r/DMAcademy • • 3d ago

Mega Player Problem Megathread

4 Upvotes

This thread is for DMs who have an out-of-game problem with a PLAYER (not a CHARACTER) to ask for help and opinions. Any player-related issues are welcome to be discussed, but do remember that we're DMs, not counselors.

Off-topic comments including rules questions and player character questions do not go here and will be removed. This is not a place for players to ask questions.


r/DMAcademy • • 3d ago

"First Time DM" and Short Questions Megathread

17 Upvotes

Most of the posts at DMA are discussions of some issue within the context of a person's campaign or DMing more generally. But, sometimes a DM has a question that is very small and doesn't really require an extensive discussion so much as it requires one good answer. In other cases, the question has been asked so many times that having the sub rehash the discussion over and over is not very useful for subscribers. Sometimes the answer to a short question is very long or the answer is also short but very important.

Short questions can look like this:

  • Where do you find good maps?
  • Can multi-classed Warlocks use Warlock slots for non-Warlock spells?
  • Help - how do I prep a one-shot for tomorrow!?
  • First time DM, any tips?

Many short questions (and especially First Time DM inquiries) can be answered with a quick browse through the DMAcademy wiki, which has an extensive list of resources as well as some tips for new DMs to get started.


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Should i have foreshadowed that the party made the worst decision?

18 Upvotes

So the party (3 people, an elementalist beastmaster, demonologist and dreamwalker) had been spending a few months in a Farmstead (is more like a farmer settlement rather than a farmstead with one family). In those months they discovered a plot of shapeshifters and found multiple inhabitants that were possessed by demons. They saved the village, made connections, developed survival and economic skills.

And then a demon invasion started to the far north of the village, and the team had three clear options; Go north and help a god fend of the invasion, Go west and help protect the villagers that are fleeing towards the nearest walled settlements. Or go east and dip.

Because they chose to go north and help the Goddess fend of the invasion (which was a week's journey) they arrive to find the Goddess having an easy time not letting demons pass through a portal. And the goddess asks them what they do there, they were asked to protect the villagers. Their reasoning was; we can protect the villagers if we avoid the demons from reaching the village. Only for them to be send back, and find that the fleeing villagers were captured and used for a ritual to open another demon gate. They pretty much find the entire town slaughtered.

Now, the moment itself was very impactful. But afterwards, they told me i didn't give enough hints about them making a wrong decision. Even though i dropped hints of another ritual being prepared all over the town, they just didn't connect the dots.

should i have given more hints? Should i have nudged them a little bit? Should I have laid out the results of their choices more clearly?

don't get me wrong, they enjoy the campaign, and they kept playing and even told me that it was the first time there were real stakes, and started playing more carefully. But the gnawing feeling that i should have told them a little bit more sticks with me.

edit: after reading some reactions it seems clear i wasn't clear about something; I re-read my post now and was unclear in one thing; the goddess had already said "she got it" and already send a messenger. They decided they would go north because they couldn't contact her anymore (as she was in continuous battle).

They had seen her in battle before, and even though they witnessed something awe-inspiring, they were told that she was holding back so they wouldn't get hurt in her defense. I thought i had set it up pretty clearly that even though she was a physical being, she deserved the title of Goddess.

second edit: The main opponent of the campaign is a group of shapeshifters, so i would think that paying attention to the acting of the DM would be important, as that is how i give the hints without making it too obvious.


r/DMAcademy • • 3h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics A spell that can create coal.

7 Upvotes

Hi, I’m going to be running my first one shot and wanted it to be themed on a runaway steam train. The engine would run with water and coal for fuel and obviously we have the create water spell to explain for constantly producing water. But I’m stuck on the coal, as I can’t imagine something like fabricate or creation spells to be able to continuously produce it.

If anyone has any suggestions that would be appreciated!

EDIT - Sorry probably should’ve added this in the OG post, the overproduction of coal is the reason the train goes haywire and starts going too fast (think Speed the Movie) and eventually I want to have the final boss of the one shot to be a monster formed of this coal at the engine of the train. I have the idea set down for the campaign but scratching my head over a spell - if not might have to homebrew


r/DMAcademy • • 7h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding At what point am I imposing my will on my players?

11 Upvotes

Hey everyone! First time DM here! (Actually first time DnD player at all) I had a question for the more experienced out there.

Some backstory, a small group of friends and I discussed interest in getting into DnD even though none of us have played before. Me being the most knowledgeable of the game (I went through a big DnD phase during COVID, just didn’t have the friends to play it with) I agreed to DM our first campaign. Here’s my issue: our campaign doesn’t start for a month or so to give me some prep time, I plan on trying to get them to make their characters sooner rather than later. However, I’ve already have a good idea for the general story. They’ll be starting off in a town that’s mostly human/halfing with small percentages of dwarves/elves/etc. But now that I’m thinking about it, there are some choices they could make during character creation that wouldn’t work with my story. For example, say they all decided they wanted to play Dragonborn. In my story, most of the Dragonborn have been called to their homeland due to a civil war, and having a group of them in this human settlement just wouldn’t make sense. I could work in one Dragonborn, maybe even two. But then I’m A: Imposing my wants onto their characters backgrounds B: Basically telling the party that only a couple of them get to play the race they want.

My main concern is player freedom and them having a good time. But I also don’t want to have to completely rework the story if they make choices during character creation thag don’t complement it. I don’t think there are many choices they could make that would affect my story in such a way, but based off the horror stories I’ve heard from other DMs I wouldn’t be shocked if they manage to make said choices. Sorry for the rant I guess I’m just not sure if it’s appropriate for me to ask my players if we could workshop their backstories together if need be. Am I already wrong for having a story prepped out without knowing their characters? Expert DMs please help me.


r/DMAcademy • • 2h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Players unable to (easily) communicate to npc, need some ideas to fix this situation

2 Upvotes

My players befriended a spider, this spider will become important later down the road, my issue is that only one of the players have speak with animals as spell and he out of character has told me he is planning on using it every time they encounter the spider. I don't really want him to burn a spell slot every single time, but I also don't really know how to make it so he doesn't have to. I do want them to keep being friends with the spider and everything cuz I am planning on having it betray them later on. We are currently playing a bunch of oneshots and will start lost mines of padelver in a few weeks, I wanted to connected the random oneshots with the campaign, which is why I introduced the spider to them.

Does anyone have any ideas on how to go about this situation?

ETA: I got adviced against having the spider itself betray them and rather have the bad guy switching the spider to avoid having players never trusting npc's again and I will be making it into a being switched scenario


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures What's the final moment of your campaign?

16 Upvotes

I'm about to have the last session of a 2-year campaign, and I'm wondering what the final moment should be.

As I currently have it planned, after the party defeats the BBEG, they celebrate with their friends, then the Queen gives each of them a reward from a grateful kingdom.

And then I'm not sure what to do. It seems pretty anticlimactic to have the Queen give out the last individual reward, and then I say, "Okay, that's it. Campaign's over."

I feel like I need some final button, scene, or moment to be the ultimate conclusion of the campaign.

What are some final moments you've used at the end of a campaign that you thought worked well?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Are ”an innumerable amount of rats” a threat to a party of lvl 10’s?

150 Upvotes

Like the title says, I’m reworking an old one shot I had for a much lower leveled party where rats are the main theme. However now I’m struggling to see how any amount of rats really pose a risk to a party of level tens. How can I keep the rats while making them enough of a threat that the party would likely try to avoid them?


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Skull Lord

3 Upvotes

I have a 5.5 WotC adventure I’m running on Friday that features two death knights. Instead, I plan to swap one out for a skull lord for some variety. The party will have 5-6 level 13 pcs. The skull lord will have 6 flaming skeleton friends.

Do you have thoughts on the Skull Lord? I have the Monsters of the Multiverse version, which seems 5.5 adjacent, but would you change it in any way? Am I correct that there is no 5.5 version of this monster? Should I upgrade the quality of the undead it summons to account for the CR downgrade from the death knight? Any other advice?

I’ve read the The Monsters Know What They’re Doing entry, but it seems like it’s for an obsolete stat block. Still, the general strategy seems sound.


r/DMAcademy • • 15m ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Question regarding trade goods in the DMG (5.5e)

1 Upvotes

The 2024 DMG lists a bunch of items to be used as rewards instead of just money, saying that the party can sell these items for their respective value. For example, 1 pound of ginger is worth 1 GP, and 1 square yard of cotton cloth is worth 5 SP.

But the PHB says that items can be sold for half their value in GP (round down). So, what is the ruling on the price of trade goods?

If 1 pound of ginger is worth 1 GP, then selling that pound of ginger should only yield 5 SP, since you can only sell items for half their value. But if the selling price of ginger is 1 GP, then that means buying ginger costs 2 GP.

Which is it?


r/DMAcademy • • 10h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Help Building A Monster - A Shambling Corpse That Gets Stronger

5 Upvotes

For an upcoming encounter, I had a particular idea. Essentially, imagine a corpse reanimated by a dark god, its body held together by a massive tangle of writhing metal wires. When the corpse is damaged, the body breaks apart, and the metal wires burst out, attacking folks around it, on top of what the corpse still attempts to do.

I want a monster like this to attack my party, which's a group of six level 8s. I'm not against giving this monster backup to help it defeat the party, since it'd otherwise be 1 against 6. For backup, ideally I'd want them to invoke ideas of body horror.

Any suggestions on how to build this creature?


r/DMAcademy • • 17h ago

Need Advice: Other Feels like i have a hard time "Keeping Focused" as a DM

13 Upvotes

I know its sacrilege to say this but one thing I really envy about live play DMs is their ability to maintain focus and well.. let scenes play out with poking their nose in it.

I often feel like when I DM I lose focus of the core timeline, and too easily throw away the game flow for a joke.

Such as leaving character as a NPC to join in a joke the player said, or speak above the table. It's often in excitement and joy but I cant help to feel the game would run smoother and MUCH more consistently if I could keep focus on the scenes and maintain better NPC consistency across sessions...

I dont want my party to feel like a person they met a week ago suddenly changed drastically the next session because me as the DM struggles to recapture that NPC


r/DMAcademy • • 12h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Advice on what to use as a set piece?

5 Upvotes

Hey y'all, I'm prepping for my party to eventually find and raid the evil cult who is hiding in a secret part of the withering wood. I have loose ideas, but what I'm lost on is inspiration or what the hideout of the evil cult even is.

Some bits of context first. The evil cult escaped from what was basically an elf Aztec empire that worshipped the sun, and after a big civil war the cult was led by a fanatic of the princess who wanted to be as radiant as she was (princess was secretly a demigod). They fled using tunnels that spanned across the ocean and into a foreign land, finding themselves in a deep part of the withering wood. The withering wood is a forest that is constantly in a state of decay, but is abundant in spirits who are invisible to the naked eye. The cult has a magic ritual dagger that when used to carve a creature's heart out of their body, can grant the consumer a trait or ability of the original creature. There's more to this but it's not necessary.

The ideas I want there are that the cult leader is some form of chimera who had quite a few hearts, and acts as the final boss and there would be some sort of menagerie or prison for creatures they've captured and plan on eventually sacrificing.

I had a thought of a wooden pyramid, but I'm not really sure how practical that would be for a dungeon/hideout. What are other things I could do, and what's the best?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Other Help me learn from your mistakes - What DM lessons did you learn the hard way?

177 Upvotes

I'm gearing up to DM my first campaign and I really want to provide enough challenge that my players feel happy when they escape/defeat foes/achieve milestones. I want them to have fun, but also want there to be consequences for murder-hoboing. I want the world to feel real with high stakes, high adventure, and devious enemies.

So lay it on me, vets. What do you wish you knew when you started? And what did you have to learn the hard way?


r/DMAcademy • • 18h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Need some help with BBEG motivation

7 Upvotes

I'm building a new long campaign while my group finishes a narrative-heavy mini campaign, and I'm struggling to find a decent motivation for the BBEG to be evil. I know who I want it to be, and I know some of how he is going to achieve his aims, I just can't seem to figure out an endgame that is interesting and not overdone.

Short version (in case my players see this - Go away "Long Way North"ers!) is the inciting request for the campaign comes from a person whose bloodline tasks him with protecting an artifact that, if unleashed, would doom the world. It unnaturally lengthens his life but also slowly drives him mad with greed, causing the protection to wane as he uses the leaking power to accumulate riches, people, and power.

Any suggestions for what he wants to get out of abdicating his responsibility and trying to take control of the artifact? Ruling the world seems so hackneyed. Lichdom feels overplayed (and I may use liches in different part of the campaign). Can it really be as simple as "I want more, and my boundless avarice will not be sated even if I extract everything of value from the entire world, nay, the planes themselves"?


r/DMAcademy • • 19h ago

Need Advice: Other DM screen wishlist from a woodworker

9 Upvotes

Greetings, all. Hope I'm in the right place. I'm a freelance woodworker who has been commissioned to make a DM screen as a gift, and as such i can't ask the recipient directly what features they would like (dice tower, drawers, clips and magnets for sheet organization, etc). The client is able to ask some questions but I want to understand how a DM thinks to some degree. I have a tendency to over-engineer if left to my own devices.

I'm curious about what any of you have found useful/ helpful with screens you've made, or bought, or seen elsewhere. What your bucket list of features might be. What sounded great in theory but was never used in practice.

These may be impossible questions if every campaign and play style is wildly unique, but even general tips would be great points of reference. Thank you!


r/DMAcademy • • 18h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Is this an ok encounter for a boss ‘stop the ritual’ encounter at the end of a dungeon?

6 Upvotes

Party of four lvl4 PCs

Hunter ranger
EK fighter
Moon Druid
Life cleric

They’ll have three combat encounters before this one throughout the dungeon

Some undead
Black pudding
Water wierd

Two spectators are the guardian monsters, they will be in direct combat with the party

Cultist fanatic as the main ritual guy

4 x cultists around the fanatic helping (maybe with a bit more health to stop them being defo 1-shot, but still a possibility with good rolls

The cultists can use an action to roll an arcana check on their turn, with a success ticking the ritual along

the players can’t damage the fanatic until the mooks have been taken out. And each mook taken out increases the number of successes needed to complete the ritual by 1?

Does this sound like it would be a fun encounter? Would 3 successes at DC18 sound like a good place to start at the beginning of the encounter? 5 maybe? Incase initiative goes against the players

If they kill all the cultists the ritual fails, if the ritual succeeds a barlgura comes through, kills all enemies currently still there and becomes the sole enemy? (It’s a portal to the abyssal plane) but not sure if that will be too much by that point?

Cheers


r/DMAcademy • • 21h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Inexperienced player now DMing for the first time for mixed experience group. Advice/basic resources appreciated

10 Upvotes

TLdR: party is unhappy with current DM, I’m a new player asked by party to try DMing. Nervous bc I don’t feel prepared and worried my sessions will be what completely breaks the group apart. What advice/extra resources should I prep for this stressful dynamic.

Main question: any advice from others that’s been there of what to expect? Im most worried about running combat (especially since I have one encounter under my belt and thats what started this whole debacle). Any extra resources recommended or even simulations I can run to practice? I got the DM guide, monster Manual and the monsters know what they’re doing books. I plan to run a one shot (wild sheep chase or one from the game masters guild of random encounters).

**Context: 5-7 player group (including current DM) that started a campaign about 8 months ago and so far have had 3 sessions. Half of us are new to DnD and those 3 sessions are our whole experience (including me), the other half have played for years even decades(including DM but it’s his 1st time trying to run a campaign).

Players from both sides of experience levels are unhappy with various things (pacing, railroading, etc) and we can’t figure out if our DM is dragging out when our next session is because he doesn’t want to do it anymore or he senses what’s happening and needs more prep time. At this point, they will drop a teaser of what to expect next weekend for a possible session and then when we meet not be prepared to run a session and we end up doing something else instead.

Tried to have a group discussion of trying to figure out what’s the core problem to come up with a solution because we just want to play more D&D, long story long, one option thrown out was I try being DM.
I feel thrown because I’ve only seen one combat encounter and just trying to learn the rules and rpg, I feel so much of a newb that I was over here having a grand ol’ time and patiently but excitedly waiting for the next session not understanding others felt this is not how it should go. We are now at a standstill where current DM is even more reluctant to run sessions and people hoping I would (I seriously think it’s because I host a lot). I feel one of the experienced players will be willing to help me above tabletop during the game if I get the rules wrong (or does it even matter?). I want to send out a survey and get character sheets ahead of time, propose a scheduled session 0-0.5, but worried the extra homework pre-session would be a turnoff (but tbh, it bothered me that my DM didn’t know my character name or class still on my 3rd session).

i know theres more context/dynamic missing and happy to fill in gaps if helpful. Is this just a sinking ship? I just want to play D&D. TIA and for making it this far


r/DMAcademy • • 15h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Mysterious bargain or informed choice? How would you run this?

3 Upvotes

I’m reading Obsidian Keep by Joseph R. Lewis, and there’s an encounter that got me thinking about how to present choices to players.

The party encounters Angelica, a half-woman, half-octopus creature who offers secrets and gifts “for a price.” One of the options in the encounter is: Feed her a finger: The character’s stump grows into a tentacle, and they gain the ability to breathe underwater.

How would you present this to your players?

* Mysterious bargain: “Give me a finger, and I’ll give you a wonderful gift.” The players know the cost, but not the reward.
* Informed bargain: “Give me a finger, and I’ll grant you the ability to breathe underwater.” The players can weigh the cost against the benefit.
* Something in between: Hint at the reward without revealing exactly what happens. Maybe, don’t reveal the stump grows into a tentacle?

I realize this depends partly on the players at your table and the kind of game you’re running. But I’m curious what else informs your decision. Do you have a general philosophy about how much information players should have before making these kinds of choices? Does it matter whether the consequences are permanent, whether the players can investigate the offer, or whether the bargain is coming from an obviously untrustworthy creature?

How would you actually run this at the table?


r/DMAcademy • • 19h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Help me tie a few plot elements together.

4 Upvotes

I'm about to be kicking off a 3.5 game with mostly strangers so I thought it would be funny to at least for the first bit of the campaign to have the PCs affected by some sort of short term amnesia, they'd still know who they were, their motivations, skills, class etc etc, just not know why they are where they are, each other, etc etc.

- The entire first continent that the PCs will be on, will also be magically excluded from the rest of the world but by some kind of effect that the PCs will be able to overcome.

- To the rest of the world, the lost continent is spoken of like Atlantis or Valyria.

- The society ON the lost continent is going to be relatively low magic and likewise have no real concept of the outside world, almost on the level of flat earthers.

- Pantheon wise I'm lazy so it's just gonna be the standard DnD gods

So yeah I just need to flesh out the magical exclusion plot device and how to tie that into the short term amnesia and if anyone has any thoughts I'm all ears


r/DMAcademy • • 20h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures What should I do to make a good solo session ?

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm the DM of a campaign that has been running for about four months, with three players (and a few friends who occasionally join us as guest players).

Recently, our level 10 Monk (Way of the Shadow) decided to travel alone to pursue his personal quest. I'm not looking for plot advice, as I already know what he's going to encounter. Instead, I need some help coming up with gameplay ideas for a solo session.

For context, his character is an assassin, so he's pretty skilled in stealth and sleight of hand.

I was thinking about including a fight inspired by the hallway scene from Oldboy, where he fights multiple enemies one after another in a sort of fully narrative, theatre-of-the-mind combat, describing every movement.

But what else would you do? Pure roleplay? Riddles? Maybe some other gameplay mechanics I haven't thought of?

Thanks for your help, and sorry if my post is a bit hard to understand!


r/DMAcademy • • 23h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Encounter Reality Check

5 Upvotes

I have a group of 5 level 11; barbarian, druid, cleric, bard and ranger. They have access to +2 weapons and armor.

I have a dungeon comming up where they will encounter an Amnizu (CR 18 Greater Devil). The Amnizu will have RP options and will offer the group a contract in exchange for access to plot relevant location. The group could also choose to just attack the Amnizu and get entry that way. I also encourage creative problem solving so combat is optional in this encounter.

The reality check is if the Amnizu being CR 18 is too much for the group. The Amnizu will also summon 3 Bearded Devils and 2 Barbed Devils to assist, but, they will not be in the room before combat begins so the party can't assess that threat.

Also, this Amnizu is not the dungeon boss, he is just a mid-dungeon guardian and optional. Boss is a named rakshasa that will have weretiger warriors as back up (I know they can handle that, they've done it before; recurring villain)

In a previous dungeon they did an Adult White Dragon, followed by a dragonbone golem/blood ooze combo followed by a modified Flesh Titan with 2 eye drakes.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Memorable NPC execution

0 Upvotes

Hey guys I'm hoping that you could provide some feedback on this idea that I've had for establishing the bbeg.

There's nothing better to motivate your players than a public execution either one which they have to escape from or one they have to foil

To sway the public back onto the bbeg side he has decided to rule with fear and create a spectacle to bring their general populars back in line

Public execution he wants to be a spectacular and gruesome as possible

My first idea is for a series of large tubs be filled with staffing rats and prisoners to be tied by there hands and lowered by a gantry into these boiling that's of starting rats

I would describe the fear on the prison space as they got lowered in a buck and move and scream muffled by their gags. They rats would claw their way up the prisoner making that way towards the face and then at the screens would change and in the crescendo they would first rats started to move inside either there mouth or their eyes

Has anyone tried this before in their games how did everyone react to it?


r/DMAcademy • • 23h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Fey misunderstanding of material plane deities?

5 Upvotes

In writing a one-shot, I've been thinking of ways in which different fey creatures might have completely misconstrued deities commonly worshipped in Faerûn, whether due to their tendency to be literal in their interpretation of iconography or something else.

For example, they might think Selûne is the goddess of pretty eyes, that Lathander is the god of babies and Ilmater could be the god of bondage in their view.

What are the funniest misunderstandings you can think of?