r/DMAcademy • u/Several-Gas-4053 • 5h ago
Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Should i have foreshadowed that the party made the worst decision?
So the party (3 people, an elementalist beastmaster, demonologist and dreamwalker) had been spending a few months in a Farmstead (is more like a farmer settlement rather than a farmstead with one family). In those months they discovered a plot of shapeshifters and found multiple inhabitants that were possessed by demons. They saved the village, made connections, developed survival and economic skills.
And then a demon invasion started to the far north of the village, and the team had three clear options; Go north and help a god fend of the invasion, Go west and help protect the villagers that are fleeing towards the nearest walled settlements. Or go east and dip.
Because they chose to go north and help the Goddess fend of the invasion (which was a week's journey) they arrive to find the Goddess having an easy time not letting demons pass through a portal. And the goddess asks them what they do there, they were asked to protect the villagers. Their reasoning was; we can protect the villagers if we avoid the demons from reaching the village. Only for them to be send back, and find that the fleeing villagers were captured and used for a ritual to open another demon gate. They pretty much find the entire town slaughtered.
Now, the moment itself was very impactful. But afterwards, they told me i didn't give enough hints about them making a wrong decision. Even though i dropped hints of another ritual being prepared all over the town, they just didn't connect the dots.
should i have given more hints? Should i have nudged them a little bit? Should I have laid out the results of their choices more clearly?
don't get me wrong, they enjoy the campaign, and they kept playing and even told me that it was the first time there were real stakes, and started playing more carefully. But the gnawing feeling that i should have told them a little bit more sticks with me.
edit: after reading some reactions it seems clear i wasn't clear about something; I re-read my post now and was unclear in one thing; the goddess had already said "she got it" and already send a messenger. They decided they would go north because they couldn't contact her anymore (as she was in continuous battle).
They had seen her in battle before, and even though they witnessed something awe-inspiring, they were told that she was holding back so they wouldn't get hurt in her defense. I thought i had set it up pretty clearly that even though she was a physical being, she deserved the title of Goddess.
second edit: The main opponent of the campaign is a group of shapeshifters, so i would think that paying attention to the acting of the DM would be important, as that is how i give the hints without making it too obvious.