r/arrow • u/ClaimCompetitive4818 • 1h ago
Entertainment is funny in its own way.
So I am almost finished with season 2 and Oliver's love life deserves its own show.
He was dating Laurel, and was an unfaithful boyfriend but he didn't just cheat on her—he got another woman, Samantha, pregnant and was never gonna tell Laurel about it. And because he was too much of a coward to tell her he wasn't ready to move in together, he decided the logical next step was to flirt with her sister.
I recall Sara telling Laurel in 2x13 that they both know at least 10 girls he slept with (jeeez)
He then secretly sneaked Sara onto the Queen’s Gambit for a trip with his father. When the boat went down, Sara died, and Oliver effectively tore the Lance family apart.
And so in the meantime, while Oliver was supposedly dead, Laurel moved on with his best friend Tommy. He was really into her and definitely fell in love with her and was ready to be committed. Oliver found out about their relationship while spending his nights as the Arrow literally stalked them from rooftops.
So Oliver convinced himself Laurel shouldn't be with him because of his "dangerous life," and that either way he did not rightfully deserve to be with her, yet he spent the whole season having this back and forth with her. Oliver in the meantime simultaneously juggled other love interests like Helena Bertinelli (The Huntress) and McKenna Hall.
At one point, he and Laurel lied to Tommy about having "secret" lunches together. Then, when Tommy broke up with her out of jealousy, after episode 1x20 (Invasion), Laurel begged Oliver to help fix her relationship with Tommy. Oliver refused, and went to talk to Tommy to urge him to fix his relationship with Laurel not only to wait twenty-four hours, totally do a 360° spin and decided that if he stopped the Undertaking, he could finally be with her.
He went to her place, slept with her claiming that she was the person that knows him the best while hiding his entire double life, and then—in a classic Oliver's move—left her in bed and rejected her again the next morning while hiding the truth about who he is.
To top it off, Oliver barely even apologized to Tommy for sleeping with the woman he had just encouraged Tommy to win back.
By Season 2, Oliver and Laurel agree they can't be together, and then Sara—the sister he supposedly watched die—shows up alive. Oliver protects Laurel from the League of Assassins and seemingly genuinely cares for Laurel as Quentin told him that she was having alcohol issues while hiding the fact that her sister was ten feet away. Oliver rejects Laurel in 2x05 again in her hallway as herself being tormented and misunderstood the wrong signals.
So basically, at one point Laurel is spiraling into a dark path and she is even working as the lawyer against Oliver’s own mother.
Once Sara officially is officially revealed herself to be alive to everyone , she and Oliver get officially together and are immediately into each other.
The peak of the drama is the Lance family dinner. Sara forces Oliver’s hand to show up (what a shitty idea) and the two of them have the absolute nerve to make heart eyes at each other across the table with Laurel sitting right next to them. (incredible acting)
When Laurel finally rightfully explodes at the sheer audacity of it all, Oliver follows her out only to say incredibly mean things and to her rejecting her once and for all.
He then left her standing in her hallway while he got back in her apartment having yummy pizzas with her family.
Laurel eventually makes up with her sister and even starts giving Oliver relationship advice about how to handle his own newly relationship Sara. He then gently takes her advice and Sara/Oliver are a thing. Oliver was eventually ready to move in with Sara but she wasn't. She was embraced by darkness and the both of them were more of a re bounce for each other given their unique shared trauma.
By the way, I really loved Sara as the Black Canary, she was stunning and Caity Lotz definitely deserved her own show. It was also great to see her bond with Nyssa and we can see their complicated feelings for each other.