I've noticed a lot of bitterness toward the Catholic Church in Christian spaces lately. I understand where it comes from, and I'm not here to make excuses for anyone. I just want to share my own experience, because it's different from what many people describe.
The beginning
I grew up in the Catholic faith. My mother was Catholic. My father didn't really go to church, and he wasn't around much. There's a story that was told about me from when I was a baby. I was being held in a pew during a christening, and as the bishop came down the aisle, he stopped right at our pew, sprinkled holy water, and blessed me. Then he blessed me a second time. People in the church talked about it as something unusual. Looking back, I believe God had His hand on me from the very beginning.
My older sister and I went to St. Gabriel's, a parochial school with a church attached. I remember preparing for my First Holy Communion. We had a priest who was a real tough guy. Back then you had to fast before receiving the Eucharist, and he knew kids loved bubblegum and candy, so he told us plainly: break that fast, and your soul would burn in hell. I don't think most of the kids paid him much attention. But I kept the fast, and my First Communion was wonderful. Every time I received the Eucharist after that, I could feel my body almost tremble. I always understood it as coming into contact with the Lord Jesus Christ, and I've never been able to explain it away.
Sent away
The principal at St. Gabriel's was a Sister of Charity, wearing the black bonnet of Mother Seton's order. She was very strict and stern, all by the book. In the fourth grade, when I was nine years old, a classmate and I did something she considered a very serious offense. The people in charge decided I was incorrigible, and I was suspended. My mother worked full time, so neighbors had to watch me, and my sister had to rush home from school every day to take care of me.
Over time, the school convinced my mother that, since there was no man in the house, she should let Catholic Charities step in. They persuaded her that I should be taken out of the house and put in a more structured place.
Then they sent a woman I'll never forget, Miss Brown. She sat down with me and opened a binder full of 8x10 glossy photographs of big buildings where they housed children. My idea of the best place in the world was my own neighborhood, where I could ride my bike, roller skate, and climb on the roofs. I didn't see any of that in those pictures, so I turned them all down. She came back with another book, and by then I understood my mother agreed and I would have to choose. So I picked the best of what looked like a lot of miserable places: dark, burnt-red buildings with a farm and a pumpkin patch, about two hours from home on the railroad. It was St. Mary's, an orphanage in Syosset, Long Island, run by the Sisters of Mercy. That was 1957, and I was ten years old.
When it was time to leave, I was confused, sad and hurt. My mother saw it, and she told me sincerely, "You'll only be gone for one year, and I will come and pick you up when that year is over." I took that as an oath. A promise.
The Sisters of Mercy
The Sisters of Mercy at St. Mary's, in their white headpieces and black veils, were some of the best people I have met in my whole life. They were gentle, kind and loving, and they seemed to take a special interest in me. It calmed me down and helped me just be a ten-year-old. Back then every little kid wanted those small cowboy and Indian figures with horses you could set them on. The sisters went out of their way to buy some for me. At breakfast or on the way to prayer, one of them would slip me a little figure, out of pure kindness. It was one of the purest forms of love I've ever felt.
At the end of that year, the sisters told us boys we were moving on to a new place on the beach. The only thing in my mind was that my mother was coming. On the day, the buses pulled up out front. I went to one of the sisters who had been so kind to me and said, "Sister, my mother's coming today to pick me up. I can't get on a bus." She looked at me kindly and said, "Okay, we'll wait. We'll wait."
It seemed to me they held those buses until the very last minute.
My mother didn't come.
I was ten years old. That was the darkest moment of my whole time in the orphanage system. I felt abandoned. I didn't know the word betrayal back then, but I must have felt a tinge of it. But I went on. In spite of my disappointment, I chose to go on and to prosper in the next place.
St. John's on the boardwalk
The next place was St. John's, on 116th Street in Rockaway, right along the boardwalk, run by brothers. I arrived in the summer of 1958 and turned eleven that September.
There I joined the band, one of the greatest experiences of my young life. I started as a beginner on the trumpet, with lessons every day, and I loved it so much that by my second year I was sitting second seat. On summer Wednesday evenings we played concerts on the parade ground facing the boardwalk, with crowds of people watching. I was called to stand and play solos, and afterward there would be tremendous applause.
There was a Puerto Rican boy named Francisco who snuck up on me every morning and kneed me in the thigh. One day I was in a game of ping pong, tied 21–21, about to make a perfect return, and he jumped in front of my paddle. That was the end of my patience, and we fought. From the next day on, we were friends, and he became one of my best friends. On weekends home I often stayed with his family in the Fort Greene Projects. His mother was very poor, and all we ate all weekend was French fries, every way she could make them. It seemed like a wonderful meal to me. I still pray he made a good life for himself.
As one of the older boys, I got a job at Playland on the boardwalk, running a bowling game. I'll confess the owner had me set the pins so the game was nearly impossible to win. It was there I met some young ladies and had my first wholesome friendships and crushes.
I also did something foolish. Eight or nine of us boys ran away in the middle of winter with about eight dollars in change between us. We rode the subway to Coney Island, slept at the top of an apartment stairwell, and lived on bread and milk we took from in front of the stores before they opened. Life on the run was hard, and after a few days we all went back. We were paddled, and my punishment was being removed from the band. That was a horrible blow. But time passed, and I got by it.
Going home
After about three years at St. John's, I was about to start the ninth grade. There was another orphanage they could have sent me to, but this time I had made up my own mind. I chose to go home to my mother's house and go to high school from there. And that's exactly what happened.
My mother
You might wonder how I feel about my mother, the woman who promised to come for me and didn't. So let me tell you.
I love my mother. To me, she became a symbol of goodness.
When I look carefully at her whole life, she was always, above everything else, loving and kind to me. When I came home from Vietnam as a young man with serious PTSD, and it seemed like I was going off the deep end, other family members were confused and didn't know what to do with me. My mother did the only thing she knew how to do. She loved me.
In the darkest days of that time, my mother was always there. I always had a place to come to, and a voice that would listen. Even in the worst of my travails, she was loving to me.
As I came through those years, I grew a deep, deep love for her. I called her almost every single day just to talk. I'd call in the morning to say, "How you doing?" and again during the week to see what she was up to. She'd call me to tell me what she'd been doing. We had a wonderful relationship.
When I decided to get married, she was so happy. She welcomed my fiancée into our family and gave her everything she could. She even helped my father come and meet her, and my fiancée embraced him too. To this day, my wife has a deep love in her heart for both my mother and my father. All the way along, my mother was super supportive of me. And oh, how she loved her grandbabies, with all of her heart.
So I don't carry a burden against my mother. Her whole life showed me how much she loved me.
Here's how I settled the orphanage in my mind. My mother was a young woman supporting her family on her own. She worked hard and diligently to do it. She didn't have a lot of sophistication in relationships, and her own marriage was broken. So she leaned on her faith, which was in the Catholic Church, and she trusted the people in the Church who had authority. I believe they convinced her that sending me away was the best plan.
Once I understood it that way, it settled in me. And I just loved her, all the way. Scripture says, "Honour thy father and mother; which is the first commandment with promise; that it may be well with thee, and thou mayest live long on the earth" (Ephesians 6:2–3). I'm 79 years old now, and I believe God has kept that promise.
Looking back
I could have chosen to be bitter about the way I was sent away. I've chosen not to be.
Looking back on my whole life, through the military, through years of war against evil spirits, through learning what real Christianity is, through facing my own sinfulness and fighting the unholy desires that came at me again and again, I pressed forward. With the Lord God Almighty, I know I'm moving in the right direction now. A little boy watching the buses wait for a mother who never came, a young Marine at war, a grown man in battle against evil spirits: through all of it, I've learned what Paul meant when he wrote, "If God be for us, who can be against us?" (Romans 8:31).
And every time I fell into sin, one scripture always came back to me: "For a just man falleth seven times, and riseth up again" (Proverbs 24:16). That verse was always the basis of my behavior. I struggled to fight against those sinful urges, falling and getting back up again, until, with God's help, I withstood them.
Here's what I've come to believe. Every denomination is made up of human beings, and human beings in any church can fall into the same extremes and the same sins. I've never been one for arguing doctrine. Whenever religion takes first place over God, I think of the Pharisees, who talked about God all the time and missed Him standing in front of them. Jesus said we would know them by their fruits. And I knew good fruit in those gentle Sisters of Mercy.
When I read Jeremiah, I recognize my own life: "Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee; and before thou camest forth out of the belly I sanctified thee" (Jeremiah 1:5). He knew me in that pew. He knew me at that altar rail. He knew me standing by those buses.
So if your experience with the Catholic Church was painful, I'm truly sorry, and I'm not asking you to see it my way. I'm only asking that you not let bitterness rule your life. God reached a little orphan boy right there, not through doctrine or rules, but through kindness and love. And He can reach anyone, anywhere.
When I look back over my whole life, my childhood, my teen years, my years in the service, my years at IBM, my marriage and my children, I can see God's hand all through it. I'm in the palm of His hand, and by His Holy Spirit, He is leading me.
I think of the psalmist's words: "O God, thou hast taught me from my youth: and hitherto have I declared thy wondrous works. Now also when I am old and grayheaded, O God, forsake me not; until I have shewed thy strength unto this generation" (Psalm 71:17–18).
Yes I'm old and grey-headed now, and that's why I share my story.
God bless you.
Tony