r/askmusicians • • Apr 06 '26

Mod Post Revamping AskMusicians! Looking for input on rules going forward

10 Upvotes

Greetings! Allow me to introduce myself — I'm /u/Quertior, and I'm the new moderator of /r/AskMusicians as of a couple days ago. I've been a redditor for over 15 years now (wow!) and a musician for longer than that.


I'm sure you've noticed that the subreddit has been in rough shape lately, due to an influx of low-effort posts and spam posts, with effectively absent moderation. I'm looking forward to getting things back on track, but to do that, I need help! To start with, I'm looking for input on these questions:

How should we handle musical self-promotion? My inclination is to allow people to post their own music only if they include a specific question about something they're having trouble with or want to improve. (For example: "how can I improve my vocal delivery in the chorus?" would be allowed, but "how are my vocals?" would not be.) I'd hope that that approach would handle the majority of "drive-by" self-promo by people who make low-effort posts to a bunch of different subs just to link their music.

How should we handle AI-generated content? Ideally, I would like to ban AI-generated content entirely. But I'm worried that a ban would be very difficult to enforce accurately, so I am more inclined to ask that post/comment authors simply disclose AI usage instead. (Obviously, comments that are misleading or factually incorrect are not allowed, whether they're written by humans or AI.)

Should we require post titles to be questions? I've seen a lot of posts that have decent questions in the body text, but very generic titles. So I've been toying with the idea of requiring that posters state their actual question in the title. Not sure if that's too draconian, though.

I expect to add, remove, and change rules according to community feedback as time goes on, so please feel free to share any general feedback on rules for posts and comments as well.


Want flair?

If you are interested in getting flair as a musician here, send a modmail with the specialties you'd like in your flair (one genre/area of expertise, and up to two instruments). I'll be looking through comments and posts to make sure you have some history of discussing music-related topics on reddit.

Non-flaired users are still fully allowed to answer questions! Both flaired and non-flaired users will be held to the same standards of civility and knowledge.


Want to help moderate?

I'm looking to bring on one or two additional moderators. Let me know if you're interested! I'll be looking for a history of discussing music-related topics on reddit. A friendly/civil attitude is a must (I do not intend for /r/AskMusicians to end up on one of those lists of subreddits with power-tripping mods!). Previous moderation experience is helpful, but not strictly necessary.


If you've read this whole thing, thank you! I hope the subreddit can continue to grow now that it once again has active moderation.


r/askmusicians • • 57m ago

who is big gabe?

Post image
• Upvotes

and what band is he in? and how does his signature make it into every bathroom around the usa? and where did he go for a few years?

I've been seeing this tag for years, I cant contain my curiosity anymore.


r/askmusicians • • 1m ago

Como me aprendo las canciones en bateria?

• Upvotes

Ya se las cosas básicas de la bateria, quiero empezar a aprenderme canciones y no se como hacerlo ni por donde empezar. Me gustaría que alguien con mas experiencia me explicara algún método o algo que les ayudo en sus inicios como bateristas para aprenderse canciones.


r/askmusicians • • 2h ago

I’m looking for a simple mobile daw for vocals

1 Upvotes

The OS doesn’t matter I got apple and android

I really want it to be simple and straightforward i honestly love bandlab but they are running ads now so here are my criteria for a new daw:

- No endless clicking around and setting up

- vocals should be easy to record and importing beats should be possible

- it should detact the key and tempo automatically

- it should have vocal effects

That’s all. Let me know if u can reccoment anything


r/askmusicians • • 8h ago

What are red flags you wish you'd known to look for when choosing music folks to work with?

2 Upvotes

\Content warning - grooming and predatory behaviour -*

Was talking with some fellow older female musician pals the other day, here are the ones we thought of. (I know each of these on its own doesn't scream predator but in our experiences, there was usually a combo)

  • They change labels every couple of years or with new albums, over a long period of time (it's a pattern). It may mean each label realizes they’re a liability and shuffles them along.
  • Former bandmates erase them from their socials, resume, etc.
  • They’re ridiculously talented and have a cult following but never seem to catch a break while their peers do, but those peers don’t bring them along. (No opening slots, no shout-outs, etc.)
  • They push the "nice guy" image REALLY hard, like the timid shy nerd, devoted dad or feminist ally, in conversations or over their socials constantly
  • Many of their so-called female friends and former bandmates don’t follow them (the whisper network may already know)
  • They mostly work with much younger musicians or older musicians coming back after a long hiatus
  • They push to do everything for you - play all your back-up instruments on recordings, they want to produce/engineer/mix/master, they don't like your friends coming to the studio (like it "ruins the vibe")
  • They slowly start bad-mouth exes and sharing inappropriate details, like slip it into conversation more and more. I've seen this with groomers, like they are testing how much you’ll normalize.

r/askmusicians • • 5h ago

Can I get your honest opinions on this

0 Upvotes

I have been writing and recording music for 6 years now never really took it seriously in terms of putting myself out there and promoting it. Some of my favorite artists barely post on social media and have a mysterious vibe to them that I admire. However I have other goals like starting a YouTube channel vloging my life and reacting to videos. If my goal is to be a big main stream artist (I know it’s not guaranteed) how do you think it would affect the perception of me and my music as a “fan”. Genuinely curious of how you guys feel about this


r/askmusicians • • 6h ago

Can anyone who can read music tell me what the music in the last panel here is?

1 Upvotes

I saw someone complaining about this strip because it's a sound gag in a visual medium and makes no sense to anyone who can't read music, and it's been bothering me ever since because I can't read music.


r/askmusicians • • 1d ago

Gift for 12 year old - music production?

10 Upvotes

Before I get killed here, this is my first time on Reddit. I have a 12 year old singer who has been spending tons of time on BandLab lately recording and layering songs. I would like to get her something for the holidays and assume there is probably something better than the BandLab app out there. I have zero understanding of this world but would love an idea of what I could get her to further her passion for music. This is her happy place and I want to feed that energy. I apologize if this question has been asked before but I’m honestly not sure what I was asking exactly.


r/askmusicians • • 1d ago

Recording a jam with everyone’s phones: will this work?

10 Upvotes

hey, I'm an electronic musician. I want to jam with some musicians who play acoustic instruments. I’d like to record the jam.

My idea: each person puts their phone near their instrument and records, and afterwards I line up all the files in my DAW and mix them.

Do you think this setup will work? Has anyone tried it? Or would you go with an interface and a few mics?


r/askmusicians • • 1d ago

Need help finding guitar and have many questions

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi I'm trying to buy a Guitar for my boyfriend but I have no idea how to go about it but I want it to be perfect he wants one like this (picture below) I found a couple but idk what ones are good or where to get it or what to get for the Guitar so he can care for it and keep it in good shape but if anyone can help me with this please comment and I'll contact you or dm me but anything helps


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

ARTIST W/ SAME NAME. ADVICE?!

2 Upvotes

My music on Instagram keeps being credited to an artist in Australia with the same name. I’ve been in touch with my distributor, CD Baby who says they have no control over the situation. “Help” from Meta is a joke.

I’m debating on changing my artist name to avoid this from continuing to happen with future releases. Easier said than done, of course, as I would have to change information on SO many websites, redesign merch/business cards to make/order, etc. and hope someone else in a different country have the same name.

Any advice?


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

How do you find local musicians to put together a show in an unfamiliar town?

3 Upvotes

I’m an independent singer-songwriter trying to put together a show in a town about 150 miles from where I live. I’d really like to get a few local musicians involved, whether that’s finding an opener or putting together a small bill with a few different artists.
The problem is that I’m not really familiar with the local music scene, and finding musicians to reach out to has been harder than I expected.
For those of you who have booked shows outside your hometown, how do you go about finding and connecting with local artists?
Do you reach out to venues and ask for recommendations? Look through local music groups? Find artists on Instagram and contact them directly?
I’d appreciate any advice, especially from independent musicians who have been in a similar situation.


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

Thoughts on Joining AFM Local 802 Union

2 Upvotes

Hi friends, I found out recently that the local musicians union in NY initiation fee to join from now until the end of the year. Wanted to know what you guys think about that, and whether you think I should join the union now before the fee waiver is gone.

I’m currently in my senior year of college in the city, and have been doing a lot of pit orchestra gigs in summer stock and student productions throughout my time in school. I want to work up to playing in higher scale productions, but I’m wondering if I join now it might be to early for me. I’m curious if y’all think I should join the union now while the deal is still going, or should I wait until I book a gig that requires me to join.


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

About music career

0 Upvotes

Hey my name is whatever it is. I want to start a music career actually I am 21 rn and I don't think it's late i know some of the things about music like production recording sampling chopping vocals delivery and I know my voice is a little annoying please tell me if wanted what Should do in this situation


r/askmusicians • • 3d ago

I don't understand how to read all these codas.

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi! So I have recently been getting back into playing with an orchestra. Now, I know how to read a D.S. and Coda - however, this modern contemporary piece I am working on has a LOT of codas, but there is no "D.S." anywhere on the page, so I am very confused about how to read these. Any insight would be much appreciated. Thanks!


r/askmusicians • • 3d ago

Can anyone sing this song on Instagram?

0 Upvotes

I wrote a song yesterday but I'm notna singer. I'll drop the lyrics below. You can use the lyrics (Please tag me if you sing it nd upload the video so that I can listen to that I would really appreciate that). The lyrics are pretty decent written based on my dreams.

Title: Somewhere Far Away

I wanna leave without a sound,

Find a place where I'm not found.

A little road, an open sky,

A thousand places passing by.

I wanna see the world someday,

Let the wind take me away.

Sleep beneath the stars at night,

Wake up somewhere new and bright.

Far away, far away,

Somewhere I can drift away.

No more worries, no more plans,

Just the world and open lands.

Take me where the rivers flow,

To all the places I don't know.

I'll keep dreaming till I find

A little peace somewhere in time.

Maybe I'm dreaming way too much,

Of distant skies and places untouched.

But if this dream is all I know,

I'll follow wherever it goes.

One day, somehow,

I'll get there someday.

Until that day,

I'll dream of far away.

Insta handle: mishkat_shahriar (Tag me)

I don’t want any credit or anything just tag me o that I can listen to it

Thanks


r/askmusicians • • 3d ago

What is this voice effect called?

1 Upvotes

I know this is a stupid meme video but I feel like I could make something that sounds cool with that voice effect. Does anyone know how to achieve it? (Sorry if this is the wrong sub for something like this)


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

What is the funniest/strangest pencil marking in music you've ever seen?

11 Upvotes

Usually, the markings someone else wrote in a book are generally useful, like breath marks and dynamics. But sometimes, it's not and it makes no sense, like the time someone randomly wrote "EEE" in a piccolo part. What is the strangest you have seen?


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

Harmony help

1 Upvotes

Hello all. When using harmony breakdown, I can harmonise well, but I can never figure it out alone! Do you just find the chord and sing all the notes in the chord or what??


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

What am I playing here?

1 Upvotes

I made this as an assignment for university. I am the vocalist and rhythm guitarist of a prog shoegaze band but I’ve been brought up on jazz. This is the first ever “beat” I’ve made but I was surprised at how good the sax sounded with the fact I only know the tiniest amount of piano theory, nothing really past 4 note or 5 note chords and the basic scales you learn in uni. What am I doing that is making the sax sound good?


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

any rythm alternatives?

0 Upvotes

can anyone give me an alternative rythym with the samw time as the drums juat diffwrent rythym? i feel its way too basic or am i wrong?


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

I have 400+ unnamed voice memos of song ideas. How do you keep track of yours?

6 Upvotes

I've played fingerstyle guitar for years, and my phone is full of recordings called "{Location} 101", or “New Recording 237” backed up in my computer from a few years back. Somewhere in there is a riff I loved, but finding it again is a nightmare.

How do you organise your unfinished ideas? Do you rename recordings, use folders, keep notes about key/tuning, or just listen through everything?

I'm a developer as well, and this has made me consider building a small tool for myself to make recordings easier to find - things like tagging original song details, key, tempo, location, and a short description so I could search for “C harmonic”, "Sungha Jung", "played with John" or even search by my particular instrument.

Before building anything, I’m curious how other songwriters handle this. What’s your current system, and where does it fall apart?


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

How can I bring a song in my head to life?

6 Upvotes

I want to begin producing the actual music to a song I’ve written. I can hear it in my head, I can hear the instruments. Like the trumpets and such, but I have no idea where to even start the process of bringing this song to life. Does anyone have any advice?


r/askmusicians • • 5d ago

Paying it forward for other musicians

7 Upvotes

Long story short, my mom was a stage manager (now works at a food bank) and my dad is an audio engineer (mostly working for corporate talks and government stuff). We’ve never been rich, but I’ve been surrounded by old music gear my whole life. There’s a pretty good local arts community, and I’ve been really hoping to contribute.
I don’t want other people to struggle with getting practice space, or basic equipment. I’ve been hoping to get in talks with some of the organizers but I don’t know where to start. Any ideas? I’m only 18 and just getting into doing this as a possible profession.


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

Any Advice/Tips

1 Upvotes

I want to perform. I want to put my music out there, have people listen to something I've created and hopefully connect with it. I want to become an actual artist, someone with their own sound and identity, like PinkPantheress. But honestly, the process of even getting started feels impossible sometimes.

I'm trying my best to learn production. I've tried with BandLab (an experience, to say the least), and GarageBand on my phone was absolute hell. My computer can't run any other production software- like ir doesnt have it in the store and when I download it from my browser it doesn’t load., so my options are pretty limited. I used to play violin, although I never really understood much beyond reading basic notes, and I'm now trying to teach myself music theory bit by bit. I literally only learned the difference between major and minor chords today.

I'm also trying to figure out what to do with my vocals, as I’m not where I want to be that I’m confident, However I do hope I can eventually ask my parents about singing lessons. The biggest problem is that songwriting is pretty much the only thing I'm confident in. I can write lyrics and imagine entire songs, but I can't seem to translate any of that into actual music. I struggle with toplining, creating melodies, producing and even singing. I can hear what I want in my head, but getting it out is another story entirely.

Music theory is also ridiculously confusing to me. Notes, counting, timing, all of it.( Even in my time in orchestra ) People explain it, simplify it, break it down, and somehow I'm still lost

Another thing I don't want to use AI to make my music. I want actual human creativity and to make something that feels like mine And overall just very disrespectful to use ai. But it's so frustrating having all these ideas and creative visions while feeling like I have absolutely no way of bringing them to life.

I know becoming an artist takes time, and I'm not expecting overnight success or anything like that . I just want to get to a point where I can actually make the music I imagine irl , maybe perform it for people and share something I've created . Right now, it feels like I'm constantly hitting a wall, and it's incredibly discouraging.