it always did. But they weren't predominantly character studies, as the greater political plot stays the focus, with the characters then being affected by that. A character study prioritizes the psychological development, whether progressive or regressive, over plot development.
  • Evangelion is a genre deconstruction. Essentially, Eva doesn't view mecha as allegory. It is not a commentary on war. It is a commentary on mecha. That subtle distinction reverberates throughout Eva, giving it a unique feel compared to Gundam.

There's also the cosmic horror aspect, but themes of that have been touched on in mecha before. I do however think Eva did it the best.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/eetsumkaus https://myanimelist.net/profile/kausdc 17h ago

Evangelion, like many pieces of art considered amazing, is also harmed by its success, influence and age, because now other stories have gone on to do the same thing, but have the ability to refine it further. That should be factored in when speaking of the quality of Evangelion.

Evangelion hasn't had the same Seinfeld effect that has plagued many works of its standing though. Fans new and old keep revisiting the story and the original series enjoys much popularity to this day. IMO Evangelion endures because, while its influence can be seen in anime to this day, no one has ever actually replicated it. Not even Anno himself.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 14h ago

Evangelion exists in the mecha genre as something similar. It was a work within a genre that dealt with bigger themes like war and oppression, or sometimes just simple wish fulfillment and power/revenge fantasies, and turned into a tragedy, a psychological thriller and a character study, using the tools of the genre as allegories and metaphors for the character.

I would argue Tomino was doing this stuff twenty years before Eva. Eva wasn’t unique by a long shot on this.

3

u/Ashteron 21h ago

Evangelion, like many pieces of art considered amazing, is also harmed by its success and influence, because now other stories have gone on to do the same thing, but have the ability to refine it further.

And none of them were able to surpass it.

8

u/Due_Enthusiasm1145 21h ago

Idk if I agree with that. I love Evangelion, but it does have flaws, particularly in its pacing and budgetary issues (if we're talking anime). I think all of its flaws add charm and shouldn't be held against it due to being so experimental and revolutionary, but if I'm looking for a cohesive experience in a mecha, I think there are other pieces that do a better job.

Code Geass is a great example of a mecha being clearly inspired by Evangelion, while also keeping those political roots to the mecha genre. I think that's something that shouldn't be counted against Evangelion, since it had to find its way through the dark, but I do think Code Geass took a lot of those themes and did refine them into a more standard mecha.

That doesn't necessarily make it better. But I also wouldn't feel comfortable saying its worse. They offer different things (psychological cosmic horror vs psychological political thriller) and I really love both of them.

7

u/eetsumkaus https://myanimelist.net/profile/kausdc 17h ago

I'd say CG is more directly influenced by the mecha genre like Gundam. Eva is actually an animated tokusatsu at its roots (this is obvious if you look at the concept art for it), while borrowing aesthetics from mecha at times. Much of its commentary on society and human nature borrows from Ultraman.

7

u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 14h ago

There’s hardly anything Eva inspired in CG. The Gundam influence is far more apparent. CG is at its core a redo of Gundam where Char is the main character.

5

u/Ashteron 20h ago

CG is great, but it felt really narratively messy at times. It's not exactly fresh in my mind, therefore I can't exactly elaborate besides mentioning that scene.

3

u/Due_Enthusiasm1145 20h ago

I think its worth a rewatch!

Its funny that I used a Shakespeare parralel in my comment because I think rewatching Code Geass as an adult made me really appreciate how Shakespearean a lot of it is, with Leloush being treated like a tragic protagonist with a hamartia and classical rise and fall, followed by redemption. Even outside of that, the plot is a really well done political thriller within the context of a "high-school anime mecha" that then eventually transcends its premise and just becomes a truly great mecha.

All this praise only applies to the original source material, none of the additional supplemental content created afterwards to capitalize on its popularity.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

108

u/Jusenkyo_5 22h ago

Bro knows ball

13

u/HanaMizukiy 21h ago

I think artists sometimes forget they don't have to surpass the greatest works ever made. Creating something that genuinely connects with even a handful of people is already worth something.

2

u/Ayiekie 18h ago

Some people have higher ambitions than that. That's okay. Some great things have come from people who wouldn't accept anything less than being the best at what they do.

23

u/ashleyriot31 22h ago

my goat

34

u/actuallyrndthoughts :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NaNiNuNeNo 20h ago

The worst thing about threads like these, is most people have their posting history hidden, so i can't go throught it to judge their so superior tastes. Like, i'm sure your battle shounen diet has nothing to do with "hating" eva. trust

8

u/eetsumkaus https://myanimelist.net/profile/kausdc 17h ago

hating eva cuts across fandoms though. It's just so popular and aesthetically unique that, just like everyone can find something to like about it, everyone can find something to hate about it too.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/Nijindia18 https://myanimelist.net/profile/IndianNinja1 19h ago

Man really said "peak" and stopped looking for another mountain 😔

44

u/Kabraxal 21h ago

No matter how you feel about NGE, that is an extreme overreaction.  There could be nothing so great in any medium that would cause me to feel despair and drop out of that participating in that industry.  

Shit work conditions and bad execs?  Sure, but “this thing was so great that it’s only downhill and not worth the effort!” is a rather pathetic attitude.  Maybe you never measure up or find its equal.  Doesn’t mean you should fucking stop trying.  

13

u/pnogg 19h ago

This is somewhat common, particularly in entertainment, music and sports.

Guys who played against Durant, LeBron or other future NBA players on highschool who just get demolished. Realizing that theyre good, college scholarship good, but not at the level thats needed to make it as a pro athlete. Musicians that realize that they dont have what it takes to make a living off their music or performing.

Murakami figured that he wasn't at that level and made a pivot when arriving at that setback. Nothing pathetic about it.

23

u/whinge11 20h ago

Meh. He went on to become an extremely successful visual artist, so who's to say he made the wrong choice?

48

u/Prince_of_DeaTh https://anilist.co/user/yokz 19h ago

"Doesn't mean you should fucking stop trying" is such a bizarrely literal, Reddit-brained way to read this.

He didn't curl up in a ball and quit art; he laughed about realizing his peers had already said what he wanted to say in anime, pivoted to contemporary art instead, and became Takashi Murakami. Knowing when to redirect your energy into a different medium where you can actually add something new isn't a pathetic attitude.

37

u/Jusenkyo_5 21h ago

I kind of get it.

I was REALLY into media analysis when I was younger, wrote a lot of reviews, talked to thousands of people about my takes on different shows, movies, series, etc, and honestly I thought (and still think) that I was good at it!

There were times that I read what other people put out and realized that I would likely never be able to reach their level. There are people who are naturally suited to certain things or have so much more time and resources to burn to get to where they want to be that it's difficult to imagine ever being able to do the same. I don't think he should have quit but not every person in the industry could be Hayao Miyazaki, and for some people it's not enough to be the 125th best director out there.

3

u/minty-moose 17h ago

i think my favourite depiction of this is shaq and kobe. One had overwhelming talent and the other put in a lot of work. In the end they both won I think

5

u/M4DM1ND 16h ago

I'm a writer and there have been times that I've read something so profound that it made me feel like I should just give up because I could never top that. Maybe it was a similar feeling for him.

2

u/Kabraxal 16h ago

I have never felt that personally.  Maybe I am capable of removing my inherent subjective lens and seeing that I will never hold my own work as high as my favourites.  I see all the little quibbles and “ah I shoulda done that!” instead of simply going along for the ride like I can do with others works.

I only take it as a challenge to keep trying.  Never know who will experience it and believe your work to be transcendent.  I may never feel that way about my own stuff, but that is art.  Each piece will hit a person differently.

4

u/eetsumkaus https://myanimelist.net/profile/kausdc 17h ago edited 17h ago

“I saw the proposal for Evangelion and felt despair. I realized there was nothing left for me to do. It was so overwhelmingly good that I just held my head in my hands.” Murakami went on to explain, “I felt that this was the culmination of everything the first generation of otaku had cultivated. It was so brilliant that I felt despair rather than awe.” Murakami confessed through laughter that Evangelion ultimately caused him to abandon his ambitions in the anime industry.

I mean, that sounds like there's quite a bit of tongue in cheek there. It's clearly hyperbole. Most likely it made him realize that his talents would be better off elsewhere.

3

u/adamroadmusic 18h ago

Happened to Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys as well. The Beatles made Rubber Soul, the Beach Boys made Pet Sounds, then the Beatles made Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.

Brian Wilson had a nervous breakdown, felt like he could never make something better than Sgt Pepper, and his work-in-progress Smile was shelved. Wilson stepped back from the Beach Boys, withdrew from public life & became reclusive for many years. His project Smile was finally released 40 years later.

3

u/0Bento 10h ago

Didn't he stay in bed for years?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Objective_Unit_7345 21h ago

Mental health issues were not handled very well in Japan.
Not much better now either.

Great for us, in that relatable content is inspired.
Terrible for the people aspiring or currently creating the content.

4

u/Constant-Pain1878 21h ago

It's inferiority syndrome

1

u/visionaryredditor 5h ago

Is realizing that you can say nothing and moving on to find your niche a pathetic thing? Murakami is one of the most famous modern visual artists who likely makes more money per art piece than the animators for a whole season of anime.

He realized his limits and moved on, that's a good thing (and given the movie he released later, it does feel like narrative storytelling isn't his strong suit). You know the funniest thing? His work ended up influencing anime (for example, virtual space in Summer Wars seems particularly influenced by Murakami's Superflat style).

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Alukrad 19h ago

Growing up I kept having people telling me that I need to watch this, so every time I attempted to watch it I just couldn't enjoy it... The main character cried too much and it annoyed me so much that I kept dropping it.

Then one day I sat through it, powered through the whole thing and it made me realize this anime is absolutely not for me. I hated all the characters, the story made absolutely no sense to me as the show kept going, and that ending left me more confused than anything. Then I jumped on the remake version, which made no sense to me either and the ending was completely different too.

I really don't understand this anime. I tried to watch a breakdown on YouTube and that left me more confused because now we're getting into alternate dimensions or something. I really don't understand what people see in this anime and I really, really tried to like it.

21

u/6Hikari6 17h ago

You can keep it simple. Its the story about severely depressed kid finding something to live for. Everything else is a fluff

3

u/thrasymacus2000 15h ago

that 'fluff' is more than a little bit distracting if it's not servicing the story.

13

u/ThatsRightSirFLOSS 17h ago

It’s a story about the human condition and how we try (and sometimes succeed, sometimes fail) to connect with each other.

The giant robots and the angels and SEELE and instrumentality, etc. are all just narrative flair on top of that. You can like it or hate it. But it’s not the heart of the story.

10

u/Kitz00n23 13h ago

Neon Genesis Evangelion is a show about facing your problems like an adult instead of trying to run away from them with fantasy. It was an extremely experimental show for it's time and one of the very few anime that actively points out a lot of problems with Japanese entertainment through it's characters, such as the use of wish fullfilment to prey on lonely men. Shinji is the ultimate reflection of this, while his feelings are completely understandable, he's still very unlikeable on purpouse and the show actively aknowledges he's a pathetic incel that should touch grass.

The actual plot is mostly flavor (almost everything in Eva is a common Mecha or Shounen trope with some David Lynch and Lovecraft influence on top) and metaphors. (Again, the angels being a metaphor for the troubles of adult life)

The alternate universes are mostly spinoffs and alternate takes by other authors. Only the original series, End of Evangelion and the Rebuilds are canon. And Hideaki Anno made the rebuilds because he wasn't satisfied with the original series and felt like it didn't reflect his views on life anymore after getting married.

5

u/eetsumkaus https://myanimelist.net/profile/kausdc 17h ago

I hated all the characters, the story made absolutely no sense to me as the show kept going, and that ending left me more confused than anything.

yeah so, I would actually say that's the point, so if you're not into that then it's not for you. It poses a lot of questions that it doesn't answer.

5

u/facubkc 17h ago

The author was very depressed when made the original and then he got better and did the remake with a more optimistic pov of life.

4

u/09philj 8h ago

The tone is completely all over the place and the plot is frequently quite obscure.

The main thing to really get your head round is that obviously all the children are kind of naturally unlikeable. Shinji is insular and depressive, Asuka is arrogant and pushy, Rei is cold and aloof. However, it's also clear that what is being done to them is horrible. They are being exploited as part of multiple conspiracies which are beyond their understanding. Nobody is going to give them the help they actually need because every interaction is filtered through the adults need to, in some way, get something out of them. Not that any of the adults could help them, because they are themselves deeply screwed up and neurotic and focused on their own concerns. This whole mess of lack of care and lack of connection is then ultimately externalised into an apocalyptic scenario. Nobody loves each other properly and so the world dies.

3

u/Hot_Preparation5330 15h ago

Honestly, sometimes the more people hype up a show, the harder it is to enjoy it without expecting too much. You gave it a fair shot, and not every popular anime is going to click with everyone.

3

u/FourRaccoonsInASuit 4h ago

I'm in the same boat. Watched the anime and was confused why it was considered so amazing, so I looked at explanations to see if I was missing something and didn't really feel they helped much. Just kind of felt like it was people overexplaining symbolism, while having different ideas on what that symbolism was. If you have a bunch of people explaining the same thing but they're all having different takeaways, it just feels like the message wasn't that clear in the first place so people are grasping at straws to validate their opinions that it's good. That being said I haven't watched the remake and it has sort of been on my "to watch" list and I've just put it off worried that I would feel the same way about it.

The characters are flawed and unlikeable, but that's not something that will make me dislike an anime, especially when that's probably the point. I enjoyed Future Diary despite the main character being whiny and pathetic. I also feel I can appreciate what an anime is even if it's not entirely for me. I enjoyed Frieren and understood it's beloved by so many people because it makes you reflect on your choices in life and confront your regrets. I didn't really need that when I watched it so I didn't get as much from it as a lot of other people, but I respect what it did.

So my takeaway has been that I think it was a mecha anime that came out in a time where mecha anime was huge, but it was extremely different and turned the genre on its head. That made it amazing to mecha fans, which gave it a strong cult following that raved about it any chance they got, which brings in more people over time that feel the same way. Honestly I think that if I was into mecha anime I might feel differently, but since it's a genre I never watch it was just an anime about a kid who was very depressed and messed up being bullied by people who were also messed up in different ways.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/0Bento 10h ago

If you don't like it, it means you're mentally healthy, so ultimately it's a good thing for you.

5

u/Le_Meme_Man12 7h ago

That's a really stupid take people have been regurgitating for years.

6

u/0Bento 5h ago

I disagree.

Eva speaks to people on a much deeper level beyond the sci-fi action surface. That's the real appeal, and those who don't relate to the characters and the overall vibe just see "whiny teenagers and messy plot."

It's like a rorschach test.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/rolim91 9h ago

Nah anime is a medium not a genre. This is is highly specific though post-apocalyptic, mecha kaiju, philosophical scifi anime.

Not everyone will like that.

2

u/TeeeldiII 5h ago

Its about depression and self-hatred, all the sci-fi and religious stuff is window dressing

3

u/Command0Dude 16h ago

100% relate to this. To be honest, I think the strength of Evangelion is that people can project their own opinions onto it very easily, because so much of the show is meaningless.

3

u/Impossible_Cover_978 16h ago

I pushed through it years ago and I have to say it was absolutely the worst media i've ever watched. They'll tell you it gets better but no, it won't

The fact that so many people insist its the holy grail of anime kept me away from the genre for a long time (not anymore though, i've found enough gems that are actually worth it)

→ More replies (4)

2

u/asspastass 17h ago

It's the poster anime of "I'm 14, and this is deep"

2

u/Ok-Wheel-4136 18h ago

That’s me but with Attack on Titan. Different people just have different tastes. I absolutely love Evangelion though.

2

u/zackphoenix123 16h ago

Pretty much me, I love Eva and didn't gel with AOT. My brother was bawling to AOT though, we were watching the same time.

1

u/Murasasme 17h ago

I'm 100% with you, and I don't think we are really wrong. That show is so convoluted, they've tried like 4 different endings because they just keep throwing shit at the wall to see what sticks.

To me it genuinely feels like people have to say this show is a masterpiece, but rarely can someone actually articulate what is so good about it.

11

u/Standing_on_rocks 16h ago

It's good because of an intensely human story about finding a reason to live.

The endings are basically just metaphors.

2

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] 7h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Majestic_Print4300 5h ago

100% with you on this.

1

u/FauxGw2 4h ago

It's about depression, abuse, and choice with religious aspects as the main driving force. Adam/Eve story that starts with Eden destruction (the Big Mechas and the first impact) as aliens going all the way to the rapture (3rd impact) with humanity choosing to pick earth or heaven which Shinji and Rei basically being the final catalyst for it. It has the spear that stabbed Jesus as another part of it. It's using the Bible start and end to showcase trauma at many levels.

The angels making Kaworu to use Shinji's abuse and neglect to be the perfect friend to try to start to impact was honestly a genius episode and is imo one of the best in anime.

1

u/KMFCM :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kmfcm 3h ago

thing is, that's how a real life teenage boy would probably react to that situation.

other than that, is understandable how that show can be an acquired taste.

1

u/CrablordNito 28m ago

It’s just vibes bro, sorry you didn’t get it. But if you really tried to like it and failed, you probably just don’t like sci-fi or 90’s animation because at a bare minimum both of those aspects of the show are phenomenal.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/CVfxReddit 15h ago

This is one of those shows I appreciate but don't actually like. But it is an interesting portrait of a guy with a lot of issues working them out on screen.
Of course it's also full of a lot of scantily clad super thin underage women which has led to the greatest merch potential in all of fiction, which says some pretty bleak things about the human race.

0

u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 14h ago

A huge part of Eva’s popularity is people lusting over Rei and Asuka. The biggest reason for its popularity was not it being a genius work. It was people obsessing over Rei. She was the most popular character in anime.

8

u/CVfxReddit 14h ago edited 14h ago

Eh, she had to be written in a way that creates that emotional attachment. Like a design isn’t enough, the connection to the character is, and then people want to see that character in various states….

All the characters are well written and it is a very honest work, but what Anno is getting at says some disturbing things about humanity 

That’s not unusual for great artists to do though. Nabokov, John Irving, David Lynch, etc. They touch on extremely sensitive subject matter 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Big-Fun9872 20h ago

クソみたいに落ち込んでる鬱病の時に見たからめちゃくちゃ良かったわ、最後のシーンは生きる力くれたよ
逆に映画は特にシンエヴァ4作はいらない、てか映画全部いらない

2

u/Slim_Charles :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SocksJunior 14h ago

旧劇もですか?

2

u/Big-Fun9872 4h ago

旧劇も良いと思わないね、面白い事やろうとしてたのは分かるけどさ
TVシリーズで完成されていたと思うよ

2

u/Low_Understanding326 16h ago

Watched it. Didn't enjoy it as much as I hoped. People said to watch the movie remakes then. Maybe one day I will.

2

u/karatemnn 15h ago

i get how the show can be confusing especially the finale, but i think people
simply saying the show is surface level don't even pay attention to the dynamics of a teenage kid going through all that shit, like the horrible actions of everyone involved in the show to the lead kid is incredibly engaging ... but people think it's just an edgy giant robot show

12

u/AscendedViking7 22h ago

Arguably the greatest anime of all time

2

u/BambooGentleman :IG: 7h ago

If someone said Evangelion is the second best anime of all time, I don't think anyone would have the face to claim first place.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

3

u/Wutanghang 20h ago

Ive never watched evangelion its too late

3

u/KernelWizard https://myanimelist.net/profile/DangoDaikazoku 11h ago edited 11h ago

Well the only thing I understand from Neon Genesis Evangelion was: Boy depressed, boy fight in giant mecha, boy wank on female friend, everyone turns to Fanta, the end lmao. I totally enjoyed it the whole way through.

8

u/gho5trun3r 21h ago

Feels like anytime someone criticizes this anime, they get met with a Rick and Morty fan logic of "you just aren't smart enough to understand. Only intellectuals can get it."

I didn't like this show. I thought the left turns were random and unearned. The trauma wasn't built up convincingly enough in the show to showcase the surreal parts that came later. And the surreal parts took over the main plot and by the end of the show, I felt like we hadn't resolved the main storyline. I feel like the show is kind of a mess and all over the place. It's also one of the weirdest shows to watch when a roommate walks by.

If people like the mess, that's fine. But calling this the best of anime is some crazy claim. The show is divisive for a reason and it's not because people just "don't get it." It's because some people "just don't like it."

42

u/Jusenkyo_5 21h ago

But calling this the best of anime is some crazy claim.

Are you not doing the exact same thing that you're bitching about from the opposite perspective?

4

u/ina_waka 20h ago

The lack of self reflection is insane lmfaooo. I was with him on his general sentiment until that last sentence.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/N7CombatWombat 21h ago

And the surreal parts took over the main plot and by the end of the show

The surreal parts were always the main plot.

11

u/PsychoSushi27 21h ago

I didn’t like Evangelion when I first watched it as a teenager. I thought Shinji was really annoying and I did not finish the anime.

I rewatched it again later in my 20s after going through some life problems and it was emotionally cathartic for me. I related so hard to Shinji’s character and I also dislike him so much because it was like looking at myself during the worst time of my life. Evangelion really captured my emotional state at my lowest even if the story did turn into a mess. It made me feel less alone knowing someone else understood what I went through.

I understand why some people don’t get it. But for a lot of people Evangelion evokes a huge emotional response which is what art is meant to do. I still think it deserves the title of the best anime of all time due to its influence on modern anime and the emotional response to it even if this opinion is subjective.

20

u/XF10 21h ago

Who tf thinks Evangelion is "divisive"? It's widely considered a masterpiece lol

I'm sorry; you not liking an anime is fine but seems like you are just butthurt and want to justify your opinion by claiming such a media-defining work is actually trash and everyone else just isn't smart as you

psychological part took over the show and we hadn't resolved the main storyline

Please tell me you didn't stop at episode 26 and watched End of Evangelion(the actual finale) too

4

u/DaBurberrySkirt 6h ago

I’ve lived back and forth in Japan for decades now. There is no anime, manga, movie, tv show, or anything other medium that has impacted the country more than Neon Genesis Evangelion.

Even today, if you walk into a 7-11 it is NGE that is stamped all over random merch from lighters to sandwich bags. Nothing comes close.

3

u/XF10 6h ago

Yeah it's a pretty well-known anecdote that you can live your whole life using only Eva merch

3

u/surrealist_poetry 20h ago

Yeah, there were scenes that felt lackluster, like they didn't fit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

3

u/megamilker101 18h ago

Reading this comment and seeing it get downvoted to the point it’s floating around zero karma makes me think the ongoing argument is a matter of timing. I watched Eva at age 14-15 in 2010-2011, the friend who introduced me to it told me it was divisive and everyone I spoked to about it hated it or found it interesting but it wasn’t a “masterpiece” in their eyes like it now seems to be unanimously considered by a younger generation.

3

u/MembershipNo2077 15h ago

I watched it in the 90's and lemme tell you the IRC chat at that time found it to generally be amazing. Most of the divisive chat was around what themes it portrayed and whether it was criticizing the genre or otaku themselves. Also the eternal asuka vs. rei, but that's a separate discussion.

Few otaku thought it was bad though there just that, a few.

Only now do I see undercurrents of pure hate for it from people who never have watched another mecha in their lives.

8

u/Ayiekie 18h ago

It really doesn't matter. It's not my favourite anime by any means either, and is my least favourite of the big three surrealist defining 90s anime, but Evangelion has always been an epochal work that influenced an enormous amount of everything that followed it.

For christ's sake, you could at one point take university courses about Evangelion and its media impact. In California.

Personal tastes are personal tastes. It's fine to say "I think Shakespeare is overrated", but to pretend like he isn't one of the most important, influential and studied authors in human history would be absurd. He is. And Eva is one of the most important, influential and studied anime that ever existed. You cannot even understand modern anime fully without understanding Eva and its place in defining so much of modern anime. That's just what it is. Clearly it was something special, regardless of its appeal to any given person.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/UltiMikee 20h ago

I think a lot of people misunderstand this show and that’s fine, but I think by a lot of metrics it deserves at the very least, a top 10 spot without question.

I started to write a list of reasons why it deserves its flowers, but it’s just too long to write out in a reddit comment. If ya don’t get it ya don’t get it. But it’s your favorite anime director’s favorite anime. It’s your favorite western director’s favorite anime. It’s easily one of the most influential pieces of media ever created and in many ways catapulted the industry into what it is today.

1

u/0Bento 10h ago

In Japan it's basically as big as Star Wars.

You may not have seen it, you may not like it, but you still recognise the characters, the music, and have a rough idea of the themes.

0

u/SocialHumbuggery 21h ago

Hey mate, I think you just aren't smart enough to understand it.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/NTolegna 21h ago

Most overrated anime

1

u/N7CombatWombat 21h ago

You should try an Intro to Film class at your local community college, it can help you find out why people rate something like Eva so high and consider it a classic.

7

u/Kirbysonicboom 18h ago

Or maybe they just don't fucking like it. Fuck off with the Rick and Morty "you just don't understand it" shit

15

u/6Hikari6 17h ago

Saying something is overrated because you didnt like it is quite pretentious I'd say

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/MacroMicro1313 12h ago

Spirited Away was better

2

u/bulovalunar 12h ago

The only reason I like it is because I love the angel designs, the theological/sci Fi aspects and concepts like the death of ego, instrumentality, SEELE etc. Couldn't care less about Shinji and the underage waifu bait. I know it doesn't make me a proper fan but I don't really care.

1

u/zz2000 10h ago

The only reason I like it is because I love the angel designs, the theological/sci Fi aspects and concepts

Not to mention the iconic "next episode preview" music.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Command0Dude 16h ago edited 15h ago

I cannot understand how people rave about this anime so much. To me, the writing is just entirely up its own ass. No matter how much people try to explain it, I just don't get it. So much of Evangelion feels superficial and shallow. I'm reminded the first time I read an article that talked about how much of the artistic iconography had no deeper meaning behind it other than it "looked cool" to Anno.

People have been bending over backwards to make this anime into a deeper story than it actually is for over 30 years now. Ironically, people didn't even 'get' the anime when it first came out. Anno released an entire redone ending that was intended to mock his own fans because of it.

I've seen so many other, better anime do the things that people purport Evangelion to be so amazing for. Welcome to the NHK is way better as a character study of otaku, there are so many Gundam shows that do "war sucks" better, Psycho Pass is a better psychological thriller, Vinland Saga is a better tragedy, and there are over a hundred anime characters that are way more interesting than Evangelion's entire cast.

2

u/Gippy_ https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gippy 11h ago

Same reason why people latched on to Revolutionary Girl Utena and Serial Experiments Lain. They came "first" and were abstract and avant-garde enough to be a completely different experience than what people were used to.

However, that doesn't mean that they were actually good. I have and always will detest avant-garde anime that try to act intelligent. In a few months, when the newest Madoka Magica movie is released worldwide, you'll see people gush over its abstract presentation, even though I thought it was garbage.

2

u/mukansamonkey 7h ago

Lain isn't abstract though? It's an entirely literal retelling of one of the most well known myths on the planet. Just translated into the present day. It's got some scifi wankery here and there, but there's almost no abstract anything.

Although it does seem to confuse the hell out of a lot of people. Which is problematic.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/visionaryredditor 5h ago

Welcome To The NHK isn't really about otaku, it's more about hikikomori/NEETs. There is an overlap but it is smaller than most people think (at least, because you need money to keep your otaku hobby going and many aspects of otakudom require socialization). Sato isn't an otaku. Kaoru is an otaku but 1) he is more collected; 2) he is a secondary character to Sato

1

u/TostVolante 4h ago

the “deeper story” you’re talking about, which i suppose is the meaning behind the metaphor of the AT-field and the human instrumentality project, is something Anno speaks about in interviews. He explains that the anime is about loneliness, solipsism, relationship issues and is ultimately a message to those people that prefer to isolate themselves instead of interacting with other human beings. Everything is there and the director explained it so you’re just plainly ignorant about it and act like everyone around you is dumb while you really see through all of it. You’re just missing out on a beautiful message and thag’s a shame, it’s ok if you don’t understand it and if it doesn’t speak to you, but that doesn’t mean that it was all an invention of nerds

→ More replies (3)

1

u/banishedwolf 20h ago

That's very interesting. I've never thought much about the impact of Eva from the perspective of someone like that.

1

u/Dizzy-By-Degrees 19h ago

Reminds me of the anecdote of how one of Picasso’s peers was so stunned by his art he decided there was no place in the world for him because he’d never compete. Young artists are competitive as they are melodramatic.

But at least he is still in the game and willing to put something out there. Never give up.

1

u/ligital 15h ago

It is very polarising, but that’s why it’s so memorable. I have already watched it thrice, and I know I will likely watch it a 4th time some day.

1

u/catinterpreter 15h ago

This is a paid promo post.

1

u/Electrical-Lack-8865 13h ago

Why is Jett not in here?

1

u/AzeiteGalo https://myanimelist.net/profile/StrawHatList 10h ago

Yes its edgy and perhaps overly depressing but I think it was groundbreaking and refreshing in the world of anime. Very few anime shows or movies dare to be that experimental and take so many risks. You hate the MC because you watch this as a kid and you are used to the Mc being the cool guy, always ready to save the day, the hero. But NGE and this finale shows what a real human kid would go through if landed in a reality like this one. Of course there are some flaws, mainly the unnecessary fanservice, but I think they needed something to keep the audiences until the end as this was not your typical show.

1

u/Jippi_kotobagari 8h ago

One thing I find interesting about Evangelion is its use of colors.

Rei is blue, Asuka is red, and Eva-01 is purple — the color you get when you mix blue and red. Blue and red are also the colors commonly used to represent veins and arteries.

Shinji's black-and-white school uniform also reminds me of piano keys.

I don't know how much of this was intentional, but Evangelion is really interesting to watch when you pay attention to the colors.

1

u/headphonesXX 7h ago

this dude never worked as an animator so why the fuck he speaking on anything? dude has a team of assistance he pays to make art for him. he physically doesnt create any art.

1

u/RollingStoned9824 5h ago

As a teenager this anime broke my brain and I loved it. I love the TV series and the ending. I so old I had to by a bootleg version of end of evangelion because it wasn't released in the States at the time. I was not a fan of the movie.

1

u/KMFCM :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kmfcm 3h ago

So, we see a bunch if conflicting opinions here.

I would like to know if the people that don't like the original series bothered watching the Rebuilds, and if so, what do they think of them.

I personally know people that love the original and disliked the Rebuilds.

1

u/ArcadiusRa 8m ago

I love the original. I watched it as it came out. I rewatch it at least once a year. I’ve never watched the Rebuilds.

1

u/Wolfrast 16m ago

I feel like this anime is more like an art house movie and what most people watch is more like Blockbuster movie versions of anime they don’t want to be challenged. They don’t want something that’s complex or artistic. They just want something. That’s fun trigger certain emotions that are familiar, like when you go to a blockbuster movie, you know what you’re getting into you have your popcorn in your soda and you have your laughs and you have your excitement and you have your sad moments at all. The music will pretty much subliminally queue, you on what to feel at certain times it’s all very rehearsed( no pun intended) but Evangelion seemed to be more like an arthouse movie, and if you like that kind of thing, it’s a great show, but the movies are better. The newer stuff I’m not a fan of, but I exceptionally enjoyed it because I don’t really want to be held at gunpoint on what to feel or think I’d rather have the space and the looseness to decide on what’s happening in my own mind instead of a very clear indication. I’ll never forget the words of the director of A Taste of Cherry, when he spoke about how movies can hold you at gunpoint, as if you were a hostage on what you should feel while watching them because of all the tools and implements that they use to create certain emotions and feelings, totally fine. His use of words is a little bit intense, but I also can see as a movie like his movie or perhaps an anime like Evangelion was striving for that sense of freedom where even the crater doesn’t know what they made.

1

u/its_Preshh 20h ago

It's in my top 3 best anime of all time alongside Attack on Titan and Legend of the Galactic Heroes.

I understand it's not for everyone and as with other critically acclaimed shows, you have the usual contrarians who claim it's bad or overrated.

Evangelion is a masterpiece. End of Evangelion is the best anime movie I've ever watched and probably the best ending I've ever seen in anime.

Not everyone will resonate with it or appreciate it and that is fine. It does not mean these people are bad at media or that the show is bad.

I only find issue with people who dedicate so much time to hating on a piece of media trying to justify themselves for not liking it. E.g "i dont like X media, so X media must be bad and everyone who likes it must be stvpid".

-1

u/gerty88 20h ago

Utter bollocks series with like 3 good moments lol. It was so monster of the week 🥱

-36

u/aDoorMarkedPirate420 22h ago

Honestly I think it’s pretty overhyped. It’s definitely good, but I don’t understand all the glaze still.

17

u/Slunto-Max 22h ago

It’s ok, good taste isn’t for everyone.

8

u/Kirbysonicboom 18h ago

This thread is the perfect example of why people hate the Eva fanbase.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)