Honestly, I still don’t quite get the creative direction behind BattleTech: Gothic. Turning the Inner Sphere into a Grimdark pastiche with bio-horror "Abominations" and cathedral-plated Mechs feels weirdly forced—like trying to mash 40k into a setting whose entire appeal is grounded, gritty military sci-fi and industrial hardware.
Meanwhile, if Catalyst wanted a fun, pulpy, alternate-universe spin-off with giant monsters fighting BattleMechs, a Dino-Riders crossover (or an AU heavily inspired by it) makes way more sense. Just think about how naturally that actually fits the classic 80s BattleTech DNA. We’re already talking about retro-futuristic 1980s sci-fi with chunky, utilitarian war machines, exposed cockpits, and oversized laser pods strapped onto everything. Strapping heavy PPCs, SRM racks, and sensor arrays onto armored Tyrannosaurs and Brontosaurs alongside Wasp and Marauder lance-mates would feel infinitely more cohesive than mutating flesh-monsters.
On top of that, it actually works within BattleTech's established lore and ruleset without breaking the tone of the universe. Having high-tech factions like the Valorians and Rulons crash-landing on a Periphery world—or Clan scientists going completely off the rails with aggressive megafauna genetics in the Deep Periphery—fits right into the setting's existing tropes. Plus, tabletop rules for armored beast-mounts and mounted weapon harnesses would honestly be a blast to play.
Anyone else feel like Gothic went completely off the rails when a Dino-Riders-style setting would have been a much better fit for the franchise's roots?
Recently I was engaging in discussions about Marauder II...
So I thought, I liked the Marauder MAD-5L very much. Can I replicate it on the Marauder II platform? I know the Capellans have a double Gauss Marauder II, but I want to try incorporate a full energy loadout and TSM...
Do you think is this 4(5)/6(8)/4 good idea? or I should tune it down to 3(4)/5(6)/3 but Standard Engine plus Reinforced Structure?
Marauder II MAD-11W
Mass: 100 tons
Chassis: Standard Biped
Power Plant: 400 XL
Cruising Speed: 43.2 kph
Maximum Speed: 64.8 kph
Jump Jets: Standard
Jump Capacity: 120 meters
Jump Booster Capacity: 0 meters
Armor: Stealth
Armament:
1 ER PPC
2 ER Medium Laser
2 ER Large Laser
Manufacturer: Unknown
Primary Factory: Unknown
Communication System: Unknown
Targeting & Tracking System: Unknown
Introduction Year: 3145
Tech Rating/Availability: F/X-X-X-E
Cost: 33,669,333 C-bills
Type: Marauder II
Technology Base: Mixed (Standard)
Tonnage: 100
Battle Value: 3,888
Equipment Mass
Internal Structure 10
Engine 400 XL 26.5
Walking MP: 4
Running MP: 6
Jumping MP: 4
Double Heat Sink 18 [36] 8
Gyro 4
Cockpit 3
Armor Factor (Stealth) 304 19
Internal Armor
Structure Value
Head 3 9
Center Torso 31 50
Center Torso (rear) 11
Torso 21 33
Torso (rear) 9
Arm 17 33
Leg 21 42
Right Arm Actuators: Shoulder, Upper Arm, Lower Arm
Left Arm Actuators: Shoulder, Upper Arm, Lower Arm
Weapons
and Ammo Location Critical Heat Tonnage
2 Jump Jet CT 2 - 4.0
Jump Jet RT 1 - 2.0
ER PPC RT 2 15 6.0
3 Triple Strength Myomer RA/LA 3/3 - 0.0
ER Medium Laser LA 1 5 1.0
ER Large Laser LA 1 12 4.0
Double Heat Sink LA 2 - 1.0
Targeting Computer LT 4 - 4.0
Jump Jet LT 1 - 2.0
Watchdog Composite Electronic Warfare System LT 2 - 1.5
3 Triple Strength Myomer RA/LA 3/3 - 0.0
ER Medium Laser RA 1 5 1.0
ER Large Laser RA 1 12 4.0
Double Heat Sink RA 2 - 1.0
Features the following design quirks: Command Mech, Hyper-Extending Actuators, Narrow/Low Profile
We now come to you, my old enemy. The Tripod I hold up as an example of something that is the worst aspects of mixed tech mechs, the most offensive machine to walk the earth with two or more legs, the reason why tripods are not widely known (well, that might be a exaggeration). And now, as I write, the mech that I feel is perhaps one of the biggest waists of potential I've ever seen. It is time to cover you:
TRISKELION!
"Huh? Me? What did I do?"
The Triskelion is one of the few non-superheavy currently in cannon, and a machine that has really irked me for various reasons. I've sighted it as "that tripod that I hate" due to it appearing to be a blatant abuse of mixed tech, saying the only thing keeping it mixed tech is the fact that the Clan techbase doesn't have tripods. While a teardown does show that this isn't the case, I still will stand by it being an abuse of the Republic of the Sphere's tech advantage, even if it doesn't amount to much.
So lets break it down:
The Triskelion TRK-4V is a 75 ton tripod mech that uses clan-grade technology extensively in it's construction, so lets get that out of the way really quick. Clan-grade components on the Triskelion include:
A 375 XL engine for a 5/8 movement profile
13.5 tons of Ferro-fibros (maximum protection without waisting points)
Two Clan LRM 15s with Artemis V (and four tons of ammo)
4 ER Medium Lasers
The rest of the components, including a Endo-Composite Skeleton, ECM, Targeting Computer, CASE II, and 15 double heat sinks are all IS tech. Thats a lot less than I initially thought but it's still quite a bit.
There are parts that I question the RotS having access to. Mainly the Artemis V. For those who aren't aware, Artemis V works like Artemis IV, but is 0.5 tons heavier, takes one more slot, and gives a +3 to the cluster hits and a -1 to-hit modifier. While I can accept that the RotS can produce clan grade weapons an armor, I question their ability to manufacture a guideline system that even now struggles to appear on clan designs.
So, how does it perform? Well, strip away all the fancy tech, and:
Trying to pick a joke is why this took so long. Also: I'm really bad at drawing people.
I joke, but it's pretty much true. If you strip away all the fancy electronics, the Triskelion is basically a catapult that gave up its jump jets for a third leg and extra speed. Which means it's going to perform well as a baseline, but I feel is also somewhat of a scathing review. The whole machine weighs 10 tons more than the Catapult, but it feels like all the potential bonuses of that just were dumped into the engine instead of anything else.
In terms of being a Tripod, I think the Triskelion fails to really use the benefits of the frame to the fullest. Sure, it does have increased mobility and gets a -1 to piloting roles, but the 5/8 mobility means that most of the time these will be largely unnoticed. The 360 torso twist and up to 3 different primary targets in the front arc is also nice, but again, it's not something the Triskelion needs. Or at least the latter is anyway. The Triskelion just doesn't have enough weapons to justify splitting fire, meaning that aspect isn't used as much either.
To me, the Triskelion feels like a Clan Invasion Heavy Omnimech. It is fast and has aspects that make it a cut above anything it will face, but then it immediately undermines itself by overspending in areas that it doesn't need to. In this case, the Triskelion spends a lot on mobility in both the engine and in the Tripod frame, leaving it with a set of weapons that, while good, aren't as substantial as its contemporaries. (It's pretty bad when I feel it's getting outdone by the Lament, a mech 10 tons lighter than it)
I think the Triskelion would have been better as a standard battlemech, where the weight that had been spent on the cockpit, armor, and structure could have been put to better use. It's still quite a good mech, but waisted it's potential as a tripod.
But is this salvageable? I think so. To take a stab at a potential heavy tripod, here's my rework of the Triskelion:
"A monstrous tripod, higher than many houses… a walking engine of glittering metal… a great body of machinery on a tripod stand" --War of the Worlds, Chapter 10
I figured if we're doing mixed tech we should just go all out and equip the most advanced tech I could think of.
The first and most obvious change I made was dropping the speed. While I think some might disagree with me, the Tripod frame would allow it to go fast enough on 4/6 movement. The minimal turning cost and 360 torso twist should allow the Triskelion to spend it's MP strafing its target while maintaining optimal positioning (plus the ability to instantly turn around means you can build TMM while staying almost stationary).
The weight savings were immediately put back into the weapons. I decided to keep the same layout but maximize striking power. The LRM 20s should always hit hard (and perhaps have a bit too much ammo) thanks to the Arti-V. The Improved Heavy Medium Lasers means each arm can force a Pilot Skill Roll on their own, making splitting fire a more viable choice, and the Targeting Computer in the head means they're still accurate, even if they're shorter range. The ECM is still there, doing its job keep enemy electronics at bay.
Some sacrifices did have to be made, as we're running into space issues. The structure had to be switched to standard, a heatsink dropped, the gyro is now compact, and the ECM is now in the front leg. This is all in service of cramming a Radical Heat Sink System into the CT to solve the heat issues. While active, the RHSS lets the Triskelion alpha strike while running and stay heat neutral. Otherwise your looking at firing the LRMs and two iHMLs and staying neutral, or firing all four lasers and building movement heat. It's not ideal, but I feel better trying to actually push the Triskelion's concept to its limits than choosing something safer.
So, what are my thoughts on the Triskelion? While I don't think its abusing mixed tech anymore, I still hate it. The design feels like a letdown: it waists a lot of it's potential as a tripod by buying a big engine, then squanders it further by filling itself with an old design but with advanced electronics rather than playing to it's strengths.
I find it to be a lot like the Republic of the Sphere in general: full of potential and advanced technology, but in the end didn't really accomplish much worth remembering.
Yeah, it's just a modified Dire Wolf model but holy shit!
If I had a nickel for each time I'd written a story featuring a mech and it later comes as part of new offical materials, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot but strange that it's only happened twice
I know they are going to re-unify in 3157, but apart from that, (which kind of feels like getting them back to where they should have been) will anything meaningful happen any time soon for them?
I somewhat feel like it shouldn't. Launching a military campaign after re-unifying your nation after the last military campaign tore it apart feels like a profoundly poor choice. I would imagine there will be some anti-pirate reunification action against the "independent worlds" between Taurus and Erod's Escape, but after that, will the Taurians go back to narrative irrelevance for another few decades while rebuilding their economy and such?
What is the best and easiest way to get MegaMek on Linux. I can't find any tutorials for people new to Linux. I use Ubuntu and struggling to make it work. I have gotten errors running it though the terminal like the website says.
I got the new box set today. Not 100% happy with it.
I'm a grognard and started playing BT when the only possible era was 3rd Succession War and the immediate aftermath. I was playing when the Clans showed up and pulled back since there was no balancing mechanism; BV had not yet been thought of.
So, the thing I am unhappy with...
Firstly it is built almost entirely for the IlClan. Oh, I get it! They want everyone to play with all the new toys! From a marketing perspective that is totally understandable, and it is the same thing that every holder of the IP has done with each new release of timeline based material. Just cuz I get it doesn't mean I have to like it.
Got a couple more map sheets and some punch out tiles for objectives. Those are cool, if totally unnecessary. You can use anything as a marker.
I do like the little reference card with hit locations and the missile cluster chart! That is very neat!
The big reference card is nice, but there are a lot of differences between it and the previous reference card. I still need to take a closer look at them.
Also, I have yet to go through the full rule book to see what (if any) changes they have made to the rules. I am hoping that none of them are too drastic or uncalled for.
My biggest complaint is the minis.
Oh, they are all very sweet! I like them! The quality is wonderful!
But since the boxed set deals with an era more than a century beyond my preferred one, all of the mechs are nearly useless to me.
They split it between four IS mechs (Holander, Uziel, Rakshasa and Eris) and four Clanners (Solitaire, Regent, Vulture Mk IV, Mad Cat Mk II). Out of the 8 I can maybe push myself to keeping 3, those being the Hollander and the Rakshasa (since they came out in 3053 and 3052 respectively and don't push my 3050 boundary so hard) and maybe the Uziel, though its production date of 3063 really pushes my envelope.
So, I have 5 models I don't need and don't want.
I may be nitpicking, and I acknowledge that. The initial release of the Clans 36 years ago (jeezus I'm old) really left a foul taste in my mouth and to this day I want nothing to do with them. That said, my attitude gets me stuck within a 50 year window of the universe's timeline.
That's about all I have to say. I love this game, have since its initial release.
What are the bottom two bits? The top is the radar dish, while the head is from the Phoenix Hawk. But the bottom left two bits seem to be explosions but I am not sure where they belong on the mech.
I'd like to start (slowly) working through the battletech novels, but this isn't like a typical series where you have Books 1 to X and you just start from 1. Where should I begin? Just go in-universe chronologically? Does it actually matter or should they be treated as a bunch of unrelated (other than universe) stories?
A lazy dirty kinda paraphrasing recolor of a Merlin done up in the death egg robot's (from sonic 2 showing how old i am) colors always thought it's looked like one recolor away from being something from the ol doctor from the sonic franchise.
It's not the only mech that looks like it but is the first one that came to my mind. My coloring skills are def not up to snuff but hopefully this should get the idea across kinda wish it had more of a proper upper part for the death egg robo's nose.
Like the title says il looking for the cgl crab. Please DM me with the offer.(picture for reference and to appreciate someone else's beautiful paint job.)
I've been working on some designs in TinkerCAD so I don't have to use the cardstock buildings in the Alpha Strike box set. These are the 1" and 1.5" small buildings and I'm working on printing the rest. Timber Wolf and Kontio for scale.