r/classicfallout • u/rshadowsail • 19h ago
I just beat Fallout 2 for the first time. Here are my thoughts Spoiler
Tl;dr: I've been on a fallout fix lately and just beat fallout 1 around a month ago. I thought that it was brilliant. One of the best games I ever played. Fallout 2 was also great but this game just has a few glaring flaws that are just simply impossible for me to ignore.
I have lots of really good things to say about fallout 2. The mid game is great. The role playing freedom is unmatched. You can truly play any role you want. You can play a quiet stealthy intellectual, a charming pornstar who woos everyone you talk too, an irrationally violent murderer, and almost anything in between. Unlike fallout 1 where I'd say some skills were just completely useless and some were beyond important, fallout 2 was designed to accommodate most builds. The build you want. Some skills are still pretty useless but I feel like skills like outdoorsman or traps were even more worthwhile investments in this game than fallout 1, but not like either of those skills are still that good in fallout 2 but you get what I'm saying. Also, there's just so much content. And content that's actually good. Not just filler; actually entertaining and fun content. There honestly wasn't a sidequest I dreaded or hated doing. Every single one was fun and felt rewarding in some capacity. It's amazing that it's even possible for a developer to do that, honestly.
People also talk about the atmosphere. Is it as good as fallout 1? No. But is it still a great atmosphere? Yeah, I'd say so. The game has a lot of goofy elements and this game doesn't balance its comedic and dark elements as well as new Vegas would end up doing, in my opinion. But there still is a great atmosphere between each location. Modoc and Gecko do genuinely feel like places falling apart, and vault city does genuinely feel like an unwelcoming, intimidating place. Though I would've liked an atmosphere more similar to fallout 1, this game was really good at going for the atmosphere within certain locations. It's good that it feels different depending on where you are because obviously it should. Of course talking to the people in Modoc will feel different than San Francisco. I think it's good that it is.
The storytelling is still pretty good but it's not as good as the first game. Fallout 2 is about the journey and definitely not the destination. I think that's how this game was designed. And that's not a bad thing. The overarching story largely feels irrelevant throughout the game. I actually forgot why I was at the oil rig by the end lol, because I just kind of forgot this game was about saving Arroyo. The overarching story is still told very well, imo. The game reminds you often enough that you're ultimately looking for the GECK.
So up until vault 13 and obtaining the GECK, this game was amazing. Some of the most fun I've had playing a fallout game. But once you grab that GECK and head over to Arroyo, my problems with this game really kick in. The last few hours of this are just bad. To put it bluntly. It's really poorly designed and loses its sense of pacing, which was honestly really good throughout the game up until this point. The fact that the NavComp parts are in Vault 13 is not obviously and poorly communicated to the player. The few quests that are here feel incomplete and not as rewarding or fun as the other quests from before getting to Navarro. Also, the pacing within the oil rig itself just isn't that good. Unlike places like the Sierra military base or Vault 13 that feel lively, complete, and well designed with good pacing with a good sense of direction to provide the player, I felt like I was just kind of expected to wander off into the direction and do the correct thing. Also, there's just not much diversity at the end of the game. I wish you could sneak or talk your way past Horrigan and the rest of the game, like you could with the master in fallout 1. I don't really want to compare this game to Fallout 1 that much but I feel like removing things like that just kind of makes a fallout game inherently worse by itself. It's like if Mario Galaxy 3 took away the gravity or space mechanic. Like why would you do that? I'm aware the endgame was rushed but y'know.
I also think the storytelling, which again is generally really good throughout the game, just isn't that good at the endgame. The mid game is really good with its storytelling. For example, the player is actually told the politics of the world without even asking or looking for it actively. If you want to learn the politics of New Reno, you'll quickly find just by literally looking and walking around that it's a clear power struggle between competitors. But it gets better than that. If you're in Redding, you can actually speak with Dan McGrew and hear his pragmatic grasp of the reality that Redding is too important for major powers to leave alone. So he explains to you who he'd rather end up falling under, which also reveals to you the broader rivalry between New Reno and Vault City. It's such a simple but good way to explain it. In the endgame, you dont really learn anything about what's going on until one conversation that's kind of just dumped on you. I guess what might've helped was to have the enclave included more apparently in some of the games dialogue, or environment. Or to just have a bit more content and better design in the endgame would've helped
Also, this game is hard. I'm aware for most crpgs of the time that that wasn't anything unique in terms of difficulty. But I feel like that doesn't make it unreasonable for me to complain about it. You'll encounter a deathclaw on your first commute to Klamath, which is just insane to me. Frank Horrigan is hard too. The Master was hard in fallout 1 but I don't feel like it was as hard as Horrigan.
So, my final thoughts on fallout 2? It was great, minus some flaws. Wasn't as good as fallout 1 and New Vegas but it was still a fantastic experience. It could've been a perfect sequel had the devs not been rushed.
Thanks for reading if you did.