r/e46 • u/DiGGityDawg2000 • 8h ago
Troubleshooting Need help diagnosing occasional inconsistent knocking noise from engine bay when car is cold.
So I have my 2003 330i automatic and ever since I’ve owned the car (bought with 75k miles, has 112k now) on cold starts, I will have the distinctive lifter ticking/knocking that lasts about 20 seconds and goes away. Doesn’t happen on every cold start but nonetheless, this sound in the video will follow immediately after the lifters go quiet. Inconsistent knocking that will last me about a minute or two and then go away. Car drives completely normal otherwise, no weird idle, no smoke. I have zero clue what it is. Work I’ve done to try and fix this: External timing chain tensioner, Klifex OFH check valve, G.A.S. DISA valve rebuild, complete CCV overhaul including new intake manifold gasket, all vacuum lines have been replaced, new fuel filter. Other engine work I’ve done include cooling system overhaul, new belt pulleys and tensioners, fan clutch, valve cover gasket. I’ve also looked at the spark plugs and all are burning evenly, no discolorations. Ignition coils are all Bosch and my uncle replaced them when he owned the car last in 2022. The only things I can think of right now I haven’t touched or looked at closely, are internal timing chain guides, and oil pump nut, and haven’t done Vanos seals or rattle kit yet. I’ve been chasing this for quite some time and I am stupidly stubborn and never want to reach out to others for help on car stuff, but I’ve given up. I also cannot find a single video on this sound whatsoever and if I do find a video that sounds close, I’ve already done the work someone else has to fix the noise, but noise still persists.
I appreciate all the help I can get, never been this stumped with a car diag before!
Thanks.