r/bigseo • u/Good-Kaleidoscope113 • 14h ago
Question Parent page shows the same prompts as its child category pages is this hurting my rankings?
I run a prompt collection site (WordPress). My topics are structured like this:
- One main collection page per topic (example: "Prom Photo Prompts for Girls")
- Child category pages under it ("Prom Couple Prompts", "Prom Night Prompts", etc.)
- The main page uses a guide layout: it shows each child as a section with a heading, and the section displays the same prompts that are on the child page
- Every prompt also has its own detail page
So the same prompt text can appear on 3 URLs: the main page section, the child page, and its own page. The written content (intro, tips, FAQ) is different on each page only the prompts themselves repeat.
An SEO audit told me this is keyword cannibalization and my pages are fighting each other. But when I checked, the child pages are NOT sharing prompts with each other each child has its own unique prompts, the main page just displays them in sections. And each level targets a different search ("prom prompts for girls" vs "prom couple prompts" vs the specific prompt name).
My plan now: stop making child pages. One main page per topic, with the groups as heading sections only (my theme already has a "section only" option the child URL 301-redirects to the section on the parent page). I would only keep a child page when the subtopic has its own real search demand, like "christmas pet photo prompts".
Questions for people who have run collection/directory sites:
- Is the main page + child page setup actually a problem if the prompts don't overlap between children and each page targets a different search?
- Is the one-page-with-headings approach better, or do focused child pages rank better for the subtopic searches?
- If I fold existing child pages into the parent with 301s, how bad is the short-term ranking hit?
What would you do?