r/decomps
•
u/Xarishark
•
20h ago
Technical discussion An open letter to recomp/decomp devs: can we agree on a few basics?
Hey everyone,
I’m the lead dev of RecompLauncher.
First I want to say that I love where we’ve arrived as a community. In my wildest dreams I never thought we’d be playing so many exclusive games natively on our PCs, in the best versions they’ve ever been. So before anything else, thank you all for what you’ve given the community ❤️❤️❤️
Every day I’m working to support as many of your projects as I can, and I try to send changes that make them better both for the devs and the players.
We’ve reached a point where the recomp/decomp scene needs some shared standards, so everyone has the same base to work from. Right now it’s a bit of a wild west, and players and devs both pay for it.
Here’s what I’m asking:
1. Ship one executable.
The most important of all by far! I keep seeing projects ship a builder exe that then builds the game exe. Please stop doing this. I get it: you can’t ship the final exe with the game code inside it. But your launcher can still detect that the game is already built in a folder and drop the player straight into it on the next launch or even provide a simple play button that is not tied to another binary. LostOdysseyRecomp does exactly this. It works perfectly, and I wish more projects copied it.
2. Make portable the default.
Do all your work in the folder your executable lives in. For AppImages, let us pass one directory and keep everything inside it. You’re not an installed app with an MSI and a proper uninstaller, so please don’t scatter files across the user’s home folder and other places only you know about. When someone deletes your folder, the game should be gone.
3. Ship a tarball next to your AppImage.
AppImages are great and you should keep shipping them. But most people playing your projects are on recent systems, and a plain tarball lets launchers like ours deploy your game even from inside the Flatpak sandbox instead of doing hacks like extracting appimages.
4. Add a CLI flag for everything.
Fullscreen, ROM path, build folder, all of it. It costs almost nothing in code and helps everyone. I know a lot of you put real work into your launchers. But when every game has its own launcher with its own quirks, a player who wants to try a few games has to learn each one. With flags, we can get your players into the game as fast as possible.
5. Please consider the penguin🐧!
Some of you know me as a Bazzite dev so I have to ask for this. Native Linux builds go a long way, and the Linux gaming crowd will love you for it. Do us a favor and where possible release native linux builds. Its easy to test them on CI and VMs.
6. Not sure how to do something? Just ask.
If you’re not sure how to do any of this, or anything else, ask before you spend a weekend on it. Our Discord already has a dev channel just for this, and a lot of devs use it every day to ask questions, bounce ideas around, or ask us how to do something. Don’t be shy. Come hang out with us instead of trying random things you’ll end up rewriting later.
None of this is meant as a complaint. I want to make things easier for players and save you from tech debt we all have to deal with later. If you have thoughts or objections, or you want help adding any of this to your project, comment here. I’m happy to help.
Thanks for everything you build, and I truly appreciate you all 🍻To a future where every game has a native decomp/recomp of its own!






