r/AskPhysics • • 1h ago

Why can't we just zoom into the particle to know it's exact position and momentum?

15 Upvotes

I'm an physics student in the IBDP 1, and just out of curiosity, I'm trying to understand the Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle...

Can't there be in the near future any device which can zoom in all the way to the exact position of a particle?

edit: Thanks to everyone who's helped me understand!!I think I've gotten it now... It's fundamentally impossible to measure simultaneously both- position and momentum of a particle since they are (at quantum scales) basically waves and that 'uncertainty' is an intrinsic property of wave nature itself...


r/AskPhysics • • 16h ago

If I shoot a laser pen into the sky on a clear night.. Assuming I miss any clouds/ atmosphere/ moon, What's the next most likely thing those photons will hit?

137 Upvotes

Basically the title asks the question..

I might have worded this poorly, but I just had a random thought about shooting a laser pen into the sky on a clear night and it never hitting anything.

So essentially I've just fired my green laser into the ether and my effect on the universe will forever outlast my existence on the earth.. Or at least whilst that beam is in motion.

That thought process lead me to where we are now.. When/ what might interrupt the flow of the beam? I've seen we can bounce a laser off the moon, so I'm assuming it can leave the atmosphere


r/AskPhysics • • 1h ago

The Planck length defines minimum distance for useful observation/experimentation. Is there an equivalent for large-scale reality?

4 Upvotes

Essentially this is a question of whether or not we could model a universe so big that our physics begin to fail and we can no longer meaningfully simulate it. Or, is this a case where the universe can become arbitrarily big and the math still holds?


r/AskPhysics • • 7h ago

Superfluid... perpetual motion?

7 Upvotes

I know perpetual motion doesn't exist and there is always a catch, but I can't find it in this idea so please tell me, what would actually happen? How is this wrong?

I saw Veritasium's video about superfluid and the Helium "climbs" the container walls and empties itself outside dripping at the bottom, so what would happen if the container was closed? Helium climbs to the top and drips back down on itself?
Wouldn't that make a perpetual motion?
Motion powered by the attraction between Helium atoms and container walls and gravity.

You could then put something mid-fall and generate energy from the falling droplets.

The only issue I could think of would be if the fluid knocks itself out of superfluid state or something but how/why?

Quick sketch for reference

Genuinely curious, superfluid is crazy...


r/AskPhysics • • 13h ago

For cosmic background radiation, what is the source of the microwaves?

20 Upvotes

If the microwaves are coming from all around us, what is actually emitting these waves? Ive read that it’s left over energy from the big bang, but they must have some event that initiates each wave?


r/AskPhysics • • 3h ago

29yo, wanting to go to college for physics, but scared

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/AskPhysics • • 12h ago

Why do we need graviton?

11 Upvotes

In QFT and morden theories about quantum gravity we try to quantize gravity. We treat as a force and try to unify it with the other three fundamental forces and trying to find out the particle behind it. But according to Einstein's General Theory of Relativity we know that gravity is not a force, but the curvature in spacetime. So why we are trying to find graviton and trying to unify it with other forces?


r/AskPhysics • • 21m ago

Energy stored in a glass measuring cup

0 Upvotes

What is energy?

Let's start here: Energy is a quantity belonging to an object or system.

A quantity is a property of an object or system whose value may be and is, in the present case, defined using a "quantity value" which is a number combined with a unit of measure.

An object can have any number of properties. Some may be quantities, and some may be qualities.

An example of a property belonging to a glass measuring cup which is also a quality would be the kind of liquid held in it. The current value would be one of many discrete values such as "water," "buttermilk," or "vegetable oil" to name a few.

An example of a property being a quantity would be the volume of liquid currently held inside. Let's say I pour 1 cup of water into it.

"1 cup" is a quantity value.

So if energy is a quantity, what exactly is measured?

Back to our definition: Energy is a quantity belonging to an object or system that measures the total amount of work it can perform on a separate system. The SI unit of measuring energy is the Joule.

So here is our glass measuring cup:

Properties:

Mass: 0.5 kg

Liquid held: 0 ml

Kind of liquid held: undefined

Energy: ? MJ

Let's rephrase the question from "how much energy is in a glass measuring cup" to "how much energy can we extract from a glass measuring cup.

Help me break down all the kinds of energy stored in a glass measuring cup and the ways it does work on other systems as that energy is extracted, including where that energy goes to. Let's assume the glass measuring cup is at room temperature (74 degrees F) and is at rest at an elevation of 0 meters above sea level.

Potential methods: Drop down a shaft to the center of the earth (gravitational potential energy) Dissolve in hydrofluoric acid (chemical bond energy)

reduction in temperature to sub 1 degree Kelvin (thermal energy)

Antimatter annihilation (nuclear energy)


r/AskPhysics • • 1h ago

When measuring the speed of water, what part of the water is being measured?

1 Upvotes

As title asks - When measuring the flow speed of water, what exactly is being measured? The velocity of an individual droplet? Something to do with air pressure? Just curious about this. Thanks!


r/AskPhysics • • 11h ago

in newtons cradle, why is the number of pushed balls always equal?

6 Upvotes

when you raise one ball on newtons cradle and let it swing, it will push away 1 ball on the other side. Same for 2, 3, etc balls. It was explained to me that momentum stays the same etc and sure but that doesn't explain why it also manifests the same way, since raising 2 balls which results in 1 ball swinging with twice the amplitude would also conserve momentum


r/AskPhysics • • 3h ago

Two questions about the Big Bang

0 Upvotes

I'm reading about the Big Bang, and the author seems to be suggesting that if we mathematically reverse the equations describing the expansion of the universe and extrapolate backwards towards t= 0, then the universe eventually contracts into a single point of infinite density.

  1. Is that infinite density a mathematical consequence of reversing the equations, rather than something we know actually happened? If so, do physicists assume that the universe started as an "almost infinitely dense point"?
  2. Whether or not the universe started as an infinite or near-infinitely dense point, do we assume that the mass of the universe during the Planck Era warped space & time the same way we observe a black hole warp space & time? Or, would there be some difference because the Big Bang wasn't expanding into space, it was creating space, while black holes already exist in space?

r/AskPhysics • • 14h ago

Does gravity have something analogous to magnetism?

8 Upvotes

Electrical charges affect and respond to the electromagnetic field, but moving charges also have a special effect that only other moving charges respond to (that being magnetism). And on closer examination, magnetism is actually required for the electric field to work in a universe governed by special relativity.

Gravity also follows laws that look mathematically very similar to electricity (or at least, the Newtonian descriptions look similar). Is there an analogous "gravitomagnetic" interaction between moving masses?


r/AskPhysics • • 4h ago

For an object to ascend at a constant rate does its upward force match or exceed gravity?

1 Upvotes

Specifically as it relates to an aircraft climbing. I saw a diagram stating that for an aircraft flying at a constant speed and level:

Thrust = drag

Lift = gravity

The aircraft is not accelerating in any direction but does this hold true for a constant rate of climb?


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

How big wingspan would a horse need to fly?

26 Upvotes

Reading "My uncle the magician" and Aslan gave the horse wings which made me ponder the question.


r/AskPhysics • • 5h ago

What happens at negative?

0 Upvotes

I know temperature cant be negative in Kelvin.

I was thinking about the weather here, -2 Celsius, and wondered: what would it mean if temperature could be negative?

For speed or force it means the direction, but surely not for temperature, right?

Or would something with -x Kelvin just absorb heat until it becomes 0K? But what if it's in a surrounding space that is all -x K?

I would love to think more about it,

Thanks in advance!


r/AskPhysics • • 22h ago

Are forces/force carriers affected by slowed time?

3 Upvotes

Let's say I have a large charged mass and measure its EM-field from far away. Time near it will be slowed from my point of observation.

The photons transferring our EM-force won't care of course, but I have no idea if the production of virtual force carriers is tied to some frequency, and if slowed time would thus affect the force it creates on charged objects.


r/AskPhysics • • 20h ago

Shouldn't it be impossible for there to be 0 current in a circuit?

2 Upvotes

So Current is as you know the amount of charge moving through a point in a time period.

Now, 0 current means no charge is moving through a point in that time period.

However, electrons still have to move even if there's no electric potential to push them due to them still having thermal energy. They can't just stop moving otherwise that would imply absolute zero which the 3rd Law of thermo tells us can't happen.

So doesn't that mean electrons always have to be moving through a point in a circuit due to their thermal energy?


r/AskPhysics • • 20h ago

How would I calculate how often planets line up?

0 Upvotes

I’m wondering what the formula would be to calculate how often in a given system all of the planets would align in a straight line (so that if you were standing on the star, you could look in one direction and have each planet eclipsing each other, NOT that they all would appear in a line across the sky).

My intuition tells me I would just multiply all of their orbital periods together but I’m not sure if that’s correct

Bonus: How would this equation change when considering moons (if I also wanted all the moons of a system to line up in this giant eclipse)?

Thanks!


r/AskPhysics • • 21h ago

Has anyone compared plasma sheath pulse responses for different electron reflection laws at the same steady wall current?

0 Upvotes

I’m trying to find a paper that compares two plasma sheaths after the same short pulse. In one, the wall reflects a fixed fraction of electrons at every energy. In the other, the chance of bouncing back depends on how much energy the electron hits the wall with.

The part I’m looking for is a comparison where both sheaths start with the same electric field profile and both walls absorb the same steady electron current. Has anyone seen a study that compares what happens to the voltage inside the plasma or the current absorbed by the wall after the pulse?

These are the closest papers I’ve found so far.

https://arxiv.org/abs/1906.07056

https://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02689


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Is there a "skill tree" / dependency graph for learning physics (like one in the link here for math)?

2 Upvotes

I really like how it's laid out its topics on its start page. It's basically a visual prerequisite graph starting from basic set theory and branching all the way up to advanced/niche stuff like unbounded operators, with lectures attached to each node, and I saw a few videos and while they're not long enough IMO they do give a very good idea of the topics and order to learn.

Does anyone know of something similar for physics? Ideally, a visual roadmap or dependency chart that goes from intro mechanics all the way up to grad-level and specialized topics (QFT, GR, condensed matter, etc.), bonus points if it shows the math prereqs needed at each step.

I've already seen "Map of Physics" video, which is great, but I'm looking for something closer to an actual learning progression/curriculum tree rather than just a concept web.


r/AskPhysics • • 23h ago

HS Physics - I get upthrust, but.. what's that got to do with displaced fluid?

0 Upvotes

I understand upthrust/buoyant force, how an object sinks, remains stagnant at a certain depth or rises to float, and the pressure applied on the object by the fluid. Makes great sense. But... what does all of this have to do with the weight of displaced fluid?

Upthrust - the upward force applied on an object due to the pressure of the fluid below the object. Particles push upwards. They also push sideways on the object, but that cancels out. They also push downwards, because there is fluid above the object too. But the downward push and upward push are not cancelled out because the pressure at both depths are different - the bottom part of the object experiences more force (more "push") because of this increase in pressure.

This upward force, when it is greater than the downward push and the weight of the object combined, causes the object to rise. If the total downward force is stronger, it sinks.

Objects that are denser sink because the particles have less surface area on which to apply pressure, and so the upthrust is weaker, and is easily countered by the greater mass (which causes greater weight). Objects that are less (average) dense float because the mass (and weight) is spread out over more volume, so more particles have the opportunity to push upwards.

  1. particles above the object feel a downward force (towards the object) via gravity. Particles below the object must also feel gravity but this force is AWAY from the object, so why is the force stronger by particles below the object?
  2. I am happy with my explanation/understanding so far, because my exam is soon and I don't have time to go as deep as I would like. I know that there may be some inaccuracies or nuances I have missed, but my exam won't be testing that much (hopefully...). I would normally stop here and move to the next topic, but I don't understand where the weight of the displaced fluid comes into this. Archimedes' Principle is key to our syllabus, and that's the only part I still don't get. Every online source I have scoured over the past few days simply state "upthrust is equal to the weight of the displaced fluid," and if I look for a "why" to that, they explain what I have explained above. I can't understand how the above explanation and understanding of this topic has to do with the weight of the amount of water a ship moves???

And if a ship isn't fully submerged, it doesn't even move the same amount of water as a sunken ship... Because less than 1/4 of the ship is actually in the water. It just doesn't make sense!!


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

If you stretched a rope between objects in two galaxies drifting apart from cosmic expansion, what would happen?

39 Upvotes

Meow


r/AskPhysics • • 2d ago

Why can't we make a spacecraft that flies like a plane until the air gets too thin to hold its weight, then switch to thrusters for the rest of the trip?

155 Upvotes

I'm not an expert, I'm just curious.


r/AskPhysics • • 14h ago

Is our mathematical framework causing a basic blind spot in physics?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I recently saw a post asking whether the Romans could have built steam engines, and most people agreed the answer was basically no; their science and engineering weren't advanced enough to make use of it even if they'd stumbled onto the underlying principle. Someone also pointed out that Roman mathematics had no concept of zero, so they were missing something needed for calculus and other higher math.

My question is whether that same idea might apply to the math we use today. For instance, we've struggled to mathematically unite quantum physics and gravity. As I understand it, this difficulty isn't because any observed evidence rules out a connection, but because our math breaks down there. Could there be some basic flaw in our mathematical system rather than a flaw in how we understand the universe? Could there be a kind of "zero" out there that we're just missing because of the way we've built our math?