r/criterion • • 22h ago

Discussion Why blind buy when you can preview most popular movies streaming first?

0 Upvotes

I see so many posts asking the community about what is worth blind buying and crowdsourcing purchase recommendations. However, I’ve noticed that so many of the repeated recommendations are already available on mainstream streaming apps, in particular HBO Max (via their extensive TCM/Criterion collection library) but also occasionally Tubi, etc. Why don’t people take a month subscription trial period of HBO or the Criterion app itself and watch the numerous films already available? For most people, it’s not feasible to purchase and then flex on the internet for fake popularity points by posting pics of their $4,000 physical media collection of 200+ Criterion Collection bluray/4k uhd movies. There are legitimate films that are often not available to stream on the popular apps, but the top 20 or so that are constantly bragged about on this sub are absolutely available on HBO. And the worst part about brags about purchasing the physical copies on this forum is that 90%+ don’t even discuss the extras. That’s literally the main reason why I purchase the physical copies. I love the commentaries, the deleted scenes, the documentaries, the specials on how the sets were constructed and visual effects were implemented, etc.


r/criterion • • 1h ago

Discussion Wild at Heart 4k

• Upvotes

I just got my 4k copy of Wild at Heart and noticed the blu ray is only the special features. Am I wrong? Criterion has usually given us both a 4k and the Blu Ray editions of the same film, wondering why this is different


r/criterion • • 10h ago

Discussion I have to think Criterion are prioritizing 4K titles that don't already have easily available UHD releases elsewhere in the world.

0 Upvotes

Does anyone think it's possible that certain Criterion titles like Army of Shadows, Double Life of Veronique, the Jean Vigo films, and Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie haven't gotten UHDs from Criterion(yet), because they already have more than serviceable UHD releases in the UK/EU that are English-friendly, meaning Criterion feels the global market is probably not big enough to support competing 4K releases of those titles?

Shoot the Piano Player has a French UHD, but it's not English-friendly. Other than the Criterion, Midnight Cowboy only has a prohibitively expensive Australian import from Imprint. Parasite and Silence of the Lambs are popular enough mainstream titles that they'll sell no matter how many times they get rereleased. I'd argue the same is true of Kurosawa titles.

Just my two cents.


r/criterion • • 22h ago

Discussion Terry Gilliam or Guillermo del Toro? Who do you prefer?

0 Upvotes

If you were to pick who you prefer a bit more over the other and are honest with yourself? I love both directors but Gilliam is my man. He worked in eight films that I obsess over. And a good portion of those abandon the standard three act structure. In interviews he oscillates between being an eloquent speaker who knows his film history. To a barely contained lunatic bursting at the seams with ideas.

I just love this man and the wild movies he’s given us. At the same time if I were in the shoes of a producer I don’t know if I’d ever have the guts to give Gilliam money. You may have a cult hit on your hand or you may be burning your money for the sake of art.

Del Toro is the safer bet in that regard. While Gilliam has played nice with studios only a few times in his long career. Del Toro has always seemed more comfortable with filtering his endless imagination through the framework of a profitable venture. It allows him to navigate the Hollywood apparatus without requiring the Spanish director to get producers wine drunk enough to sign a new feature film.


r/criterion • • 7h ago

Discussion Criterions Policy with disc replacement when scratched?

0 Upvotes

I grabbed the big red box, and one of the discs has a very, very nasty scratch in it. See here https://imgur.com/a/vJg6sgi

The disc in question is the UHD for The Shining, probably the one that will get the most use out of the set...

I can go to Barnes & Noble and return it today and get a new box, possibly with its own issues, or I can contact them and ask for an individual replacement.

Do they have a track record for replacements like that? I had to condemn all the other discs in that box, because they're fine, but I really can't live with this huge nasty scratch.


r/criterion • • 17h ago

Collection That’s more like it.

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

I’m really new to criterion and it’s funny that this is how I found it.I wanted this movie and I found it and of course in its original packaging it looks like any other blu ray but I read it and said what the hell is the criterion collection,I know someone’s sells a custom art for this fitted for the normal criterion cases but i wanted to keep it original but still pay homage how it originally came so I went with the clear normal blu ray case and think it looks fantastic just wanted to share.


r/criterion • • 5h ago

Discussion False Hope

Post image
52 Upvotes

This absolutely rules, but I also hate it because there is no goddamn way that a24 is going to give up physical distro to Criterion after lighting their bank accounts on fire at Cannes to keep Club Kid out of Neon’s hands.

Other than it just looking and feeling correct to have a Club Kid Criterion beside my Araki trilogy I have a vendetta against a24 for the dogshit Lionsgate POD release of Climax I paid way too much for and the totally generic blurays for Mother Mary and The Invite. I’m not looking forward to giving them money for their house Club Kid and Tony releases, lol.

Anyway, Club Kid is in theatres nationwide. Go see it. It’s more than worth the hype.


r/criterion • • 21h ago

Pickup Recent Pick-Ups

Post image
16 Upvotes

I stopped buying movies for a few years, unfortunately. It was harder to justify finding physical media when I could stream it. Still, I kept virtually every DVD and Blu-Ray I’ve ever owned. Moving cities and states, finishing grad school, landing a career, and building a career along with a family became more important.

Also, skateboarding was on the back burner for too many years. That’s another story. I’m getting back to the things I love. I started off the year with a new sound system since I’ve been a big proponent of vinyl records since 2011. Even having the sound upgrade from my fiancée’s budget soundbar to Polk loudspeakers makes movies and shows more enjoyable.

  1. What is the first movie you plan to watch from your haul and why? -Barry Lyndon. I’ve had friends and an in-law recommend Barry Lyndon. Allegedly it’s a cinematic masterpiece and one of Kubrick’s more underrated films. I’m inclined to believe it.
  2. Is there anything from this haul that you have been looking forward to owning for a long time? -Most of this haul involves movies I started getting into during my mid-teens and early 20s. I’ve wanted a copy of American Psycho and A Clockwork Orange for 15+ years now.
  3. Are any of your purchases blind buys? If so, why did you select them? -Uncut Gems, Barry Lyndon, and Army of Darkness. My fiancée is a fan of Uncut Gems. It was recently removed from HBO, so now we own it. No hunting down a streaming service to watch it on. Barry Lyndon due to my love of every Kubrick movie I’ve seen and the favorable opinion towards the cinematography. Army of Darkness due to growing up with the Evil Dead (OG) and Evil Dead II.
  4. What is a Criterion you’re hoping to add to your collection next? -The Elephant Man, first and foremost.

Additionally, Wild at Heart, Pee-Wee’s Big Adventure, the Silence of the Lambs, the Royal Tenenbaums, Pink Flamingos, Full Metal Jacket, Do the Right Thing, Malcolm X, No Country for Old Men, the Qatsi trilogy, Stalker, Gummo, Videodrome, Scanners, and Crash are all on my list. Between this sale, the sale next spring, and the sale next fall, I should be able to knock most of these out. I will also likely continue to tweak the list based on availability and new additions.


r/criterion • • 18h ago

Pickup recent sale haul

Post image
18 Upvotes

honestly Isle of Dogs is likely the first i’ll watch.


r/criterion • • 23h ago

Pickup Took advantage of the sale...

Thumbnail
gallery
86 Upvotes

Picked up six today, the rest will be here soon! The only other Criterion dvd I own is a copy of Chasing Amy i bought from a thrift store. I ALMOST got the archive collection, but these covers are too magnificent to pass up. Also long live Bowie ⚡️


r/criterion • • 2m ago

Pickup New Barnes and Noble Haul

Post image
• Upvotes
  1. I plan to watch Marie Antoinette tonight
  2. Marie Antoinette’s been on my watchlist for forever
  3. They’re all blind buys. For the most part Criterion’s are new for me outside of stuff like KPop Demon Hunters and I’ve rarely been burnt.
  4. Super excited for Jay Kelly and hopefully the rumored Michael Clayton

r/criterion • • 1h ago

Discussion PSA: SONY UBP-X700 skipping errors? Try this and report back

• Upvotes

I've been seeing a LOT of comments on posts lately discussing disc skipping issues, and I feel like the people sharing these issues are often using 4k discs in the SONY UBP-X700.

With my own player, I came across this fix by a person on YouTube: https://youtu.be/Sym8ayOpL-4?si=Sy_KuVFGZes6Ge8N&t=176

From a comment below:

"Also, that guy’s video is crazy long. There are just 2 settings to tweak and they’re both in “Screen Settings”

4K Upscale Setting: Off
Cinema Conversion Mode: Video

That’s it. I’ve been in the habit of just changing the upscaling to Auto when I’m watching a Blu Ray and turning it back off when I’m watching 4K."

It has worked for me! In a couple replies, people have shared with me it worked for them! I don't understand the 'why' behind it, truthfully. (And neither did the video creator really lol.)

Maybe it will work for you? Give it a whirl and see if it fixes it. Let me know if you try it and it doesn't work so I know whether to keep sharing it when I see others with disc read problems and this player.

Ok, good luck.

EDIT TO ADD: Thanks to everyone chiming in. It seems to be a toss up whether these settings in particular solve the issue for people.


r/criterion • • 2h ago

Discussion Is there any logic to which movies get digipak releases instead of regular plastic cases?

7 Upvotes

I've always found it confusing that there doesn't seem to be any logic as to which movies get digipak releases. I have a lot of movies that easily could have just had a plastic case.The only digipak I have that seemed necessary was Vampyr because it came with it's screenplay. Most of the digipaks have regular length booklets. There's also some confusing choices like every lynch film being a digipak except for Inland empire.


r/criterion • • 4h ago

Discussion What Pierre Ètaix movie should I watch first?

2 Upvotes

Just got the DVD, what should I put on first? I was thinking either Yoyo or Got Your Health. Thank you!

Update: Watched the commentary that begins Yoyo, changed my mind, and watched The Suitor. Fantastic film!


r/criterion • • 21h ago

Discussion Wild at Heart UDH Clarification

2 Upvotes

I only have a Blu-Ray player, but typically purchase the UHD option of movies to acquire the Blu-Ray version but also to have the UHD if/when I decide to upgrade to UHD. Just received my wild at Heart UHD, but is the "Blu-Ray with the special features" truly only the special features without the movie? Trying not to return it if I don't have to, and don't want to open to test just in case I do need to return it. Thanks in advance!


r/criterion • • 5h ago

Criterion Channel City As Character & Time Capsule

Post image
19 Upvotes

Realized when I paused this movie how much I love films (most often found in The Criterion Collection or Criterion Channel) that feature world class motion picture photography of cities, and especially when it captures a period that's long past.

What are some titles to watch that can scratch this itch? Honestly, it does not have to be a prominent aspect of the film. I'd say most are simply establishing shots of the setting.

Anybody know what's featured in the screen grab?


r/criterion • • 2h ago

Pickup haul :)

Post image
11 Upvotes

from the toronto sale 😸


r/criterion • • 1h ago

Discussion Pornographic but not

• Upvotes

I'm looking for more movies like "In the Realm of the Senses."

I had seen it before years and years ago but thought I was blind buying it during this month's sale because I didn't remember the title of it. Now I'll never forget it. It's an amazing movie and I'm looking for more like it! Not horny pinku eiga movies or just movies with sex, but movies with really good stories and explicit nudity.

The fact that this film is social commentary springing from a real story and has absolutely wild moments but is also incredibly acted just blows me away....and there are blowjobs in it? So fascinating.

Any recs?

Also, any thoughts on this film are welcome!


r/criterion • • 1h ago

Discussion Anyone know if the Jacques Tati Blu Ray set will be restocked during the B&N sale?

• Upvotes

Does anyone have any ideas on the Tati Blu Ray set, I’ve been checking the Barnes and Noble app but since the sale started they’ve been out of stock except maybe in stores but no stores near me have it in stock. I’ve been hoping that they were going to restock it, but I just saw that StudioCanal is releasing a 4K boxset the first week of December. Also the Blu Ray set is currently unavailable on the Criterion website. Does this mean Criterion no longer has the rights to them?


r/criterion • • 12h ago

Discussion These were blind boys, and my god, they broke me.

Post image
150 Upvotes

I don’t see these two discussed much on here, so perhaps they’re super underrated but man, both films had me thinking deeply about life with a new perspective.

Both films started off so whimsical and so innocent, and all it took was one scene to completely shatter you and change your perspective on what you watched for 90% of the movie.

I’ll probably never stop thinking about these films for the rest of my life.


r/criterion • • 4h ago

Pickup My haul from the Criterion sale

Post image
15 Upvotes
  1. I gotta watch All That Heaven Allows cause it’s such a perfect autumn movie!
  2. I’ve been waiting to get True Stories for a while. It’s a comfort watch and the soundtrack is a go-to listen when I need a pick-me-up.
  3. No blind buys, although I haven’t seen the second Lady Snowblood but I loved the first one, so I’m looking forward to a double feature of those.
  4. Next will probably be The Night Porter. (love me some Dirk Bogarde)

r/criterion • • 22h ago

Pickup Drove to my local B&N to pick up Wild at Heart

Post image
46 Upvotes

Not a big haul this time around, but glad to finally add another David Lynch film to the collection :) excited to pop this in and enjoy this release in all its 4k glory


r/criterion • • 2h ago

Discussion B&N criterion sale.

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/criterion • • 14h ago

Pickup My latest criterion haul

Post image
19 Upvotes

I plan to watch Eraserhead first. I've been looking to own Eraserhead and especially night and Basqiat. Crash is my blindbuy, selected that one because James Spader is always in his kinky movies. I'm hoping to add some more David Lynch movies to the collection eventually.


r/criterion • • 22h ago

Collection Time to watch the start of the filmography of one of my favourite director‘s ever.

Thumbnail
gallery
54 Upvotes