r/dune • u/TonyChen_72 • 18h ago
r/dune • u/Only_Difference192 • 19h ago
All Books Spoilers Was anyone else underwhelmed by the payoff to Alia's Abomination storyline?
I'm rewatching Dune with my mother who has dementia, in spite of the challenges of her illness, it's oddly enjoyable to re-explain the universe to her while she's only a mild case.
During the rewatch, I saw the scene of the former Reverand Mother prior to Jessica eliciting "what have we done," as if a decision that may doom the order entirely was mistakenly made.
Throughout Dune and Dune Messiah, Herbert establishes Abomination as something profoundly terrifying, particularly through the reactions of the Bene Gesserit. Reverend Mothers, including the Mother Superior, regard the possibility of ancestral possession with absolute horror. Alia's very existence is treated as something unnatural and potentially catastrophic.
Naturally, this builds the expectation that Abomination represents an extraordinary threat, especially considering Alia's abilities, ancestral knowledge, and political influence.
Yet by Children of Dune, when Alia finally succumbs to the Baron, the actual consequences feel surprisingly underwhelming.
Rather than becoming some uniquely formidable adversary, Alia becomes increasingly paranoid, politically incompetent, and psychologically unstable. The Baron doesn't seem to accomplish anything particularly extraordinary through possessing her. If anything, Alia appears considerably less capable than she was before.
I understand the thematic significance. Abomination represents the loss of individual identity, something fundamentally horrifying to the Bene Gesserit given their emphasis on absolute self-control. Alia's downfall also serves as a contrast to Leto II and Ghanima, who manage to navigate their ancestral consciousness without suffering the same fate.
But I can't help feeling that Herbert built up Abomination as this monumental danger, only for its most prominent example to amount to a relatively conventional story of corruption and political deterioration.
It seems especially strange when Leto II ultimately demonstrates just how extraordinary someone with access to ancestral consciousness can become. In comparison, the Baron possessing Alia feels like a remarkably limited exploration of the concept.
Am I misunderstanding what Herbert intended Abomination to represent, or did anyone else find the payoff disappointing?