x2 new Apple TV setup on day of release - one in Living room - one in Master bedroom. Both setup initially under my Apple account. All good. Add apps downstairs - and they appear upstairs. Great.
Add wife profile using her Apple account
Add daughter profile using her Apple account
Add niece profile using her Apple account.
So x4 ATV profiles setup up.... But am i missing something here?
1 - Profile changing / selection
Four profiles on living room TV. However - anyone can select another profile and go straight in. No PIN protection or anything? My profile is set to download apps automatically during this setup stage.... Other accounts are restricted. However in theory they could just hop on to mine and download willy nilly? As well as see my content? Which may not be child friendly.
2 - Custom icon layout per profile
Bit rubbish that each ATV profile cannot have their own icon layout - but ok can live with that - unless i am missing something?
3 - Top row of apps on main grid
So on my main grid (and therefore everyone else's profile), top row i have the core main apps:
Plex
Now TV
Disney +
Netflix
Apple TV
Except - On plex it shows me "continue watching" featuring movies / tv shows which i have started watching - which also appear like for like on the three other profiles... Including the kids. Do i really want my 9 years old to see i have been watching an 18 rated film? No?
Apple says: "Place your favourite apps on the top row of the Home Screen so that when they’re highlighted, you see a preview of what’s in the app. Swipe up to see the preview in full screen" - I don't expect everyone to see my choices? I would expect each ATV to user to see their choices.
Can i turn this off?
4 - Auto login / profile mapping
Each user, when they launch each app, has to login a second time (to each app). So load up Plex, have to sign in to Plex. Load up Netflix, have to sign in to Netflix. Load up BBC iPlayer, have to sign in to BBC iPlayer... Would it not be better to have some sort of mapping system so an Apple TV user can be mapped to appropriate profile within each steaming service?
Being a Mac user since 2004, have the whole family running on 100% Apple hardware - and had high expectations for Apple TV... but i'm disappointed in the implementation of user profiles? Unless i am missing something - but have went through all the settings multiple times...
Conclusion
I'd love user profiles on ATV to be Pin protected - to protect against viewing inappropriate material or changing settings - would love each ATV profile to be able to customise their own app layout removing icons they don't use. Would love the each ATV user sees their own "continue watching" on the top row apps, and the game changer would be once a user has logged into their ATV profile - once configured, it automatically logs into correct profile on each app (though i appreciate this needs the co-operation of those application providers). If you don't use the app, and thus don't have profile mapping, you can simply remove the icon from your ATV profile.
The ATV has potential to be a first class streaming / entertainment box for the family home - but right now i feel it is a half arsed attempt and not quite there yet - which for the price of the hardware being charged these days, is really not reflective of the functionality? As a single user device, it's bang on the money. As a shared device in family environment, i'm not quite sure.....?