Did anyone really wanted an explicit under the Highwind scene? Personally I do want them to have a canon moment of physical intimacy there, but like Lake Macalania in X I'd prefer it to be a tasteful allusion rather than going full R-18 like I The Witcher.
To clarify I don't mean exactly like Lake Macalania: the language of 3D visuals in AAA gaming evolved a lot since then and good as it is, the scene is kinda date in certain respects, but I cordially dislike the scenes in The Witcher merely on artistic terms: while the context around each sex scene is well curated and they sell the characters well, the models pantomiming sex, while the VA make their best impressions feels stiff and wrong.
Also, and I may be wrong on this, to truly sell Cloud and Tifa being two 20yo insecure virgins they would have to lean heavily on their insecurities and awkwardness, which, while I believe the team could go for, would probably be seen super controversial by people that see Cloud as a super badass and cry "woke" and "recon" every time the character who's designer defined as a "weak person" actually shows weakness and has to grow. This might not be a sticking point in a cloti community because I believe most of you do get that if they try to have sex and one of them freaks out it's 99% gonna be Cloud with Tifa pulling him back together, but believe you me, it's full of dumb people that see Cloud as the badass he likes to pretend he is.
This all reminds me of my favorite explicit scene in media, Guts and Casca sex scene in the chapter Wounds of Berserk. It completely leans on their vulnerabilities and their trauma, Guts has a mental breakdown in the middle of it, she helps him, and there is a lot of true chemistry, intimacy and warmth through. It is an absolute work of art that should be studied in schools, if anything to demistify a lot of young men's misconceptions about sex.
And I would love to see something like that with Cloud and Tifa but I just don't feel like the 3D graphics would do it justice: part of the art is in the delicate illustration of the late Miura and, while the retrilogy team has demonstrated an impressive mastery of displaying emotion in 3D animations, I don't believe it would really work that well in 3D, it would still feel like a pantomime of the real thing instead of an artistic rendering, call it uncanny valley effect if you want...
TL;DR I hope they don't coward out of them getting canonically intimate but I think not going too much out there is the right call.