r/eb_1a • • Jun 24 '26

EB-1A for Founders: Which Criteria Actually Apply [1/3]

0 Upvotes

If you’re a founder interested in living permanently in the U.S., the EB-1A could be your fastest path towards an employment-based Green Card. It does not require an employer sponsor, skips the lengthy PERM certification process, and has a much shorter backlog when compared to the EB-2 and EB-3 categories.

The catch? You have to meet USCIS’s extraordinary ability criteria, and prove you're at the top of your field. Here's what that actually looks like for founders.

The EB-1A criteria that actually apply to founders

Not all 10 criteria map cleanly to startup work. Here are the ones founders most commonly use, with notes on what USCIS actually wants to see.

Awards or prizes for excellence

What can qualify:

  • Accelerator fellowships with competitive acceptance rates (YC, Techstars, a16z Speedrun)
  • Innovation awards from established industry bodies
  • Government-backed grants tied to merit selection (NSF SBIR, DARPA programs)
  • Forbes 30 Under 30, TIME100 Next, and similar lists in prominent media outlets

What doesn't qualify:

  • "Startup of the Year" awards from local chambers of commerce
  • Internal company recognition
  • Pay-to-play badges or participation certificates

Tip: For every award, document the selection criteria, acceptance/rejection rate, and who judged it. USCIS wants to see selectivity, not just a trophy.

Membership in associations requiring outstanding achievement

What can qualify:

  • Fellowship status in selective professional organizations (such as being an IEEE or ACM Fellow)
  • Invitation-only entrepreneurial networks where membership is vetted by peers
  • National academies or boards with documented selection criteria

What doesn't qualify:

  • Open-membership trade groups
  • LinkedIn communities
  • Groups where anyone can apply and pay to join

Published material about you

What can qualify:

  • Profiles in TechCrunch, Forbes, Wired, Bloomberg, or comparable media outlets
  • Trade press coverage in your specific industry
  • Podcast interviews where you are the main subject

What doesn't qualify:

  • Press releases your PR team wrote
  • Articles you're quoted in briefly, but are not the sole focus
  • Company announcements

Tip: When presenting published material about you, include the outlet's traffic data alongside the articles. USCIS has asked petitioners to prove that publications are "major media,” and circulation numbers can help minimize the risk of a Request for Evidence.

Judging the work of others

What can qualify:

  • Judging startup competitions
  • Peer reviewing for industry conferences or journals
  • Serving on grant review panels
  • Advisory roles where you formally evaluate applications or projects

What doesn't qualify:

  • One-off informal feedback sessions
  • Mentorship where there's no formal evaluation process

Tip: Get documentation from the organizer, such as an invitation letter naming you as a judge, the selection criteria for judges, and the scope of what you reviewed.

Original contributions of major significance

What can qualify:

  • A patented technology that others in the industry have adopted or built on
  • An open-source framework or methodology that has measurable adoption outside your company
  • A new business model or technical approach that changed how a field operates
  • Research or whitepapers that influenced standards, regulation, or practice

What doesn't qualify:

  • Internal processes that haven't been publicly adopted
  • Contributions only recognized by your own team or investors

Tip: This criterion lives or dies on independent expert letters. You need 3–5 letters from recognized experts who have no financial relationship with you. Each letter needs to explain specifically what you contributed and why it matters to the field, not just praise your work generally.

Authorship of scholarly articles

What can qualify:

  • Peer-reviewed academic papers
  • Technical deep-dives in recognized trade publications
  • Industry reports published by major research institutions
  • Long-form pieces in recognized outlets like Harvard Business Review, MIT Technology Review

What doesn't qualify:

  • Your own company blog
  • LinkedIn articles
  • Blog posts on outlets like Medium or Substack that lack third-party editorial oversight

Leading or critical role in a distinguished organization

What can qualify:

  • Holding a C-suite role (CEO, CTO, CPO) at a startup that has raised significant funding, reached a meaningful user base, or been recognized by press and industry
  • Critical technical or operational roles at well-known companies before you started your startup
  • Board seats or advisory roles at recognized organizations where you made material decisions

What counts as distinguished in an organization:

  • Press coverage, especially from major outlets
  • Funding from recognized investors (can be tier-1 VCs or government grants)
  • Measurable user or revenue scale
  • Awards or rankings the organization received

Tip: Distinguished is relative to your industry, so you’ll need to include evidence on what those benchmarks are. Document it with press coverage, customer case studies, and third-party recognition.

High salary or remuneration relative to others in the field

What can qualify:

  • W-2 salary well above BLS benchmarks for your occupation
  • Equity compensation with documented cap table position, valuation evidence, and funding round records
  • Consulting or advisory fees significantly above market rate

Tip: Use BLS Occupational Employment Statistics to benchmark your salary, and for equity, include cap table documentation and the most recent 409A valuation or funding round post-money valuation.

The two EB-1A criteria founders most commonly skip (and the rare cases where they fit)

The guide above covers eight of the ten EB-1A criteria. The two left out (Criterion 7 and 10) are targeted for artists and performers, so most founders pass on them. But they aren't automatically off the table, and in the right case they can round out a petition.

Display of your work at artistic exhibitions or showcases. 

When a founder might consider it: 

  • You build in a creative or design-driven field (generative art, industrial or product design, architecture, gaming, or AR/VR), and your work has been shown at recognized exhibitions, biennials, or curated showcases.
  • A museum, gallery, or design institution (not a sales expo) selected and displayed your work.
  • Your product or research was featured in a juried showcase where selection was competitive and curated.

What still won't count: a booth you paid for at CES, a pitch at Demo Day, or a conference talk. The venue has to be artistic and the selection has to be independent.

Commercial success in the performing arts. 

When a founder might consider it:

  • Your company operates in music, film, streaming, gaming, or live entertainment, and you can show commercial performance in those terms. In practice, that looks like chart positions, box office revenue, and verified streaming or sales figures.
  • You hold a creator or performer credit in addition to your founder role, with documented commercial results tied to your name.

Bottom line: Don't pad a petition with these two just to reach three criteria. But if your work genuinely lives in a creative or performing-arts field, naming the right one can make or break the strength of your overall petition.

IN OUR NEXT GUIDE: We’ll dive how the final merits determination applies to founders specifically.

(Please note: Any information shared here is for general educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. Your situation may require fact-specific guidance. For personalized legal advice, please consult an immigration attorney directly.)


r/eb_1a • • Apr 15 '26

Welcome to eb_1a! (new rules, new Mod, and a growing community)

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

This community has been growing quickly, and it’s been great to see so many people sharing their immigration experiences, questions, and insights. With that growth, though, comes the need to keep this community organized and ensure its trustworthiness. 

To help with that, we’re introducing a set of community rules to improve the quality of discussions and protect users from misinformation, spam, and bad actors. I won’t list every detail here, but please check updated community rules for more information.

The goal is to make this subreddit more useful, more reliable, and safer for everyone navigating immigration.

If you’re here to:

  • Share real experiences
  • Ask thoughtful questions
  • Help others with accurate information

You’ll be just fine!

If you have feedback, concerns, or questions, feel free to reach out to any of the moderators via modmail.

Thanks again for being part of this community. We’re excited to keep building it with you to be the #1 source of information on all things EB-1A. 

  • Mod Team

r/eb_1a • • 1h ago

O1 after approved EB1A

• Upvotes

has anyone here filed O-1 after an approved EB1A ?


r/eb_1a • • 7h ago

Experience with Shawn sedaghat law firm

7 Upvotes

I retained the firm for an EB-1A petition and paid $6,900 in attorney fees, with a refund clause for denial. My petition ultimately received a NOID and was denied. After the denial, the firm told me that, in their professional opinion, an appeal was potentially appropriate. I requested their recommendation on whether to proceed, including the legal/factual grounds, likelihood of success, process, timeline, and costs.
I followed up several times while the I-290B filing window was still open and did not receive any response and the deadline passed. the firm later responded and stated that they understood my refund request as an indication that I did not want to appeal. My emails, however, specifically said that I was waiting for their professional assessment so I could decide whether to proceed.
Communication had also been a recurring issue during my representation. I have since requested a full refund of the $6,900 attorney fees. The firm initially offered a $1,000 “goodwill” refund.
Has anyone dealt with a similar issue and what should be my next steps? The firm is not responsive and the retainer agreement clearly states a refund clause


r/eb_1a • • 5h ago

EB-1A Regular Processing January 5, 2024 and awaiting a decision. Anyone in a Similar Situation?

3 Upvotes

EB-1A Regular Processing – Anyone in a Similar Situation?

I’m looking to connect with others who might be in a similar situation.

Here is my timeline:

  • EB-2 NIW I-140: Filed and approved on January 10, 2024, with a decision received within approximately 8 months.
  • EB-1A I-140: Filed on January 5, 2024, under regular processing.
  • Current status: Still awaiting a decision on my EB-1A petition.

I’m originally from India but currently living in Canada and have obtained Canadian citizenship.

It’s been a long wait for the EB-1A petition, especially considering that my EB-2 NIW was approved.

A few questions:

  1. Is anyone from India who filed an EB-1A around January 2024 under regular processing still waiting?
  2. Has anyone with a similar filing timeline recently received an approval, RFE, or any update?
  3. Does anyone know whether being a Canadian citizen and residing in Canada has any relevance to EB-1A processing timelines?

Would appreciate hearing about your experiences, timelines, or any insights. Thanks!


r/eb_1a • • 23m ago

Cancellation Notice for Request for Addtitional Evidence

• Upvotes

Hi all, my EB1A I140 has been pending since Jan 6, 2026, was filed via premium and received refund sometime in July for the premium fee. I am from one of the previously banned 39 countries.

Have called USCIS and also did congress inquiry.

Today I saw a notice that there was a cancellation notice for an RFE. But an RFE was never issued.

Question: Anyone experienced this before for their case here?

What was the next outcome?

Thanks.


r/eb_1a • • 26m ago

Whoever received silent updates on 11/14, 11/15 and 11/17 on I765 filed in March/April 2026 and not approved yet?

• Upvotes

r/eb_1a • • 6h ago

Eb1 A - PP

3 Upvotes

My case was filed on Sept 11 in PP, no update yet. Is there anyone filed around the same time, and waiting for an update.


r/eb_1a • • 3h ago

EB-1A RFE — Has anyone had all their evidence for Original Contributions dismissed and still gotten approved?

0 Upvotes

I recently received an EB-1A RFE where USCIS accepted my judging and scholarly authorship criteria but rejected Original Contributions of Major Significance (OCMS).

What concerns me is that the officer seems to have dismissed every type of evidence submitted for OCMS, including publications, citation records, comparative citation metrics, independent research citations, and recommendation letters.

The RFE essentially argues that publishing in reputable venues and receiving citations are normal academic activities and that the evidence doesn't sufficiently establish major significance or widespread implementation in the field.

I'm working with my attorneys on a response, but the language of the RFE feels quite discouraging, almost as though the officer has already made up their mind.

I'm curious whether anyone here has experienced something similar:

  1. Did your RFE dismiss virtually all the evidence you submitted for OCMS?
  2. Were you eventually approved after responding, or was your petition denied?
  3. If approved, what additional evidence made the difference?
  4. Did you obtain new recommendation letters, or were independent citing papers and other objective evidence sufficient?

I'd particularly appreciate hearing from people who received similarly worded RFEs, rather than general experiences with OCMS RFEs.

Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences!


r/eb_1a • • 8h ago

EB-1C I-485 Status and AC21 Job Portability – Seeking Guidance

1 Upvotes

I would appreciate your guidance on a couple of questions regarding my pending EB-1C adjustment of status application.

Current Status:

  • My I-485 has been pending for over 250 days.
  • My dependents received their EADs in June 2026.
  • For my EAD (primary applicant), I recently received a notification yesterday Nov 17, 2026 stating that a decision has been rendered. I am hopeful this indicates approval, although I am awaiting confirmation.
  • Our priority date (June 15, 2023) is not yet current.

1. I-485 Approval Timeline

Assuming all other processing steps, including biometrics and background checks, are complete, is it reasonable to expect that my green card could be approved relatively quickly once my priority date becomes current? what is a good time frame to expect?

2. Employer Change and AC21 Portability

If I receive an offer from another employer for a position comparable in compensation, designation, managerial responsibilities, and field of work, would I be able to start using my EAD directly, or would I also need to file Form I-485 Supplement J under AC21 portability provisions to preserve my pending green card application?

Given that my I-485 has been pending for more than 180 days, would you recommend engaging an immigration attorney before making such a transition? If so, I would appreciate any recommendations for experienced immigration law firms or attorneys specializing in EB-1C portability cases.

Thank you in advance for your guidance.

With appreciation,


r/eb_1a • • 4h ago

RFE response delivered 2 months ago, but no acknowledgment. What happens after the deadline?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/eb_1a • • 6h ago

San Fernando valley office- Submitted my medical rfe response. Case is being pending since 80 days

1 Upvotes

I140 approved under eb1a category.
My I485 case is pending at SFV office.
RD - May 2026
Biometric complete
Priority date is current.
Medical rfe response submitted on August 2026

It’s been more than 80 days but no further update.

Emma agent said your case is still with SFV and interview waived.

How long to wait for medical rfe to get reviewed??!


r/eb_1a • • 8h ago

Dec 2026 VB

0 Upvotes

When? 🥺


r/eb_1a • • 8h ago

CONCERNS

1 Upvotes

Hello guys, I recieved NOID for EB1A and I had 30 days to respond and my response was sent day 27th and its Day 30th and USCIS has not acknowledged. Should I be worried at this point?


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Greened

11 Upvotes

The feeling of having my GC in khans is massive. I can’t believe that i can travel back home anytime 😂

I am wishing you all the best 🙌
ROW EB1A April 2026 filer


r/eb_1a • • 22h ago

Does it really take this long for AP on i-485 pending

3 Upvotes

Does it really take this long for AP on i-485 pending


r/eb_1a • • 16h ago

EB1A attorney recommendations for industry profile

0 Upvotes

I am looking for a very hands on and responsive attorney to file my EB1A application. I will be involved closely, but I would like the attorney to take the lead role in drafting the petition and recommendation letters. Someone who is knowledgeable with tech industry profiles and can help draft the petition considering the latest USCIS trends would be ideal. If you have any recommendations please send them through and also mention the fees they charge for filing. Thanks.


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Texas EB‑1A premium processing: How long did your case and email reply take?

6 Upvotes

My EB‑1A I‑140 is pending at Texas Service Center. My I‑907 receipt date was October 8, and USCIS told me my 15-business-day premium window ended October 30. As of November 17 (business day 26), I still hadn’t received a decision or RFE. I called the premium processing line and was told email replies could take 30–60 business days.
For anyone with a recent Texas EB‑1A premium case: How many business days did it take to get a decision or RFE? If you emailed the premium processing unit, how long did they take to reply, and did you get a case update first?


r/eb_1a • • 2d ago

Finally Greened 🎉| EB1A | I-485 | India | Approved

95 Upvotes

Finally Greened! 🎉 | EB1A | I-485 | India | Approved – My Timeline & Journey

I wanted to share my EB1A and green card journey with this community. Hopefully, my experience will help others going through the same process.

EB1A I-140 (Premium Processing – Nebraska): Self-petition

  • Background: 20+ years of experience in Cloud, Data Analytics, and AI.
  • Filed: June 08, 2026
  • Approved: June 24, 2026
  • RFE: None

I-485 / I-131 / I-765 (Family of 4) – Sponsored and Filed by My Current Employer

  • I-485 Approved: October 21, 2026 (all four family members)
  • Green Cards Produced: October 23, 2026

My Experience & Advice

I would strongly recommend focusing on objective evidence rather than relying too heavily on recommendation letters. Clearly demonstrate your contributions, their measurable impact, and recognition beyond your organization. I kept my petition cover letter under 50 pages, while the complete petition, including all supporting evidence, was close to 750 pages.

I religiously followed this GitHub guide while preparing my EB1A petition. It was extremely helpful throughout the process, and I highly recommend it to anyone considering self-petitioning.

https://github.com/razvanmarinescu/EB1A

Also, based on my experience, self-filling is definitely worth considering if you're comfortable preparing and organizing your own evidence. Online filing makes it easier to manage your application and track progress.

The entire EB1A process was smooth and faster than I expected. For the I-485 process, I would give full credit to my company for sponsoring and supporting the I-485, I-131, and I-765 applications for my entire family together. I'm truly grateful for their support throughout the process.

Thanks to everyone in this community who shared their experiences. Wishing all EB1A applicants the very best! 🎉


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Insights from an EB-1A recipient (approved two weeks ago)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Here is a video on Insights from an EB-1A recipient (approved two weeks ago).


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Bunch of SU's on EAD (I-765) | EB1 | March 2026 Filer | PD Not Current

2 Upvotes

Hi Fam, I got 3 SU's on my EAD on 11/15,11/16, and 11/17. There is another post for people who have been receiving EAD approvals lately for March-April-May filers.

Has anyone from this group had their EAD approved with similar SU's who filed in that time range?

https://www.reddit.com/r/EB2NIW_I485_AOS/s/yKuxa9b9fS

**************************************************************************************
UPDATE 11/18:

MY EAD was approved. Approval came on 11/17 last night at 10.30 pm, recieved and email saying we have take action on your case. Followed by a second approval email. Under the Documents section on myUSCIS, I can see "I765 C09 Standalone Approval"


r/eb_1a • • 20h ago

EB-1A Denied After RFE – Postdoc, Granted Patents, 131 Citations & $30M ( 240 cr INR) Commercialization. Seeking Advice .

0 Upvotes

My EB-1A petition was denied on November 17, 2026, despite submitting a detailed RFE response. Filed under Premium Processing at Nebraska Service Center.

Timeline:

July 13: Case received
July 30: RFE issued
November 2: RFE response received
November 17: USCIS processing status updated
November 17: Case denied

Research Profile:

Postdoctoral researcher at a leading US research hospital, specializing in drug discovery and biomedical sciences.
10 initial publications (4 first-author), followed by 2 additional first-author publications.
Citations increased from 102 at filing to 131 during RFE.
4 published patent applications at filing.
Patents subsequently granted in China, Taiwan, and Japan; pending in the USA, Canada, and other countries.
First-listed inventor on a patent filed by a major pharmaceutical company.
Research compound transferred to the pharmaceutical company through an approximately $30 million commercialization deal; currently in clinical trials.
Government-funded Senior Research Fellowship (India).
$250,000 institutional research grant as Co-PI.
Two first-author ASGCT poster presentations in the USA, another in India, and AHA conference participation.

EB-1A Criteria:

Claimed 4 criteria. USCIS acknowledged that the Leading or Critical Role criterion was satisfied but questioned Scholarly Articles and Original Contributions of Major Significance, along with final merits.

Our RFE response included granted patents, updated citations, recommendation letters, and additional evidence of research impact.

Unfortunately, USCIS denied the petition. I’m awaiting the detailed denial notice.


r/eb_1a • • 2d ago

EB1 rejected after RFE

44 Upvotes

To give more context
1500 citations
Field- Neuro AI (NeuroScience Inspired AI)
PhD from top 10 university
Tenure track Professor at R1 university
Over 3M in state and federal funding.
Papers over 60
Reviews over 120
Lawyer - Chen
Don’t know what they are looking for these days.
Additional details- EB1A
Yes will be applying via university now for EB1B
Officer is XM1845


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Advice on building eb1A profile during AI/ML PhD

6 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm a second-year PhD student in machine learning at a US university, here on an F-1 from India.

I have around 550 citations, with a few first-author papers and regularly review for top ML venues.

My question is

  1. For people who got EB-1A during or right after their PhD, which criteria did you lean on, and what made the difference in the final merits review?

  2. How much do citations matter compared with first-author count, and how do officers judge citations in a fast-moving field like ML?

  3. What's worth investing in over the next 2–3 years ?

  4. Did you file EB-2 NIW first to lock in a priority date? If so, when did you do it?

I'd really appreciate the opinion.

Thanks


r/eb_1a • • 2d ago

DOL just proposed the first major PERM overhaul since 2004. Here’s what would change.

21 Upvotes

On Nov. 16, 2026, the Department of Labor (DOL) released a proposed rule that would overhaul PERM processing for employers. Recruitment standards, layoff safeguards, nondiscriminatory hiring, and record retention could all change if the proposal gets implemented as-is.

The big thing to remember: These changes remain proposals and have not taken effect. Current PERM rules still apply, including for pending applications.

Here’s a quick rundown of what the proposal would change:

  • Recruitment: Online recruitment steps would replace print newspaper ads. Employers would post the open role on their business websites and on at least one external job-search platform. Each ad would list the wage offer or wage range, which must meet or exceed the prevailing wage.
  • Longer recruitment: The job order and online ads would each run for at least 90 calendar days. These recruitment steps must be completed no more than 60 calendar days but no fewer than 30 calendar days before the expected filing date.
  • Layoffs: Employers would need to attest that they have not laid off any U.S. workers in the same or similar occupation and area of intended employment within two years before filing. Layoffs after filing would trigger a new obligation to notify the DOL and USCIS within five business days.
  • Nondiscrimination: Employers could not reject a qualified U.S. worker over cost, including salary or benefit differences. Employers that require interviews would have to offer them by phone or video.
  • Recordkeeping: Employers would have to submit a signed recruitment report, U.S. applicants’ resumes or applications, and recruitment records with the PERM application.
  • Schedule A: The proposed rule would eliminate Schedule A, including both its nursing and physical therapy group and its exceptional ability group. Employers sponsoring these workers would have to complete the same recruitment as other PERM cases.

When would this take effect?
The DOL proposes a 90-day transition period. A final rule would take effect 60 days after publication, and DOL would apply current rules for 30 more days. Applications submitted on or after day 90 would have to meet the new rules, even if recruitment started earlier.

So if the DOL published a final rule on June 1, 2027, it would take effect July 31, but applications submitted through Aug. 29, 2027, would still be processed under the current rules.

Happy to answer questions in the comments. This post is general information, not legal advice for your specific case.

(Please note: this is for general educational purposes only, not legal advice, and doesn't create an attorney-client relationship. For guidance on your specific case, consult an immigration attorney directly.)