I recently commented under a post asking 'how would you reboot the DCU?' and it got me thinking so here's my pitch. Firstly, no reboot. This franchise has had enough reboots and I think a total reset would kill it dead. I think my most controversial decision would be to scrap the Brave and the Bold, merge Matt Reeves' Batman into the DCU. I know people say "the tones don't match" and "there are no meta-humans in The Batman", but when the MCU started it was the exact same thing. Ironman didn't feature any super powers, gods or aliens, just a regular dude in a grounded world. Then just a few movies later we got Thor, who exists in a crazy sci fi world and holds immense power. Yet no one complained that those two characters existed in the same universe. So with that hurdle out of the way, here is my structure for the DCU going forward, building up to Blackest Night and Crisis on Infinite Earths.
Phase 1 (basically what we've currently got):
Blue Beetle -
Just canonise the movie since it already exists.
The Suicide Squad -
Same thing, just canonise it fully. If characters need to be recast, so what.
Peacemaker (TV) -
Cadmus takes down an alien threat with the help of Peacemaker and Vigilante.
The Batman -
Batman faces off against the Riddler, Penguin and the Falcone crime family with the help of Catwoman.
The Penguin (TV) -
Oswald Cobb becomes the biggest crime boss in Gotham.
Superman -
Superman faces off against a clone made by Lex Luthor with the help of the Justice Gang.
Peacemaker (TV): Earth X -
Peacemaker discovers the alternate Earth X and is sent to Salvation by Cadmus.
Supergirl -
Kara and Lobo race to save Krypto.
Lanterns (TV) -
John Stewart becomes the Green Lantern of Earth.
Clayface -
Matt Hagan goes on a murder spree after gaining shapeshifting powers.
Man of Tomorrow -
Superman, Supergirl and the Justice Gang take on Brainiac with the help of Wonder Woman and Green Lantern. Together they form the Justice League.
Phase 2:
Jimmy Olsen: The People V Gorilla Grodd (TV) -
Gorilla Grodd is put on trial for murder after being taken down by the Flash and is sent to Salvation.
The Batman: Court of Owls (The Batman Part II) -
With Gotham in chaos, Batman must untangle a web of corruption headed by the Court of Owls. He is aided by his close friend, Harvey Dent, who is horrifically scarred during a trial. Driven to madness, he causes the deaths of the flying Graysons. Feeling responsible, Bruce Wayne adopts an orphaned Dick Grayson.
Mr Miracle (TV) -
Mr Miracle escapes Darkseid and lives on Earth with Big Barda.
Wonder Woman: Paradise Lost -
Hercules and Cheetah find a motherbox and fall under the control of Granny Goodness who attempts to take over Themyscira. Wonder Woman stops their scheme with the help of Mr Miracle. Cheetah finds herself on Salvation and Hercules is redeemed as a hero.
Batman and Nightwing -
Nightwing and Batman go up against Bane and Deathstroke. After being almost killed by Bane, Batman realises he cannot fight alone and joins the Justice League.
Teen Titans: The Judas Contract -
Nightwing forms the Teen Titans, consisting of: Cyborg, Raven, Beast Boy, Starfire, Hawk, Dove, Donna Troy and Terra. Terra, under the employ of Deathstroke, betrays the team. Donna Troy and Hawk are killed. Deathstroke is defeated and sent to Salvation.
Lanterns (TV): Sinestro War -
Sinestro creates the Yellow Lantern. John Stewart and Guy Gardner take him down and send him to Salvation. Carol Ferris becomes Star Sapphire.
Peacemaker (TV): Salvation Run -
Peacemaker encounters Gorilla Grodd, Sinestro, Cheetah, Lex Luthor, and Deathstroke on Salvation. They form Legion of Doom and escape.
The Justice League V The Legion of Doom -
The Legion of Doom takes on the Justice League. A team comprised of: Superman, Wonder Woman, Batman, Green Lantern, Mr Terrific, and Hawkgirl.
Phase 3:
Lanterns (TV): Hellish Hate -
John Stewart faces off against the newly formed Red Lanterns with the help of Carol Ferris as they fight over a motherbox. Guy Gardner becomes a Red Lantern.
Booster Gold (TV) -
A loser from the future goes back in time to be a superhero. He becomes friends with Blue Beetle and their scrappy duo competes with Wally West to take on the Rogues.
Jimmy Olsen (TV): The Atlantis Accords -
Due to rising global tensions, Aquaman meets with various world leaders to come to an accord and is shot by Bloodsport, hired by Vandal Savage. Jimmy Olsen investigates to uncover who shot the King of Atlantis.
Wonder Woman V Aquaman -
After a failed assassination attempt against Aquaman, Atlantis goes to war with the land dwellers. The Amazons step in. Wonder Woman and Aquaman clash before realising they've been manipulated by Vandal Savage.
Superman: Apokolips -
Darkseid comes to Earth for his motherboxes but is stopped by Superman, Wonder Woman, Aquaman and Mr Miracle. Supergirl is killed by Darkseid. They expand the Justice League from a team to a global organisation run from the Watchtower. Expanding the roster to: Superman, Wonder Woman, Batman, Green Lantern, The Flash, Mr Terrific, Hawk Girl, Booster Gold, Mr Miracle, Big Barda, Hercules, Blue Beetle, Martian Manhunter, Green Arrow, Orion, aided by the Teen Titans.
Lanterns (TV): The War of Light -
John Stewart, Carol Ferris, Guy Gardner, Sinestro and Atrocitus encounter Blackhand. Kyle Rayner has replaced Guy as Green Lantern. Guy dies in heroic sacrifice.
The Batman: Death in the Family -
Batman adopts Jason Todd and goes up against Clayface, Joker, Penguin and Two Face with the help of Catwoman and Nightwing. Jason Todd is tragically killed by the Joker.
The Trinity -
On Superman's birthday, Wonder Woman and Batman go to the fortress of solitude to find Superman in the grasp of an alien plant that gives him his greatest desires while sucking his life force. Wonder Woman faces off against Mongol while Batman tries to free Superman.
Justice League: Blackest Night -
Blackhand resurrects dead heroes and villains with the power of the Black Lantern Corp. Both the Justice League, Teen Titans, and Legion of Doom must team up to prevent the death of all life on Earth. Kyle Rayner becomes the first White Lantern to defeat Nekron. Blackhand's army includes: Guy Gardner, Hal Jordan, Abin Sur, Hawkman, Sinestro, Jay Garrick, Ted Kord, Supergirl, Terra, White Dragon, Hawk, Donna Troy, dead members of the Suicide Squad, and Jason Todd.
Phase 4:
Jimmy Olsen (TV): Who is the Last Martian? -
Investigative reporter Jimmy Olsen interviews Martian Manhunter to uncover the lost history of Mars and the war between the green and white Martians.
Constantine (TV) -
Something, something, demons...
The Flash: Race Against Time -
Wally West goes on an adventure through time to stop a mysterious speedster from the future from causing havoc. He encounters a younger Barry Allen before his disappearance and together they meet the Justice Society of America, a younger Vandal Savage, and Wonder Woman. The speedster is revealed to be none other than the Reverse Flash. Barry dies in the final battle, revealing why he went missing all those years ago.
Mr Freeze (TV): Heart of Ice -
Victor Fries turns to crime in a desperate bid to save his wife from a terminal illness while she is kept in cryostasis.
Aquaman: Heir to Atlantis -
Aquaman must protect his newborn son during an attempted coup by Ocean Master. To save his son he is forced to cut off his own arm. Idk, I don't really care about Aquaman.
Shazam V Black Adam -
Pretty self explanatory.
The Batman: Under the Red Hood -
A mysterious criminal known as the Red Hood causes havoc in Gotham. With the help of a young Batgirl, Batman uncovers the truth and learns that Jason Todd is alive and seeking revenge. Ultimately, Jason is forced to reconcile with Bruce to rescue Barbara from the Joker, culminating in a showdown between the three.
Teen Titans: Terror of Trigon -
The Titans go up against Trigon with the help of Constantine and Doctor Fate.
The Suicide Squad: Tower of Babel -
After the events of Blackest Night, Amanda Waller has been granted permission to reform Task Force X. Their first mission: kill the Justice League. Lead by Vandal Savage, the team steals Batman's contingency plans against the Justice League's strongest members. With the multiversal technology confiscated from Peacemaker, they manage to trap the Justice League in an alternate universe.
Justice League: Crisis on Earth Two -
The Justice League are pulled into Earth Two, a warped version of their own reality that is ruled by the Crime Syndicate. Their leader is none other than Ultraman, the evil clone of Superman. During the conflict, Ultraman punches a hole in reality, causing an anti-matter wave to sweep across the multiverse.
Justice League: Crisis on Infinite Earths -
The fate of all reality is at stake. Heroes from across the multiverse must fight to prevent the destruction of their universes. CAMEOS GALORE from the many previous adaptations of this franchise across the years. Given no other choice, the Flash goes back in time to ensure Ultraman is never sent to Earth 2. The movie ends on a cliffhanger.
Phase 5:
The Flash: Flashpoint -
Wally West wakes up in a restored Earth Prime, but all is not as it seems. His alteration of the timeline has rippled through history. He has no powers, Superman is nowhere to be seen, Batman is a cold-blooded killer, Aquaman and Wonder Woman are at war, the Justice League does not exist. With the help of Thomas Wayne, Wally reclaims his speed, however he is unable to go back in time to fix the timeline due to something siphoning his speed force.
Jimmy Olsen: On the Ground with Lois Lane (TV) -
In the alternate timeline where the world is on the brink of destruction, Lois Lane and Jimmy Olsen document the escapades of heroes like Cyborg, Shazam and Captain Slade Wilson in their attempts to fend off the armies of Atlantis and Themyscira. They uncover a superweapon that uses the body of Captain Atom.
To be continued...
Then from there I'm imagining a couple projects set in the Flashpoint timeline before Wally has a final showdown with Reverse Flash, allowing him to go back in time to try again. Full reboot, new universe, new cast. Classic DC maneuver. By the end of it all we have a complete Batman saga and Bat Family, a Superman trilogy, two Wonder Woman movies, Two Suicide Squads, Two Teen Titans, Two Flash movies, a comprehensive Green Lantern series, and a handful of other projects that shed light on some smaller scale stories I'd like to see.