r/EDH • • 1d ago

Daily Tuesday Rulesday: Ask your rules questions here! - November 17, 2026

1 Upvotes

Welcome to Tuesday Rulesday!

Please use this thread to ask and discuss your rules questions. Also make sure to use the upvote button to thank those who take the time to give correct answers. If you need immediate assistance, please head over to the IRC live judge chat or the rules question channel in the EDH discord server.

Remember that rules questions aren't allowed on /r/EDH outside of this weekly post, so if you have a rules question and aren't getting a response here you can head to the two links above, or to /r/mtgrules.


r/EDH • • 9h ago

Daily Oh, Wise One Wednesday - What's my Bracket/Power Level? - November 18, 2026

2 Upvotes

It's Wednesday, my Planeswalkers!

There are only two days left until your weekly FNM. You have a new commander list you've thrown together, and despite what your deckbuilder site is telling you, you're not sure if you've landed solidly into a bracket or specific power level. You don't want to be the next 'Bracket 1 cEDH Magda'. That's where this weekly thread comes in.

Feel free to use this space to share decklists and request a second set of eyes on your deck's bracket/power level. Please avoid asking complex questions that would be better suited for a 'deckhelp' post of its own.

Consider sorting the comments by "new" (instead of "best" or "top") to see the newest posts and answer those that haven't been answered already.


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Discussion Friend only builds monoblack

133 Upvotes

Have an issue in my local meta— my friend only builds monoblack and keeps using thinks like Gary and [[grave pact]] along with recursion to win games in turn 3/4. the rest of the local pod members don’t run GY hate and say they don’t like to dilute their decks to add GY interaction.

Do I just find other pods at this point? I play to have fun but get very bored with what turns out to be 10 minute turns from someone just playing solitaire monoblack stax.

Also, since i’m the only one hip to the idea that we have to just kill them turns 1-3, they complain bitterly if I attack them (whilst playing aggro) or counter their commander (whilst playing control). It’s a “hey don’t stop me from abusing our local meta” situation and very frustrating.


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Question You have to live with your last commander as your roommate for a year. How screwed are you?

74 Upvotes

So your last commander is now your roommate for the next 12 months lol. They have to live in your house, share your kitchen and you cant kick them out no matter what happens. I’m guessing some commanders would actually be pretty chill to live with while others would probably burn the house down within a week. Who are you stuck with and how bad is your living situation gonna be? 😂


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Question Are costly commanders (6, 7+ mana) that don't have green realistically usable in b3?

38 Upvotes

Hello, all! I've been thinking about building a [[Nissa, Leyline Tamer]] and a [[Tariel, Reckoner of Souls]] decks, but lots of people (especially on the internet) says they're too slow to be competitive due the fact they cost a lot of mana and can't ramp with green. People who run costly commanders, are they viable? How do your games play? Do you have success with them?

Any help would be appreciated! Thanks in advance


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Discussion What is a card that you constantly hear is a staple or really busted but for some reason just doesn't work out for you.

327 Upvotes

Mine is [[hullbreaker horror]] I know its an extremely powerful card but for some reason I haven't had success with it yet. I rarely draw it and when I do it's just too expensive for the moment.

Also many of my blue decks just don't seem to want it. Either it's not on theme or the deck focuses more on other things than casting alot of spells.


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Discussion How did you find your main deck, if you have a main deck?

31 Upvotes

For context, I’m fairly new to Magic/EDH as a whole. I started playing in April of this year. My first deck was the Ureni Precon, and the obsession began. Since then I’ve “built” a Bello Deck, Mono-Green Six Deck, and started on a Vincent Valentine Deck. I’ve play tested other decks across many colors.

I curious on mindsets/thought processes when you realized you found your main deck. The deck that will always be your go to. I understand spending time to find out what play style(s) you enjoy, and understanding what your commander/deck wants to do. I’m wondering what was your “ah-ha” moment. How are you evaluating your deck for things like countering opponents, responding to opponents, while maintaining your game plan. How are you managing card draw/ramp/counterspells. I know it’s not a simple answer, I know it’s commander/color specific. I’m just looking for how others process their decks, so maybe I can improve how I process mine if that makes sense.

I’ve spend an embarrassing amount of time looking at so many commanders and cards, and it’s been a challenge finding a commander I want to build out and try..I just haven’t found one that strikes that itch that says “this is my deck, the deck that I will work on until I’m satisfied”. Don’t get me wrong I have my decks that I absolutely enjoy playing, but I haven’t found that Main deck yet. As always GGs, thanks for any inputs and I’ll respond when I can👍🏼


r/EDH • • 17h ago

Question Your kid is named after your last commander you played. How many years of therapy will it take to undo that damage?

350 Upvotes

I’m guessing that the amount of damage will vary substantially.

Some commanders have normal names. Especially universes beyond. I think probably the worst is going to be naming your kid “RMS Titanic”.

Last deck I played was Winota, which you know in the scheme of things isn’t the worst name it the world.

What’s your kid named now?


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Discussion What are the must-have includes for the Multiverse Reforged precon?

32 Upvotes

I'm planning to pick up the Multiverse Reforged Commander precon and would like to know which cards are considered must-haves for this deck.

I'm not looking to turn it into a super competitive deck. I'd prefer to keep it casual and consistent, ideally around Bracket 2.

I'd appreciate your recommendations. Thanks!


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Meta How do we bridge the gap on players wanting deck feedback?

134 Upvotes

Hey what's poppin, I'm Izzet_Aristocrat and I'm a mod over at DegenerateEDH, terrible name, wish I could change it.

As someone whose played MTG since Theros and been online since Shadows Over Innistraad, the big thing I've noticed as time has gone on is just how hard it is to get feedback on commander decks.

Many people, in my own sub, and places like r/EDH upload decklists to little to no fanfare. Posts get downvoted to zero which results in them disappearing from Hot which gets them hidden from people browsing.

Often this is done to hide a post so someone will elevate their own shit. It's a reddit thing since the site's inception. Want to make your own post visible? Downvote every other recent one.

What I have noticed more over the past few years however, is the influx of lists that get no attention due to other contextual factors. UB is a big one. I notice that unless it's from a precon or it's a very big deal like John Benton, a commander being from a UB set is pretty much a death sentence if a player is looking for help with it.

And as the years have gone on, the issue has seemed to grow, if your commander isn't EDHREC top 100, you're on your own.

As a CEDH player, many people flock to discord, I use it myself for Niv-Mizzet and Light-Paws. But this only goes so far. If your commander isn't CEDH viable or happen to be very popular, you're out of luck. And even then popularity isn't always enough.

We're a very big game, and we're only getting bigger and the number of legendary creatures is only getting bigger.

Some of it can be assumed to be effort. If someone just makes a post that says Hey I'm building mono white Cloud, what cards? that can often be assumed that since the post is low effort, the feedback will be too.

Over on the sub I moderate, a lot of the time people will try to post jokes or meme images to try to get attention on their posts. And as a long time poster here, I know what posts actually get comments.

So how do we fix this? Most commanders aren't unique. No one's asking for a primer for every legendary in existence. Very few do something no other legendary does. The question is;

How do we get the community to actually engage?


r/EDH • • 22h ago

Discussion Monocolor Appreciation Thread

197 Upvotes

I'm a minimalist when it comes to color identity. If I have an idea for a deck, and later find I can accomplish the same feel with fewer colors, I almost always take that option. The decks I've made with 3+ colors are typically hyper-specific and built around interactions that just aren't possible otherwise.

WotC on the other hand, feels the opposite. Especially recently, the vast majority of precons printed have 3+ colors at their disposal which leads to a feeling of decks/commanders that can "have it all" with no effort from the player at all. This doesn't even come with a significant drawback, with the sheer number of untapped dual lands, triomes and the social stigma that comes with attacking greedy manabases.

In spite of this though, there's a certain elegance to running a 1-2 color deck. Embracing the limitations that come with it may not provide any mechanical benefit, but in my experience those decks usually feel less cluttered and as such are more fun to play.

Instead of whinging more about the current multicolor slop paradigm, though, I'd like to take a moment to recognize mono color decks and celebrate how fun they are. Come sing the praises of your favorite monocolor decks! From stock CEDH [[Magda]] decks to janky lists featuring the Myojin, all are welcome.

My current lists are:

[[The Queen of Dale]] Reanimator. Having a quasi-looter in the zone helps fuel the graveyard and hitting an [[Avacyn, Angel of Hope]] with a [[False Defeat]], or [[Refurbish]]-ing a [[Phyrexian Porta]] feels so good.

[[Kaho Minamo Historian]] Polymorph. You can search [[Synthetic Destiny]] with it. It's like that one Urza Polymorph deck but less turbo and more toolbox.

[[Vnwxt]] Flying Men. You can get to max speed pretty quickly and then draw your deck while beating people up. Workout exclusively at the library.

[[Sidisi, Regent of the Mire]] Aristocrats. Bag some flesh, engage in mercantilism with Gary and employ the services of [[Syr Konrad]] over and over and over again. So many [[Gravecrawlers]]

[[not in the wary]] Burn. [[impact Tremors]] tribal, no [[Confusion in the Ranks]] everyone is dead before that matters.

[[Six]] Lands Combo. Dollar Store yawgmoths will in the zone loops [[Aftermath Analyst]], [[Lumra]] and/or [[Will of the Sultai]].

[[yeva, natures herald]] Mono Green Control. [[Seedborn Muse]] and [[Wilderness Reclamation]] effects enable a cute draw-go play pattern.


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Deck Help Land destruction hearthhull ideas?

4 Upvotes

As the title says I’m looking for some card ideas to turn my hearthhull deck more land destruction. I figured it would work pretty well since like every other card in my deck lets me get lands from the graveyard. It would probably be better if the cards involve sacrificing lands as well so I get the benefits from my commander. I just wanna have some excuses to add some salty cards in there too can’t lie.

https://moxfield.com/decks/i8YwioHk2k-C4xvjcPp2TQ


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Deck Help Lyna deck Eval

3 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/Gwl-7SKkpkCQ80K6ASaxQA

So first time trying to build a deck, this was my favorite commander from the Mystery set.

The whole idea is making creatures nearly unblockable, drawing cards through combat, and using cards like Virtus, Unstoppable Slasher, and Vorpal Sword to eliminate players.

I wanted something different from traditional Esper control, so I went with a lower-curve Bracket 4 build focused on combat damage and resource denial.

I've been working on optimizing it and would love some feedback, especially from anyone who's played shadow-based strategies.


r/EDH • • 1d ago

Discussion Sometimes, it's not about whether it's B4 or not

271 Upvotes

And when I say "sometimes", I mean "basically every time".

We've seen it very often. Something like:

My deck wins 75% of the time when playing with my friends. They say it's B4, but I think it's B3. Is my deck B4?

But it doesn't matter if it's actually B4 or not. When one knows for a fact a deck doesn't fit at an established table due to empirical play experience, getting lost in the minutiae of Brackets is wasting time.

Brackets open the conversation up, but, if the mismatch can be identified without using Brackets, then the strict definitions matter less and become counterproductive to the conversation.


r/EDH • • 12m ago

Deck Help New player, Stumbled onto Kaalia as my first Commander

2 Upvotes

Im having a bit of a problem. When going to make my first custome deck I wanted to run an angels and demons tribal, it sounded like a fun flavor to try. A friend of mine suggested using Kaalia as a commander, knowing nothing, I saw her ability and her art and was 100% in on that idea (lmao).

I have rebuilt the deck many times and have experienced the, what i now know, are common kaalia things. Being targeted by everyone, not enough mana, needing protection, etc.

In response to all of that I have dug around the internet and have upgraded the deck considerably in order to shore up those defenses, only to realize the deck may be a little strong for my pod potentially.

So the issue im having is can I even play Kaalia in a B2/B3 environment? What i mean is either im too weak and dont get to really play, or feel so strong that im enemy number one and no one is having fun lol.

I will post my decklist if that helps:

https://moxfield.com/decks/c5LpXpfpBkym1HZ5itO5dA

I really like this commander, but im starting to feel myself min/max and im not trying to stomp my friends every game (not that this actually happens). Im sure most people will suggest removing MOC, and this is something I have debated heavily. I almost never use it, so its wasted space, but the idea of using it to win feels like a fun concept.


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Question Question about muckslinger gang

4 Upvotes

Let's say I'm running Coram, The undertaker and I have Yargle and Multani in my graveyard, plus the Muckslinger gang on the field. Muckslinger gives y+m that extra 3, making it a 21 power creature, and that counts for coram to make him a 21/5, correct?

This means that my Coram + Mr. Orfeo + Chandra's ignition fires off for 42 damage, all but guaranteeing the win?


r/EDH • • 21h ago

Question What are the most fun precons?

84 Upvotes

I know that’s quite an open ended question, but I recently came into a decent amount of money, and I’d like to use it to purchase some more magic stuff. I’ve quite enjoyed playing decks with a reanimator focus and big timmy stompy creatures, but I’ve wanted to try branch out a bit. Some that I’ve been interested in are World Shaper, Blood Rites, and Veloci-ramp-tor (although this last one is pretty much hitting the budget limit)


r/EDH • • 46m ago

Deck Help Xu-Ifit Ostheoharmonist Evaluation

2 Upvotes

I've been trying to optimize this Xu-Ifit list to play this weekend:

https://moxfield.com/decks/CgW8knn7UUyPFtoNo4aGNA

I've playtested a lot of hands and i think it's okay, sometimes i get stuck with hands that miss one of the things to get the ball rolling, like having no way to get creatures on the yard, or having no way to sac them for advantage, and I'm not sure of some of my choices, if i play more sac outlets, if i try to optimize to win faster (things can get out of hand by turn 4/5 if can get the commander on curve and he doesn't get removed.)


r/EDH • • 1d ago

Deck Showcase My 4-year old prediction came true: Loran, Disciple of History is now a menace

137 Upvotes

[[Loran, Disciple of History]] says that whenever a legendary creature enters the battlefield under your control, you return an artifact card from your graveyard to your hand. Obviously, if you play legendary artifact creatures, you can never die: every legendary artifact creature can recur the next one in the chain, and artifacts are notoriously easy to make cheap.

So four years ago I wrote in the set review for Brother’s War that Loran would be a commander to keep an eye on, because she’d only get better with time.

Well, it’s time.

Back when I wrote this article, there were 7 legendary artifact creatures in white. Now, thanks to UB, there are over 30. Don’t have an artifact creature to recur? No problem, play [[Urza’s Bauble]] and now all your legendary creatures come with free card draw. [[Moonsilver Key]] can find every piece of an infinite combo: two two-cost legendary artifact creature mana dorks and [[Ashnod’s Altar]]. If you wanted to play the KCI combo in real life this is the deck for you.

Check out my decklist here: https://moxfield.com/decks/KEVfdrfJ30KFPecs-JDblg

And that doesn’t even include all the other cool cards that I didn’t think to include: https://recommander.cards/individual/9d1f232c-e904-46f6-a4b7-24ca2ede711c how in the world did I forget [[Slagstone Refinery]]?


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Deck Showcase Tricky Frog - Helga Budget Combo Deck (~$80)

3 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/cuuhAdAcIXyZv9_0R3kzqw

Late 2026 Update for my pet deck - Unfortunately the cost has gone up a bit due to card pricing increases but still a budget deck

The deck still plays the same, get Helga out then pump and dump whilst holding protection. The deck's become a lot more interactive since the first iteration.

Deck plan: Mulligan for Bant lands, Dig for Neoform + 4 mana creature or Chakram Retriever/Intruder alarm, get enough card draw down so you can't miss on creature drops or find Ancestral statue/Aethersnipe targeting itself on cast, turn Helga into a helicopter to find Tidespout tyrant or Psychosis Crawler and present the loop of repeated casting to either force your opponent to pick up their entire board including lands or ping them all to death. Knowledge is power is the overrun if both Chakram and Intruder get shut down but there are probably better alternative wincons for the deck, commander OHKOs are also surprisingly viable if the game runs long with pump + doublers

There's just enough removal and counters to deal with anything that shuts down the deck but not enough to stop someone else's win con or stopping so you're going to have to be a bant player and ignore everything else that isn't effecting you directly. Try to hold up protection for Helga, if you have a passive group turn 3 Helga is fine but turn 4 Helga tends to survive a lot more and makes greedy lands less punishing in your mulligan, if Helga is getting bullied out. Adventure's/Warp let you use your interaction whilst still being able to cast and warp casts see the full mana costs for some cheeky pumping.

Still my favourite pet deck, it's a shame I can't tell anyone I run no artifacts anymore. Knowledge is power, Mikaeus, and Broodlord are next on the chopping block. Maybe Blinking Spirit and Thryx, the sudden Storm will get shuffled in at some point.

Updated to include some new toys from the latest sets. Nothing groundbreaking in the budget department for this deck has come out just a few budget upgrades and power creeped pump spells. Doc Samson, Super Psychiatrist is the most notable budget addition to the deck giving a source of back up mana when going off and faster scaling on Helga, some additional card draw with Tanufel Rimespeaker, more efficient untaps with Guac & Marshmallow Pizza, Tethermage's Advantage, and Giant-Sized Flying Ant, Angel of Indemnity to bring back intruder alarm, Chameleon, Master of Disguise reprint causing a price drop makes it a worthy edition, and finally Beorn, Reluctant Host // Till and Tend for another adventure ramp early.

The main cost of the deck is Helga, Chakram Retriever, Tidespout Tyrant, Intruder Alarm, Restoration Magic, Mightform harmonizer, and Chulane Teller of Tales. Restoration Magic can be replaced with Shields Up!, Mightform harmonizer with Owlin Spiralmancer, and Chulane with any 4/5cmc additional lands creature you have or Gallant Citizen to drop some of the costs, Chakram and Intruder are the core combo pieces and Tidespout is the solve for end game so no cheaper alternatives there that I've found.

Additional notes: Instill energy is insanely good in this deck particularly for coming back explosive turns but it's too pricey for me, some additional scaling mana dorks such as Arbor Adherent and Kami of Whispered Hopes also gives more outs for coming backs that I will add to the deck at some point. You can trade out the X spell theme quite cleanly, more combo's/tutors would be the strongest option but my playgroup doesn't like dedicated combo lists.


r/EDH • • 1d ago

Discussion I hope titanbreach makes mutate viable

101 Upvotes

In my opinion, mutate has the potential to be one of the most fun mechanics, but ikoria fell short of making it happen. I think one of the issues is that it’s too vulnerable, and the mutate costs are far to great. It’s disappointing, as mutate is a really interesting mechanic and the arts on them from ikoria are so cool, though it’s not possible to make a deck built around mutate unless your playing jank b2, and even then it’s so fragile the play pattern isn’t the best. I hope titan breach features mutate a lot, hopefully with some stronger cards, and mutate costs that cause less. Perhaps also protection spells that say like “phase out all mutated permanents” or wipes that say “destroy all non mutated creatures.” I also think they might give artifacts some mutate abilities too, being able to mutate onto an artifact or enchantment would be cool, maybe even lands too.


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Deck Help Volrath the Fallen, Bracket 2

4 Upvotes

I have a Volrath deck I've been workshopping for quite some time. It's a place for a lot of my pet cards to live and also lets me play Voltron, something I've not played before. It does decently in casual play, but I'm looking to make final cuts on the decklist. I've just been rotating cards in and out irl but I'd like a solid base. Everything in the list and considering section I own, so feel free to make those recommendations as well. Any and all suggestions would be welcome!

https://moxfield.com/decks/49EZjHmw-UOvL-yCeT10Yg


r/EDH • • 10h ago

Discussion What Does a Bracket 2 Game Look Like to You?

7 Upvotes

I often see green decks that are chucking out double figures of mana by turn 4, voltron or aggro strategies that knock a player out turn 4 or 5, or stax/tax strategies that specifically make combat a chore by running all the pay to swing/enters tapped effect enchantments. These feel to me like they go against the spirit of the bracket 2 outlines, but given the resistance and pushback, I thought I'd ask.

Setting aside that B2 is no longer the "precon bracket", which mostly comes down to some precons punching higher rather than B2 decks needing to be stronger, the above experiences haven't made sense to me given a look at the bracket outlines. Yet in every case, when asked, the same defenses keep being reiterated - run more interaction, my deck never does this, strategies shouldn't be soft banned from any bracket of play, etc. The problem is never the deck being an obvious outlier going unchallenged in the pod, its always the fault of the other 3 decks somehow.

So having asked about voltron specifically here before, I wanted to skip the remaining individual strategies and player etiquette and just ask what does a Bracket 2 deck/game look like to you?


r/EDH • • 3m ago

Question How would I make an archeology themed build?

1 Upvotes

Anthropology and archeological cards are both welcomed, I would like something that my archeology majors/friends can enjoy. It would be nice in bracket 3 but tbh it doesn't have to be strong I'm more so looking for good thematic cards and some synergies to go with them. Red/white has passionate archeologist and Ardenn but green/blue/white has Tocasia so it's kind a hard choice especially since I don't know every card, but like it can be as simple as digging, shovel, sherds, artifacts, etc.