r/ecommerce • u/Own-Specialist9934 • 20m ago
๐ข Marketing We hit $38K in GMV last month and still lost money
For about two weeks I felt like a genius because the dashboard showed our best month so far, the affiliate videos kept landing and I posted a screenshot of the number in a group chat with a proud little message and I was happy until my accountant sent a one line email asking where the profit was.
So I sat down with a spreadsheet and rebuilt the month order by order, starting from the sale price and subtracting the platform fee, the affiliate commission, shipping, packaging, the free samples, the refunds and the ad spend, and what remained was a loss of roughly $1,900, which meant the number I had celebrated measured activity far more than money.
The product with the highest sales was the worst offender, since it carried a 20% commission, a low price and a return rate near 12%, so each order that looked like a win left me with less than two dollars before ad spend, and a few of the orders that felt small, the higher-priced bundles with fewer returns, were quietly paying for everything.
What changed my approach was tracking contribution margin per product instead of GMV, which means the profit left from each order after every cost tied to that order, and once I could see it, I raised the price of the weak product, moved the commission down on it, and pushed the bundles in every brief I sent to creators.
The month after, GMV fell by about a fifth while profit turned positive, and that trade felt strange at first, because the vanity number dropped, yet the bank balance finally agreed with the story.
The catch is that margin math only helps when every cost goes in, including the unglamorous ones like samples that never turn into videos, so I now add a flat per-order allowance for those, and I revisit it each month because returns shift with seasons and creators.
Which number do you look at first when you judge a month, GMV, profit per order or something else, and has a good-looking month ever turned out to be a loss once you added everything up?