I've been using XTEINK devices for quite a few months now. I originally had the X4 and while I loved the little thing, I really missed having a front light. So when I found out the X4 Pro had one, I jumped on it as soon as it became available on Amazon and yeah I love this thing. I use it for both books and manga which apparently makes me a bit of a lunatic judging by some of the reactions I've seen online to people reading manga on these tiny e-readers lol but hear me out!
There's a website called XTCJS.app that lets you convert manga into a format compatible with XTEINK devices. And surprisingly the experience is pretty good. I'd honestly give it an 8/10. I've never really felt like the screen was too cramped or that I was forcing myself to enjoy something that clearly wasn't meant for a device this small. There is one caveat though. Occasionally certain panels don't display properly. From what I understand, you can mess around with dithering and some of the advanced conversion settings to improve this but I haven't been able to find a consensus on the best settings. When it happens, I just pull out another device, read the problematic panel and then continue on the X4 Pro. It's a minor inconvenience but it happens infrequently enough that I don't consider it a dealbreaker.
Reading books is where the X4 Pro really shines for me especially with how much better the stock software Licorice has gotten. It now supports features like bionic reading and KOReader progress syncing which are pretty much exactly what I was looking for. I'm a very casual reader. I've finished around six books over the past two years and I'm currently starting my seventh. I'm also someone who frequently has to reread sentences because I'll realize that despite technically reading the words, I didn't actually comprehend what I just read. Bionic reading seems to help with that. Sometimes I wonder if it's just a placebo but other times I genuinely feel like I'm retaining more of what I'm reading. Either way I'm glad Licorice has implemented it.
For context, I also own a Galaxy Tab S9 which I use for reading manga. And while the larger screen is obviously nice, I've noticed that manga just looks... different on a traditional digital display? I don't know how to explain it but something about reading manga on e-ink looks so much better to me. It feels more natural, almost like I'm reading an actual printed manga volume. So that's another reason I wanted to give the Clara BW a shot. I wanted something that offered a better manga reading experience than the tiny X4 Pro without giving up that e-Ink look. Lately I've been seeing more people mention that they initially bought the X4 Pro as a supplementary device to something like the Kobo Clara BW only to eventually abandon the Kobo and use the X4 Pro exclusively which got me curious. I already had some experience with Kobo devices having owned a Libra 2 about two years ago. I liked that device (particularly its physical page turning buttons) and I also used KOReader on it. So I decided to give the Clara BW a shot and see whether having both devices would make sense for me. And I have to say, the Clara BW is a nice little e-reader. It's a completely different approach from the X4 Pro. No physical page turning buttons, just a touchscreen, a power button on the back and USB-C on the bottom. It's also waterproof which is pretty cool.
I've actually taken it into the shower a few times to read manga. Yes really lol. There's a manga I follow weekly and its chapters are relatively short so I figured why not? The screen sometimes gets a little foggy or hazy when I do that (which affects legibility) but it's still manageable.
I've installed KOReader on the Clara BW and have been experimenting with different plugins and settings. I've been using KOReader for about two years now going back to when I had the Kobo Libra 2 and Kindle Paperwhite. One thing I've always disliked about KOReader is how barebones and raw the interface feels. But today I discovered and installed the Simple UI plugin and wow what a difference. I really like it! I've also installed a plugin that adds bionic reading and guided dots. Personally I find Guided Dots a little excessive so I've been sticking with bionic reading. Another thing I've been trying to do is make KOReader's reading interface look as close as possible to Kobo's stock reader. I came across a post recommending the following settings:
Font: Rakuten Serif
Left/right margins: 40
Top/bottom margins: 20
View mode: Page
Rendering mode: Book
Zoom DPI: 300
Line spacing: 140%
Word spacing: Medium
Font size: Around 24
I haven't gotten around to extracting Rakuten Serif from the Kobo's files yet so I've been alternating between Atkinson Hyperlegible, Literata and IBM Plex Serif. I also haven't figured out how to disable hyphenation or ignore publisher margins. If anyone has suggestions for making KOReader resemble stock more closely I'd love to hear them.
One of the things that made me excited about using both devices was discovering that Licorice supports KOReader progress syncing.
In theory, I should be able to read on my X4 Pro, put it away, pick up the Clara BW and continue where I left off (ensuring both are connected to WiFi). Unfortunately it hasn't been very reliable. Neither device seems particularly good at syncing, although the X4 Pro tends to work more often than the Kobo. For example, let's say I'm on Chapter 2 on the Clara BW. I switch to the X4 Pro, read until Chapter 3 and then return to the Kobo. When I try pulling the latest reading progress, KOReader tells me I'm already at the latest position even though I'm clearly not. I'm not sure whether I've configured something incorrectly or if there's a known issue with syncing between Licorice and KOReader. If anyone has experience with this setup, I'd appreciate some advice!
I've been trying to develop a new reading habit lately. Instead of automatically reaching for my phone and doomscrolling whenever I have some downtime, I've been making an effort to pick up my e-reader instead. For example, when I'm a passenger in the car, I'll pull out the X4 Pro and read. I used to find it difficult to concentrate on reading when people around me were talking, but I've been trying to tune out the background chatter and focus on the book. I think I'm slowly getting better at it. My current plan is to use the X4 Pro whenever I'm out and the Clara BW when I'm home. And so far it's been working reasonably well.
But here's the thing. The X4 Pro is just so ridiculously comfortable to use. I never feel like I need a grip, a stand or a remote page turner. It just feels perfect in one hand. The way I have Licorice configured is incredibly intuitive too. My index finger naturally rests on the left button which goes back a page. My thumb rests on the right button which goes to the next page. Pressing both buttons toggles night mode. Double pressing the power button toggles the front light. Tapping the home button goes back and holding it goes to the home screen. Everything feels natural and I barely have to think about what I'm doing. With the Clara BW, there have been a handful of occasions where I've been reading and thought "you know what? I'd rather just use the X4 Pro." It's not that the Clara is uncomfortable. It's just that the X4 Pro feels that good in my hand. The Clara's touchscreen only approach for sure has its advantages. It's minimalistic and there's nothing distracting you from the reading experience. But I'm still getting accustomed to KOReader's gestures. I've figured out the front light gesture but most of the others I've discovered completely by accident.
I'm generally a dark mode on everything kind of person. My phone, tablet and most of my other devices are almost always in dark mode. But for some reason, when it comes to e-readers, I actually prefer the traditional black text on white background appearance. Reading in night mode just feels a little strange to me. Oddly enough though I find myself more inclined to use night mode on the Clara BW than on the X4 Pro. I have absolutely no idea why.
I realize I've been singing the X4 Pro's praises throughout this post but there's one thing about it that drives me absolutely crazy. The pogo pins. I know some people will say "Well I barely ever need to charge it and I don't transfer books that often so it's really not a big deal." And that's totally fair! If that's how you use the device, I can see why it wouldn't bother you. But I'm someone who likes experimenting with things, especially fonts. If I find out there's a new font that people are recommending over whatever the current favorites are, I'm probably going to want to try it immediately. And while Licorice has an import fonts feature that makes this somewhat easier, I still prefer doing this kind of stuff on my computer. My phone is getting a little old by my standards. And before anyone asks what phone I have, I'm sure you'd laugh at me for calling it old haha.
But it feels slow to me and I generally don't enjoy doing file management or anything more involved on it. I'd much rather use my PC. That's why I really wish the X4 Pro had retained the regular USB-C port from the original X4. I genuinely think that would've made the hardware pretty much perfect for me. But I guess manufacturers can't let us have everything right? I know some people also wish the X4 Pro had retained the original X4's navigation buttons but personally I don't miss them at all. I've gotten so used to the X4 Pro's combination of touch controls and left/right buttons that I actually prefer it. Navigating feels faster and more intuitive than using the X4's directional and selection buttons.
There is however one software feature I really wish Licorice would borrow from CrossPoint which is the ability to disable touch while reading. I've heard that the developers might be collaborating although I'm not entirely sure. Considering that Licorice has already added features like bionic reading, I'm hoping touch disabling might eventually make its way over too. If that happens, I think Liqurish would genuinely be a 10/10 reading experience for me.
As it stands right now, I'd give the X4 Pro's hardware a 9/10 with that missing point going entirely to those annoying pogo pins. And this is one area where I absolutely prefer the Kobo Clara BW. It has a regular USB-C port and connecting it to my computer is incredibly straightforward. Plug it in, confirm USB mode and you're good to go. With the X4 Pro, you have to deal with the pogo pin connection and manually navigate to file transfer mode. It's a small difference on paper but when you're someone who frequently tinkers with their devices, that convenience really adds up. So yeah as much as I love the X4 Pro, it's definitely not perfect.
Sooo... which one am I keeping? I'm still figuring that out. The Clara BW is undeniably better for reading manga. The larger screen makes a difference and I'm not going to pretend otherwise. But at the same time I don't find reading manga on the X4 Pro unpleasant. If I'm out somewhere and want to read a chapter, I'm perfectly happy doing so on the X4 Pro. It's not like I feel compelled to wait until I get home to use the Kobo. For regular books, I'm increasingly finding myself gravitating toward the X4 Pro. There are times when I'm alert, sitting comfortably and don't mind holding a device with two hands. In those situations, the Clara BW is nice. But for everything else, the X4 Pro is just so convenient.
My current plan is to use the Clara BW primarily for manga and the X4 Pro primarily for books. I'll keep experimenting with that setup for a little while longer. But if I had to make a prediction right now, I think there's a pretty good chance I'll eventually return the Clara BW and stick exclusively with the X4 Pro. Which is funny because I initially thought the X4 Pro would be the supplementary device. Turns out it might be the main thing.