r/cosmererpg • u/SarahSpatuladen • 12h ago
Game Questions & Advice Have some questions as a new GM running [Stonewalkers] Spoiler
Here’s the main questions without context for the TL;DR, since I ended up writing a lot…
TL;DR; New GM running Stonewalkers for 5 players (4 new to Stormlight). Looking for advice on:
- Combat length: Fights take up to 2 hours. How do you speed them up, and keep track of NPCs?
- Creative actions: Players get stuck after attacking. How do you help them use the other options during their turn in fun and creative ways?
- Rules questions: How do you get players to know their own mechanics without being their encyclopedia?
- Tangents: How do you handle off-script ideas and questions without railroading or breaking the story?
- Plot die: How do you come up with good opportunities and complications?
- Challenge vs. creativity: How do you keep pushback meaningful while still rewarding clever ideas?
---
This is my first time GMing, but I've played D&D for a number of years. I'm a big Stormlight fan and have read all the books. One of my players has too, but the rest are brand new to it.
We've done Bridge 9 and the first step, and just completed chapter 2 of Stonewalkers. I'd love any insight on the difficulties I'm running into.
We're admittedly a large group, with 5 players. I know some of my struggles come from that, especially as a new GM, but we're all good friends and the challenge is worth it to me.
A lot of my hesitation around improvising, and letting players get crazy with their ideas, is that I don't have the experience yet to be sure I won't accidentally spoil the story or badly break the game balance. To be clear, I don't want to limit my players' ingenuity or their desire to have fun. I just want to maintain flow, continuity, and engaging conflict.
## Combat
- Our combat scenes take a really long time, sometimes up to 2 hours, even when they're not overly complex. I know group size and being new to the system are factors, and I sometimes struggle to keep track of all the NPCs and choose their actions. Has anyone else found combat slow, and did you find anything that helped it move faster or more smoothly?
- My players, and sometimes myself, struggle to find creative actions beyond the typical attack, heal, defend. They're often stumped on what to do after they attack, and seem a bit discouraged or frustrated by feeling limited. Any tips for helping them enjoy the options?
- I'm often bombarded mid-combat with mechanics questions, some of which I feel players could look up or already know. I'm happy to help with complex ones, but being a full-on encyclopedia for everyone eats up time. Players also often forget things on their turn, like adding the right modifiers, which dice to roll, or rolling both at the same time. They're my friends and I want us to learn together, up to a point. Has anyone found a good-natured way to get players to focus up, pay attention, and know their shit a little better?
## Storytelling
- Because I'm new, I've been open with my players that I'm using a module since I'm not yet comfortable coming up with stories and characters on my own. They sometimes get hellbent on a tangent, or misunderstand something I've read aloud and veer off course, or ask questions that jump several steps ahead of where we are. I'm not always sure how to respond, either as an NPC or as GM. I don't want to railroad, and I don't want a free-for-all with no interesting conflict or pushback. I know improvising is a big part of GMing, but I don't yet have the skill to avoid breaking the story if I go too far with it.
## Mechanics/Gameplay
- Plot die: I've seen posts about using the plot die at dramatic moments and asking players what outcome they'd like or expect. I find myself avoiding it because it's hard to come up with opportunities/complications that are more than just an opportunity on the roll. I think this will come with experience, but advice is still appreciated.
## Table management
- We're all friends, so there's no drama. My struggle is keeping challenge and conflict fun. It sometimes feels like my players think that because they asked a question or attempted something, they're entitled to the outcome they want. How do you balance challenge and conflict while still rewarding creativity, ingenuity, and playfulness?
---
TL;DR; New GM running Stonewalkers for 5 players (4 new to Stormlight). Looking for advice on:
- Combat length: Fights take up to 2 hours. How do you speed them up, and keep track of NPCs?
- Creative actions: Players get stuck after attacking. How do you help them use the other options during their turn in fun and creative ways?
- Rules questions: How do you get players to know their own mechanics without being their encyclopedia?
- Tangents: How do you handle off-script ideas and questions without railroading or breaking the story?
- Plot die: How do you come up with good opportunities and complications?
- Challenge vs. creativity: How do you keep pushback meaningful while still rewarding clever ideas?
---