r/askphilosophy • • Jul 01 '23

Modpost Welcome to /r/askphilosophy! Check out our rules and guidelines here. [July 1 2023 Update]

67 Upvotes

Welcome to /r/askphilosophy!

Welcome to /r/askphilosophy! We're a community devoted to providing serious, well-researched answers to philosophical questions. We aim to provide an academic Q&A-type space for philosophical questions, and welcome questions about all areas of philosophy. This post will go over our subreddit rules and guidelines that you should review before you begin posting here.

Table of Contents

  1. A Note about Moderation
  2. /r/askphilosophy's mission
  3. What is Philosophy?
  4. What isn't Philosophy?
  5. What is a Reasonably Substantive and Accurate Answer?
  6. What is a /r/askphilosophy Panelist?
  7. /r/askphilosophy's Posting Rules
  8. /r/askphilosophy's Commenting Rules
  9. Frequently Asked Questions

A Note about Moderation

/r/askphilosophy is moderated by a team of dedicated volunteer moderators who have spent years attempting to build the best philosophy Q&A platform on the internet. Unfortunately, the reddit admins have repeatedly made changes to this website which have made moderating subreddits harder and harder. In particular, reddit has recently announced that it will begin charging for access to API (Application Programming Interface, essentially the communication between reddit and other sites/apps). While this may be, in isolation, a reasonable business operation, the timeline and pricing of API access has threatened to put nearly all third-party apps, e.g. Apollo and RIF, out of business. You can read more about the history of this change here or here. You can also read more at this post on our sister subreddit.

These changes pose two major issues which the moderators of /r/askphilosophy are concerned about.

First, the native reddit app is lacks accessibility features which are essential for some people, notably those who are blind and visually impaired. You can read /r/blind's protest announcement here. These apps are the only way that many people can interact with reddit, given the poor accessibility state of the official reddit app. As philosophers we are particularly concerned with the ethics of accessibility, and support protests in solidarity with this community.

Second, the reddit app lacks many essential tools for moderation. While reddit has promised better moderation tools on the app in the future, this is not enough. First, reddit has repeatedly broken promises regarding features, including moderation features. Most notably, reddit promised CSS support for new reddit over six years ago, which has yet to materialize. Second, even if reddit follows through on the roadmap in the post linked above, many of the features will not come until well after June 30, when the third-party apps will shut down due to reddit's API pricing changes.

Our moderator team relies heavily on these tools which will now disappear. Moderating /r/askphilosophy is a monumental task; over the past year we have flagged and removed over 6000 posts and 23000 comments. This is a huge effort, especially for unpaid volunteers, and it is possible only when moderators have access to tools that these third-party apps make possible and that reddit doesn't provide.

While we previously participated in the protests against reddit's recent actions we have decided to reopen the subreddit, because we are still proud of the community and resource that we have built and cultivated over the last decade, and believe it is a useful resource to the public.

However, these changes have radically altered our ability to moderate this subreddit, which will result in a few changes for this subreddit. First, as noted above, from this point onwards only panelists may answer top level comments. Second, moderation will occur much more slowly; as we will not have access to mobile tools, posts and comments which violate our rules will be removed much more slowly, and moderators will respond to modmail messages much more slowly. Third, and finally, if things continue to get worse (as they have for years now) moderating /r/askphilosophy may become practically impossible, and we may be forced to abandon the platform altogether. We are as disappointed by these changes as you are, but reddit's insistence on enshittifying this platform, especially when it comes to moderation, leaves us with no other options. We thank you for your understanding and support.


/r/askphilosophy's Mission

/r/askphilosophy strives to be a community where anyone, regardless of their background, can come to get reasonably substantive and accurate answers to philosophical questions. This means that all questions must be philosophical in nature, and that answers must be reasonably substantive and accurate. What do we mean by that?

What is Philosophy?

As with most disciplines, "philosophy" has both a casual and a technical usage.

In its casual use, "philosophy" may refer to nearly any sort of thought or beliefs, and include topics such as religion, mysticism and even science. When someone asks you what "your philosophy" is, this is the sort of sense they have in mind; they're asking about your general system of thoughts, beliefs, and feelings.

In its technical use -- the use relevant here at /r/askphilosophy -- philosophy is a particular area of study which can be broadly grouped into several major areas, including:

  • Aesthetics, the study of beauty
  • Epistemology, the study of knowledge and belief
  • Ethics, the study of what we owe to one another
  • Logic, the study of what follows from what
  • Metaphysics, the study of the basic nature of existence and reality

as well as various subfields of 'philosophy of X', including philosophy of mind, philosophy of language, philosophy of science and many others.

Philosophy in the narrower, technical sense that philosophers use and which /r/askphilosophy is devoted to is defined not only by its subject matter, but by its methodology and attitudes. Something is not philosophical merely because it states some position related to those areas. There must also be an emphasis on argument (setting forward reasons for adopting a position) and a willingness to subject arguments to various criticisms.

What Isn't Philosophy?

As you can see from the above description of philosophy, philosophy often crosses over with other fields of study, including art, mathematics, politics, religion and the sciences. That said, in order to keep this subreddit focused on philosophy we require that all posts be primarily philosophical in nature, and defend a distinctively philosophical thesis.

As a rule of thumb, something does not count as philosophy for the purposes of this subreddit if:

  • It does not address a philosophical topic or area of philosophy
  • It may more accurately belong to another area of study (e.g. religion or science)
  • No attempt is made to argue for a position's conclusions

Some more specific topics which are popularly misconstrued as philosophical but do not meet this definition and thus are not appropriate for this subreddit include:

  • Drug experiences (e.g. "I dropped acid today and experienced the oneness of the universe...")
  • Mysticism (e.g. "I meditated today and experienced the oneness of the universe...")
  • Politics (e.g. "This is why everyone should support the Voting Rights Act")
  • Self-help (e.g. "How can I be a happier person and have more people like me?")
  • Theology (e.g. "Can the unbaptized go to heaven, or at least to purgatory?")

What is a Reasonably Substantive and Accurate Answer?

The goal of this subreddit is not merely to provide answers to philosophical questions, but answers which can further the reader's knowledge and understanding of the philosophical issues and debates involved. To that end, /r/askphilosophy is a highly moderated subreddit which only allows panelists to answer questions, and all answers that violate our posting rules will be removed.

Answers on /r/askphilosophy must be both reasonably substantive as well as reasonably accurate. This means that answers should be:

  • Substantive and well-researched (i.e. not one-liners or otherwise uninformative)
  • Accurately portray the state of research and the relevant literature (i.e. not inaccurate, misleading or false)
  • Come only from those with relevant knowledge of the question and issue (i.e. not from commenters who don't understand the state of the research on the question)

Any attempt at moderating a public Q&A forum like /r/askphilosophy must choose a balance between two things:

  • More, but possibly insubstantive or inaccurate answers
  • Fewer, but more substantive and accurate answers

In order to further our mission, the moderators of /r/askphilosophy have chosen the latter horn of this dilemma. To that end, only panelists are allowed to answer questions on /r/askphilosophy.

What is a /r/askphilosophy Panelist?

/r/askphilosophy panelists are trusted commenters who have applied to become panelists in order to help provide questions to posters' questions. These panelists are volunteers who have some level of knowledge and expertise in the areas of philosophy indicated in their flair.

What Do the Flairs Mean?

Unlike in some subreddits, the purpose of flairs on r/askphilosophy are not to designate commenters' areas of interest. The purpose of flair is to indicate commenters' relevant expertise in philosophical areas. As philosophical issues are often complicated and have potentially thousands of years of research to sift through, knowing when someone is an expert in a given area can be important in helping understand and weigh the given evidence. Flair will thus be given to those with the relevant research expertise.

Flair consists of two parts: a color indicating the type of flair, as well as up to three research areas that the panelist is knowledgeable about.

There are six types of panelist flair:

  • Autodidact (Light Blue): The panelist has little or no formal education in philosophy, but is an enthusiastic self-educator and intense reader in a field.
  • Undergraduate (Red): The panelist is enrolled in or has completed formal undergraduate coursework in Philosophy. In the US system, for instance, this would be indicated by a major (BA) or minor.
  • Graduate (Gold): The panelist is enrolled in a graduate program or has completed an MA in Philosophy or a closely related field such that their coursework might be reasonably understood to be equivalent to a degree in Philosophy. For example, a student with an MA in Literature whose coursework and thesis were focused on Derrida's deconstruction might be reasonably understood to be equivalent to an MA in Philosophy.
  • PhD (Purple): The panelist has completed a PhD program in Philosophy or a closely related field such that their degree might be reasonably understood to be equivalent to a PhD in Philosophy. For example, a student with a PhD in Art History whose coursework and dissertation focused on aesthetics and critical theory might be reasonably understood to be equivalent to a PhD in philosophy.
  • Professional (Blue): The panelist derives their full-time employment through philosophical work outside of academia. Such panelists might include Bioethicists working in hospitals or Lawyers who work on the Philosophy of Law/Jurisprudence.
  • Related Field (Green): The panelist has expertise in some sub-field of philosophy but their work in general is more reasonably understood as being outside of philosophy. For example, a PhD in Physics whose research touches on issues relating to the entity/structural realism debate clearly has expertise relevant to philosophical issues but is reasonably understood to be working primarily in another field.

Flair will only be given in particular areas or research topics in philosophy, in line with the following guidelines:

  • Typical areas include things like "philosophy of mind", "logic" or "continental philosophy".
  • Flair will not be granted for specific research subjects, e.g. "Kant on logic", "metaphysical grounding", "epistemic modals".
  • Flair of specific philosophers will only be granted if that philosopher is clearly and uncontroversially a monumentally important philosopher (e.g. Aristotle, Kant).
  • Flair will be given in a maximum of three research areas.

How Do I Become a Panelist?

To become a panelist, please send a message to the moderators with the subject "Panelist Application". In this modmail message you must include all of the following:

  1. The flair type you are requesting (e.g. undergraduate, PhD, related field).
  2. The areas of flair you are requesting, up to three (e.g. Kant, continental philosophy, logic).
  3. A brief explanation of your background in philosophy, including what qualifies you for the flair you requested.
  4. One sample answer to a question posted to /r/askphilosophy for each area of flair (i.e. up to three total answers) which demonstrate your expertise and knowledge. Please link the question you are answering before giving your answer. You may not answer your own question.

New panelists will be approved on a trial basis. During this trial period panelists will be allowed to post answers as top-level comments on threads, and will receive flair. After the trial period the panelist will either be confirmed as a regular panelist or will be removed from the panelist team, which will result in the removal of flair and ability to post answers as top-level comments on threads.

Note that r/askphilosophy does not require users to provide proof of their identifies for panelist applications, nor to reveal their identities. If a prospective panelist would like to provide proof of their identity as part of their application they may, but there is no presumption that they must do so. Note that messages sent to modmail cannot be deleted by either moderators or senders, and so any message sent is effectively permanent.


/r/askphilosophy's Posting Rules

In order to best serve our mission of providing an academic Q&A-type space for philosophical questions, we have the following rules which govern all posts made to /r/askphilosophy:

PR1: All questions must be about philosophy.

All questions must be about philosophy. Questions which are only tangentially related to philosophy or are properly located in another discipline will be removed. Questions which are about therapy, psychology and self-help, even when due to philosophical issues, are not appropriate and will be removed.

PR2: All submissions must be questions.

All submissions must be actual questions (as opposed to essays, rants, personal musings, idle or rhetorical questions, etc.). "Test My Theory" or "Change My View"-esque questions, paper editing, etc. are not allowed.

PR3: Post titles must be descriptive.

Post titles must be descriptive. Titles should indicate what the question is about. Posts with titles like "Homework help" which do not indicate what the actual question is will be removed.

PR4: Questions must be reasonably specific.

Questions must be reasonably specific. Questions which are too broad to the point of unanswerability will be removed.

PR5: Questions must not be about commenters' personal opinions.

Questions must not be about commenters' personal opinions, thoughts or favorites. /r/askphilosophy is not a discussion subreddit, and is not intended to be a board for everyone to share their thoughts on philosophical questions.

PR6: One post per day.

One post per day. Please limit yourself to one question per day.

PR7: Discussion of suicide is only allowed in the abstract.

/r/askphilosophy is not a mental health subreddit, and panelists are not experts in mental health or licensed therapists. Discussion of suicide is only allowed in the abstract here. If you or a friend is feeling suicidal please visit /r/suicidewatch. If you are feeling suicidal, please get help by visiting /r/suicidewatch or using other resources. See also our discussion of philosophy and mental health issues here. Encouraging other users to commit suicide, even in the abstract, is strictly forbidden and will result in an immediate permanent ban.

/r/askphilosophy's Commenting Rules

In the same way that our posting rules above attempt to promote our mission by governing posts, the following commenting rules attempt to promote /r/askphilosophy's mission to provide an academic Q&A-type space for philosophical questions.

CR1: Top level comments must be answers or follow-up questions.

All top level comments should be answers to the submitted question or follow-up/clarification questions. All top level comments must come from panelists. If users circumvent this rule by posting answers as replies to other comments, these comments will also be removed and may result in a ban. For more information about our rules and to find out how to become a panelist, please see here.

CR2: Answers must be reasonably substantive and accurate.

All answers must be informed and aimed at helping the OP and other readers reach an understanding of the issues at hand. Answers must portray an accurate picture of the issue and the philosophical literature. Answers should be reasonably substantive. To learn more about what counts as a reasonably substantive and accurate answer, see this post.

CR3: Be respectful.

Be respectful. Comments which are rude, snarky, etc. may be removed, particularly if they consist of personal attacks. Users with a history of such comments may be banned. Racism, bigotry and use of slurs are absolutely not permitted.

CR4: Stay on topic.

Stay on topic. Comments which blatantly do not contribute to the discussion may be removed.

CR5: No self-promotion.

Posters and comments may not engage in self-promotion, including linking their own blog posts or videos. Panelists may link their own peer-reviewed work in answers (e.g. peer-reviewed journal articles or books), but their answers should not consist solely of references to their own work.

Miscellaneous Posting and Commenting Guidelines

In addition to the rules above, we have a list of miscellaneous guidelines which users should also be aware of:

  • Reposting a post or comment which was removed will be treated as circumventing moderation and result in a permanent ban.
  • Using follow-up questions or child comments to answer questions and circumvent our panelist policy may result in a ban.
  • Posts and comments which flagrantly violate the rules, especially in a trolling manner, will be removed and treated as shitposts, and may result in a ban.
  • No reposts of a question that you have already asked within the last year.
  • No posts or comments of AI-created or AI-assisted text or audio. Panelists may not user any form of AI-assistance in writing or researching answers.
  • Harassing individual moderators or the moderator team will result in a permanent ban and a report to the reddit admins.

Frequently Asked Questions

Below are some frequently asked questions. If you have other questions, please contact the moderators via modmail (not via private message or chat).

My post or comment was removed. How can I get an explanation?

Almost all posts/comments which are removed will receive an explanation of their removal. That explanation will generally by /r/askphilosophy's custom bot, /u/BernardJOrtcutt, and will list the removal reason. Posts which are removed will be notified via a stickied comment; comments which are removed will be notified via a reply. If your post or comment resulted in a ban, the message will be included in the ban message via modmail. If you have further questions, please contact the moderators.

How can I appeal my post or comment removal?

To appeal a removal, please contact the moderators (not via private message or chat). Do not delete your posts/comments, as this will make an appeal impossible. Reposting removed posts/comments without receiving mod approval will result in a permanent ban.

How can I appeal my ban?

To appeal a ban, please respond to the modmail informing you of your ban. Do not delete your posts/comments, as this will make an appeal impossible.

My comment was removed or I was banned for arguing with someone else, but they started it. Why was I punished and not them?

Someone else breaking the rules does not give you permission to break the rules as well. /r/askphilosophy does not comment on actions taken on other accounts, but all violations are treated as equitably as possible.

I found a post or comment which breaks the rules, but which wasn't removed. How can I help?

If you see a post or comment which you believe breaks the rules, please report it using the report function for the appropriate rule. /r/askphilosophy's moderators are volunteers, and it is impossible for us to manually review every comment on every thread. We appreciate your help in reporting posts/comments which break the rules.

My post isn't showing up, but I didn't receive a removal notification. What happened?

Sometimes the AutoMod filter will automatically send posts to a filter for moderator approval, especially from accounts which are new or haven't posted to /r/askphilosophy before. If your post has not been approved or removed within 24 hours, please contact the moderators.

My post was removed and referred to the Open Discussion Thread. What does this mean?

The Open Discussion Thread (ODT) is /r/askphilosophy's place for posts/comments which are related to philosophy but do not necessarily meet our posting rules (especially PR2/PR5). For example, these threads are great places for:

  • Discussions of a philosophical issue, rather than questions
  • Questions about commenters' personal opinions regarding philosophical issues
  • Open discussion about philosophy, e.g. "who is your favorite philosopher?"
  • Questions about philosophy as an academic discipline or profession, e.g. majoring in philosophy, career options with philosophy degrees, pursuing graduate school in philosophy

If your post was removed and referred to the ODT we encourage you to consider posting it to the ODT to share with others.

My comment responding to someone else was removed, as well as their comment. What happened?

When /r/askphilosophy removes a parent comment, we also often remove all their child comments in order to help readability and focus on discussion.

I'm interested in philosophy. Where should I start? What should I read?

As explained above, philosophy is a very broad discipline and thus offering concise advice on where to start is very hard. We recommend reading this /r/AskPhilosophyFAQ post which has a great breakdown of various places to start. For further or more specific questions, we recommend posting on /r/askphilosophy.

Why is your understanding of philosophy so limited?

As explained above, this subreddit is devoted to philosophy as understood and done by philosophers. In order to prevent this subreddit from becoming /r/atheism2, /r/politics2, or /r/science2, we must uphold a strict topicality requirement in PR1. Posts which may touch on philosophical themes but are not distinctively philosophical can be posted to one of reddit's many other subreddits.

Are there other philosophy subreddits I can check out?

If you are interested in other philosophy subreddits, please see this list of related subreddits. /r/askphilosophy shares much of its modteam with its sister-subreddit, /r/philosophy, which is devoted to philosophical discussion. In addition, that list includes more specialized subreddits and more casual subreddits for those looking for a less-regulated forum.

A thread I wanted to comment in was locked but is still visible. What happened?

When a post becomes unreasonable to moderate due to the amount of rule-breaking comments the thread is locked. /r/askphilosophy's moderators are volunteers, and we cannot spend hours cleaning up individual threads.

Do you have a list of frequently asked questions about philosophy that I can browse?

Yes! We have an FAQ that answers many questions comprehensively: /r/AskPhilosophyFAQ/. For example, this entry provides an introductory breakdown to the debate over whether morality is objective or subjective.

Do you have advice or resources for graduate school applications?

We made a meta-guide for PhD applications with the goal of assembling the important resources for grad school applications in one place. We aim to occasionally update it, but can of course not guarantee the accuracy and up-to-dateness. You are, of course, kindly invited to ask questions about graduate school on /r/askphilosophy, too, especially in the Open Discussion Thread.

Do you have samples of what counts as good questions and answers?

Sure! We ran a Best of 2020 Contest, you can find the winners in this thread!


r/askphilosophy • • 2d ago

Open Thread /r/askphilosophy Open Discussion Thread | November 16, 2026

6 Upvotes

Welcome to this week's Open Discussion Thread (ODT). This thread is a place for posts/comments which are related to philosophy but wouldn't necessarily meet our subreddit rules and guidelines. For example, these threads are great places for:

  • Discussions of a philosophical issue, rather than questions
  • Questions about commenters' personal opinions regarding philosophical issues
  • Open discussion about philosophy, e.g. "who is your favorite philosopher?"
  • "Test My Theory" discussions and argument/paper editing
  • Questions about philosophy as an academic discipline or profession, e.g. majoring in philosophy, career options with philosophy degrees, pursuing graduate school in philosophy

This thread is not a completely open discussion! Any posts not relating to philosophy will be removed. Please keep comments related to philosophy, and expect low-effort comments to be removed. Please note that while the rules are relaxed in this thread, comments can still be removed for violating our subreddit rules and guidelines if necessary.

Previous Open Discussion Threads can be found here.


r/askphilosophy • • 7h ago

Are there any modern day philosophers who defend Neoplatonism?

34 Upvotes

Hi all,

I’m currently working on my PhD, and a key aspect of it deals with how Neoplatonic thought spread in late antiquity and the medieval era.

This got me thinking, are there any contemporary (let’s say in the last 100-200 years) philosophers who defended Neoplatonism or had a Neoplatonically-tinged philosophical bent? Of course there are many scholars who write about Neoplatonism, but I’m wondering if there are any who have adopted it as a philosophical framework that they defend in the same way philosophers might adhere to idealism or nihilism.

Many thanks!


r/askphilosophy • • 2h ago

Why do you have to believe anything to be moral? As in are there any beliefs inherently immoral?

11 Upvotes

Like hypothetically imagine someone who believes every anti semitic conspiracy theory out there but treats Jewish people well and equally and never outwardly expresses these beliefs to other people. Are they doing anything immoral?

Or say someone who believes they are better than everyone and that everyone is stupid or lesser in some form or they have an immense desire to cause suffering but no intention to act on it . If they act as a a good person for whatever reason.

Then are the beliefs in of themselves immoral?


r/askphilosophy • • 4h ago

My professor’s definition of analytical and continental philosophy is really true or what?

14 Upvotes

My premise is that I’m not in any way knowledgeable since I’m on my first year of university. We have this course called Theoretical Philosophy. So I asked my professor whether he identified himself more with the analytical side or the continental side of philosophy (I don’t personally give credit to this split but that’s my two cents) and he said he’s more on the analytical side since “the continental is just an exegesis of the great classics” and this consideration didn’t quite resemble what people usually told me about the split, and in general, I don’t see his definition as true at all, since there are a lot of continental philosophers who didn’t just do an exegesis of previous works.

I might be wrong, idk


r/askphilosophy • • 7h ago

What does Wittgenstein mean by sense?

5 Upvotes

I’ve been picking up Wittgenstein’s Tractatus and having quite the trouble reading through it. In his usage of “sense”, I understand it as content, but it seems to be more than that because he also talks of sense as something separate as content. Am I misunderstanding him or what does he mean by “sense”?


r/askphilosophy • • 12h ago

Help me understand moral non-cognitivism

10 Upvotes

So, as far as I understand it, there are three broad positions in metaethics. Moral realism, error theory, and non-cognitivism. I don’t understand what it means to say that ethical statements are not truth-apt, and I don’t understand how non-cognitivism doesn’t collapse into error theory.
What does it mean to say that moral statements express ‘beliefs’ rather than ‘truths’? Is it not true that every expression of belief contains within it a claim about something, and that every claim about what is true expresses some belief? I don’t think that claiming moral statements are expressions of attitude rather than truth holds much weight either, as the proof for this seems to be that moral statements tend to express attitudes about things. People hold moral beliefs that conflict with their desires and they hold moral beliefs that they disregard without feeling much of anything about it. Even if it is true that moral claims are closer to expressions of attitude than truth-claims, they are still making a claim about something, no? When I say murder is wrong, I am not only expressing that I disapprove of murder, I am also attributing a real positive quality (that of ‘wrongness’) to the act of murder.
I am woefully uneducated in both ethics & metaethics, so I strongly doubt that the non-cognitivist position is as weak as it appears to me, and I would like to know why people hold this view I find so peculiar.


r/askphilosophy • • 7h ago

Say I've read a contemporary introduction to a topic, and perhaps know a few historical episodes (perhaps even not), Where to go from there?

3 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 7h ago

What would be the best approach for studying Process Philosophy/Ontology? Due to its engagement with scientific concepts would Philosophy of Science/Physics/HPS courses or departments be best suited?

2 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 3h ago

Are there any good books about logic?

0 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 3h ago

Help understanding Mamin's objection to Nado about conceptual engineering

1 Upvotes

Nado's account & Mamin's Objection:

According to Nado, the targets of CE are classification procedures. Classification procedures are recipes for picking out entities. They work like algorithms (another analogy Nado uses ). So, for instance, the aim for CE might be to replace a classification procedure excluding trans men with a classification procedure including them. As Nado mentions herself, classification procedures come close to Fregean senses, so there is no huge gap to the view that concepts, characterised as ways of thinking, are the targets of CE. (For instance, the procedure of picking out renates and the procedure of picking out cordates are different, even if they result in the same extension.) Accordingly, Nado does not deny that CE might target concepts. However, Nado thinks that talking about ‘senses’ “does nothing but muddy the waters here, tying us to various presuppositions and assumptions that are more likely to confuse than illuminate”. 31 So, according to Nado, we do not need to refer to the contested notion of concepts. Instead, we can think about classification procedures. I think that Nado is right that CE is often about changing classifications instead of changing linguistic meanings. However, my main worry against her view is that we cannot explain CE of the second kind by restricting ourselves to classification procedures. As we have seen in the meat example, the classification stays the same even though MEAT is replaced with FLESH OF TORTURED ANIMALS. So, changing a way of thinking can be an aim of CE, even though this does not change a classification.

The meat case:

Consider a conceptual engineer who proposes to replace the concept MEAT with FLESH OF TORTURED ANIMALS. This replacement will typically be expressed by proposing to redescribe a given classification. For instance, looking at the same goods in a supermarket, Harry may say “this is meat”. Sally may disagree and answer “no, this is flesh of tortured animals.” The engineering part would not only consist in Sally developing her new way of thinking about meat but also in trying to persuade Harry to adopt it. Such a redescription is not mere wordplay. Each word expresses a different concept (MEAT / FLESH OF TORTURED ANIMALS), even if both concepts yield the same classification.

I do not understand his objection at all. Nado's account can simply explain the difference in the inferential content through the difference in the way a classification procedure arrives at a given classification. Mamin himself notes that the extension can be the same while the classification procedure is different. So how exactly is this argument supposed to show that Nado's account cannot adequately explain the conceptual engineering of inferential content?

Any help would be appreciated.


r/askphilosophy • • 8h ago

Do some concepts exist in the mind before sense impressions can be properly experienced?

2 Upvotes

as a problem of empiricism i cant find anything


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

If human reason is the instrument we use to understand reality, how can we establish that human reason itself is reliable?

41 Upvotes

I've been stuck on a rather strange problem.

Everything we know about the world, including our scientific theories, philosophical arguments and concepts of truth, is ultimately evaluated through human cognition.

But consider this:

If our cognitive faculties have limitations, biases and evolutionary origins, then those same limitations must also affect how we evaluate the reliability of our own reasoning.

We use reason to examine reason. We use perception to investigate perception. We construct theories about reality using a mind that has never experienced reality independently of its own cognitive framework.

How, then, can we establish that our methods of understanding are actually capable of reaching truth rather than merely producing internally consistent explanations?

And there's a further complication.

If we somehow discovered that our cognitive faculties were fundamentally unreliable, wouldn't we have to use those same faculties to understand and accept that discovery?

It seems like we're caught in a loop where the instrument being examined is also the only instrument available for examining it.

Is this a genuine epistemological problem, or does it rest on a mistaken assumption that knowledge requires some external, independent standard of validation?

I'd be particularly interested in perspectives from epistemology, philosophy of mind, Kant, and naturalized epistemology.


r/askphilosophy • • 15h ago

The difference between AI art and human art.

5 Upvotes

All art is from the experience of the people who make it. They take those experiences and rearrange them to make art.

Ai art looks at past experiences and then makes something by rearranging their experiences.

So philosophically what is the difference?


r/askphilosophy • • 8h ago

Looking for a philosophical symbol for the limits of human understanding

1 Upvotes

I’m designing a tattoo of Icarus falling, representing humanity’s endless pursuit of knowledge and truth, even when they might be beyond our reach.
The idea is inspired by Camus’ absurdism: our desire to find meaning in a universe that may never give us answers.
Questions like: Why do we exist? Does God exist? Are there truths we’re fundamentally incapable of understanding?
I’m looking for an object to place above Icarus that symbolizes the unknown or the limits of human understanding.
I’ve considered a question mark, a Möbius strip, and impossible geometric shapes, but nothing feels quite right.
Any ideas for a philosophical paradox, mathematical concept, or visual symbol that could capture this tension between human curiosity and the unknowable?


r/askphilosophy • • 15h ago

Is it ill-advised to read the second critique before the first critique?

3 Upvotes

I am very much interested in Kant’s practical philosophy and have been going down a rabbit-hole, recently. I’ve read some contemporary works on his ethics, and I’ve gone through the Groundwork almost three times now. I want to expand my knowledge of his practical philosophy, which is why I want to read the second critique, but I’m worried I’ll be missing a whole lot of stuff if I don’t read the first critique. Now, I have, already, a sort of half-formed idea of his overall project and transcendental idealism (given to me mostly indirectly by my excursions into his ethics), but I do wonder how much of the first critique is necessary to read the second.

Thanks in advance!


r/askphilosophy • • 18h ago

If you only do good actions because of a promised reward (going to heaven, etc.) but want to change to doing good things for the sake of doing good things, is there a way to consciously decide to do that?

4 Upvotes

It seems like just saying in your mind “i should do good their own sake” wouldn’t be enough to actually believe it, since people don’t usually choose their motivations / beliefs. (this is inspired by the discussion around the song “charlie’s inferno”)


r/askphilosophy • • 17h ago

Looking for existentialist fiction

3 Upvotes

I'm working on a horror-fantasy novel with existentialist/nihilistic undertones, and I'd like to immerse myself more in the literature before continuing further. Can you please recommend me some essential philosophical fiction that explores these themes? The darker the better; I'd like to peer as deeply into the void as I can, so to speak.


r/askphilosophy • • 12h ago

What are current questions of philosophy of ai in academia?

1 Upvotes

Hey fellow peps, as ai is growing exponentially, I want to tackle down what are the academic areas or questions of concerns of ai that philosophy scholar are faced with? Provide ai free responses, thanks you!


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

Is Schropenhauer's idea of all pleasures being negative an indefensible position in light of modern psychology?

5 Upvotes

I understand Schropenhauer's idea of pleasure as just being the absence of pain, and what we call pleasure is just confusion produced by the relief of suffering that something has been added to our life.

But in psychology there are distinctive spots in the brain called hedonic hot spots and cold spots, each associated with pleasure and pain respectfully. Is there anyway to reconcile the Shropenhauer view in light of psychology? Has anyone written a defense of this view?


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

What do you do when don't understand a text during your reading?

12 Upvotes

I am pretty new to philosophy and also new to reading literature at the same time. I have found philosophy so interesting that it has also kickstarted reading as a whole for me.

but because im such a newbie to literature I genuinely find it troubling to understand a lot of sentences I read, as in I can't decipher meaning out of stuff by myself or sometimes altogether can't piece even a general understanding of what i'm looking at. When i first started "Either/Or" by kierkegaard I used chatgpt to understand a line (I know this is cringe, to say the least) but thought quickly that doing so is completely counter-intuitive and won't help develop the obviously lacking skills i need to comprehend the concepts being written.

but I also REALLY wanna enjoy the book, so when I just wanna get around to reading it and i'm getting stuck attempting to understand what the writers trying to convey every 3 lines it's very enticing to use smth like chatgpt

So i'm asking what do you do when u don't understand something?
What are your methods that i can replicate to see if i can at least nudge a brain cell to think?


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

What do academic philosophers think of Palantir co-founder Alex Karp's doctoral dissertation?

182 Upvotes

The pdf is here - https://d-nb.info/966060652/34

I was reading Karp's wiki page and found that he did his PhD under Jurgen Habermas in the University of Goethe in Germany. Seemed quite surprising, considering Palantir's work in mass surveillance, the military industrial complex and genocide, and Jurgen Habermas's work in deliberative democracy.

Any ideas?


r/askphilosophy • • 22h ago

Is Leibniz correct that a prophet who predicts the future would require God's assistance?

2 Upvotes

This may appear to be a wacky question, but it appears to me that it is relevant to us. This is because there has recently been a large-scale debate on YouTube and Substack about so-called Catholic "vindicatory miracles." If you aren't familiar, see the YouTube channel "Majesty of Reason" or Ethan Muse's Substack. I believe the following quote could have implications for that debate.

"It is true that the devil can mimic some miracles. But there is a kind of miracle that the devil could not imitate, all powerful and all enlightened as he is, which is prophecy. For if a person can tell me many particular truths about general affairs which are due to happen, for example in a year here, I will hold it as certain that it is God who enlightens him. For it is impossible for anyone bar God to see the general chain of causes which have to come together in the production of contingent things."

Is Leibniz right?


r/askphilosophy • • 22h ago

Rounding out my Philosophy Education

2 Upvotes

I am thinking about going back to college for an advanced degree in philosophy. The problem is I only have a minor in it and was able to pick my own adventure through it. So, I took no general philosophy classes (Philosophy 101, etc). I mostly stuck to ethics and logic. Any recommendations on how to round out my knowledge? I want to be able to ensure I have the right knowledge base to even consider applying.

Also, any insight on what the day-to-day would look like for a profession in philosophy looks like would be greatly appreciated?