remember when glinda asked dorothy if she was a good witch or a bad witch??? well, i think we need to start asking celebrities a similar question. are you a good diva, or are you a bad diva??? because apparently we’ve completely lost the plot on what being a diva even means. LMFAOOOO 😭💖
to me, being a diva isn’t about being the most famous woman in the room, having the biggest fanbase, or getting everybody to worship the ground u walk on. it’s about being authentically urself, knowing ur worth, minding ur damn business, & being a boss ass bitch without needing to make everybody else’s life miserable in the process. but somewhere along the way, we’ve started confusing having an enormous ego with having an enormous amount of talent, & being successful with actually being somebody worth celebrating.
& i think the way we discuss female celebrities is a PERFECT example of how fucked up our standards have become. 😭 why is it that there’s seemingly only ever room for ONE woman to be celebrated at a time??? why does everybody else have to be compared to her, criticized for not being her, or treated like they’re somehow less deserving of recognition??? & why do the standards magically change depending on which woman we’re talking about???
take taylor swift & beyoncé, for example. why are we constantly comparing two women who have completely different artistic strengths, performance styles, & approaches to music??? beyoncé is an exceptionally skilled vocalist & performer, while taylor’s appeal is much more rooted in songwriting & storytelling. so what exactly are we comparing here??? 😭 if we’re gonna compare artists, can we at least compare people based on what they actually DO??? & can we acknowledge how weird it is that black female artists are so frequently expected to demonstrate an entirely different level of technical excellence just to receive the same recognition???
meanwhile, rihanna apparently can’t sing because she’s occasionally inconsistent live, even though the woman very obviously CAN sing. tori kelly can sing her fucking face off, but apparently she’s boring because she sings about god too much. victoria justice barely got the opportunity to establish herself independently before everybody decided she was the boring one compared to ariana grande. LMFAOOOO. so which is it??? do we care about vocal ability? personality? originality? performance? because every time a different woman enters the conversation, somebody moves the fucking goalpost.
& that’s what gets me about celebrity worship in general. people will excuse practically anything when it’s somebody they’ve already decided deserves to be on top, but they’ll nitpick the most ridiculous things about somebody they don’t particularly care for. some celebrities get endless grace for genuinely questionable behavior, meanwhile another woman could mind her business for twenty years & still get dragged because somebody decided she’s boring. 😭
& yes, ariana grande is somebody i personally think has benefited from that culture of selective accountability. i have plenty of criticisms about her public controversies surrounding cultural appropriation, relationships, & beauty standards, but this isn’t exclusively about her. it’s about WHY we decide certain celebrities deserve to be defended from every criticism while others can’t even get recognition for their actual talents.
because this stuff DOES affect real people. when celebrities promote unrealistic beauty standards or aren’t transparent about cosmetic procedures, ordinary people can end up comparing themselves to appearances that cost thousands of dollars to maintain. when fans dismiss discussions about cultural appropriation or harmful behavior because their favorite celebrity is involved, what message are we sending about whose experiences actually matter???
& every single time somebody brings up these conversations, somebody else comes running in to announce that it’s not that deep. BITCH, IT’S ALWAYS BEEN THAT DEEP. 😭😭😭 we’re talking about the way society decides which behaviors are acceptable, which people deserve admiration, & whose concerns are worth listening to. culture doesn’t exist in some magical little vacuum where nothing has consequences. the things we repeatedly excuse eventually become the things we normalize, & then everybody acts shocked when those attitudes show up elsewhere in society.
i just think we’ve gotten entirely too comfortable treating fame as a substitute for character, & popularity as proof that somebody deserves to be celebrated. why can’t we appreciate women like tori kelly, victoria justice, rihanna, kehlani, or whoever else for what they individually bring to the table without constantly needing to establish which one is superior??? why does appreciating one woman’s talent apparently require us to invalidate somebody else’s???
& that’s the whole point of the good diva versus bad diva distinction. the good diva doesn’t need everybody else to be beneath her to know she’s THAT girl. she can be talented, successful, unapologetically herself, & still recognize that other people matter. the bad diva mentality is when admiration turns into entitlement, accountability becomes persecution, & everybody else’s experiences suddenly stop mattering because somebody’s ego needs protecting.
& to be clear, i’m not saying being a good diva means being some flawless little angel who’s never made a mistake. LMFAOOOO. i’m saying there’s a difference between having confidence & thinking the world revolves around u, just like there’s a difference between being iconic & simply being impossible to criticize.
so maybe we should stop asking which woman deserves to be THE diva, & start asking what qualities we’re actually celebrating in the first place.
because honey, having a crown doesn’t automatically mean u deserve to wear it. 💖